Players still taking the knee…
#61
(08-15-2021, 04:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: I will quickly have my say on this. I never normally post on anything remotely political on here.

I'm sure a good proportion of the people that boo the taking of the knee at football matches have absolutely no concept of why they are booing. I'm sure if you asked them they'd say something like "I dunno. It's political innit" or words to that effect. Agree or disagree with the taking of the knee but to boo it is fucking ridiculous when the players and the F. A have come out and said its purely an Anti Rasict gesture. Quite why supporters can't grasp that very simple message is beyond me. The players have said it's an anti racist gesture so supporters need to take them at their word.

Which brings me on to my second point.

Given that there has been opposition to the Knee, and the links to BLM and booing last season and this summer, I firmly believe that The FA and kick it out have missed a real opportunity here. They could have used this summer to see there was clearly an anti knee feeling and really owned a new initiative. If all players on each team linked arms for 10 seconds instead, standing shoulder to shoulder with their team mates of all ethnicities, I believe that would have sent out a fresh approach. To show that football will find its own way to show they are against racism in all forms.

With the right lead up to this season, and conveyed to all fans this is what was happening, I think it could have been a really positive move.

That is all.

I don’t think it’s the actual gesture that’s issue anymore. Any new gesture, whether it’s linking arms, black Panther salutes, standing on their heads… will just illicit the same reactions IMO.
Reply
#62
I must admit that i preferred Luton's arms around each other gesture more than the knee, it seemed more inclusive and more like a string statement of being together.

I didn't hear anyone boo the knee taking though.
Reply
#63
(08-15-2021, 04:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: I will quickly have my say on this. I never normally post on anything remotely political on here.

I'm sure a good proportion of the people that boo the taking of the knee at football matches have absolutely no concept of why they are booing. I'm sure if you asked them they'd say something like "I dunno. It's political innit" or words to that effect. Agree or disagree with the taking of the knee but to boo it is fucking ridiculous when the players and the F. A have come out and said its purely an Anti Rasict gesture. Quite why supporters can't grasp that very simple message is beyond me. The players have said it's an anti racist gesture so supporters need to take them at their word.

Which brings me on to my second point.

Given that there has been opposition to the Knee, and the links to BLM and booing last season and this summer, I firmly believe that The FA and kick it out have missed a real opportunity here. They could have used this summer to see there was clearly an anti knee feeling and really owned a new initiative. If all players on each team linked arms for 10 seconds instead, standing shoulder to shoulder with their team mates of all ethnicities, I believe that would have sent out a fresh approach. To show that football will find its own way to show they are against racism in all forms.

With the right lead up to this season, and conveyed to all fans this is what was happening, I think it could have been a really positive move.

That is all.

I agree with this. If the people booing are claiming to do so due to the knee potentially having alternative associations then a different gesture would eradicate this. There could then be no excuses or misunderstandings and anyone booing a new gesture would be clearly showing themselves in a negative light.
Reply
#64
(08-15-2021, 05:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: People who are anti-knee claim it’s because BLM adopted it to reflect the kneeling on the neck and they are against the politics of the BLM. 

This obviously ignores the previous anti-racism message of the gesture, the FA, the players, Kick it Out, our own manager and Gareth Southgate.

I’m sure they’re also the very same people that bemoan the Cross of St George being branded as racist just because it was used by NF, EDL and FLA for their ideologies.

(08-15-2021, 05:38 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 04:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: I will quickly have my say on this. I never normally post on anything remotely political on here.

I'm sure a good proportion of the people that boo the taking of the knee at football matches have absolutely no concept of why they are booing. I'm sure if you asked them they'd say something like "I dunno. It's political innit" or words to that effect. Agree or disagree with the taking of the knee but to boo it is fucking ridiculous when the players and the F. A have come out and said its purely an Anti Rasict gesture. Quite why supporters can't grasp that very simple message is beyond me. The players have said it's an anti racist gesture so supporters need to take them at their word.

Which brings me on to my second point.

Given that there has been opposition to the Knee, and the links to BLM and booing last season and this summer, I firmly believe that The FA and kick it out have missed a real opportunity here. They could have used this summer to see there was clearly an anti knee feeling and really owned a new initiative. If all players on each team linked arms for 10 seconds instead, standing shoulder to shoulder with their team mates of all ethnicities, I believe that would have sent out a fresh approach. To show that football will find its own way to show they are against racism in all forms.

With the right lead up to this season, and conveyed to all fans this is what was happening, I think it could have been a really positive move.

That is all.

I don’t think it’s the actual gesture that’s issue anymore. Any new gesture, whether it’s linking arms, black Panther salutes, standing on their heads… will just illicit the same reactions IMO.

That Sir, is bollocks. In my opinion of course.

(08-15-2021, 05:39 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 04:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: I will quickly have my say on this. I never normally post on anything remotely political on here.

I'm sure a good proportion of the people that boo the taking of the knee at football matches have absolutely no concept of why they are booing. I'm sure if you asked them they'd say something like "I dunno. It's political innit" or words to that effect. Agree or disagree with the taking of the knee but to boo it is fucking ridiculous when the players and the F. A have come out and said its purely an Anti Rasict gesture. Quite why supporters can't grasp that very simple message is beyond me. The players have said it's an anti racist gesture so supporters need to take them at their word.

Which brings me on to my second point.

Given that there has been opposition to the Knee, and the links to BLM and booing last season and this summer, I firmly believe that The FA and kick it out have missed a real opportunity here. They could have used this summer to see there was clearly an anti knee feeling and really owned a new initiative. If all players on each team linked arms for 10 seconds instead, standing shoulder to shoulder with their team mates of all ethnicities, I believe that would have sent out a fresh approach. To show that football will find its own way to show they are against racism in all forms.

With the right lead up to this season, and conveyed to all fans this is what was happening, I think it could have been a really positive move.

That is all.

I agree with this. If the people booing are claiming to do so due to the knee potentially having alternative associations then a different gesture would eradicate this. There could then be no excuses or misunderstandings and anyone booing a new gesture would be clearly showing themselves in a negative light.

Correct. At the moment racists have a get out clause due to where the gesture came from
Reply
#65
(08-15-2021, 03:34 PM)Wotty Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:51 PM)sickParrot Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:41 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:34 PM)Wotty Wrote: What Luton did is much better imo.
Showing a togetherness against racism and moving away from the knee which is still dividing people.
It’s sad that you either agree with that particular gesture (the knee) or you’re a racist and seemingly a wanker. Really sad.

It's been said many times that it's a stand against racism and nothing to do with politics. Not really sure why you'd be against it if you want to see a end to racism.

Agree, there is only one reason anyone would be against this.

There really isn’t and that is so ignorant and so typical of the left’s attitude of agree or you’re a racist.

It’s one gesture I don’t agree with as it was created by a racist organisation ( yes I know other people have taken the knee for different reasons historically )

That does not make me a racist, because I’m not, far from it.

We really shouldn’t be implying people are racist just because they have a different view, it’s extremely insulting and quite frankly should not be allowed on here

Who are "the left" in this instance? Should I be forming a mental image of Peter Mandelson, or Derek Hatton? Clement Attlee or Pol Pot? 

Just for context.
Reply
#66
(08-15-2021, 07:48 PM)Ossian Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 03:34 PM)Wotty Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:51 PM)sickParrot Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:41 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:34 PM)Wotty Wrote: What Luton did is much better imo.
Showing a togetherness against racism and moving away from the knee which is still dividing people.
It’s sad that you either agree with that particular gesture (the knee) or you’re a racist and seemingly a wanker. Really sad.

It's been said many times that it's a stand against racism and nothing to do with politics. Not really sure why you'd be against it if you want to see a end to racism.

Agree, there is only one reason anyone would be against this.

There really isn’t and that is so ignorant and so typical of the left’s attitude of agree or you’re a racist.

It’s one gesture I don’t agree with as it was created by a racist organisation ( yes I know other people have taken the knee for different reasons historically )

That does not make me a racist, because I’m not, far from it.

We really shouldn’t be implying people are racist just because they have a different view, it’s extremely insulting and quite frankly should not be allowed on here

Who are "the left" in this instance? Should I be forming a mental image of Peter Mandelson, or Derek Hatton? Clement Attlee or Pol Pot? 

Just for context.

“It’s disgraceful that people who don’t like the knee are generalised as racists”… “this is what the left does”.

It’s like rayaaaaaaaaaan on your wedding day…
Reply
#67
(08-15-2021, 02:34 PM)Wotty Wrote: What Luton did is much better imo.
Showing a togetherness against racism and moving away from the knee which is still dividing people.
It’s sad that you either agree with that particular gesture (the knee) or you’re a racist and seemingly a wanker. Really sad.

I'm really pleased that the players taking the knee upsets you so much.
Reply
#68
(08-15-2021, 08:02 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 07:48 PM)Ossian Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 03:34 PM)Wotty Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:51 PM)sickParrot Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:41 PM)tiptontown Wrote: It's been said many times that it's a stand against racism and nothing to do with politics. Not really sure why you'd be against it if you want to see a end to racism.

Agree, there is only one reason anyone would be against this.

There really isn’t and that is so ignorant and so typical of the left’s attitude of agree or you’re a racist.

It’s one gesture I don’t agree with as it was created by a racist organisation ( yes I know other people have taken the knee for different reasons historically )

That does not make me a racist, because I’m not, far from it.

We really shouldn’t be implying people are racist just because they have a different view, it’s extremely insulting and quite frankly should not be allowed on here

Who are "the left" in this instance? Should I be forming a mental image of Peter Mandelson, or Derek Hatton? Clement Attlee or Pol Pot? 

Just for context.

“It’s disgraceful that people who don’t like the knee are generalised as racists”… “this is what the left does”.

It’s like rayaaaaaaaaaan on your wedding day…

(08-15-2021, 08:20 PM)Moore Than Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 02:34 PM)Wotty Wrote: What Luton did is much better imo.
Showing a togetherness against racism and moving away from the knee which is still dividing people.
It’s sad that you either agree with that particular gesture (the knee) or you’re a racist and seemingly a wanker. Really sad.

I'm really pleased that the players taking the knee upsets you so much.

It doesn’t really upset me, i don’t react to it at the game in any way, I just don’t agree with that gesture and I don't like it. I wish they’d do something else.
Reply
#69
I think it makes sense. It's why I've always been against it. 

I'm not convinced 'entertainment' is the right arena for such a gesture anyway, especially if it's mandated. However, if that's what people want to do, maybe taking away the 'baggage of the knee gesture would make sense. It would be interesting to see who booed it then. Although I'm guessing it would be explained as booing a political (?!) gesture still.   

You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink.
Reply
#70
(08-15-2021, 05:49 PM)Wotty Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 05:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: People who are anti-knee claim it’s because BLM adopted it to reflect the kneeling on the neck and they are against the politics of the BLM. 

This obviously ignores the previous anti-racism message of the gesture, the FA, the players, Kick it Out, our own manager and Gareth Southgate.

I’m sure they’re also the very same people that bemoan the Cross of St George being branded as racist just because it was used by NF, EDL and FLA for their ideologies.

(08-15-2021, 05:38 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 04:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: I will quickly have my say on this. I never normally post on anything remotely political on here.

I'm sure a good proportion of the people that boo the taking of the knee at football matches have absolutely no concept of why they are booing. I'm sure if you asked them they'd say something like "I dunno. It's political innit" or words to that effect. Agree or disagree with the taking of the knee but to boo it is fucking ridiculous when the players and the F. A have come out and said its purely an Anti Rasict gesture. Quite why supporters can't grasp that very simple message is beyond me. The players have said it's an anti racist gesture so supporters need to take them at their word.

Which brings me on to my second point.

Given that there has been opposition to the Knee, and the links to BLM and booing last season and this summer, I firmly believe that The FA and kick it out have missed a real opportunity here. They could have used this summer to see there was clearly an anti knee feeling and really owned a new initiative. If all players on each team linked arms for 10 seconds instead, standing shoulder to shoulder with their team mates of all ethnicities, I believe that would have sent out a fresh approach. To show that football will find its own way to show they are against racism in all forms.

With the right lead up to this season, and conveyed to all fans this is what was happening, I think it could have been a really positive move.

That is all.

I don’t think it’s the actual gesture that’s issue anymore. Any new gesture, whether it’s linking arms, black Panther salutes, standing on their heads… will just illicit the same reactions IMO.

That Sir, is bollocks. In my opinion of course.

(08-15-2021, 05:39 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(08-15-2021, 04:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: I will quickly have my say on this. I never normally post on anything remotely political on here.

I'm sure a good proportion of the people that boo the taking of the knee at football matches have absolutely no concept of why they are booing. I'm sure if you asked them they'd say something like "I dunno. It's political innit" or words to that effect. Agree or disagree with the taking of the knee but to boo it is fucking ridiculous when the players and the F. A have come out and said its purely an Anti Rasict gesture. Quite why supporters can't grasp that very simple message is beyond me. The players have said it's an anti racist gesture so supporters need to take them at their word.

Which brings me on to my second point.

Given that there has been opposition to the Knee, and the links to BLM and booing last season and this summer, I firmly believe that The FA and kick it out have missed a real opportunity here. They could have used this summer to see there was clearly an anti knee feeling and really owned a new initiative. If all players on each team linked arms for 10 seconds instead, standing shoulder to shoulder with their team mates of all ethnicities, I believe that would have sent out a fresh approach. To show that football will find its own way to show they are against racism in all forms.

With the right lead up to this season, and conveyed to all fans this is what was happening, I think it could have been a really positive move.

That is all.

I agree with this. If the people booing are claiming to do so due to the knee potentially having alternative associations then a different gesture would eradicate this. There could then be no excuses or misunderstandings and anyone booing a new gesture would be clearly showing themselves in a negative light.

Correct. At the moment racists have a get out clause due to where the gesture came from

Yep. Exactly my point. A new gesture would be a new line in the sand. There would be no grey area's. There would be no history. There would be no government interference as it would be created by a collaboration between fa/Premier League/kick it out and owned by the players at its inception. Get all club captains together for one press conference. Done. You are either in or out.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: