Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
(09-01-2021, 09:09 AM)Duffers Wrote: I don’t particularly care about going up anymore. I obviously understand the importance from a financial stability perspective, but the Premier League holds little interest for me anymore. I just want to enjoy watching Albion again, regardless of division. I want to see a committed, attacking team and that’s what I’m seeing at the moment, so I’m happy.
+1. You enjoy a season of winning games and being successful. Unfortunately the 'prize' is then being talked about and treated with disdain, losing most weeks, biased referreeing and a total lack of respect from the 'big boys'. With a wad of cash sent your way as a gagging order.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
09-01-2021, 09:57 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-01-2021, 10:00 AM by Hopalong.)
(08-31-2021, 09:56 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (08-31-2021, 09:44 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Firstly your post is remarkably sensible and states it as it is.
As to why they are moaning I think that’s a much bigger question.
Questions are being posed due to the regime, style of play and general dissatisfaction after a poor last 12 months or so.
Keep winning and the moaners will have very little ammunition.
The vast majority will be underwhelmed but realise you can’t argue with results and the start of the season so let’s see how it pans out.
You’re spot on Spandau, it’s questions about the regime and running of the club, the fact we’ve not outplayed a transfer fee after selling our star player for 17m only fuels the fire
Ronnie is right, we have a decent squad but others have strengthened better than us IMO and have closed the gap on us in terms of the race for promotion, it’s just that constant frustrate at we don’t see an opportunity and take it, also Ken pulling the wool over the fans eyes to sell season tickets
Competitive budget my arse
Cuzer
Genuine question Cuzer who are the others you refer to? I would argue that only Fulham on paper have a better squad but it's all about results and at the moment we are level pegging with them after arguably a more difficult start.
Apart from Pereira who we had little choice but to sell really, we have kept our substantive prem squad in place and have added 6 new players, three of them signed from Premier League clubs.
We have also kept Sam who may or may not sign a new improved contract and if we go up he stays - win:win.
The others who have strengthened are probably taking a massive gamble based on how poor the Championship is.
Personally I wouldn't bet against our name being in the automatic promotion places come May - would you?
(08-31-2021, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I've followed the Baggies since the 60s, when a World Cup win for England and League and FA Cup wins for the Albion drew me in. My Dad worked in Cornwall Road, Smethwick, so The Hawthorns was the obvious place to be (despite living in Villa territory and the old fellow being a Derbyshire man).
That was the only time we were regarded as a fully established top level club, with a chance of winning stuff. We nearly clawed it back in the 70s/early 80s, but were run on a miserly budget by a troop of people whom Ron Atkinson referred to as "The Lavender Hill Mob". Laurie Cunningham was on a tiny wage even for those days - it was a miracle we held onto any good players at all.
From the 1986 relegation we lurched from one financial crisis to another, repeated poor managerial appointments, no long term plan to stabilise or recover our top flight status. Even after the Ardiles promotion, we looked amateurish - right up to Megson's time there was boardroom conflict. The Peace era culminated in 8 straight seasons in the Premier League where we were tantalised with the prospect of becoming a "safe" mid-table side. But the fans were never happy with Peace, in the end the football under Pulis was uncompromisingly "functional" and it just wasn't much fun being last on MotD every week and tipped for the drop every autumn.
Now we're back to yo-yoing for a while. The first half season of Bilic was a breath of fresh air, promotion gave us a boost. The Prem season was awful and now (maybe) we're in with a chance of doing well back in the Champ.
So I'm asking, at what point in recent Albion history (say since 1981) were we really happy with the manager, the squad, the style of play, the way the club was being run, the results we were getting? Have there been many moments when fans would say "well that was OK" on deadline day? I think not. We are an up-and-down club with a set of fans who aren't smug, self-satisfied or blindly loyal. It becomes a habit to look for the catch and boards like this offer the ideal medium for some industrial quality grumbling. It's part of the whole experience.
Spot on Chesh.
If you go back 20 years we can only have dreamt of the success we've had since then, based on the previous 20!
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(09-01-2021, 08:53 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:27 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:18 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:17 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:13 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Mass.
We're scoring goals and winning games, if that's not decent football I don't know what is.
May as well watch that goal ball game then if that is all that counts. Like I say, I'm currently feeling somewhat indifferent to this season.
I don't understand what you want, sorry i don't.
Skilled players playing football, where we pass the ball around with a bit of style and maybe even some finesse, that leads to scoring opportunities and maybe some goals. Maybe heck we'll look composed on the ball and in control of things for a bit.
Currently we have a park's team that basically just swarms the ball and bundles it in. Yes we are scoring, yes we are shooting, but that really is about it. And yes at times it has been enjoyable and fun, but The Posh game I found incredibly dull, and I'm expecting more of that this season. I don't like the 'dark arts' that a lot on here are now lauding, I hated it when Italy beat England using them, even though I know a lot praise them for it.
Personal preference innit? I like pretty football, and yes I do appreciate effort, usually when we're the underdog, not the favourite though.
As I said I mostly stopped only wanting us to win a while ago. What's the prize? Oh yeah, another season of utter abject rubbish in the Prem.
Honestly, MD, I don't quite get what your problem is. We play high energy, not terrible sophisticated football. It would be nice to see a bit of composure, but we don't yet know how things will develop during the season. Or maybe it was you who stole the seeing stone and you do know.
But what kind of football do you want to see? Ron Atkinson's team of swaggerers, with a handful of truly world class players? We haven't got that. Ossie's full scale five-a-side approach? That only just got us up from Div 2. The best moments of Mowbray, RDM and Clarke, with none of the downsides of their tenure thrown in? Unrealistic. I think you're just being contrary, sitting on the sidelines moaning like a sulky kid at a party, but still eating the cake and taking the goodie-bag home.
I recall a coach or someone, years back, saying`there is no right or wrong way to win a match`. Yes, I loved Atkinsons team, but, those days are gone. A team like us, or Southampton, Burnley etc, can only survive in the Prem by being organised,working hard, maybe one or two quality players, who will get snapped up by bigger clubs after a couple of years.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(09-01-2021, 08:53 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:27 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:18 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:17 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:13 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Mass.
We're scoring goals and winning games, if that's not decent football I don't know what is.
May as well watch that goal ball game then if that is all that counts. Like I say, I'm currently feeling somewhat indifferent to this season.
I don't understand what you want, sorry i don't.
Skilled players playing football, where we pass the ball around with a bit of style and maybe even some finesse, that leads to scoring opportunities and maybe some goals. Maybe heck we'll look composed on the ball and in control of things for a bit.
Currently we have a park's team that basically just swarms the ball and bundles it in. Yes we are scoring, yes we are shooting, but that really is about it. And yes at times it has been enjoyable and fun, but The Posh game I found incredibly dull, and I'm expecting more of that this season. I don't like the 'dark arts' that a lot on here are now lauding, I hated it when Italy beat England using them, even though I know a lot praise them for it.
Personal preference innit? I like pretty football, and yes I do appreciate effort, usually when we're the underdog, not the favourite though.
As I said I mostly stopped only wanting us to win a while ago. What's the prize? Oh yeah, another season of utter abject rubbish in the Prem.
Honestly, MD, I don't quite get what your problem is. We play high energy, not terribly sophisticated football. It would be nice to see a bit of composure, but we don't yet know how things will develop during the season. Or maybe it was you who stole the seeing stone and you do know.
But what kind of football do you want to see? Ron Atkinson's team of swaggerers, with a handful of truly world class players? We haven't got that. Ossie's full scale five-a-side approach? That only just got us up from Div 2. The best moments of Mowbray, RDM and Clarke, with none of the downsides of their tenure thrown in? Unrealistic. I think you're just being contrary, sitting on the sidelines moaning like a sulky kid at a party, but still eating the cake and taking the goodie-bag home.
I'm not actually moaning. because I like a certain style does not mean that I am moaning.
Slav, RDM, Ossie and Atkinson mixed would be fine with me. And you are right no-one knows what is to come, I just can't see us getting that composure or any level of sophistication, so that makes me a moaner, I'll add it to the list under my name. What is wrong with wanting to enjoy something that has been a big part of your life?
It's hilarious, because I was one of the original happy clappers way back when, I guess several promotions and the expected demises have just changed my views on what I want to see.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(09-01-2021, 09:57 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (08-31-2021, 09:56 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (08-31-2021, 09:44 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Firstly your post is remarkably sensible and states it as it is.
As to why they are moaning I think that’s a much bigger question.
Questions are being posed due to the regime, style of play and general dissatisfaction after a poor last 12 months or so.
Keep winning and the moaners will have very little ammunition.
The vast majority will be underwhelmed but realise you can’t argue with results and the start of the season so let’s see how it pans out.
You’re spot on Spandau, it’s questions about the regime and running of the club, the fact we’ve not outplayed a transfer fee after selling our star player for 17m only fuels the fire
Ronnie is right, we have a decent squad but others have strengthened better than us IMO and have closed the gap on us in terms of the race for promotion, it’s just that constant frustrate at we don’t see an opportunity and take it, also Ken pulling the wool over the fans eyes to sell season tickets
Competitive budget my arse
Cuzer
Genuine question Cuzer who are the others you refer to? I would argue that only Fulham on paper have a better squad but it's all about results and at the moment we are level pegging with them after arguably a more difficult start.
Apart from Pereira who we had little choice but to sell really, we have kept our substantive prem squad in place and have added 6 new players, three of them signed from Premier League clubs.
We have also kept Sam who may or may not sign a new improved contract and if we go up he stays - win:win.
The others who have strengthened are probably taking a massive gamble based on how poor the Championship is.
Personally I wouldn't bet against our name being in the automatic promotion places come May - would you?
(08-31-2021, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I've followed the Baggies since the 60s, when a World Cup win for England and League and FA Cup wins for the Albion drew me in. My Dad worked in Cornwall Road, Smethwick, so The Hawthorns was the obvious place to be (despite living in Villa territory and the old fellow being a Derbyshire man).
That was the only time we were regarded as a fully established top level club, with a chance of winning stuff. We nearly clawed it back in the 70s/early 80s, but were run on a miserly budget by a troop of people whom Ron Atkinson referred to as "The Lavender Hill Mob". Laurie Cunningham was on a tiny wage even for those days - it was a miracle we held onto any good players at all.
From the 1986 relegation we lurched from one financial crisis to another, repeated poor managerial appointments, no long term plan to stabilise or recover our top flight status. Even after the Ardiles promotion, we looked amateurish - right up to Megson's time there was boardroom conflict. The Peace era culminated in 8 straight seasons in the Premier League where we were tantalised with the prospect of becoming a "safe" mid-table side. But the fans were never happy with Peace, in the end the football under Pulis was uncompromisingly "functional" and it just wasn't much fun being last on MotD every week and tipped for the drop every autumn.
Now we're back to yo-yoing for a while. The first half season of Bilic was a breath of fresh air, promotion gave us a boost. The Prem season was awful and now (maybe) we're in with a chance of doing well back in the Champ.
So I'm asking, at what point in recent Albion history (say since 1981) were we really happy with the manager, the squad, the style of play, the way the club was being run, the results we were getting? Have there been many moments when fans would say "well that was OK" on deadline day? I think not. We are an up-and-down club with a set of fans who aren't smug, self-satisfied or blindly loyal. It becomes a habit to look for the catch and boards like this offer the ideal medium for some industrial quality grumbling. It's part of the whole experience.
Spot on Chesh.
If you go back 20 years we can only have dreamt of the success we've had since then, based on the previous 20!
Hi Hopalong, for me I'd say Fulham, Stoke, Boro and Bournemouth have all strengthened better than we have, QPR have a decent squad too and Andre Gray may split opinion but is arguably on a par with Hugill if not better
Fulham apart I'd say the others have closed the gap on us in personally in terms of quality and depth
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(09-01-2021, 09:09 AM)Duffers Wrote: I don’t particularly care about going up anymore. I obviously understand the importance from a financial stability perspective, but the Premier League holds little interest for me anymore. I just want to enjoy watching Albion again, regardless of division. I want to see a committed, attacking team and that’s what I’m seeing at the moment, so I’m happy.
I enjoy watching premier league football, but I dont enjoy watching us at that level.
The strategic leadership at the club currently, isn't good enough to make us sufficiently competitive at premiership level to make it that enjoyable to watch us.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(09-01-2021, 10:56 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:53 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:27 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:18 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:17 AM)MassDebater Wrote: May as well watch that goal ball game then if that is all that counts. Like I say, I'm currently feeling somewhat indifferent to this season.
I don't understand what you want, sorry i don't.
Skilled players playing football, where we pass the ball around with a bit of style and maybe even some finesse, that leads to scoring opportunities and maybe some goals. Maybe heck we'll look composed on the ball and in control of things for a bit.
Currently we have a park's team that basically just swarms the ball and bundles it in. Yes we are scoring, yes we are shooting, but that really is about it. And yes at times it has been enjoyable and fun, but The Posh game I found incredibly dull, and I'm expecting more of that this season. I don't like the 'dark arts' that a lot on here are now lauding, I hated it when Italy beat England using them, even though I know a lot praise them for it.
Personal preference innit? I like pretty football, and yes I do appreciate effort, usually when we're the underdog, not the favourite though.
As I said I mostly stopped only wanting us to win a while ago. What's the prize? Oh yeah, another season of utter abject rubbish in the Prem.
Honestly, MD, I don't quite get what your problem is. We play high energy, not terribly sophisticated football. It would be nice to see a bit of composure, but we don't yet know how things will develop during the season. Or maybe it was you who stole the seeing stone and you do know.
But what kind of football do you want to see? Ron Atkinson's team of swaggerers, with a handful of truly world class players? We haven't got that. Ossie's full scale five-a-side approach? That only just got us up from Div 2. The best moments of Mowbray, RDM and Clarke, with none of the downsides of their tenure thrown in? Unrealistic. I think you're just being contrary, sitting on the sidelines moaning like a sulky kid at a party, but still eating the cake and taking the goodie-bag home.
I'm not actually moaning. because I like a certain style does not mean that I am moaning.
Slav, RDM, Ossie and Atkinson mixed would be fine with me. And you are right no-one knows what is to come, I just can't see us getting that composure or any level of sophistication, so that makes me a moaner, I'll add it to the list under my name. What is wrong with wanting to enjoy something that has been a big part of your life?
It's hilarious, because I was one of the original happy clappers way back when, I guess several promotions and the expected demises have just changed my views on what I want to see.
I think (hope) that we might become a bit more composed as the season goes on. We may have focussed early in the Val era on the most important thing of getting the ball and players into the danger area as quickly as possible to give us the best chance of winning games. This buys the manager time and the backing of fans to gradually refine things. If we'd have put playing in a more composed manner as top of our priorities then maybe we'd not have got as many points and the manager and team would be under more pressure which doesn't help matters.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(09-01-2021, 12:34 PM)TartanRug Wrote: (09-01-2021, 10:56 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:53 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:27 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-01-2021, 08:18 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't understand what you want, sorry i don't.
Skilled players playing football, where we pass the ball around with a bit of style and maybe even some finesse, that leads to scoring opportunities and maybe some goals. Maybe heck we'll look composed on the ball and in control of things for a bit.
Currently we have a park's team that basically just swarms the ball and bundles it in. Yes we are scoring, yes we are shooting, but that really is about it. And yes at times it has been enjoyable and fun, but The Posh game I found incredibly dull, and I'm expecting more of that this season. I don't like the 'dark arts' that a lot on here are now lauding, I hated it when Italy beat England using them, even though I know a lot praise them for it.
Personal preference innit? I like pretty football, and yes I do appreciate effort, usually when we're the underdog, not the favourite though.
As I said I mostly stopped only wanting us to win a while ago. What's the prize? Oh yeah, another season of utter abject rubbish in the Prem.
Honestly, MD, I don't quite get what your problem is. We play high energy, not terribly sophisticated football. It would be nice to see a bit of composure, but we don't yet know how things will develop during the season. Or maybe it was you who stole the seeing stone and you do know.
But what kind of football do you want to see? Ron Atkinson's team of swaggerers, with a handful of truly world class players? We haven't got that. Ossie's full scale five-a-side approach? That only just got us up from Div 2. The best moments of Mowbray, RDM and Clarke, with none of the downsides of their tenure thrown in? Unrealistic. I think you're just being contrary, sitting on the sidelines moaning like a sulky kid at a party, but still eating the cake and taking the goodie-bag home.
I'm not actually moaning. because I like a certain style does not mean that I am moaning.
Slav, RDM, Ossie and Atkinson mixed would be fine with me. And you are right no-one knows what is to come, I just can't see us getting that composure or any level of sophistication, so that makes me a moaner, I'll add it to the list under my name. What is wrong with wanting to enjoy something that has been a big part of your life?
It's hilarious, because I was one of the original happy clappers way back when, I guess several promotions and the expected demises have just changed my views on what I want to see.
I think (hope) that we might become a bit more composed as the season goes on. We may have focussed early in the Val era on the most important thing of getting the ball and players into the danger area as quickly as possible to give us the best chance of winning games. This buys the manager time and the backing of fans to gradually refine things. If we'd have put playing in a more composed manner as top of our priorities then maybe we'd not have got as many points and the manager and team would be under more pressure which doesn't help matters.
Hopefully you are correct, time will tell.
|