How not to VAR...
#1
YAnyone who remembers back to the WC knows I’m a big fan of VAR, and think it’s long overdue, but watching the City game tonight isn’t a classic example of how not to do it.

Unclear penalty shout, after initially not giving it the ref argues with players resulting in a few bookings, has to chat to the captains, then after 3 minutes of chatting over an ear piece gives the pen... City look totally shaken, and the players are now questioning every decision he makes.

Quite what’s happened to his little TV screen I’ve no idea! How a ref can overturn his decision after chatting over a mic I’ve no idea!
Reply
#2
Exactly why I hate it. That pen was in the "I've seen 'em given" category and this is absolutely NOT what VAR is for. Mission creep is impossible to stop and pressure via the media from players and managers will eventually ensure that every tiny little decision is looked at and what it is to be a football fan will be lost forever. That celebration last night at QPR? Nah. Gotta wait for a minute until any possible reason not to give the goal is looked at. I always find it hilarious when anyone in favour of it relentlessly trots out the line: "But it was the right decision in the end." That utterly misses the point (not that the Schalke penalty was in any way objective). Athletico had a penalty correctly ruled out in the other game by VAR. I'd be more than happy for it to have stood - in football, things sometimes go for you, sometimes they don't. I was massively in favour of technology in football until I witnessed it in action. Now I'm massively against it.
Reply
#3
Technology in football will be slowly used to get the "right result" in games or put simply the result sky and the media and the big boys want the more Var and the like are used the less chance of an upset imvho, but then I'm just a cynical old git.
Reply
#4
(02-20-2019, 09:13 PM)steviedm Wrote: Exactly why I hate it. That pen was in the "I've seen 'em given" category and this is absolutely NOT what VAR is for. Mission creep is impossible to stop and pressure via the media from players and managers will eventually ensure that every tiny little decision is looked at and what it is to be a football fan will be lost forever. That celebration last night at QPR? Nah. Gotta wait for a minute until any possible reason not to give the goal is looked at. I always find it hilarious when anyone in favour of it relentlessly trots out the line: "But it was the right decision in the end." That utterly misses the point (not that the Schalke penalty was in any way objective). Athletico had a penalty correctly ruled out in the other game by VAR. I'd be more than happy for it to have stood - in football, things sometimes go for you, sometimes they don't. I was massively in favour of technology in football until I witnessed it in action. Now I'm massively against it.

Not sure I agree with that, if anything I’d say VAR is being used less now than in games when it first came into use, plenty of FA Cup games have occurred without a stoppage for example.

I can understand why people think it’ll ruin fan experience, but again the likelihood of a last minute goal being reviewed is very, very low... I think after the Liverpool debacle we’ll always think the worst, but as long as refs are strong on bookings when players make the TV sign to them that can be managed.

Agree tonight’s decision shouldn’t have been reviewed as it just wasn’t a clear pen for me, but can hardly argue it went for the team the bookies/media want to win!
Reply
#5
(02-20-2019, 09:22 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Technology in football will be slowly used to get the "right result" in games or put simply the result sky and the media and the big boys want the more Var and the like are used the less chance of an upset imvho, but then I'm just a cynical old git.

This is my view. It's hard enough to play the chosen few without the ref being influenced by them. VAR will just be used to enforce the status quo.
 Cynical?  Yeah, it's what happens when you've seen it often enough.
Reply
#6
Athletico have a goal ruled out for a push that would not be picked up most of the time. I’m with Danny Baker on this one: it’ll be the death of the game.

By the way, apparently the delay with the Schalke penalty was because the pitch side screen wasn’t working and the ref couldn’t review it. He was then told to award the penalty by the VAR officials. Scandalous. Surely you have to go with his original decision if the technology is not working.
Reply
#7
(02-20-2019, 09:22 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Technology in football will be slowly used to get the "right result" in games or put simply the result sky and the media and the big boys want the more Var and the like are used the less chance of an upset imvho, but then I'm just a cynical old git.

Totally agree.
Reply
#8
(02-20-2019, 09:39 PM)steviedm Wrote: Athletico have a goal ruled out for a push that would not be picked up most of the time. I’m with Danny Baker on this one: it’ll be the death of the game.

By the way, apparently the delay with the Schalke penalty was because the pitch side screen wasn’t working and the ref couldn’t review it. He was then told to award the penalty by the VAR officials. Scandalous. Surely you have to go with his original decision if the technology is not working.

Yeah they mentioned it in the second half.

Agree in that very rare scenario, they should have stayed with his initial decision, but I suppose when they have 40 odd angles and multiple replays, if they say to the ref they overwhelmingly believe it was the wrong decision, there’s a need for a degree of trust and so can understand why he went with their call.

As refs go, he was weak all night so it’s no shock. As much of a prick as he is I doubt someone like Mason would have listened!
Reply
#9
Goal-line technology works fantastic. I’m not a fan of VAR, I guess for people sat at home and watching on tv it works. It’s shite for attending spectators and it will just creep in more and more.

They can shove the offside rule/not interfering/second phase up their arse as well. I still don’t understand how you can be miles offside, never played back on side and have a square or pulled back ball to score from. Fundamentally wrong IMO.
Reply
#10
(02-20-2019, 10:33 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Goal-line technology works fantastic.  I’m not a fan of VAR, I guess for people sat at home and watching on tv it works.  It’s shite for attending spectators and it will just creep in more and more.

They can shove the offside rule/not interfering/second phase up their arse as well.  I still don’t understand how you can be miles offside, never played back on side and have a square or pulled back ball to score from. Fundamentally wrong IMO.

It's simple to fix imo. Each team should be allowed just one challenge in any game. They can use that challenge when they see fit. Once they've used it either sucesssful or not then that's it.

It will free the ref up to ref the game normally but equally teams will know that a proper contentious decision can be challenged.

Goal line technology is great and for me was the only thing that was ever needed.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)