Ferguson tribunal
#11
(09-09-2021, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 11:18 AM)Sliced Wrote: Just to get the series of events correct, please correct me if this is wrong:

Ferguson played consistently for us before January, Palace put in an accepted 11m pound bid but said that Ferguson had failed the medical and requested that Ferguson have knee surgery, we weren't happy with this.

Despite him failing a medical, Palace sign him on a free anyway at the end of the season, Ferguson has the surgery and his recovery time is much longer than they anticipated. He then has 2 subsequent injuries the most recent of which requires surgery.

Sounds like the initial surgery was the problem, or he's another George Thorne in the making
Very good points. I hope we are making that clear to the tribunal.

The key thing for me will be arguing the fee needs to reflect where he was at the time Palace decided to sign him. Whilst the tribunal will take into account the fact he'd had surgery and wasn't 100% fit upon signing, this transfer was agreed shortly after both parties agreed an £11m fee, and we rejected a latter £4m offer. 

The tribunal shouldn't allow the fact he hasn't kicked a ball competitively since January 2020 influence the fee, although the longer it goes on, the lower I think the fee will become. Ferguson was an £11m player, he followed a course of surgery Palace felt would cure the injury and he's been crocked ever since. In my mind, he's still an £11m player, but I bet we'll be lucky to see a third of that now.
Reply
#12
(09-09-2021, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 11:18 AM)Sliced Wrote: Just to get the series of events correct, please correct me if this is wrong:

Ferguson played consistently for us before January, Palace put in an accepted 11m pound bid but said that Ferguson had failed the medical and requested that Ferguson have knee surgery, we weren't happy with this.

Despite him failing a medical, Palace sign him on a free anyway at the end of the season, Ferguson has the surgery and his recovery time is much longer than they anticipated. He then has 2 subsequent injuries the most recent of which requires surgery.

Sounds like the initial surgery was the problem, or he's another George Thorne in the making
Very good points. I hope we are making that clear to the tribunal.

I think he had the surgery whilst with us (against our wishes but he insisted) and never played for us again.
Reply
#13
I'm not sure we can say he was an £11m player. He was if he was in mint condition, which Palace decided he wasn't. They then decided he was worth £4m "second hand".

I have a suspicion that is how the tribunal will look at it, and the fee will be closer to £4m than it is to £11m.
Reply
#14
(09-09-2021, 03:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I'm not sure we can say he was an £11m player. He was if he was in mint condition, which Palace decided he wasn't. They then decided he was worth £4m "second hand".

I have a suspicion that is how the tribunal will look at it, and the fee will be closer to £4m than it is to £11m.

That’s not how it works.   He was in £11m condition when he joined them and was the basis on which Palace signed him.   Any reduction in value thereafter based on his injury is for Palace to claim for under their insurance policy.  They won’t be out of pocket - that’s what insurance is for.
Reply
#15
(09-09-2021, 03:52 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 03:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I'm not sure we can say he was an £11m player. He was if he was in mint condition, which Palace decided he wasn't. They then decided he was worth £4m "second hand".

I have a suspicion that is how the tribunal will look at it, and the fee will be closer to £4m than it is to £11m.

That’s not how it works.   He was in £11m condition when he joined them and was the basis on which Palace signed him.   Any reduction in value thereafter based on his injury is for Palace to claim for under their insurance policy.  They won’t be out of pocket - that’s what insurance is for.

Indeed… and according to that article we have rejected further bids from Palace for an out of tribunal settlement. Sadly I have zero confidence that we will get more than £3-4m
Reply
#16
(09-09-2021, 05:43 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 03:52 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 03:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I'm not sure we can say he was an £11m player. He was if he was in mint condition, which Palace decided he wasn't. They then decided he was worth £4m "second hand".

I have a suspicion that is how the tribunal will look at it, and the fee will be closer to £4m than it is to £11m.

That’s not how it works.   He was in £11m condition when he joined them and was the basis on which Palace signed him.   Any reduction in value thereafter based on his injury is for Palace to claim for under their insurance policy.  They won’t be out of pocket - that’s what insurance is for.

Indeed… and according to that article we have rejected further bids from Palace for an out of tribunal settlement. Sadly I have zero confidence that we will get more than £3-4m

When he failed the medical, Palarse dropped their offer to £4 million, they've since made several offers to avoid going to tribunal, which we've rejected, I can see no good reason why we shouldn't expect to get somewhere between the 4 mill, & 11mill.
Unless like a lot of things in football, the tribunal's fucking bent.
Reply
#17
(09-09-2021, 05:54 PM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 05:43 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 03:52 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 03:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I'm not sure we can say he was an £11m player. He was if he was in mint condition, which Palace decided he wasn't. They then decided he was worth £4m "second hand".

I have a suspicion that is how the tribunal will look at it, and the fee will be closer to £4m than it is to £11m.

That’s not how it works.   He was in £11m condition when he joined them and was the basis on which Palace signed him.   Any reduction in value thereafter based on his injury is for Palace to claim for under their insurance policy.  They won’t be out of pocket - that’s what insurance is for.

Indeed… and according to that article we have rejected further bids from Palace for an out of tribunal settlement. Sadly I have zero confidence that we will get more than £3-4m

When he failed the medical, Palarse dropped their offer to £4 million, they've since made several offers to avoid going to tribunal, which we've rejected, I can see no good reason why we shouldn't expect to get somewhere between the 4 mill, & 11mill.
Unless like a lot of things in football, the tribunal's fucking bent.

London club
Premier league club…

Plenty of reasons to doubt the integrity immediately.

And let’s face it, Ferguson hasn’t kicked a ball in 18 months and counting, and since he last played Covid has happened driving down values… 

You just know we are going to end up with peanuts when by rights Palace should be coughing up £7-8m as a minimum.
Reply
#18
(09-09-2021, 06:36 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 05:54 PM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 05:43 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 03:52 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 03:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I'm not sure we can say he was an £11m player. He was if he was in mint condition, which Palace decided he wasn't. They then decided he was worth £4m "second hand".

I have a suspicion that is how the tribunal will look at it, and the fee will be closer to £4m than it is to £11m.

That’s not how it works.   He was in £11m condition when he joined them and was the basis on which Palace signed him.   Any reduction in value thereafter based on his injury is for Palace to claim for under their insurance policy.  They won’t be out of pocket - that’s what insurance is for.

Indeed… and according to that article we have rejected further bids from Palace for an out of tribunal settlement. Sadly I have zero confidence that we will get more than £3-4m

When he failed the medical, Palarse dropped their offer to £4 million, they've since made several offers to avoid going to tribunal, which we've rejected, I can see no good reason why we shouldn't expect to get somewhere between the 4 mill, & 11mill.
Unless like a lot of things in football, the tribunal's fucking bent.

London club
Premier league club…

Plenty of reasons to doubt the integrity immediately.

And let’s face it, Ferguson hasn’t kicked a ball in 18 months and counting, and since he last played Covid has happened driving down values… 

You just know we are going to end up with peanuts when by rights Palace should be coughing up £7-8m as a minimum.

Of course we will. Can’t see us getting anything over £3m to be honest.
Reply
#19
Whats the odds that as soon as the tribunal sets the fee at around £3mill ,Ferguson makes a miraculous recovery from injury and starts playing again, or am i being to cynical in my old age!
Reply
#20
He may as well gone for £0 because whatever the fee we won't know the truth ,and it will go straight to Lai bank account so we won't benefit from the playing side .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)