Posts: 499
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Soap 6 Just kick long every now and then
Gibbo 6 poor by his usual standards
Heggo 6 head like a 50p feet are worse
Daws 5 simply poor
Barry 4 tired early, gave the ball away countless times
Harps 5 trying to hard, keep it simple
Lives 4 pedestrian at best
Matty 6 needs games
J rod 5 tried hard, no end result
Gayley 4 now a marked man
Subs
Toss 6 did as required
Monty 5 headless chicken
BD 4 why can’t he see 4 3 3 at home doesn’t work??
Play Gayley and JRod through the middle, not out wide!!
Posts: 110
Threads: 24
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
Im sorry but Livermore contributes absolutely nothing and that keeper causes more problems than he solves
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Knew as soon as the teams were announced we wouldn’t win that one. Played entirely into their hands. Whilst Big Dave’s pre match comments about bumps in the road and frustrations are valid, we need to see something resembling an element of nous from the management team. For me, today was the most frustrating day of the season... anyone who was watched United play will know how they play, and what their strengths and weaknesses are, and yet we played straight into their hands.
Looking at United’s side today there are maybe 2 or 3 players I’d take in our match squad... however Wilder plays to their strengths, and has moulded a side that knows how to win. He has a bench of options and did a complete job on us... he’s an excellent manager and they were probably the best side we’ve played.
Johnstone - 8 - One excellent save, didn’t do a lot wrong.
Holgate - 4 - Brain dead, moronic, inexperienced.... it’s a good job he’s quick as he offered nothing else
Dawson - 6 - Did his job, wasn’t really tested.
Hegazi - 6 - our best player, a huge loss if he’s out long.
Gibbs - 5 - silly challenge early on and poor display again.
Barry - 5 - His worst game of the season for us. Wasteful, pedestrian, slow....
Harper - 5 - looked like making things happen, but was clearly knackered for the last 30 and faded badly
Livermore - 5 - Looked knackered again, did the running for Barry.
Gayle - 4 - Wasted out wide again, he won’t score every chance he gets, so when he only gets one a game we can’t expect him to always score.
Rodriguez - 4 - Loads of running but didn’t get on the ball at all. Not sure why he handled for the disallowed goal
Phillips - 5 - no width at all first half, did a fair bit of running but no end product.
Tosin - 7 - played very well when he came on
Montero - 6 - one woeful corner aside, he made things happen. Should have been on much, much earlier
Edwards - barely on long enough.
Moore - what’s the lowest score I can possibly give? Sorry Dave but today was utterly awful. You got this completely wrong. The line up was wrong, the tactics were wrong, the subs were wrong... we are in the playoffs because of your fantastic work this season, but we are now destined for the playoffs because of your naivity.
So who do we want in the playoffs?
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
Our midfield three should have easily the lowest three ratings. Holgate's crossing was poor but to call him brain dead is absolutely ridiculous. Not sure why you have it in for him so much.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(02-23-2019, 07:38 PM)Sliced Wrote: Our midfield three should have easily the lowest three ratings. Holgate's crossing was poor but to call him brain dead is absolutely ridiculous. Not sure why you have it in for him so much.
I don’t have it in for him, he is either excellent or awful. His decision making is atrocious and his end product tonight awful.
Posts: 1,717
Threads: 212
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(02-23-2019, 07:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Knew as soon as the teams were announced we wouldn’t win that one. Played entirely into their hands. Whilst Big Dave’s pre match comments about bumps in the road and frustrations are valid, we need to see something resembling an element of nous from the management team. For me, today was the most frustrating day of the season... anyone who was watched United play will know how they play, and what their strengths and weaknesses are, and yet we played straight into their hands.
Looking at United’s side today there are maybe 2 or 3 players I’d take in our match squad... however Wilder plays to their strengths, and has moulded a side that knows how to win. He has a bench of options and did a complete job on us... he’s an excellent manager and they were probably the best side we’ve played.
Johnstone - 8 - One excellent save, didn’t do a lot wrong.
Holgate - 4 - Brain dead, moronic, inexperienced.... it’s a good job he’s quick as he offered nothing else
Dawson - 6 - Did his job, wasn’t really tested.
Hegazi - 6 - our best player, a huge loss if he’s out long.
Gibbs - 5 - silly challenge early on and poor display again.
Barry - 5 - His worst game of the season for us. Wasteful, pedestrian, slow....
Harper - 5 - looked like making things happen, but was clearly knackered for the last 30 and faded badly
Livermore - 5 - Looked knackered again, did the running for Barry.
Gayle - 4 - Wasted out wide again, he won’t score every chance he gets, so when he only gets one a game we can’t expect him to always score.
Rodriguez - 4 - Loads of running but didn’t get on the ball at all. Not sure why he handled for the disallowed goal
Phillips - 5 - no width at all first half, did a fair bit of running but no end product.
Tosin - 7 - played very well when he came on
Montero - 6 - one woeful corner aside, he made things happen. Should have been on much, much earlier
Edwards - barely on long enough.
Moore - what’s the lowest score I can possibly give? Sorry Dave but today was utterly awful. You got this completely wrong. The line up was wrong, the tactics were wrong, the subs were wrong... we are in the playoffs because of your fantastic work this season, but we are now destined for the playoffs because of your naivity.
So who do we want in the playoffs?
Villa can't sneak in can they?, that would be my nightmare
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Thought Holgate's overall play was good enough, obviously his crossing was poor tonight.
Posts: 406
Threads: 7
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
Player marks
1 to 11 - not relevant
subs - not relevant
Management - a big fat fucking ZERO
Just so blindingly obvious today. Naïve doesn't even cover it. Tactically out-thought and no other way of playing when behind at home.
Posts: 1,139
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(02-23-2019, 08:31 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: Player marks
1 to 11 - not relevant
subs - not relevant
Management - a big fat fucking ZERO
Just so blindingly obvious today. Naïve doesn't even cover it. Tactically out-thought and no other way of playing when behind at home. This isn’t a knee jerk reaction from today but I wonder how many points we’d have with Wilder in charge? Like Farke he gets the absolute most out of some limited players playing a system that suits them perfectly and players that slot into it and are well organised.
We constantly gift the opponents soft goals, are slow and laboured, unfit and easy to break down playing a system that seems to suit no-one now Barnes has left. In hindsight, as well as we played v Villa, we were fortunate to get the three points against a poor QPR team who we gifted presents to.
|