Livermore in Beast mode
#11
(08-01-2021, 08:46 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm not entirely onboard with this fulsome praise of Livermore throughout the promotion season. JKE says he "stopped playing under Allardyce". Not true, he stopped playing after the big lockdown. Whatever caused the Bilic meltdown from June 2020 onwards, Livermore was a huge part of it. His uninspired play and captaincy carried on through the disastrous start to 2020-21 season in the Premier League, and he lacked the character to step up and lead the charge under Allardyce. As club captain he should have rallied the troops behind the new coach, instead of sulking with the rest of the gang.

I'll be delighted to see him rejuvenated and playing to his potential, but I was annoyed by his comments about "we now have a smile on our faces". It implies that if you're not happy in your work, it's OK to slack off a bit. That was never the case anywhere I worked, and I wasn't paid £25,000 per week.

Pretty much nails it.
Reply
#12
(08-01-2021, 08:46 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm not entirely onboard with this fulsome praise of Livermore throughout the promotion season. JKE says he "stopped playing under Allardyce". Not true, he stopped playing after the big lockdown. Whatever caused the Bilic meltdown from June 2020 onwards, Livermore was a huge part of it. His uninspired play and captaincy carried on through the disastrous start to 2020-21 season in the Premier League, and he lacked the character to step up and lead the charge under Allardyce. As club captain he should have rallied the troops behind the new coach, instead of sulking with the rest of the gang.

I'll be delighted to see him rejuvenated and playing to his potential, but I was annoyed by his comments about "we now have a smile on our faces". It implies that if you're not happy in your work, it's OK to slack off a bit. That was never the case anywhere I worked, and I wasn't paid £25,000 per week.

Agree with a lot of this.

Livermore started well under Bilic, as he did under Moore the previous season, however his impact badly faded as the season went on, and his form post Christmas was very poor, and the less said about his post-lockdown condition, the better.

I have 2 main qualms with Jake… firstly I think his base fitness is poor. Every time he gets a knock or a suspension and misses a couple of games he seems to need a few matches to look right again - similar to Phillips, and secondly I just don’t think he’s captain material. I can count on one hand the number of games in the last 5 years I think he’s impacted, and his comments about feeling the pressure under lockdown and the “smiles on our faces” comment you mention don’t sit well with me as a leader of men. 

He’ll do OK this year, he’ll no doubt start well enough, but we need at least one more in his position. Ideally someone a little more creative.  

Oh, and last season he was truly awful. His passing was atrocious, his fitness and mobility laughable and his defensive contribution was next to nothing. There is absolutely no zero PL ability still in Jake.
Reply
#13
(08-01-2021, 09:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-01-2021, 08:46 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm not entirely onboard with this fulsome praise of Livermore throughout the promotion season. JKE says he "stopped playing under Allardyce". Not true, he stopped playing after the big lockdown. Whatever caused the Bilic meltdown from June 2020 onwards, Livermore was a huge part of it. His uninspired play and captaincy carried on through the disastrous start to 2020-21 season in the Premier League, and he lacked the character to step up and lead the charge under Allardyce. As club captain he should have rallied the troops behind the new coach, instead of sulking with the rest of the gang.

I'll be delighted to see him rejuvenated and playing to his potential, but I was annoyed by his comments about "we now have a smile on our faces". It implies that if you're not happy in your work, it's OK to slack off a bit. That was never the case anywhere I worked, and I wasn't paid £25,000 per week.

Agree with a lot of this.

Livermore started well under Bilic, as he did under Moore the previous season, however his impact badly faded as the season went on, and his form post Christmas was very poor, and the less said about his post-lockdown condition, the better.

I have 2 main qualms with Jake… firstly I think his base fitness is poor. Every time he gets a knock or a suspension and misses a couple of games he seems to need a few matches to look right again - similar to Phillips, and secondly I just don’t think he’s captain material. I can count on one hand the number of games in the last 5 years I think he’s impacted, and his comments about feeling the pressure under lockdown and the “smiles on our faces” comment you mention don’t sit well with me as a leader of men. 

He’ll do OK this year, he’ll no doubt start well enough, but we need at least one more in his position. Ideally someone a little more creative.  

Oh, and last season he was truly awful. His passing was atrocious, his fitness and mobility laughable and his defensive contribution was next to nothing. There is absolutely no zero PL ability still in Jake.

Spot on

PL wise he had a good couple of months after he arrived in 16/17 and then under Big Dave
Reply
#14
MancBaggie Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:I'm not entirely onboard with this fulsome praise of Livermore throughout the promotion season. JKE says he "stopped playing under Allardyce". Not true, he stopped playing after the big lockdown. Whatever caused the Bilic meltdown from June 2020 onwards, Livermore was a huge part of it. His uninspired play and captaincy carried on through the disastrous start to 2020-21 season in the Premier League, and he lacked the character to step up and lead the charge under Allardyce. As club captain he should have rallied the troops behind the new coach, instead of sulking with the rest of the gang.

I'll be delighted to see him rejuvenated and playing to his potential, but I was annoyed by his comments about "we now have a smile on our faces". It implies that if you're not happy in your work, it's OK to slack off a bit. That was never the case anywhere I worked, and I wasn't paid £25,000 per week.

Agree with a lot of this.

Livermore started well under Bilic, as he did under Moore the previous season, however his impact badly faded as the season went on, and his form post Christmas was very poor, and the less said about his post-lockdown condition, the better.

I have 2 main qualms with Jake… firstly I think his base fitness is poor. Every time he gets a knock or a suspension and misses a couple of games he seems to need a few matches to look right again - similar to Phillips, and secondly I just don’t think he’s captain material. I can count on one hand the number of games in the last 5 years I think he’s impacted, and his comments about feeling the pressure under lockdown and the “smiles on our faces” comment you mention don’t sit well with me as a leader of men. 

He’ll do OK this year, he’ll no doubt start well enough, but we need at least one more in his position. Ideally someone a little more creative.  

Oh, and last season he was truly awful. His passing was atrocious, his fitness and mobility laughable and his defensive contribution was next to nothing. There is absolutely no zero PL ability still in Jake.

Spot on

PL wise he had a good couple of months after he arrived in 16/17 and then under Big Dave
I am in this camp. Overall, I like Jake and am sure he will do a decent job this season. I'd like to see a true leader as captain though. For all the "they shouldn't need a captain" comments, Albion have always looked much better when we've had a proper one.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)