Second referendum
#41
(02-27-2019, 01:02 PM)Lillwall\s left foot Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:04 PM)Beano Wrote: Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.

It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.

Thanks Beano - a valid point and a benefit to the UK by coming out of the EU. Areas that rely on seasonal workers will employ more of the local workforce during that season and reduce the welfare costs therefore allowing the government to spend more on something else e.g. the NHS.

This will also have a knock on effect of raising wages for the local workforce as well due to less competition. As you say this will mean the costs of that produce will increase but that is understood and a price worth paying (forgive the pun).

See that was easy - any more benefits?

So benefit number one is that seasonal businesses will need to pay more money to less motivated workers, thus increasing the cost of the product and potentially reducing the quality.   I'd be all for that if I saw huge queues of local workers held back at the gates and if I expected all our leave voting friends to happily swallow the hyper inflated prices that will follow. "I don't mind paying £5 for a bag of spuds, they were picked by local workers".

But then, a decent wage for a decent job helping the local economy grow, spreading profits and reduce benefits.  Who could argue with that.

Fugg,  I wish I lived in the polarized world many seem to now inhabit instead of having to look at both sides of the argument in a reasoned way.....it's bloody hard work!

Ps.  What happens to the local workforce out of season?
Pps. If your benefits were impacted for the rest of the year because you have declared a few months seasonal work....would you do it?

Never simple is it.........

All very true, and basically as I see it, but I'm still trying to understand the benefits and need the brexiteers to speak up without fear of being shot down immediately. I am genuinely intrigued as to why there is still a thought process that we will benefit from this decision.

(02-27-2019, 01:54 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Well the benefits politically or economically long term are unknown - it would be based on how well the UK managed being out of the EU and would be down to the competence of politicians and civil servants and private businesses etc. Also down to external factors like how other economies are doing and how willing they are to have a trade deal with the UK.  

The idea that the UK is leaving a constantly stunningly successful economic unit though should be challenged - the rise of the far right in Europe is tied to continual poor economic performance and the EUs austerity response. 

No surprise the vote was for out  - it was during yet another downturn when folk were pissed off. Happy folk don't vote for major change. There were also previous bad recessions in the EU prior to this so I don't despair that the UK is not capable of doing a better job long term - I do despair that the UK may not have the right parties to achieve this though and the exit from the EU looks like it will be punishing (if it happens!)

If I read into what you've said there am I right to interpret it as we don't know the future (either way) and we are taking a punt on having the right politicians, civil servants and business decision makers - which you don't think we have in place now.

I don't think that the EU is seen as a stunningly successful economic unit - I don't think that was the argument, the point always was that we are working towards a better future and being part of a large trading block helps us with trade movement and negotiating power throughout the world.

And if the vote would have been in less recessionary times we would have probably stayed in - another thing to thank Cameron for.
Reply
#42
(02-27-2019, 01:58 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 01:02 PM)Lillwall\s left foot Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:04 PM)Beano Wrote: Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.

It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.

Thanks Beano - a valid point and a benefit to the UK by coming out of the EU. Areas that rely on seasonal workers will employ more of the local workforce during that season and reduce the welfare costs therefore allowing the government to spend more on something else e.g. the NHS.

This will also have a knock on effect of raising wages for the local workforce as well due to less competition. As you say this will mean the costs of that produce will increase but that is understood and a price worth paying (forgive the pun).

See that was easy - any more benefits?

So benefit number one is that seasonal businesses will need to pay more money to less motivated workers, thus increasing the cost of the product and potentially reducing the quality.   I'd be all for that if I saw huge queues of local workers held back at the gates and if I expected all our leave voting friends to happily swallow the hyper inflated prices that will follow. "I don't mind paying £5 for a bag of spuds, they were picked by local workers".

But then, a decent wage for a decent job helping the local economy grow, spreading profits and reduce benefits.  Who could argue with that.

Fugg,  I wish I lived in the polarized world many seem to now inhabit instead of having to look at both sides of the argument in a reasoned way.....it's bloody hard work!

Ps.  What happens to the local workforce out of season?
Pps. If your benefits were impacted for the rest of the year because you have declared a few months seasonal work....would you do it?

Never simple is it.........

All very true, and basically as I see it, but I'm still trying to understand the benefits and need the brexiteers to speak up without fear of being shot down immediately. I am genuinely intrigued as to why there is still a thought process that we will benefit from this decision.


I am open to any conversation, reason  or benefit on Brexit that can be provided that isn't based around obvious bullshit or rhetoric.   Even if it does not change my.mind as a staunch remainer it may shape the way i feel about the EU, of which i still know too little. It nay help me in discussing with my kids.4  So Brexiteers please educate me as well in simple terms......what are the benefits, either economically, politically or jusy socially? to leaving. I just can't see any but thete must be some absolute doozers??
Reply
#43
(02-27-2019, 12:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:04 PM)Beano Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:51 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote: No problems Cornish.

Now - seeing as I have answered your questions. Can I ask again for you to give me one benefit to the country, the economy, our job prospects, our children's futures, or absolutely anything by leaving.

I'm afraid you haven't, you have just repeated the oft used mantra " you didn't know what you were doing " so we go again, but you know we get it, before the vote anyone voicing concerns on immigration, were racist, anyone with concerns on the EU were little englanders, you don't think any of this comes as a surprise to anyone that voted leave, we are used to being shut up, so we are just now waiting for the ultimate putdown to shut us up. If and when it happens, politicians will never be trusted again, I am confident that remain will win the losers referendum because I know of so many people that voted leave, will never put cross to paper again including me.

What negative effect did immigration have on Cornwall?

Not sure about Cornwall in particular, but I think you will find that many areas that relied on seasonal work have
seen huge challenges in opportunity following the arrival of so many Eastern European folks seeking work. That
is good and bad I suppose. Good if you run a business and want to keep costs down whilst increasing unsocial
hours, bad if your a local dependant on such work to avoid being trapped on Welfare.

It is not the fault of the East Europeans, they just want to better themselves but to believe that comes without
consequences for pay and conditions is delusional.

I asked the question I didn’t give an answer. 

However my observation is most of the jobs that the Eastern European’s do / did are ones UK people won’t do and no amount of carrot or stick from the government would ensure they would. Also why would any company want a employeee who is been forced to work anyway? 

I await the fruit pickers and cleaners from the local sink estate starting work as soon as Brexit actually happens.

Another poster pointed out that EE's offer a solution to bridge the skills gap in engineering and that is both true and
very important, the best welder that I have here is a Lithuanian lad, he is paid the best rate for that job in the business
because his work is second to none and his productivity good.

However, the FLT drivers in the local brewery work 3 shifts, 7 days a week and have fought over many years giving up
breaks and other benefits to enhance rewards. Almost all of them have been tempted by early retirement packages to leave
so terms can be changed. They have been replaced by many EE's who now work for agencies at just £9 per hour. What was
a job that the unskilled local lads could earn a decent living at, is now poorly paid for the hours and conditions. So lets not
talk just about fruit and vegetable pickers, many decent jobs have headed down the route of the race to the bottom as the
EE's accept to them, what seems good work. It is not the fault of the EE lads and lasses, some pretty poor employment
tactics have become the norm taking advantage to reduce wages and introduce poorer conditions.
Reply
#44
(02-26-2019, 04:36 PM)Only one real Albion Wrote:
(02-25-2019, 11:28 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: it would be madness for anyone in power to allow a second vote that had the option to remain on it.
Why?

It was an incredibly close vote and clearly the promises of the leave camp don't seem to stand up to the scrutiny. It was treated as a mad by-election protest vote that could impact a generation- I also think many remainers didn't think it would happen so didn't bother voting. If it's truly the will of the people then a second vote would get clarity.

After all I know at least two who voted to leave who now feel they've made a big mistake.

I'm not sure 1.5 million is that close. The only reason some want a 2nd is they can't accept defeat.
Reply
#45
(02-27-2019, 05:36 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 04:36 PM)Only one real Albion Wrote:
(02-25-2019, 11:28 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: it would be madness for anyone in power to allow a second vote that had the option to remain on it.
Why?

It was an incredibly close vote and clearly the promises of the leave camp don't seem to stand up to the scrutiny. It was treated as a mad by-election protest vote that could impact a generation- I also think many remainers didn't think it would happen so didn't bother voting. If it's truly the will of the people then a second vote would get clarity.

After all I know at least two who voted to leave who now feel they've made a big mistake.

I'm not sure 1.5 million is that close. The only reason some want a 2nd is they can't accept defeat.

It's not 1.5 million CIM, it's a swing of less than 700k needed
Reply
#46
17,410,742 voted Leave
16,141,241 voted Remain. 
1.3 million. That's quite a significant difference

If Remain won a 2nd referendum what concessions woukd they make to take into consideration the millions of Leave voters? None I suspect.
Reply
#47
Yeah, and that means you only have to have 650k people change their vote from Leave to Remain to make it swing the other way.

And what considerations would you want?
Reply
#48
how on earth can you have a second referendum when the result of the first has not been implemented?

a good chunk of mps are really letting democracy down in this country.

we as the public were asked a question.

we answered and from day one there have been way to many with power who have not respected the result.
Reply
#49
(02-27-2019, 09:38 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: how on earth can you have a second referendum when the result of the first has not been implemented?

a good chunk of mps are really letting democracy down in this country.

we as the public were asked a question.

we answered and from day one there have been way to many with power who have not respected the result.

The only reason why this is not done and dusted is that some leave supporting MPs refused to back May's deal - if they had it would be all finished.

As a remain voter I am not in favour of a second referendum, but I am even less in favour of leaving the EU without a deal. Either the ERG group get their act together and stop trying to block the best deal out there - from a leave perspective, as a remainer I think May's deal is atrocious - or risk the whole thing being sent back to the electorate to sort out.

With May's deal I see no massive economic consequences either positive or negative, we will lose significant influence and there may be massive freedom of movement issues for British people in Europe. Leave without a deal and I suspect there will be turmoil in the short term and it won't be much better in the medium term either.
Reply
#50
(02-27-2019, 09:38 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: how on earth can you have a second referendum when the result of the first has not been implemented?

a good chunk of mps are really letting democracy down in this country.

we as the public were asked a question.

we answered and from day one there have been way to many with power who have not respected the result.

The problem with the whole thing is we were asked a very simple question to a very complicated issue. 

I see nothing wrong in asking more grown up questions in a second referendum that take into account what we have learnt over the last two years. Things I have learnt are:

Both campaigns were appalling and full of misinformation 
Leaving means a lot of different things to different people
Some would jump out of a plane without a parachute for the most spurious and nebulous of reasons 
Our political parties do what is in their interest not the countries
Dogmatic mantra’s repeat ad nauseam should always come before any well thought out argument
I have grown more critical of those that voted leave than I was after the result. Particularly the over 50s who won’t really be effected by their decision but cling to an ideal that never existed. 
I haven’t heard one tangible argument that will make leaving better for us
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)