Investment/wasting money
#1
So now the dust has settled, and we have all had time to take in the multiple freds about the squad, and strength in depth etc. etc. 

I have been thinking about our constant battle in previous seasons. We have always had ageing squads when relegated, had huge turn overs of first team players, and we have signed players that are too good for the championship but not quite good enough to be PL regulars. But this time we have got relegated with for the most part, a first XI being in their mid twenties, are seasoned Championship performers, with many showing they have what it takes to play a part if we were to be promoted. 

This year we have neither (had to) invested in risky signings ala Ajayi, Kipre, Furlong, Townsend, but neither have we wasted money on people like Zohore, Austin, Grosiki, who would never offer owt in the prem.  We now have the opportunity, if we do get promoted to invest solely in players who are premier league quality, which can be the cherries on our functional cake of a squad. A nice position to be in finally.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
I still think Austin would do a job in a team that revolves around him. He couldn't play Valball, but if he stays fit he is a 20+ striker in The Chump.
Reply
#3
(09-01-2021, 08:56 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I still think Austin would do a job in a team that revolves around him. He couldn't play Valball, but if he stays fit he is a 20+ striker in The Chump.

That kind of the point I am making, I think. 

In previous years we have had to waste money, both in terms of fees and wages across multiple year contracts on players that had no use to us in the league we are aiming to get into. Which has always put us on the back foot in the following window.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#4
Agree with that Lurker.
Reply
#5
(09-01-2021, 09:12 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-01-2021, 08:56 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I still think Austin would do a job in a team that revolves around him. He couldn't play Valball, but if he stays fit he is a 20+ striker in The Chump.

That kind of the point I am making, I think. 

In previous years we have had to waste money, both in terms of fees and wages across multiple year contracts on players that had no use to us in the league we are aiming to get into. Which has always put us on the back foot in the following window.

Which of the signings that we've made this season have any real use to us in the league we're aiming to get back into? Mowatt possibly, but the rest, no.

We've also got a much worse squad than the one that fell massively short last time we were there.

This season's recruitment was all about consolidating the players we had and investing sensibly in players that we feel we could develop with the view to stepping up or selling on, and put simply we have not done that.  Yes we have a competitive squad for the division we are in, and yes we are fortunate to be carrying few legacy costs of this season into next year, but should we get promoted we're going to need a LOT of investment to be anything other than a laughing stock again.
Reply
#6
(09-01-2021, 09:30 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-01-2021, 09:12 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-01-2021, 08:56 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I still think Austin would do a job in a team that revolves around him. He couldn't play Valball, but if he stays fit he is a 20+ striker in The Chump.

That kind of the point I am making, I think. 

In previous years we have had to waste money, both in terms of fees and wages across multiple year contracts on players that had no use to us in the league we are aiming to get into. Which has always put us on the back foot in the following window.

Which of the signings that we've made this season have any real use to us in the league we're aiming to get back into? Mowatt possibly, but the rest, no.

We've also got a much worse squad than the one that fell massively short last time we were there.

This season's recruitment was all about consolidating the players we had and investing sensibly in players that we feel we could develop with the view to stepping up or selling on, and put simply we have not done that.  Yes we have a competitive squad for the division we are in, and yes we are fortunate to be carrying few legacy costs of this season into next year, but should we get promoted we're going to need a LOT of investment to be anything other than a laughing stock again.

I disagree with the notion out squad now is "much worse" than the one we got promoted with last time around. It may not be as deep  in terms of senior names. But our starting XI and bench is just as strong as it was.

With regards to your first point. None, thats the point. We have invested little money in permanent transfers, in terms of both fees and contract value. We are basing our current players as the important core, a core that will go up with us. We have no players kn loan which will be that important to us that any transfer budget next year will have to be used on them. Clarke, Molumby and Hugill would combine cost no more than Periera you would feel  if we did want to keep them for any prem involvement. 

If we go up  we would need 5 EPL level signings, as always. The remaining 18 would form the squad and underbelly.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#7
I didn’t say the squad was much worse than the last time we got promoted - it’s weaker for sure, but so is the division so they cancel eachother out. What I said is that our squad is massively weaker than the one that competed in the PL last season.

If we are to get promoted this season we will need massive work to make this side even remotely fit for purpose next year… who in the squad currently could operate at PL level? Johnstone, Townsend, Mowatt… the rest are squad fillers at best.

The only way we will ever stop the yo-yo’ing will be if we invest into players we believe we can develop into PL players at this level - we need to be finding our Toney, Watkins, Maddison, Wilson etc… and the only way we will do that is by actually buying players.

We’ve kept the bulk of the players together, we’ve made a couple good loan signings… but to what end? Promotion and a need to buy far more players than we are likely to afford.
Reply
#8
I’m genuinely tired of the same old trope of this being a weak squad without any real analysis. I’ve tried to do this on a few threads but it gets ignored because it doesn’t fit the narrative.

What is starting to grate is we are singularly looking as players as individual talent and not looking at the tactics, system and the collective.

As I laid out in the other thread this team 1 to 18 is as good if not better than 19/20 in my opinion because we have players who fit the system, they have a role and capability match and the players as a collective understand their jobs.

I do agree we would need significant investment of promoted, however, and this is key, we wouldn’t have to use that investment simply to retain the players that got us promoted. Think Krov, Diang, Robinson et al - all with loan fees, transfer fees and signings on in excess of £20m. Then there’s there’s the £16m paid for Grant. If Molumby and Clarke make the grade that’s probably £3-5m.

I think investing £25-30m correctly in this team would give us a much stronger chance of being competitive to stay up than the squad we had at the end of the Summer transfer window last year. If Val is here I know we also have a much better chance of spending it wisely.
Reply
#9
(09-01-2021, 08:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: So now the dust has settled, and we have all had time to take in the multiple freds about the squad, and strength in depth etc. etc. 

I have been thinking about our constant battle in previous seasons. We have always had ageing squads when relegated, had huge turn overs of first team players, and we have signed players that are too good for the championship but not quite good enough to be PL regulars. But this time we have got relegated with for the most part, a first XI being in their mid twenties, are seasoned Championship performers, with many showing they have what it takes to play a part if we were to be promoted. 

This year we have neither (had to) invested in risky signings ala Ajayi, Kipre, Furlong, Townsend, but neither have we wasted money on people like Zohore, Austin, Grosiki, who would never offer owt in the prem.  We now have the opportunity, if we do get promoted to invest solely in players who are premier league quality, which can be the cherries on our functional cake of a squad. A nice position to be in finally.

Good post/analysis Lurker. 

If we maintain our position,  hopefully we will be progressively scouting inexpensive players that would help to keep us there, especially Bosmans. 

West Ham have picked up three from Czech Republic.  Soucek was expensive but the other two affordable.  Brighton picked up Moder who looks useful. Also the likes of Chalobah who we were close to getting - the Euros/injuries gave him the opportunity which he's grabbed with both hands - but you just feel with the players they're signing he'll possibly be available next summer.  

There have to be more Geras out there - in fact Hungary looked quite good in the Euros.
Reply
#10
Our first 11 isn’t as strong as it was. Some players that couldn’t get in the first team have improved, but Pereira alone puts that team ahead of this one.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)