Posts: 9,649
Threads: 520
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(09-01-2021, 10:40 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I didn’t say the squad was much worse than the last time we got promoted - it’s weaker for sure, but so is the division so they cancel eachother out. What I said is that our squad is massively weaker than the one that competed in the PL last season.
If we are to get promoted this season we will need massive work to make this side even remotely fit for purpose next year… who in the squad currently could operate at PL level? Johnstone, Townsend, Mowatt… the rest are squad fillers at best.
The only way we will ever stop the yo-yo’ing will be if we invest into players we believe we can develop into PL players at this level - we need to be finding our Toney, Watkins, Maddison, Wilson etc… and the only way we will do that is by actually buying players.
We’ve kept the bulk of the players together, we’ve made a couple good loan signings… but to what end? Promotion and a need to buy far more players than we are likely to afford.
Apologies SW4, I misread your post whilst pretending to be interested in a teams meeting.
From the current Squad I think; Johnstone, Ajayi, O'Shea, Furlong, Townsend, Mowatt, Diangana, Robinson, Phillips, Grant, are, or will be good enough to make up half of a first XI in the premier league. Many of which have developed into what they are now over the last 2 years.
I agree we need to invest in players who can make the step up, but Think they always have to be your players that are back up in teh Prem or first team in the Championship. We have our Championship first teamers right now. Buying more would clog up the squad in terms of wages and squad places for what is undoubtedly a tough job for when we get promoted. If we can get promoted, we will have the cash to buy some better, younger, progressive players, with teh fabled re-sale potential. This summer was always about ensuring we keep our developing players (Furlong, Johnstone, Townsend, Robinson etc.), padding the squad with short term options with no real future commitment to eat into our next budget.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-01-2021, 10:41 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: I’m genuinely tired of the same old trope of this being a weak squad without any real analysis. I’ve tried to do this on a few threads but it gets ignored because it doesn’t fit the narrative.
What is starting to grate is we are singularly looking as players as individual talent and not looking at the tactics, system and the collective.
As I laid out in the other thread this team 1 to 18 is as good if not better than 19/20 in my opinion because we have players who fit the system, they have a role and capability match and the players as a collective understand their jobs.
I do agree we would need significant investment of promoted, however, and this is key, we wouldn’t have to use that investment simply to retain the players that got us promoted. Think Krov, Diang, Robinson et al - all with loan fees, transfer fees and signings on in excess of £20m. Then there’s there’s the £16m paid for Grant. If Molumby and Clarke make the grade that’s probably £3-5m.
I think investing £25-30m correctly in this team would give us a much stronger chance of being competitive to stay up than the squad we had at the end of the Summer transfer window last year. If Val is here I know we also have a much better chance of spending it wisely.
Exactly. A fit and well-organised team is what we need to survive. Talent is not enough. We entered the PL in 2020 with an unfit, disorganised team and a manager who didn't know his best 11. A world away from a Valball team.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Aa fit and organised team who fight for every ball has note chance of staying up than a more technical but lazy, unfit team.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
A good insightful post Lurker.
As ever with all things Albion many posters find something to justify their mindset using a mixture of past failings/successes, current form and dialogues from the pixies living in their heads.
To survive in the Prem we need to add to a strong Championship squad with a handful of quality players rather than total reassembly.
This squad has the nucleus of something good.
Posts: 10,866
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(09-01-2021, 10:40 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I didn’t say the squad was much worse than the last time we got promoted - it’s weaker for sure, but so is the division so they cancel eachother out. What I said is that our squad is massively weaker than the one that competed in the PL last season.
If we are to get promoted this season we will need massive work to make this side even remotely fit for purpose next year… who in the squad currently could operate at PL level? Johnstone, Townsend, Mowatt… the rest are squad fillers at best.
The only way we will ever stop the yo-yo’ing will be if we invest into players we believe we can develop into PL players at this level - we need to be finding our Toney, Watkins, Maddison, Wilson etc… and the only way we will do that is by actually buying players.
We’ve kept the bulk of the players together, we’ve made a couple good loan signings… but to what end? Promotion and a need to buy far more players than we are likely to afford.
Absolutely bang on SW4. Not sure about Watkins but the other three were on our radar and we actually gave Wilson a trial but chose a player called Kaydelen Brown instead of him!
We have to be quicker and act with more conviction at moving for these players earlier. We also saw both Demari Gray and Nathan Redmond move from Blues when they were achievable targets.
But all of this only works with a cohesive club with a plan. I really don't feel like we have that set up anymore.
Val and his team appear to be a great acquisition but we need the club to start speculating again and be progressive in its recruitment. When you are miles behind the pack in finances you have to be clever. We used to good at it when we were finding players like Dorrans, Mulumbu and Wood etc. We need to get back to unearthing some gems.
Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(09-01-2021, 05:51 PM)Peachy Wrote: (09-01-2021, 10:40 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I didn’t say the squad was much worse than the last time we got promoted - it’s weaker for sure, but so is the division so they cancel eachother out. What I said is that our squad is massively weaker than the one that competed in the PL last season.
If we are to get promoted this season we will need massive work to make this side even remotely fit for purpose next year… who in the squad currently could operate at PL level? Johnstone, Townsend, Mowatt… the rest are squad fillers at best.
The only way we will ever stop the yo-yo’ing will be if we invest into players we believe we can develop into PL players at this level - we need to be finding our Toney, Watkins, Maddison, Wilson etc… and the only way we will do that is by actually buying players.
We’ve kept the bulk of the players together, we’ve made a couple good loan signings… but to what end? Promotion and a need to buy far more players than we are likely to afford.
Absolutely bang on SW4. Not sure about Watkins but the other three were on our radar and we actually gave Wilson a trial but chose a player called Kaydelen Brown instead of him!
We have to be quicker and act with more conviction at moving for these players earlier. We also saw both Demari Gray and Nathan Redmond move from Blues when they were achievable targets.
But all of this only works with a cohesive club with a plan. I really don't feel like we have that set up anymore.
Val and his team appear to be a great acquisition but we need the club to start speculating again and be progressive in its recruitment. When you are miles behind the pack in finances you have to be clever. We used to good at it when we were finding players like Dorrans, Mulumbu and Wood etc. We need to get back to unearthing some gems. Furlong and Townsend are unearthed gems, now shining. And who is to say we won't get some shine off others? As for cohesive set-up, we haven't really had that since Dashworth left and McDonut ruined so much else. I prefer what we have now to Bilic's Lucky bag.
Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-01-2021, 08:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: So now the dust has settled, and we have all had time to take in the multiple freds about the squad, and strength in depth etc. etc.
I have been thinking about our constant battle in previous seasons. We have always had ageing squads when relegated, had huge turn overs of first team players, and we have signed players that are too good for the championship but not quite good enough to be PL regulars. But this time we have got relegated with for the most part, a first XI being in their mid twenties, are seasoned Championship performers, with many showing they have what it takes to play a part if we were to be promoted.
This year we have neither (had to) invested in risky signings ala Ajayi, Kipre, Furlong, Townsend, but neither have we wasted money on people like Zohore, Austin, Grosiki, who would never offer owt in the prem. We now have the opportunity, if we do get promoted to invest solely in players who are premier league quality, which can be the cherries on our functional cake of a squad. A nice position to be in finally.
Great post Lurker, completely agree with all the points you’ve made. A voice of sanity rather than knee jerk nonsense. Have a special k.
|