Posts: 1,131
Threads: 164
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
I think a return to the back 3 system may work well for us now. A lot of the frailties before were down to Bartley playing left side. A back 3 of Holgate, Dawson and Hegazi would be solid, with Gibbs as left wing back, and Phillips(or Edwards if Matty snags another toenail) on the right. This would enable us to play Livermore(or Barry, not both), Johansen and Harper as a narrow 3, and get Gayle back up centrally, alongside JRod. We need those 2 paired together again, and this would be, IMO,the best way to achieve that.
Posts: 341
Threads: 14
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
Still not sure we have the right combination of centre backs to go to a back 3. I do wonder if we should try 442, given it worked so successfully at the end of last season. Would allow us to stick with the back 4, get Gayle and Rodriguez central and get our wide players into better areas.
Centre of midfield might take a bit of work, but it needs some anyway. We’d need Morrison in there and probably Johansen.
Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
I agree that a lot of the problems at the start of the season were down to Bartley playing on the left and some general ring rust/not knowing the system. With Holgate and Gibbs/Phillips as wing backs we could actually move the ball with some pace and purpose which is something we've been lacking recently.
Would also take 442 as I think our most pressing concern is getting Gayle back in the box where he belongs
Posts: 830
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Some of our performances playing 3-5-2 away from home were very bad, don't think you can just blame Bartley.
Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
Fair enough, would also add letting the centre halfs do what they're good at and not try to be franco baresi
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
03-03-2019, 02:21 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-03-2019, 02:24 PM by Hopalong.)
(03-03-2019, 11:09 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: I think a return to the back 3 system may work well for us now. A lot of the frailties before were down to Bartley playing left side. A back 3 of Holgate, Dawson and Hegazi would be solid, with Gibbs as left wing back, and Phillips(or Edwards if Matty snags another toenail) on the right. This would enable us to play Livermore(or Barry, not both), Johansen and Harper as a narrow 3, and get Gayle back up centrally, alongside JRod. We need those 2 paired together again, and this would be, IMO,the best way to achieve that.
At home I should stick with a 4 with Holgate and Gibbs really pushing on and Barry/Johansen shielding the back 2.
If fit Murphy has to start. If Phillips not fit, Montero to start. Maybe Mozza as 10.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(03-03-2019, 11:09 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: I think a return to the back 3 system may work well for us now. A lot of the frailties before were down to Bartley playing left side. A back 3 of Holgate, Dawson and Hegazi would be solid, with Gibbs as left wing back, and Phillips(or Edwards if Matty snags another toenail) on the right. This would enable us to play Livermore(or Barry, not both), Johansen and Harper as a narrow 3, and get Gayle back up centrally, alongside JRod. We need those 2 paired together again, and this would be, IMO,the best way to achieve that.
We keep having this discussion on here. Of the players we've seen in the back three system, only Hegazi has enough pace and comfort on the ball to play as the middle man. So we end up with Bartley on the left. Could Holgate be the middle man, flanked by Dawson and Hegazi? Maybe. Phillips playing as absentee right wing back was the main weakness for us, never mind Bartley looking out of place on the left.
I think it's a fashion. I'll be surprised if BD goes back to it and I'm sure it won't ever become the norm in the English Leagues or elsewhere in the world.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(03-03-2019, 02:59 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 11:09 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: I think a return to the back 3 system may work well for us now. A lot of the frailties before were down to Bartley playing left side. A back 3 of Holgate, Dawson and Hegazi would be solid, with Gibbs as left wing back, and Phillips(or Edwards if Matty snags another toenail) on the right. This would enable us to play Livermore(or Barry, not both), Johansen and Harper as a narrow 3, and get Gayle back up centrally, alongside JRod. We need those 2 paired together again, and this would be, IMO,the best way to achieve that.
We keep having this discussion on here. Of the players we've seen in the back three system, only Hegazi has enough pace and comfort on the ball to play as the middle man. So we end up with Bartley on the left. Could Holgate be the middle man, flanked by Dawson and Hegazi? Maybe. Phillips playing as absentee right wing back was the main weakness for us, never mind Bartley looking out of place on the left.
I think it's a fashion. I'll be surprised if BD goes back to it and I'm sure it won't ever become the norm in the English Leagues or elsewhere in the world.
Agree with all of this. Three centre backs has a fad about every ten to fifteen years. The latest one peaked about 2 seasons ago but most clubs are now playing a back four again.
I think it’s also worth saying a ‘back 3’ can mean very different things, and is often pretty much a back 5 ( see boro this season) which is a defensive system. Our 3 at the back was much more attacking than that (and we let shit loads of goals in). So I’m wary of lumping all types of back 3 into one formation. But I agree that whichever way it’s played, it’s normally a trend for a couple of years that then fizzles out for a decade.
Posts: 4,768
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
27
03-03-2019, 04:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-03-2019, 04:11 PM by GunsOfNavarone.)
If we revert to a back three Barry slots in to the left of Hegazi with Holgate on the right for me (Dawson continues to flirt between generally over rated, shite on the ball and generally dozy - I am not a fan of his, that said he's still ahead of Brain Fart). Midfield five of Johansen, Harper and Phillips if all are fit with Gibbs and Murphy pushing up from out wide, Gayle and J Rod up front.
Johansen and Harper give us mobility and passing options with Phillips providing central creativity, Gibbs and Murphy the width and dropping back when we defend. If Murphy's not up to the defensive side of things Phillips plays wide with Livermore/Field central. If Phillips is not fit enough then unfortunately Dawson plays on the right of the back three with Holgate out wide on the right. Johansen and Harper can drop back to form a central midfield block in front of the back three if required.
If Phillips is not fit enough for his midfield berth then it's Johansen, Livermore/Field and Harper with Jake/Sam playing anchor as the others again provide legs, mobility and passing options. We have the resources for this, if we return to a back three then use them. Just do not obsess over pass after pass to and from the back. If it's on then play to open up the rest of the pitch, if not then move the ball through the pitch quicker.
Defensive 5-3-2:
(Gibbs, Barry, Hegazi, Holgate [Dawson], Murphy [Phillips, Holgate]) (Johansen, Phillips [Livermore, Field], Harper) (Gayle, JRod)
Open play 3-5-2 with the above and attack with 3-3-4.
(Ed: and we can have a keeper too  )
Posts: 1,236
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
I'd have gone back to 3 at home a long time ago. The chances we create have dried up in tandem.
|