Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
I’m amazed some ruling hasn’t been brought in guaranteeing any development club a seriously sizable sell on fee if a player has been at a club for over 5 years, say 25-50%
This would make big clubs only cherry pick the talent they think will really kick on and let clubs keep their up and coming prospects, as you say as it is it costs a club bugger all to take a punt on a player and in the process piss off an old fool like me who clearly gets way too worked up about it
Yes, I’m still smarting……
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 19,496
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(07-06-2021, 08:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I’m amazed some ruling hasn’t been brought in guaranteeing any development club a seriously sizable sell on fee if a player has been at a club for over 5 years, say 25-50%
This would make big clubs only cherry pick the talent they think will really kick on and let clubs keep their up and coming prospects, as you say as it is it costs a club bugger all to take a punt on a player and in the process piss off an old fool like me who clearly gets way too worked up about it
Yes, I’m still smarting……
Cuzer
Or potentially an annual development fee which rises every year they are there…
Posts: 290
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2021
Our academy "the envy of the premier league" produced one player who cut it in the prem consistently (berahino).
Look back and you see will see Blose and Cov have produced better academy players who have had Premier league careers. We produce lower league players. Even the ones who have been poached by Chelsea and Liverpool have not made it in the prem.
We like to think our academy is brilliant, but the facts say otherwise.
Blose have produced England Internationals in Butland, Redmond, Gray and Bellingham.
We all want them to do well, but in all honesty our youth players don't go on to have long term prem careers.
I don't include Wood as he came to us at a letter age than our other youth players.
Hopefully, Stevens can break the ceiling and produce proper Premier league players for us.
Posts: 10,866
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(07-06-2021, 09:17 PM)Korenavirus Wrote: Our academy "the envy of the premier league" produced one player who cut it in the prem consistently (berahino).
Look back and you see will see Blose and Cov have produced better academy players who have had Premier league careers. We produce lower league players. Even the ones who have been poached by Chelsea and Liverpool have not made it in the prem.
We like to think our academy is brilliant, but the facts say otherwise.
Blose have produced England Internationals in Butland, Redmond, Gray and Bellingham.
We all want them to do well, but in all honesty our youth players don't go on to have long term prem careers.
I don't include Wood as he came to us at a letter age than our other youth players.
Hopefully, Stevens can break the ceiling and produce proper Premier league players for us.
Quick question. If our academy was so shit why did villa take our acedemy manager, our head of recruitment and 5 coaches to build their new academy set up?
They did it because they knew what a talented and well built set up we had.
Where we have always been poor is giving the best kids first team football. All those blues players you mentioned got given a chance to prove themselves.
Posts: 19,496
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(07-06-2021, 09:58 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-06-2021, 09:17 PM)Korenavirus Wrote: Our academy "the envy of the premier league" produced one player who cut it in the prem consistently (berahino).
Look back and you see will see Blose and Cov have produced better academy players who have had Premier league careers. We produce lower league players. Even the ones who have been poached by Chelsea and Liverpool have not made it in the prem.
We like to think our academy is brilliant, but the facts say otherwise.
Blose have produced England Internationals in Butland, Redmond, Gray and Bellingham.
We all want them to do well, but in all honesty our youth players don't go on to have long term prem careers.
I don't include Wood as he came to us at a letter age than our other youth players.
Hopefully, Stevens can break the ceiling and produce proper Premier league players for us.
Quick question. If our academy was so shit why did villa take our acedemy manager, our head of recruitment and 5 coaches to build their new academy set up?
They did it because they knew what a talented and well built set up we had.
Where we have always been poor is giving the best kids first team football. All those blues players you mentioned got given a chance to prove themselves.
Unfortunately we just weren’t in a position to take chances on our best kids whereas Blues and Coventry needed to out of necessity. I’m sure both academies have produced plenty of players currently making a living in Leagues One and Two
Posts: 290
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2021
07-07-2021, 12:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-07-2021, 12:23 AM by Korenavirus.)
(07-06-2021, 09:58 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-06-2021, 09:17 PM)Korenavirus Wrote: Our academy "the envy of the premier league" produced one player who cut it in the prem consistently (berahino).
Look back and you see will see Blose and Cov have produced better academy players who have had Premier league careers. We produce lower league players. Even the ones who have been poached by Chelsea and Liverpool have not made it in the prem.
We like to think our academy is brilliant, but the facts say otherwise.
Blose have produced England Internationals in Butland, Redmond, Gray and Bellingham.
We all want them to do well, but in all honesty our youth players don't go on to have long term prem careers.
I don't include Wood as he came to us at a letter age than our other youth players.
Hopefully, Stevens can break the ceiling and produce proper Premier league players for us.
Quick question. If our academy was so shit why did villa take our acedemy manager, our head of recruitment and 5 coaches to build their new academy set up?
They did it because they knew what a talented and well built set up we had.
Where we have always been poor is giving the best kids first team football. All those blues players you mentioned got given a chance to prove themselves.
Who the fuck are villa, they recently spent 3 years in the championship.
Name the great long term premiership players we've produced at our "brilliant" academy?
I don't subscribe to the theory that we don't play them. They go elsewhere and play and still don't become prem players.
Bera went out on loan and we played him. We play them if they are good enough. We have had false dawns from the likes of Field and others, but they cannot do it consistently at the top level.
We needed a revamp and we got it, and we can only hope it produces more.
I honestly believe we got the hype about our great avademy because of the amount of youth internationals we had/have, but that matters not a jot if they don't progress.
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(07-07-2021, 12:20 AM)Korenavirus Wrote: (07-06-2021, 09:58 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-06-2021, 09:17 PM)Korenavirus Wrote: Our academy "the envy of the premier league" produced one player who cut it in the prem consistently (berahino).
Look back and you see will see Blose and Cov have produced better academy players who have had Premier league careers. We produce lower league players. Even the ones who have been poached by Chelsea and Liverpool have not made it in the prem.
We like to think our academy is brilliant, but the facts say otherwise.
Blose have produced England Internationals in Butland, Redmond, Gray and Bellingham.
We all want them to do well, but in all honesty our youth players don't go on to have long term prem careers.
I don't include Wood as he came to us at a letter age than our other youth players.
Hopefully, Stevens can break the ceiling and produce proper Premier league players for us.
Quick question. If our academy was so shit why did villa take our acedemy manager, our head of recruitment and 5 coaches to build their new academy set up?
They did it because they knew what a talented and well built set up we had.
Where we have always been poor is giving the best kids first team football. All those blues players you mentioned got given a chance to prove themselves.
Who the fuck are villa, they recently spent 3 years in the championship.
Name the great long term premiership players we've produced at our "brilliant" academy?
I don't subscribe to the theory that we don't play them. They go elsewhere and play and still don't become prem players.
Bera went out on loan and we played him. We play them if they are good enough. We have had false dawns from the likes of Field and others, but they cannot do it consistently at the top level.
We needed a revamp and we got it, and we can only hope it produces more.
I honestly believe we got the hype about our great avademy because of the amount of youth internationals we had/have, but that matters not a jot if they don't progress.
The fact our U23's are consistently one of the poorer performers in the bottom division of the level they play at, and our U18's have consistently poor results, suggests we might not have such a swathe of starlets as people think. Finally doing well in the Youth Cup is a good start, though.
However, in any team's academy, there are very very few players who go on to have a successful Premier League career with their team. Villa have just won the Youth Cup, how many of their "starlets" will make the grade?
Posts: 2,431
Threads: 137
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
KV makes some valid points. Though losing a decent prospect smarts, our academy hasn't (yet) produced much of Premiership quality. The financial side might look different.
Presumably Brexit will bring more opportunity for younger playas as it will become more difficult to hire in from abroad, and we're unlikely to want to pay £20 toll treatment fees.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(07-07-2021, 07:33 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: (07-07-2021, 12:20 AM)Korenavirus Wrote: (07-06-2021, 09:58 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-06-2021, 09:17 PM)Korenavirus Wrote: Our academy "the envy of the premier league" produced one player who cut it in the prem consistently (berahino).
Look back and you see will see Blose and Cov have produced better academy players who have had Premier league careers. We produce lower league players. Even the ones who have been poached by Chelsea and Liverpool have not made it in the prem.
We like to think our academy is brilliant, but the facts say otherwise.
Blose have produced England Internationals in Butland, Redmond, Gray and Bellingham.
We all want them to do well, but in all honesty our youth players don't go on to have long term prem careers.
I don't include Wood as he came to us at a letter age than our other youth players.
Hopefully, Stevens can break the ceiling and produce proper Premier league players for us.
Quick question. If our academy was so shit why did villa take our acedemy manager, our head of recruitment and 5 coaches to build their new academy set up?
They did it because they knew what a talented and well built set up we had.
Where we have always been poor is giving the best kids first team football. All those blues players you mentioned got given a chance to prove themselves.
Who the fuck are villa, they recently spent 3 years in the championship.
Name the great long term premiership players we've produced at our "brilliant" academy?
I don't subscribe to the theory that we don't play them. They go elsewhere and play and still don't become prem players.
Bera went out on loan and we played him. We play them if they are good enough. We have had false dawns from the likes of Field and others, but they cannot do it consistently at the top level.
We needed a revamp and we got it, and we can only hope it produces more.
I honestly believe we got the hype about our great avademy because of the amount of youth internationals we had/have, but that matters not a jot if they don't progress.
The fact our U23's are consistently one of the poorer performers in the bottom division of the level they play at, and our U18's have consistently poor results, suggests we might not have such a swathe of starlets as people think. Finally doing well in the Youth Cup is a good start, though.
However, in any team's academy, there are very very few players who go on to have a successful Premier League career with their team. Villa have just won the Youth Cup, how many of their "starlets" will make the grade?
I'll be honest, seeing 8 out of the youth cup team sign pro contracts, suggests that roughly 1 in 2 are considered good enough, at that age, and with further improvements if another 1 in 2 end up playing at the club's current level or higher than that is impressive, if 1 in 2 of them then become first team regulars then that is really good... So if 4 of them play for us in the Champ then I think that is good, and if 2 of them become first team regulars then I'm impressed.
There's 92 clubs, say on average they each have 20 players who are regulars, then that is only 1,840 actual professional, regular playing jobs that are available, round it up to 2000 for arguments sake.
if 30 clubs have academies, and they each have an U23, U21 and U18 squad (of say 16 players) then there are 1440 players coming through every 2-3 years... this is ignoring the fact that loads of players come from abroad etc... and ignoring that there are probably more than 30 academies. Ignoring the U21 and U18 teams you still have far more players coming from academies then there are clubs to be able to offer them jobs.
With it seeming that average players are now playing for a couple of years longer than they used to, then it is no wonder that very few Academy players go on to make it.
For comparison, how many of these names do you recognise from Man U's academy in the last few years??
https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/manchest...verein/985
|