Best squad in the division
#11
It’s one of the best squads in the league and this is a season we have a good chance of promotion. This opportunity may become more difficult IF we don’t get promotion. There is nothing in this statement that isn’t true and those trying to crowbar bullshit about agenda’s etc is not looking at the situation objectively.

We still have a great chance to go up via the play-offs and a slim chance via the auto’s but could we have done better so far? Maybe in my opinion by playing to the players strengths but it’s an hypothetical argument as we will never know.
Reply
#12
Playing devils advocate who does have a stronger squad?
Reply
#13
(03-02-2019, 07:34 AM)aj21 Wrote: Why the fuck does this line keep getting pedalled out? 

Best squad? So where are all the left and right backs that we needed all season...we didn’t have a right back for the first half of the season and with Gibbs injured we have no left back bar Townsend who is clearly a league one player and cost buttons.

We have some really good players but that Leeds team is full of young quick hungry players, just because you lot who pedal this best squad haven’t heard of them doesn’t mean that they aren’t better.

Why is our squad the best? Barry has become a pivotal player, he’s 38 and the last two games have showed up his lack of pace, no one expected us to have to rely on him this season. 

So many of you call HRK shit - why has he had to play such a major role if we have the best squad in the division.

Our scouting network has cleary disappeared, Pulis never signed foreign players and all our signings have been from the UK, Norwich and Leeds have both picked up quality players from across Europe. I said at the start of the season our squad is OAPs, kids and loans - it’s not easy to make that work

Pulis never signed foreign players?

Rondon

Hegazi

Krychowiak


Etc. 
Reply
#14
(03-02-2019, 07:34 AM)aj21 Wrote: Why the fuck does this line keep getting pedalled out? 

Best squad? So where are all the left and right backs that we needed all season...we didn’t have a right back for the first half of the season and with Gibbs injured we have no left back bar Townsend who is clearly a league one player and cost buttons.
We have some really good players but that Leeds team is full of young quick hungry players, just because you lot who pedal this best squad haven’t heard
of them doesn’t mean that they aren’t better.


Why is our squad the best? Barry has become a pivotal player, he’s 38 and the last two games have showed up his lack of pace, no one expected us to have to rely on him this season. 

So many of you call HRK shit - why has he had to play such a major role if we have the best squad in the division.

Our scouting network has cleary disappeared, Pulis never signed foreign players and all our signings have been from the UK, Norwich and Leeds have both picked up quality players from across Europe. I said at the start of the season our squad is OAPs, kids and loans - it’s not easy to make that work

This is a really good point.

There is no doubt we have a good squad for this division, maybe even a very good squad, and I think we will secure a play off place. But not one that I think is good enough to get into the top 2.

The point about Barry is apposite, there isn't a player in the division who could touch Barry when he was it his peak, but at 38 he is no longer capable of matching players like Phillips of Leeds.

(03-02-2019, 08:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s one of the best squads in the league and this is a season we have a good chance of promotion. This opportunity may become more difficult IF we don’t get promotion. There is nothing in this statement that isn’t true and those trying to crowbar bullshit about agenda’s etc is not looking at the situation objectively.

We still have a great chance to go up via the play-offs and a slim chance via the auto’s but could we have done better so far? Maybe in my opinion by playing to the players strengths but it’s an hypothetical argument as we will never know.

And I agree with this as well.
Reply
#15
It's how we are utilizing our squad that is the issue. Sheff Utd have a whole squad that cost about the same as we payed for a single player like Livermore
Reply
#16
We have some excellent individual players.

We don't have the best squad in the division, that's Leeds or Norwich, because they have squads that were built with a purpose in mind and the players belnd well together.
Reply
#17
(03-02-2019, 08:06 AM)clem4england Wrote:
(03-02-2019, 07:51 AM)aj21 Wrote:
(03-02-2019, 07:45 AM)clem4england Wrote: Those two teams play systems to suit those young or foreign talents and new players fit in like a glove. Does our system suit our players? We are playing a system that actually hinders players - Dawson, Hegazi, Gayle etc. Make Pontus Jansson into a ballplaying centre half and watch him struggle too.

Agree tactically it’s been poor but it’s a myth we have the best squad in the league
Until January I agreed with you as the balance was all wrong but now the squad looks better balanced albeit we lost our best player.

We have some very good players but there is something not right. Tactics, fitness, understanding the system. Whatever it is it has rarely worked all season apart from Barnes’ moments of genius.

Never under estimate how big a loss Barnes was in our set up.
His brilliance got us of the sh8te on so many occasions remember and terrified the opposition when we broke.
Remember the dire away performances at the start of the season where Forest, Birmingham and Sheff Wed ? They all destroyed us similar to Leeds but failed the put the goals away and we nicked something undeserved due to Barnes and Phillips's individual brilliance.
Reply
#18
(03-02-2019, 10:00 AM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
(03-02-2019, 08:06 AM)clem4england Wrote:
(03-02-2019, 07:51 AM)aj21 Wrote:
(03-02-2019, 07:45 AM)clem4england Wrote: Those two teams play systems to suit those young or foreign talents and new players fit in like a glove. Does our system suit our players? We are playing a system that actually hinders players - Dawson, Hegazi, Gayle etc. Make Pontus Jansson into a ballplaying centre half and watch him struggle too.

Agree tactically it’s been poor but it’s a myth we have the best squad in the league
Until January I agreed with you as the balance was all wrong but now the squad looks better balanced albeit we lost our best player.

We have some very good players but there is something not right. Tactics, fitness, understanding the system. Whatever it is it has rarely worked all season apart from Barnes’ moments of genius.

Never under estimate how big a loss Barnes was in our set up.
His brilliance got us of the sh8te on so many occasions remember and terrified the opposition when we broke.
Remember the dire away performances at the start of the season where Forest, Birmingham and Sheff Wed ? They all destroyed us similar to Leeds but failed the put the goals away and we nicked something undeserved due to Barnes and Phillips's individual brilliance.

Phillips in particular has been the huge miss. The goals he got against Forest and Birmingham, particularly the latter were completely against the run of play. We could have done with that last night. Had we even slightly rattled Leeds, things could have been different. Unfortunately it was the dream performance for them, start to finish.

Whereas Sheffield Wednesday, was Barnes brilliance enabled by DM changing the formation and flooding the midfield (could have done with that last night).
Reply
#19
(03-02-2019, 07:34 AM)aj21 Wrote: Why the fuck does this line keep getting pedalled out? 

Best squad? So where are all the left and right backs that we needed all season...we didn’t have a right back for the first half of the season and with Gibbs injured we have no left back bar Townsend who is clearly a league one player and cost buttons.

We have some really good players but that Leeds team is full of young quick hungry players, just because you lot who pedal this best squad haven’t heard of them doesn’t mean that they aren’t better.

Why is our squad the best? Barry has become a pivotal player, he’s 38 and the last two games have showed up his lack of pace, no one expected us to have to rely on him this season. 

So many of you call HRK shit - why has he had to play such a major role if we have the best squad in the division.

Our scouting network has cleary disappeared, Pulis never signed foreign players and all our signings have been from the UK, Norwich and Leeds have both picked up quality players from across Europe. I said at the start of the season our squad is OAPs, kids and loans - it’s not easy to make that work

Nail on head spot on AJ we been lucky with individual performances papering over the cracks and deficiencies in the squad once that stopped we were always going to struggle, some on here with the "best squad" line are refusing to accept the evidence in front of them.
Reply
#20
(03-02-2019, 09:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We have some excellent individual players.

We don't have the best squad in the division, that's Leeds or Norwich, because they have squads that were built with a purpose in mind and the players belnd well together.

Totally agree Birdman.

We have the greatest depth of squad, so we can go to a place like Bolton and win fairly comfortably despite having a good number of first team players missing. 

But when we are up against the very best teams in the league, not sure we have enough. 

Its a fair point about Barnes, but it's not just him is it. Phillips has been missing since Xmas and Livermore's form has fallen off a cliff since returning from suspension. Those are key performers from the first half of the season, who we are missing at the moment.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: