England v India
#51
(08-16-2021, 01:14 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: those 2 openers should never play for England again.
I'd rather pick the one day openers and accept that it may only come off 50% of the time than 2 players who can only score in one area each and have no sign of being able to take on any bowler. Pathetic shower those pair

I'd say they've kept their place for the last 6 months based on the lack of talent in the County Championship. The alternative is Jason Roy who was routinely found out the last time he played test cricket and averaged less than 20. The ECB have made it clear they will never pick Alex Hales again so I don't know where they turn.
Reply
#52
(08-16-2021, 01:35 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 01:14 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: those 2 openers should never play for England again.
I'd rather pick the one day openers and accept that it may only come off 50% of the time than 2 players who can only score in one area each and have no sign of being able to take on any bowler. Pathetic shower those pair

I'd say they've kept their place for the last 6 months based on the lack of talent in the County Championship. The alternative is Jason Roy who was routinely found out the last time he played test cricket and averaged less than 20. The ECB have made it clear they will never pick Alex Hales again so I don't know where they turn.

absolutely agree. My issue with a player like Sibley is he has no real scoring shots. He basically plays the same innings every game. Regardless of game situation or what's needed. He has no way of upping the scoring rate, doesn't look to rotate the strike and basically goes nowhere.

As for Roy, you are spot on, but one thing you know with him is he has the ability to take a game to the bowlers. I've never seen Sibley do that.
Hameed should be the next opener and Malan should be back in at 3 IMO.
Reply
#53
Harsh on Burns IMO, he’s average but he’s as good as we’ve got IMO.

Roy was garbage.

Hameed has a lot to prove yet. First baller first innings and already dropped at slip on 6 today. This is his kind of situation though so he needs to dig in.
Reply
#54
Hameed must be given a run. Burns probably will get longer. Sibley must be dropped. Malan or Vince are the only realistic alternatives. Vince annoyingly gets out for 35-40 once set, but I'd take that right now!
Reply
#55
Burns' dismissal was bizarre.

Managing to get caught at mid-off from a ball outside the leg stump was the kind of thing that used to happen at the level I played at.
Reply
#56
(08-16-2021, 01:49 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 01:35 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 01:14 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: those 2 openers should never play for England again.
I'd rather pick the one day openers and accept that it may only come off 50% of the time than 2 players who can only score in one area each and have no sign of being able to take on any bowler. Pathetic shower those pair

I'd say they've kept their place for the last 6 months based on the lack of talent in the County Championship. The alternative is Jason Roy who was routinely found out the last time he played test cricket and averaged less than 20. The ECB have made it clear they will never pick Alex Hales again so I don't know where they turn.

absolutely agree. My issue with a player like Sibley is he has no real scoring shots. He basically plays the same innings every game. Regardless of game situation or what's needed. He has no way of upping the scoring rate, doesn't look to rotate the strike and basically goes nowhere.

As for Roy, you are spot on, but one thing you know with him is he has the ability to take a game to the bowlers. I've never seen Sibley do that.
Hameed should be the next opener and Malan should be back in at 3 IMO.

The only worry with Roy is that in test cricket bowlers know if they bowl line and length at him for ten overs then he will get himself out. Burns gets one final chance for me.

Burns, Hameed, Malan, Root, Bairstow, Buttler, Ali, Curran, Robinson, Wood, Anderson

Another failure for Rory Burns in the next game and I'd be looking for Roy, Jennings etc to come into the side.

(08-16-2021, 01:57 PM)Ossian Wrote: Burns' dismissal was bizarre.

Managing to get caught at mid-off from a ball outside the leg stump was the kind of thing that used to happen at the level I played at.

Playing the ball way out in front of himself, Sibley gets out doing it all the time. Not to mention the fact the ball Burns actually got out to he could have just allowed to go behind him.
Reply
#57
Root gone now, we'll do well to lose this from the position this morning, classic England....


Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#58
Buttler and Mo aren't the pair I would choose for a long dig-in.

My record with predictions should help them grit it out.
Reply
#59
On the bright side, we're good at turning games around. We looked like winning at noon.

I genuinely don't remember a worse batting line up in England's history. When we were crap in the 90s, we had Atherton, Stewart, Thorpe and Butcher who would stroll into this team.

Good job Anderson and Broad have lots of years left in them...oh.
Reply
#60
Not very good are we
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)