Posts: 1,777
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(02-23-2019, 07:38 PM)Sliced Wrote: Our midfield three should have easily the lowest three ratings. Holgate's crossing was poor but to call him brain dead is absolutely ridiculous. Not sure why you have it in for him so much.
Agree on the midfield three. That's where the game was won and lost. Barry has given massively contrasting performances against Staff Utd. In the first fixture he gave an imperious performance, probably the best individual performance by any of our squad this season. Today though, along with his two colleagues, he was anonymous. It was his worse performance of the season to date.
Can just imagine Wilder all week in his midfielders ears, telling them they were dominated last game, and they needed to win it for them this time around.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(02-23-2019, 09:18 PM)clem4england Wrote: (02-23-2019, 08:31 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: Player marks
1 to 11 - not relevant
subs - not relevant
Management - a big fat fucking ZERO
Just so blindingly obvious today. Naïve doesn't even cover it. Tactically out-thought and no other way of playing when behind at home. This isn’t a knee jerk reaction from today but I wonder how many points we’d have with Wilder in charge? Like Farke he gets the absolute most out of some limited players playing a system that suits them perfectly and players that slot into it and are well organised.
We constantly gift the opponents soft goals, are slow and laboured, unfit and easy to break down playing a system that seems to suit no-one now Barnes has left. In hindsight, as well as we played v Villa, we were fortunate to get the three points against a poor QPR team who we gifted presents to.
One thing to say for them is that they all seemed to know their shape and seemed to be set up in a zonal way that when the ball broke down on our side they always has presence in the middle of the park to pick up and counter-attack (even more so second half, of course). It's better now we have the Holgate option wide right although better crossing would help (or even earlier crossing) but we rarely have that same option on the left but movement forwards is rarely that quick and gives teams time to get set.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(02-23-2019, 07:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Knew as soon as the teams were announced we wouldn’t win that one. Played entirely into their hands. Whilst Big Dave’s pre match comments about bumps in the road and frustrations are valid, we need to see something resembling an element of nous from the management team. For me, today was the most frustrating day of the season... anyone who was watched United play will know how they play, and what their strengths and weaknesses are, and yet we played straight into their hands.
Looking at United’s side today there are maybe 2 or 3 players I’d take in our match squad... however Wilder plays to their strengths, and has moulded a side that knows how to win. He has a bench of options and did a complete job on us... he’s an excellent manager and they were probably the best side we’ve played.
Johnstone - 8 - One excellent save, didn’t do a lot wrong.
Holgate - 4 - Brain dead, moronic, inexperienced.... it’s a good job he’s quick as he offered nothing else
Dawson - 6 - Did his job, wasn’t really tested.
Hegazi - 6 - our best player, a huge loss if he’s out long.
Gibbs - 5 - silly challenge early on and poor display again.
Barry - 5 - His worst game of the season for us. Wasteful, pedestrian, slow....
Harper - 5 - looked like making things happen, but was clearly knackered for the last 30 and faded badly
Livermore - 5 - Looked knackered again, did the running for Barry.
Gayle - 4 - Wasted out wide again, he won’t score every chance he gets, so when he only gets one a game we can’t expect him to always score.
Rodriguez - 4 - Loads of running but didn’t get on the ball at all. Not sure why he handled for the disallowed goal
Phillips - 5 - no width at all first half, did a fair bit of running but no end product.
Tosin - 7 - played very well when he came on
Montero - 6 - one woeful corner aside, he made things happen. Should have been on much, much earlier
Edwards - barely on long enough.
Moore - what’s the lowest score I can possibly give? Sorry Dave but today was utterly awful. You got this completely wrong. The line up was wrong, the tactics were wrong, the subs were wrong... we are in the playoffs because of your fantastic work this season, but we are now destined for the playoffs because of your naivity.
So who do we want in the playoffs?
Eh? Holgate is one of our best players and performers. He had an off day yesterday with his crossing but way too harsh on him.
Posts: 4,751
Threads: 374
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(02-23-2019, 07:29 PM)Baggie Rick Wrote: Soap 6 Just kick long every now and then
Gibbo 6 poor by his usual standards
Heggo 6 head like a 50p feet are worse
Daws 5 simply poor
Barry 4 tired early, gave the ball away countless times
Harps 5 trying to hard, keep it simple
Lives 4 pedestrian at best
Matty 6 needs games
J rod 5 tried hard, no end result
Gayley 4 now a marked man
Subs
Toss 6 did as required
Monty 5 headless chicken
BD 4 why can’t he see 4 3 3 at home doesn’t work??
Play Gayley and JRod through the middle, not out wide!!
Montero was our best player.
Posts: 37
Threads: 1
Joined: Feb 2019
I thought Robson Kanu was by far the best yesterday
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Here we go again we lose and the overreaction is incredible, some of you should think before you post.some of those ratings are pathetic Livermore was easily along with Johnstone and Hegazi our better players,but the downer on Livermore is ridiculous.So bad day at the office we move on now to Leeds and we are only 4 points off the automatic places so to say it’s over is pathetic.
Posts: 778
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(02-23-2019, 07:30 PM)Xitan Wrote: Im sorry but Livermore contributes absolutely nothing and that keeper causes more problems than he solves
Agree re Livermore don't see what he brings to the side slow cant make a decisive pass to hurt the opposition gives the ball away probably more than any other player , no im not having him .
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(02-24-2019, 01:10 PM)wba13 Wrote: Here we go again we lose and the overreaction is incredible, some of you should think before you post.some of those ratings are pathetic Livermore was easily along with Johnstone and Hegazi our better players,but the downer on Livermore is ridiculous.So bad day at the office we move on now to Leeds and we are only 4 points off the automatic places so to say it’s over is pathetic.
Yes 4 pts of top 2 same as we were 6 or so games ago a win yesterday and a win over Leeds Friday would have put us in 2nd spot 2pts clear now we are 4pts adrift with 6 games less to catch up plus we now have to rely on both Norwich & Sheff dropping points so based on this and our piss poor home form its quite understandable why people think the chance has gone, I hope we can still do it but imho it's playoffs for us.
Posts: 406
Threads: 7
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(02-24-2019, 01:10 PM)wba13 Wrote: Here we go again we lose and the overreaction is incredible, some of you should think before you post.some of those ratings are pathetic Livermore was easily along with Johnstone and Hegazi our better players,but the downer on Livermore is ridiculous.So bad day at the office we move on now to Leeds and we are only 4 points off the automatic places so to say it’s over is pathetic.
Amazing, isn't it? A football forum discussing a performance.....
It was a bad day that could and should have been avoided. Team set up and personnel were wrong. It was discussed on here how Sheff Utd like to attack and then watch their goal. Right sided centre half on the overlap and crosses from the deadball line. Not one of our midfielders or the left sided attacker tracking anywhere near. Plenty of other mistakes that could be highlighted.
Posts: 1,352
Threads: 22
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
(02-24-2019, 03:01 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (02-24-2019, 01:10 PM)wba13 Wrote: Here we go again we lose and the overreaction is incredible, some of you should think before you post.some of those ratings are pathetic Livermore was easily along with Johnstone and Hegazi our better players,but the downer on Livermore is ridiculous.So bad day at the office we move on now to Leeds and we are only 4 points off the automatic places so to say it’s over is pathetic.
Amazing, isn't it? A football forum discussing a performance.....
It was a bad day that could and should have been avoided. Team set up and personnel were wrong. It was discussed on here how Sheff Utd like to attack and then watch their goal. Right sided centre half on the overlap and crosses from the deadball line. Not one of our midfielders or the left sided attacker tracking anywhere near. Plenty of other mistakes that could be highlighted. In this system the left sided attacker needs to stay forward. Playing left of the midfield three it's Livermore that should helping Gibbs out. I still think Gibbs should've stopped the cross though and Barry was caught on his heels in the area.
|