Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
To put things into perspective, this whole clickbait story seems to stem, from Nixon being asked on twitter by an Albion fan.
"It's ever so quiet at west Brom with incomings, is that likely to change anytime soon"?
Nixon replied, "Coach seems happy enough with what he has".
Hardly a big news headline saying no fuggers coming in, IMVHO.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
With addition to the squad, it's a case of do we have enough quantity and do we have enough quality.
Quality is a subjective judgement, quantity less so.
Playing 343 I think we need.
2 or 3 goalkeepers Johnstone, Button Palmer.
5 or 6 Central defenders, Bartley, O Shea, Ajayi C Clarke Kipre and poss Caleb Taylor.
4 wing backs Furlong, Townsend , Reach , Ingram
5 Central Midfield Mowatt, Livermore, Sawyers, Castro?,Taylor Hickman.
6 Forwards, Robinson, Diangana, Grant, Zohore, Tulloch Phillips Snodgrass.
I think there are a few who are capable of being in more than one category.
So I think Central Midfield is where we are short of bodies and probably quality.
I think although we have enough forwards in the squad I think we needed extra quality.
I would say 3 to 4 to come in, with 1to3 to leave based on the players mentioned above.
Posts: 1,324
Threads: 117
Joined: Dec 2020
(08-09-2021, 09:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: With addition to the squad, it's a case of do we have enough quantity and do we have enough quality.
Quality is a subjective judgement, quantity less so.
Playing 343 I think we need.
2 or 3 goalkeepers Johnstone, Button Palmer.
5 or 6 Central defenders, Bartley, O Shea, Ajayi C Clarke Kipre and poss Caleb Taylor.
4 wing backs Furlong, Townsend , Reach , Ingram
5 Central Midfield Mowatt, Livermore, Sawyers, Castro?,Taylor Hickman.
6 Forwards, Robinson, Diangana, Grant, Zohore, Tulloch Phillips Snodgrass.
I think there are a few who are capable of being in more than one category.
So I think Central Midfield is where we are short of bodies and probably quality.
I think although we have enough forwards in the squad I think we needed extra quality.
I would say 3 to 4 to come in, with 1to3 to leave based on the players mentioned above.
There is an argument that only one of our 'forwards' is a forward. And that's only if you accept Ken is even a footballer in the first place.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(08-09-2021, 11:21 AM)DJPunkRoc Wrote: (08-09-2021, 09:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: With addition to the squad, it's a case of do we have enough quantity and do we have enough quality.
Quality is a subjective judgement, quantity less so.
Playing 343 I think we need.
2 or 3 goalkeepers Johnstone, Button Palmer.
5 or 6 Central defenders, Bartley, O Shea, Ajayi C Clarke Kipre and poss Caleb Taylor.
4 wing backs Furlong, Townsend , Reach , Ingram
5 Central Midfield Mowatt, Livermore, Sawyers, Castro?,Taylor Hickman.
6 Forwards, Robinson, Diangana, Grant, Zohore, Tulloch Phillips Snodgrass.
I think there are a few who are capable of being in more than one category.
So I think Central Midfield is where we are short of bodies and probably quality.
I think although we have enough forwards in the squad I think we needed extra quality.
I would say 3 to 4 to come in, with 1to3 to leave based on the players mentioned above.
There is an argument that only one of our 'forwards' is a forward. And that's only if you accept Ken is even a footballer in the first place.
True. All our forwards are wide men. We need a proper no9
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
08-09-2021, 11:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-09-2021, 11:37 AM by Peachy.)
(08-09-2021, 08:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-09-2021, 07:53 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Striker - yes, we need an out and out no.9. Zahore to be shifted on.
6 players fighting for 3 spots:
_______ (New)
Phillips
Grady
Robinson
Grant
Tulloch
Wing backs - assuming cover exists for Townsend and Furlong. We will utilise the likes of Reach, Snodgrass and Phillips.
4(5) players plus any youth fighting for 2 spots.
Townsend
Furlong
Reach
Snodgrass
Centre mids - yes we need one, two if Sawyers leaves.
4 players plus any youth (Castro) fighting it out for 2 spots:
Mowatt
Livermore
Sawyers (replacement)
________ (New)
Defence - at present we have enough but if any leave (Kipre or Ajayi we replace)
5 players plus any youth fighting it out for 3 spots:
Clarke
Bartley
Ajayi
Kipre
O’Shea
We’re in a good position. We also can utilise the likes of Reach and Snodgrass if we go to a 4 or 5 in midfield to close a game or if VI wants to shake it up depending on opposition.
In summary this means we need right now:
1 x Striker
1 x Midfielder
If any leave we’d also need to replace e.g. Sawyers, Ajayi.
I think we need more than 2 Ronnie - that would still leave us light. It's all well and good having players who can cover 2-3 positions, but if we get a couple of injuries/suspensions at the same time, our cover can't play 2 positions at once.
We need another striker, MC and fullback as a bare minimum, and then to replace whoever leaves (Zohore, Sawyers, Ajayi).
Dike, Hamer and Ogbeta from Shrewsbury would be a good start to rounding our squad off, and then replacements for anyone who leaves on loan.
Agree
Also am I on my own in thinking playing wide midfielders as wingback is a tad risky? Anyone who watched us the other night could see how Bournemouth targeted our full backs when up the pitch. And that was against two experienced wing backs. As a one off stop gap its OK but I'd hate to go in to the season with only two recognised full backs.
Also I'd argue there is no way on God's earth Snodgrass could play as a wing back in a Val side with the sheer amount of running involved. He'd last 15 minutes before his lungs dropped out of his sphincter!
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(08-09-2021, 11:35 AM)Peachy Wrote: (08-09-2021, 08:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-09-2021, 07:53 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Striker - yes, we need an out and out no.9. Zahore to be shifted on.
6 players fighting for 3 spots:
_______ (New)
Phillips
Grady
Robinson
Grant
Tulloch
Wing backs - assuming cover exists for Townsend and Furlong. We will utilise the likes of Reach, Snodgrass and Phillips.
4(5) players plus any youth fighting for 2 spots.
Townsend
Furlong
Reach
Snodgrass
Centre mids - yes we need one, two if Sawyers leaves.
4 players plus any youth (Castro) fighting it out for 2 spots:
Mowatt
Livermore
Sawyers (replacement)
________ (New)
Defence - at present we have enough but if any leave (Kipre or Ajayi we replace)
5 players plus any youth fighting it out for 3 spots:
Clarke
Bartley
Ajayi
Kipre
O’Shea
We’re in a good position. We also can utilise the likes of Reach and Snodgrass if we go to a 4 or 5 in midfield to close a game or if VI wants to shake it up depending on opposition.
In summary this means we need right now:
1 x Striker
1 x Midfielder
If any leave we’d also need to replace e.g. Sawyers, Ajayi.
I think we need more than 2 Ronnie - that would still leave us light. It's all well and good having players who can cover 2-3 positions, but if we get a couple of injuries/suspensions at the same time, our cover can't play 2 positions at once.
We need another striker, MC and fullback as a bare minimum, and then to replace whoever leaves (Zohore, Sawyers, Ajayi).
Dike, Hamer and Ogbeta from Shrewsbury would be a good start to rounding our squad off, and then replacements for anyone who leaves on loan.
Agree
Also am I on my own in thinking playing wide midfielders as wingback is a tad risky? Anyone who watched us the other night could see how Bournemouth targeted our full backs when up the pitch. And that was against two experienced wing backs. As a one off stop gap its OK but I'd hate to go in to the season with only two recognised full backs.
Also I'd argue there is no way on God's earth Snodgrass could play as a wing back in a Val side with the sheer amount of running involved. He'd last 15 minutes before his lungs dropped out of his sphincter!
Snodgrass is apparently one of the fittest members of our squad.
Val loves him apparently.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
For me we need 2 CMs now, regardless of the Sawyers situation. If Livermore or Mowett can't play on Saturday then I'd expect we'd have to change the system, we have literally no one else to play that role. We may be able to shoe horn Reach, Phillips or Sawyers in for one game if we adjust the way we play a little, not a solution for a longer spell and certainly not an answer to Saturday, Tuesday, Saturday spells.
We also need a CF, in the mould of Dike. Sawyers leaving may free up the opportunity to get a different type of forward, maybe a loan kid from Man City type thing and bye, bye BigK. After that it's just someone to challenge Furlong at RWB like Reach does with Townsend.
If we could move Big Ken as well as Sawyers then that's 5 in and 2 out. Only a net addition of 3 but would leave the squad looking much more to the shape that 6 wants.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(08-09-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-09-2021, 11:35 AM)Peachy Wrote: (08-09-2021, 08:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-09-2021, 07:53 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Striker - yes, we need an out and out no.9. Zahore to be shifted on.
6 players fighting for 3 spots:
_______ (New)
Phillips
Grady
Robinson
Grant
Tulloch
Wing backs - assuming cover exists for Townsend and Furlong. We will utilise the likes of Reach, Snodgrass and Phillips.
4(5) players plus any youth fighting for 2 spots.
Townsend
Furlong
Reach
Snodgrass
Centre mids - yes we need one, two if Sawyers leaves.
4 players plus any youth (Castro) fighting it out for 2 spots:
Mowatt
Livermore
Sawyers (replacement)
________ (New)
Defence - at present we have enough but if any leave (Kipre or Ajayi we replace)
5 players plus any youth fighting it out for 3 spots:
Clarke
Bartley
Ajayi
Kipre
O’Shea
We’re in a good position. We also can utilise the likes of Reach and Snodgrass if we go to a 4 or 5 in midfield to close a game or if VI wants to shake it up depending on opposition.
In summary this means we need right now:
1 x Striker
1 x Midfielder
If any leave we’d also need to replace e.g. Sawyers, Ajayi.
I think we need more than 2 Ronnie - that would still leave us light. It's all well and good having players who can cover 2-3 positions, but if we get a couple of injuries/suspensions at the same time, our cover can't play 2 positions at once.
We need another striker, MC and fullback as a bare minimum, and then to replace whoever leaves (Zohore, Sawyers, Ajayi).
Dike, Hamer and Ogbeta from Shrewsbury would be a good start to rounding our squad off, and then replacements for anyone who leaves on loan.
Agree
Also am I on my own in thinking playing wide midfielders as wingback is a tad risky? Anyone who watched us the other night could see how Bournemouth targeted our full backs when up the pitch. And that was against two experienced wing backs. As a one off stop gap its OK but I'd hate to go in to the season with only two recognised full backs.
Also I'd argue there is no way on God's earth Snodgrass could play as a wing back in a Val side with the sheer amount of running involved. He'd last 15 minutes before his lungs dropped out of his sphincter!
Snodgrass is apparently one of the fittest members of our squad.
Val loves him apparently.
Well I will bow to Val's superior knowledge. I like Snoddy but given he's been injured for 95% of his time with us I'd have serious doubts, at 33 years old, about using him as a wing back on a regular basis. Just my onions.
I tell you who would have loved it. Nathan fucking Ferguson! Made for Val's side. Such a shame.
What side does Ingram play?
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(08-09-2021, 12:07 PM)Peachy Wrote: (08-09-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-09-2021, 11:35 AM)Peachy Wrote: (08-09-2021, 08:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-09-2021, 07:53 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Striker - yes, we need an out and out no.9. Zahore to be shifted on.
6 players fighting for 3 spots:
_______ (New)
Phillips
Grady
Robinson
Grant
Tulloch
Wing backs - assuming cover exists for Townsend and Furlong. We will utilise the likes of Reach, Snodgrass and Phillips.
4(5) players plus any youth fighting for 2 spots.
Townsend
Furlong
Reach
Snodgrass
Centre mids - yes we need one, two if Sawyers leaves.
4 players plus any youth (Castro) fighting it out for 2 spots:
Mowatt
Livermore
Sawyers (replacement)
________ (New)
Defence - at present we have enough but if any leave (Kipre or Ajayi we replace)
5 players plus any youth fighting it out for 3 spots:
Clarke
Bartley
Ajayi
Kipre
O’Shea
We’re in a good position. We also can utilise the likes of Reach and Snodgrass if we go to a 4 or 5 in midfield to close a game or if VI wants to shake it up depending on opposition.
In summary this means we need right now:
1 x Striker
1 x Midfielder
If any leave we’d also need to replace e.g. Sawyers, Ajayi.
I think we need more than 2 Ronnie - that would still leave us light. It's all well and good having players who can cover 2-3 positions, but if we get a couple of injuries/suspensions at the same time, our cover can't play 2 positions at once.
We need another striker, MC and fullback as a bare minimum, and then to replace whoever leaves (Zohore, Sawyers, Ajayi).
Dike, Hamer and Ogbeta from Shrewsbury would be a good start to rounding our squad off, and then replacements for anyone who leaves on loan.
Agree
Also am I on my own in thinking playing wide midfielders as wingback is a tad risky? Anyone who watched us the other night could see how Bournemouth targeted our full backs when up the pitch. And that was against two experienced wing backs. As a one off stop gap its OK but I'd hate to go in to the season with only two recognised full backs.
Also I'd argue there is no way on God's earth Snodgrass could play as a wing back in a Val side with the sheer amount of running involved. He'd last 15 minutes before his lungs dropped out of his sphincter!
Snodgrass is apparently one of the fittest members of our squad.
Val loves him apparently.
Well I will bow to Val's superior knowledge. I like Snoddy but given he's been injured for 95% of his time with us I'd have serious doubts, at 33 years old, about using him as a wing back on a regular basis. Just my onions.
I tell you who would have loved it. Nathan fucking Ferguson! Made for Val's side. Such a shame.
What side does Ingram play?
No idea. Think it's right but could be wrong.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-09-2021, 12:08 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-09-2021, 12:07 PM)Peachy Wrote: (08-09-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-09-2021, 11:35 AM)Peachy Wrote: (08-09-2021, 08:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we need more than 2 Ronnie - that would still leave us light. It's all well and good having players who can cover 2-3 positions, but if we get a couple of injuries/suspensions at the same time, our cover can't play 2 positions at once.
We need another striker, MC and fullback as a bare minimum, and then to replace whoever leaves (Zohore, Sawyers, Ajayi).
Dike, Hamer and Ogbeta from Shrewsbury would be a good start to rounding our squad off, and then replacements for anyone who leaves on loan.
Agree
Also am I on my own in thinking playing wide midfielders as wingback is a tad risky? Anyone who watched us the other night could see how Bournemouth targeted our full backs when up the pitch. And that was against two experienced wing backs. As a one off stop gap its OK but I'd hate to go in to the season with only two recognised full backs.
Also I'd argue there is no way on God's earth Snodgrass could play as a wing back in a Val side with the sheer amount of running involved. He'd last 15 minutes before his lungs dropped out of his sphincter!
Snodgrass is apparently one of the fittest members of our squad.
Val loves him apparently.
Well I will bow to Val's superior knowledge. I like Snoddy but given he's been injured for 95% of his time with us I'd have serious doubts, at 33 years old, about using him as a wing back on a regular basis. Just my onions.
I tell you who would have loved it. Nathan fucking Ferguson! Made for Val's side. Such a shame.
What side does Ingram play?
No idea. Think it's right but could be wrong.
Pretty sure he’s seen as right sided.
I’d be very nervous about using Snodgrass at fullback… Townsend’s lack of pace (and he’s not SLOW) was exposed by Bournemouth on Friday night, and Snodgrass really will struggle to cover back. With Clarke and O’Shea playing on their natural sides I think we’ll have more cover from the wide CBs however.
Also worth remembering Bournemouth have one of the best front 3s in the division, and we won’t face that much quality every week.
|