MP to Al-Hilal
(08-05-2021, 01:46 PM)Anew Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 01:16 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: A player is only worth what buyers will pay! Simple as that.

Clubs know, including WBA believe it or not, if bigger bids are on the way or have a chance. Agents will know even earlier…..it’s football! 

IF huge IF leic were interested they’d have signalled a price. Same with Villa -
Never happening as got matey from Norwich.  West Ham made an offer…. 

To go and play for Leic for example he’d easily have picked up £50-60k per week.   

Do you really think his agent NOT MP (make no mistake) would have been pushing the Saudi deal if he knew premier league offers were on the table…. of course he wouldn’t! 

This was the only viable deal available for MP, Agent and WBA. 

We haven’t f**** up!  It’s the market! It’s his reputation in the game.  It’s his contract. It’s the fact we’re selling from the championship and not the premier league.  

We should be happy to double our money, have an unhappy player gone and have the time to reinvest some of the money in good time, not on deadline day.

Val said in one of his interviews or pressers this week that he was happy with his squad so in that respect we don't NEED to sell.As for being a disruptive influence in the dressing room well he's not the first player to be(even at our.club) and he'd definitely won't be the last 


If you could give me a least one example of a club that has sold a player for half their value when he plays up for a move  I'd be more than surprised.

Who’s doing this valuation? You say selling at half his valuation, so you’re suggesting it’s £34m plus??? 

Who’s valued him at that? Club? Fans? Twitter? Facebook? 

His pure market/contractual value is £13.5m….no context added to that etc.  See other posts above for explanation. 

We’re selling potentially for £17m.  Could we have got more?  Of course if people willing to pay it. It’s clear no one is.   Club(WBA) will have had a valuation that they were willing to accept taking into consideration, market and contractual valuation PLUS managers view.
Reply
I'm going with the £17M disclosed and £10M direct to China theory which means we have got the value out of him, just not going to see all of the dosh. This will come back to bite us in a few years time but if it gets Lai closer to selling then maybe not a bad thing.
Reply
(08-05-2021, 01:54 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 01:46 PM)Anew Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 01:16 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: A player is only worth what buyers will pay! Simple as that.

Clubs know, including WBA believe it or not, if bigger bids are on the way or have a chance. Agents will know even earlier…..it’s football! 

IF huge IF leic were interested they’d have signalled a price. Same with Villa -
Never happening as got matey from Norwich.  West Ham made an offer…. 

To go and play for Leic for example he’d easily have picked up £50-60k per week.   

Do you really think his agent NOT MP (make no mistake) would have been pushing the Saudi deal if he knew premier league offers were on the table…. of course he wouldn’t! 

This was the only viable deal available for MP, Agent and WBA. 

We haven’t f**** up!  It’s the market! It’s his reputation in the game.  It’s his contract. It’s the fact we’re selling from the championship and not the premier league.  

We should be happy to double our money, have an unhappy player gone and have the time to reinvest some of the money in good time, not on deadline day.

Val said in one of his interviews or pressers this week that he was happy with his squad so in that respect we don't NEED to sell.As for being a disruptive influence in the dressing room well he's not the first player to be(even at our.club) and he'd definitely won't be the last 


If you could give me a least one example of a club that has sold a player for half their value when he plays up for a move  I'd be more than surprised.

Who’s doing this valuation? You say selling at half his valuation, so you’re suggesting it’s £34m plus??? 

Who’s valued him at that? Club? Fans? Twitter? Facebook? 

His pure market/contractual value is £13.5m….no context added to that etc.  See other posts above for explanation. 

We’re selling potentially for £17m.  Could we have got more?  Of course if people willing to pay it. It’s clear no one is.   Club(WBA) will have had a valuation that they were willing to accept taking into consideration, market and contractual valuation PLUS managers view.

Which ever way you try and explain it, there's no getting away from the fact we've been shafted on the fee. Benrahma went for more 0 PL appearances. Eze went for more 0 PL appearances. Buendia went for double. We paid similar amounts for Grady and Grant. We will never know if we would have got more because we've caved in and accepted this offer. I can understand why they've done it, but doesn't mean we have to sit here and pat them on the back for it. Let's just hope we can reinvest enough of the money wisely on what we need otherwise we will have lost the best player in the division and our biggest asset for nothing.
Reply
(08-05-2021, 02:18 PM)wbamitch Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 01:54 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 01:46 PM)Anew Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 01:16 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: A player is only worth what buyers will pay! Simple as that.

Clubs know, including WBA believe it or not, if bigger bids are on the way or have a chance. Agents will know even earlier…..it’s football! 

IF huge IF leic were interested they’d have signalled a price. Same with Villa -
Never happening as got matey from Norwich.  West Ham made an offer…. 

To go and play for Leic for example he’d easily have picked up £50-60k per week.   

Do you really think his agent NOT MP (make no mistake) would have been pushing the Saudi deal if he knew premier league offers were on the table…. of course he wouldn’t! 

This was the only viable deal available for MP, Agent and WBA. 

We haven’t f**** up!  It’s the market! It’s his reputation in the game.  It’s his contract. It’s the fact we’re selling from the championship and not the premier league.  

We should be happy to double our money, have an unhappy player gone and have the time to reinvest some of the money in good time, not on deadline day.

Val said in one of his interviews or pressers this week that he was happy with his squad so in that respect we don't NEED to sell.As for being a disruptive influence in the dressing room well he's not the first player to be(even at our.club) and he'd definitely won't be the last 


If you could give me a least one example of a club that has sold a player for half their value when he plays up for a move  I'd be more than surprised.

Who’s doing this valuation? You say selling at half his valuation, so you’re suggesting it’s £34m plus??? 

Who’s valued him at that? Club? Fans? Twitter? Facebook? 

His pure market/contractual value is £13.5m….no context added to that etc.  See other posts above for explanation. 

We’re selling potentially for £17m.  Could we have got more?  Of course if people willing to pay it. It’s clear no one is.   Club(WBA) will have had a valuation that they were willing to accept taking into consideration, market and contractual valuation PLUS managers view.

Which ever way you try and explain it, there's no getting away from the fact we've been shafted on the fee. Benrahma went for more 0 PL appearances. Eze went for more 0 PL appearances. Buendia went for double. We paid similar amounts for Grady and Grant. We will never know if we would have got more because we've caved in and accepted this offer. I can understand why they've done it, but doesn't mean we have to sit here and pat them on the back for it. Let's just hope we can reinvest enough of the money wisely on what we need otherwise we will have lost the best player in the division and our biggest asset for nothing.

Shafted in the current market?? That market outside the premier league??
Reply
17 million Zimbabwean dollars innit
Reply
Interesting question but will this be the highest fee received in the Championship for a player not going to the Premiership?

Can only think of Bellingham being higher @ £25m
Reply
(08-05-2021, 02:44 PM)MGalea Wrote: Interesting question but will this be the highest fee received in the Championship for a player not going to the Premiership?

Can only think of Bellingham being higher @ £25m

Ramsdale £18m??? Can’t remember exactly……. Sorry just re-read message.
Reply
(08-05-2021, 02:44 PM)MGalea Wrote: Interesting question but will this be the highest fee received in the Championship for a player not going to the Premiership?

Can only think of Bellingham being higher @ £25m

Top 5 

Bellingham £21million
Rondon £16 Million
De Roon £15 million
Estupiñán £13 Million
Burke £13 million
Reply
(08-05-2021, 02:48 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 02:44 PM)MGalea Wrote: Interesting question but will this be the highest fee received in the Championship for a player not going to the Premiership?

Can only think of Bellingham being higher @ £25m

Ramsdale £18m??? Can’t remember exactly……. Sorry just re-read message.

If that was the case… Benrhama, Buendia… both inferior players Wink
Reply
Is he there yet?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: