Well thats that then....
#11
(08-31-2021, 01:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Squad seems fine to me, little thin but that's the risk. As you said first team wise it's top 2 in the league, Ajayi and Grady can perform very well at this level as we've seen before, Moloumby will add some energy and take some off the load of Livermore and Mowatt, Snodgrass has some quality, Hugill can be that physical presence to disrupt defences if we need as seen at Posh. Really it's mainly the full back/wing back position for me that we don't have someone able to come in straightaway as we did with Furlong and Townsend under Slav, not convinced with Reach yet.

To be honest though, I thought we'd start slow and grow into the season. We've given ourselves a hell of a platform with a couple of tough games at the start.

a fit Philips could cover right wing back for me. and would be decent at this level.

Reach at the mo doesnt look of the required quality, harsh after a couple of games i know. lets hope Connor stays fit
Reply
#12
(08-31-2021, 01:12 PM)Rom2021 Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Squad seems fine to me, little thin but that's the risk. As you said first team wise it's top 2 in the league, Ajayi and Grady can perform very well at this level as we've seen before, Moloumby will add some energy and take some off the load of Livermore and Mowatt, Snodgrass has some quality, Hugill can be that physical presence to disrupt defences if we need as seen at Posh. Really it's mainly the full back/wing back position for me that we don't have someone able to come in straightaway as we did with Furlong and Townsend under Slav, not convinced with Reach yet.

To be honest though, I thought we'd start slow and grow into the season. We've given ourselves a hell of a platform with a couple of tough games at the start.

a fit Philips could cover right wing back for me. and would be decent at this level.

Reach at the mo doesnt look of the required quality, harsh after a couple of games i know. lets hope Connor stays fit
You never know with injuries but Townsend  does look like he has games in him, unlike Crisp Packet Legs. He went off with a muscle injury for Orlando last week, BTW.
Reply
#13
(08-31-2021, 01:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:12 PM)Rom2021 Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Squad seems fine to me, little thin but that's the risk. As you said first team wise it's top 2 in the league, Ajayi and Grady can perform very well at this level as we've seen before, Moloumby will add some energy and take some off the load of Livermore and Mowatt, Snodgrass has some quality, Hugill can be that physical presence to disrupt defences if we need as seen at Posh. Really it's mainly the full back/wing back position for me that we don't have someone able to come in straightaway as we did with Furlong and Townsend under Slav, not convinced with Reach yet.

To be honest though, I thought we'd start slow and grow into the season. We've given ourselves a hell of a platform with a couple of tough games at the start.

a fit Philips could cover right wing back for me. and would be decent at this level.

Reach at the mo doesnt look of the required quality, harsh after a couple of games i know. lets hope Connor stays fit
You never know with injuries but Townsend  does look like he has games in him, unlike Crisp Packet Legs. He went off with a muscle injury for Orlando last week, BTW.

It's bad but I can't stop laughing at that
Reply
#14
(08-31-2021, 01:06 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:03 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:01 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 12:58 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: And we were all patting ourselves on the back after the 2018 window when Pulis was pulling rabbits out of the hat only for us to be rock bottom and gone a few months later.

Truth is we don't know how it will all pan out and there may well be 2 or 3 guys who make the breakthrough as well. We really have no idea what is happening behind the scenes.

We are top 2 after 5 games and things are not so bad.

Exactly.

Remember that last Pulis window everyone felt we were ready to push on as a club, media saying we won the transfer window, other clubs fans jealous.

We got relegated.

I also remember us signing Austin, Periera and Diangana on deadline day in 2019.

We got promoted.

Yes, because the manager wanted them.

Val seems happy with what we have. He likes small squads, covered by young players, like Bielsa, like Klopp.

If he was unhappy then the concerns of fans are fair, but he's actually had what he wanted, barring Dike which was impossible, and it dies seem we'll try again in January.

Yup seems that way.

My concern however is that Val's methods have never been tested over a 50 game season... his successes came in the lower leagues in Germany and in Austria where seasons are 30-36 games... another 10 league games plus the cups at the intensity of the Championship is a a very different test for this level of football. For all the lauding of Bielsa, Leeds collapsed in his first season and were fortunate COVID gave them a recovery period second time round, and Barnsley looked leggy going into the play-offs.

Whether that will be a factor or not, only time will tell... let's just hope we can get through to January without too many injuries/suspensions and regroup.
Reply
#15
(08-31-2021, 01:26 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:06 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:03 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:01 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 12:58 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: And we were all patting ourselves on the back after the 2018 window when Pulis was pulling rabbits out of the hat only for us to be rock bottom and gone a few months later.

Truth is we don't know how it will all pan out and there may well be 2 or 3 guys who make the breakthrough as well. We really have no idea what is happening behind the scenes.

We are top 2 after 5 games and things are not so bad.

Exactly.

Remember that last Pulis window everyone felt we were ready to push on as a club, media saying we won the transfer window, other clubs fans jealous.

We got relegated.

I also remember us signing Austin, Periera and Diangana on deadline day in 2019.

We got promoted.

Yes, because the manager wanted them.

Val seems happy with what we have. He likes small squads, covered by young players, like Bielsa, like Klopp.

If he was unhappy then the concerns of fans are fair, but he's actually had what he wanted, barring Dike which was impossible, and it dies seem we'll try again in January.

Yup seems that way.

My concern however is that Val's methods have never been tested over a 50 game season... his successes came in the lower leagues in Germany and in Austria where seasons are 30-36 games... another 10 league games plus the cups at the intensity of the Championship is a a very different test for this level of football. For all the lauding of Bielsa, Leeds collapsed in his first season and were fortunate COVID gave them a recovery period second time round, and Barnsley looked leggy going into the play-offs.

Whether that will be a factor or not, only time will tell... let's just hope we can get through to January without too many injuries/suspensions and regroup.

We have better players than Leeds, once the fitness left them, they had little quality to fall back on. As shown the other night, we can grind results out when we're not doing well.

Leeds didn't actually burn out, stats wise their running stats etc never dropped, however they seemed to bottle it, mentally and technically.
Reply
#16
It really shouldn’t be the case, but having a chance at promotion at this point involves crossing our fingers and praying for no injuries. There are teams who have spent 5-6 years in the champ with a better squad depth than ourselves.
Reply
#17
(08-31-2021, 01:30 PM)Sliced Wrote: It really shouldn’t be the case, but having a chance at promotion at this point involves crossing our fingers and praying for no injuries. There are teams who have spent 5-6 years in the champ with a better squad depth than ourselves.

Bites....but is bored at work. Like?
Reply
#18
(08-31-2021, 01:30 PM)Sliced Wrote: It really shouldn’t be the case, but having a chance at promotion at this point involves crossing our fingers and praying for no injuries. There are teams who have spent 5-6 years in the champ with a better squad depth than ourselves.

We don't know for sure what injuries will do, until they happen. We have got players, some are academy graduates, we don't know whether they can cover for an injury or not, Val is happy they can.

Or would you rather we wasted our very, very little budget on squad players that return no value, and are deadweight next season should we go up, preventing us signing more?

We are in a troublesome position, this is really the best solution for me, get a manager who knows how, and prefers to work with a small squad, use our genuinely top class medical and sports science team and get up so we actually gave a better Sumner should we go up. And hopefully some youth players become full first team squad members.
Reply
#19
(08-31-2021, 01:33 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(08-31-2021, 01:30 PM)Sliced Wrote: It really shouldn’t be the case, but having a chance at promotion at this point involves crossing our fingers and praying for no injuries. There are teams who have spent 5-6 years in the champ with a better squad depth than ourselves.

Bites....but is bored at work. Like?

better squad depth does not equal better players though. Fewer of better quality beats more of lower quality...mostly... Until the suspensions and injuries kick in...
Reply
#20
(08-31-2021, 01:30 PM)Sliced Wrote: It really shouldn’t be the case, but having a chance at promotion at this point involves crossing our fingers and praying for no injuries. There are teams who have spent 5-6 years in the champ with a better squad depth than ourselves.

be interested to see who you think has a better bench than this? outside of B'mouth, Fulham , Sheff united ( on paper) 

Diangana, Hurgil, Ajeyi , Reach , Mulomby , Snoddy , Button
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)