End Of The Keir Show?
#41
(07-02-2021, 04:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2021, 02:57 PM)Ossian Wrote: The response of the supposedly mainstream political parties to issues like islamofascism (and indeed any other forms of divisive extremism) should be broadly consistent and not tailored to any local audience for electoral expediency. FPTP unfortunately encourages just that approach.

FPTP encourages that approach where a party believes it owns that vote.

There's only one Party that believes it owns that vote.

(07-02-2021, 12:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: They are one of the only people holding this government to account. I do wonder what you consider working class.

Except they're not, and they're driven by their own metropolitan self righteous indignation rather than by any popular mandate.

You really think that the general public aren't pissed off with the Tory party helping their mates out and shoving money in their own back pockets. There is absolutely a popular mandate for this.
Reply
#42
Oh yes, but shrill Remainiacs like Maugham are not the vehicle.
Reply
#43
(07-02-2021, 06:48 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: So in the end it's more "nothing to see here" than "end of the Keir show". Typical bye-election with loads of candidates bringing national issues and different agendas to distort the statistics.

I'm not expecting Starmer to be leader by the next election. He's an important transitional figure to put some distance between Labour and the disastrous Corbyn era. The fact that so many Labour movers and shakers still can't acknowledge how badly Labour have performed for over 10 years is a millstone for the party and for Britain. This decade of "one party state" hasn't been brilliant.

There are potential candidates for the leadership, especially those with the credibility of doing big jobs as mayors. Rayner's biggest problem is that she talks like a 15 year old high school dropout from Stockport. It might impress the "mates in minimum wage jobs" she's always talking about, but it won't win a General Election. No-one minds an accent, but it's necessary to speak English properly.

She is absolutely nowhere near leadership material. I am not being rude for the sake of it when I don't think she is even councillor calibre, as we would hope that any elected rep would be better than she is.

I wouldn't assume that people in minimum wage jobs are all not very bright, though. I know someone on minimum wage who is massively educated and had a prestigious, well-paid job. Mental health problems then kicked-in and he's a lot poorer but happier in his current job.

(07-02-2021, 07:44 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The ludicrous infighting in the Labour Party has to stop if they want any chance of winning an election. Galloway, Owen Jones are the reasons they lose not a solution. Until those to the left of the party realise this, the party will simply limp on.

That said, it was nice seeing a downbeat media this morning reporting on it. Waaah it wasn’t the Red Wall crumbling story we wanted!

If there was a defeat in B & S I wondered if there would have been a split - but instead of a moderate SDP breakaway, this time, one by the Burgon and McDonnell wing of the party.

(07-02-2021, 06:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Holding a seat with a former 16k majority by 300 votes. The Starmer dream train rolls on.

My old mate Derek is jubilant but after 11 years of Conservative government (in effect) Labour should be winning seats all over the place in by elections, not celebrating holding a seat by 300 votes.

Still, whatever gives his neo-Blairite fantasies succour, I suppose.
Reply
#44
(07-02-2021, 09:01 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-02-2021, 08:27 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Funny how all those now moaning about infighting spent the previous four years siding with the Tories, Libs, media to undermine the then leader.

It's almost as if they don't give a fuck.

Labour has LOST FOUR elections since New Labour at some point the penny will drop that Corbyn and Co were never going to win an election. I cannot think of a worse Tory Party than the last two incarnations and they still won! Either Labours left want to win or they would rather walk around with inter-changeable demonstration placards at meaningless protests in London every six weeks holiday or just when the sun comes out these days seemingly! 

The pathetic thing is looking in from the outside hoping for change and a non Tory government all I see is childish counter productive bickering since Blair and Brown. It's spectacularly stupid, myopic and failing people who need them to get their shit together and oppose the Tories not enable them by navel gazing, plotting and back stabbing each other. The Labour Party needs to grow the feck up and be a credible party again. 

Sorry Ted but Labour will never win an election again unless they appeal to swing voters who won't be joining protests, or marches or getting angry on Twitter. They will be going to work, paying their taxes, abiding by the law, taking their kids to school and wondering wtf represents them!?! The last election presented a shit or sick sandwich as a choice of party to vote for many and I include myself in this group. Sadly the shit sandwich won but I didn't much fancy the sick sandwich either. 

Just keep the message clear, keep policies simple and relatable, for example  tackling anti-social behaviour, tackling violent crime, decent jobs, decent services, give a positive direction for the country that doesn't scare swing voters but is equitable and fair. I know you will say the manifesto at the last election did this and to some extent it did but the party was never seen as credible with Corybyn leading it. Add Brexit to that and it gets us to where the country is now and the Labour Party.

Rant over and nowt personal TM just my opinion from the outside looking in

As much as I may disagree with you on politics Derek, this is spot on in analysing the issue labour have.
Reply
#45
Incidentally, Starmer is acting the big man with his victory but if the swing to the Tories was replicated nationally, the Tories would increase their majority by 40 to 120 MPs.
Reply
#46
(07-02-2021, 10:20 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Incidentally, Starmer is acting the big man with his victory but if the swing to the Tories was replicated nationally, the Tories would increase their majority by 40 to 120 MPs.

Maybe not 

Were you saying the same after the Lib Dem victory in Chesham and Amersham with a huge swing away from your beloved party? Or were you parroting the, ‘well it was a very particular set of circumstances’ routine?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: