End Of The Keir Show?
#11
(07-01-2021, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.

It would be the most hilarious of ironies if the deluded Left started a leadership challenge only to end up with Yvette Cooper. 

Cooper or not, the question remains, what does Labour stand for? On the evidence of the last couple of weeks in Batley it would appear they have no idea - as their beloved multiculturialism begins to eat itself, they've comprehensively failed to support that poor teacher and managed to offend both Muslims and Hindus. Beyond the vapid slogans that are often repeated on here there is nothing to suggest that Labour has a reason to exist.

Without a decent opposition to this government I dread to think where this country is heading.
Reply
#12
(07-01-2021, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.

It would be the most hilarious of ironies if the deluded Left started a leadership challenge only to end up with Yvette Cooper. 

Cooper or not, the question remains, what does Labour stand for? On the evidence of the last couple of weeks in Batley it would appear they have no idea - as their beloved multiculturialism begins to eat itself, they've comprehensively failed to support that poor teacher and managed to offend both Muslims and Hindus. Beyond the vapid slogans that are often repeated on here there is nothing to suggest that Labour has a reason to exist.

Proth why was it up to Labour to defend that teacher. Surely that's the job of the teaching union he belongs to. And if he as been the victim of threats of violence then it is the job of the police.

As I understand his job is not under threat and he is welcome to return to the school to continue teaching.

I would ask you this, do you think it is appropriate for a teacher to use blasphemous material in a classroom, even if it is done with the best of intentions.

People like Laurence Fox have tried to make this into a freedom of speech, it's not. There are always going to be limits to what teachers can say or do in their classroom. And to be even handed about this, people have a legal right to demonstrate outside a school to protest about things that happen in school, as long as the protests are peaceful. But to mind it is never appropriate to do that.

Just because you have a legal right to do something, doesn't  mean that it is right to do it.
Reply
#13
(07-01-2021, 05:07 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.

It would be the most hilarious of ironies if the deluded Left started a leadership challenge only to end up with Yvette Cooper. 

Cooper or not, the question remains, what does Labour stand for? On the evidence of the last couple of weeks in Batley it would appear they have no idea - as their beloved multiculturialism begins to eat itself, they've comprehensively failed to support that poor teacher and managed to offend both Muslims and Hindus. Beyond the vapid slogans that are often repeated on here there is nothing to suggest that Labour has a reason to exist.

Proth why was it up to Labour to defend that teacher. Surely that's the job of the teaching union he belongs to. And if he as been the victim of threats of violence then it is the job of the police.

As I understand his job is not under threat and he is welcome to return to the school to continue teaching.

I would ask you this, do you think it is appropriate for a teacher to use blasphemous material in a classroom, even if it is done with the best of intentions.

People like Laurence Fox have tried to make this into a freedom of speech, it's not. There are always going to be limits to what teachers can say or do in their classroom. And to be even handed about this, people have a legal right to demonstrate outside a school to protest about things that happen in school, as long as the protests are peaceful. But to mind it is never appropriate to do that.

Just because you have a legal right to do something, doesn't  mean that it is right to do it.
Surely it's up to all parties to defend the right of teachers to teach? 
Do you think it's correct that a teacher should be forced to self censor in order not to offend a religious minority? A minority that some of in Birmingham have also seen fit to embark on campaign rooted in religiously based homophobia. 
Of course it's a freedom of speech issue, a teacher is being told they can't do something as simple as show a picture to children because some religious types are offended. 
Was there a call to commit acts of violence by this teacher? No. 
Was anyone induced to break the law? No.
Should people have the right to display images that are not untruthful, pornographic or intended to cause violence no matter what a few religious bigots may think? Yes.
Reply
#14
(07-01-2021, 06:25 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 05:07 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.

It would be the most hilarious of ironies if the deluded Left started a leadership challenge only to end up with Yvette Cooper. 

Cooper or not, the question remains, what does Labour stand for? On the evidence of the last couple of weeks in Batley it would appear they have no idea - as their beloved multiculturialism begins to eat itself, they've comprehensively failed to support that poor teacher and managed to offend both Muslims and Hindus. Beyond the vapid slogans that are often repeated on here there is nothing to suggest that Labour has a reason to exist.

Proth why was it up to Labour to defend that teacher. Surely that's the job of the teaching union he belongs to. And if he as been the victim of threats of violence then it is the job of the police.

As I understand his job is not under threat and he is welcome to return to the school to continue teaching.

I would ask you this, do you think it is appropriate for a teacher to use blasphemous material in a classroom, even if it is done with the best of intentions.

People like Laurence Fox have tried to make this into a freedom of speech, it's not. There are always going to be limits to what teachers can say or do in their classroom. And to be even handed about this, people have a legal right to demonstrate outside a school to protest about things that happen in school, as long as the protests are peaceful. But to mind it is never appropriate to do that.

Just because you have a legal right to do something, doesn't  mean that it is right to do it.
Surely it's up to all parties to defend the right of teachers to teach? 
Do you think it's correct that a teacher should be forced to self censor in order not to offend a religious minority? A minority that some of in Birmingham have also seen fit to embark on campaign rooted in religiously based homophobia. 
Of course it's a freedom of speech issue, a teacher is being told they can't do something as simple as show a picture to children because some religious types are offended. 
Was there a call to commit acts of violence by this teacher? No. 
Was anyone induced to break the law? No.
Should people have the right to display images that are not untruthful, pornographic or intended to cause violence no matter what a few religious bigots may think? Yes.

So no pornography in the classroom, presumably because you would find that objectionable. Probably correctly. 
But other people's sensibilities are fair game?

Threats of violence against this teacher are wrong and unacceptable and I would be amazed if the labour party disagreed with this.
Reply
#15
(07-01-2021, 05:07 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.

It would be the most hilarious of ironies if the deluded Left started a leadership challenge only to end up with Yvette Cooper. 

Cooper or not, the question remains, what does Labour stand for? On the evidence of the last couple of weeks in Batley it would appear they have no idea - as their beloved multiculturialism begins to eat itself, they've comprehensively failed to support that poor teacher and managed to offend both Muslims and Hindus. Beyond the vapid slogans that are often repeated on here there is nothing to suggest that Labour has a reason to exist.

Proth why was it up to Labour to defend that teacher. Surely that's the job of the teaching union he belongs to. And if he as been the victim of threats of violence then it is the job of the police.

As I understand his job is not under threat and he is welcome to return to the school to continue teaching.

I would ask you this, do you think it is appropriate for a teacher to use blasphemous material in a classroom, even if it is done with the best of intentions.

People like Laurence Fox have tried to make this into a freedom of speech, it's not. There are always going to be limits to what teachers can say or do in their classroom. And to be even handed about this, people have a legal right to demonstrate outside a school to protest about things that happen in school, as long as the protests are peaceful. But to mind it is never appropriate to do that.

Just because you have a legal right to do something, doesn't  mean that it is right to do it.

Anything that mentions the prophet in a non-positive light is seen as blasphemous by his followers. It’s lunacy, it’s dangerous and we shouldn’t be cow-towing to such ideas in a 21st century quasi-secular state.
Reply
#16
(07-01-2021, 07:07 PM)Fido Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 05:07 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.

It would be the most hilarious of ironies if the deluded Left started a leadership challenge only to end up with Yvette Cooper. 

Cooper or not, the question remains, what does Labour stand for? On the evidence of the last couple of weeks in Batley it would appear they have no idea - as their beloved multiculturialism begins to eat itself, they've comprehensively failed to support that poor teacher and managed to offend both Muslims and Hindus. Beyond the vapid slogans that are often repeated on here there is nothing to suggest that Labour has a reason to exist.

Proth why was it up to Labour to defend that teacher. Surely that's the job of the teaching union he belongs to. And if he as been the victim of threats of violence then it is the job of the police.

As I understand his job is not under threat and he is welcome to return to the school to continue teaching.

I would ask you this, do you think it is appropriate for a teacher to use blasphemous material in a classroom, even if it is done with the best of intentions.

People like Laurence Fox have tried to make this into a freedom of speech, it's not. There are always going to be limits to what teachers can say or do in their classroom. And to be even handed about this, people have a legal right to demonstrate outside a school to protest about things that happen in school, as long as the protests are peaceful. But to mind it is never appropriate to do that.

Just because you have a legal right to do something, doesn't  mean that it is right to do it.

Anything that mentions the prophet in a non-positive light is seen as blasphemous by his followers. It’s lunacy, it’s dangerous and we shouldn’t be cow-towing to such ideas in a 21st century quasi-secular state.

Correct well said sir, it's the 21st century not the bloody dark ages.
Reply
#17
(07-01-2021, 07:05 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 06:25 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 05:07 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 03:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.

It would be the most hilarious of ironies if the deluded Left started a leadership challenge only to end up with Yvette Cooper. 

Cooper or not, the question remains, what does Labour stand for? On the evidence of the last couple of weeks in Batley it would appear they have no idea - as their beloved multiculturialism begins to eat itself, they've comprehensively failed to support that poor teacher and managed to offend both Muslims and Hindus. Beyond the vapid slogans that are often repeated on here there is nothing to suggest that Labour has a reason to exist.

Proth why was it up to Labour to defend that teacher. Surely that's the job of the teaching union he belongs to. And if he as been the victim of threats of violence then it is the job of the police.

As I understand his job is not under threat and he is welcome to return to the school to continue teaching.

I would ask you this, do you think it is appropriate for a teacher to use blasphemous material in a classroom, even if it is done with the best of intentions.

People like Laurence Fox have tried to make this into a freedom of speech, it's not. There are always going to be limits to what teachers can say or do in their classroom. And to be even handed about this, people have a legal right to demonstrate outside a school to protest about things that happen in school, as long as the protests are peaceful. But to mind it is never appropriate to do that.

Just because you have a legal right to do something, doesn't  mean that it is right to do it.
Surely it's up to all parties to defend the right of teachers to teach? 
Do you think it's correct that a teacher should be forced to self censor in order not to offend a religious minority? A minority that some of in Birmingham have also seen fit to embark on campaign rooted in religiously based homophobia. 
Of course it's a freedom of speech issue, a teacher is being told they can't do something as simple as show a picture to children because some religious types are offended. 
Was there a call to commit acts of violence by this teacher? No. 
Was anyone induced to break the law? No.
Should people have the right to display images that are not untruthful, pornographic or intended to cause violence no matter what a few religious bigots may think? Yes.

So no pornography in the classroom, presumably because you would find that objectionable. Probably correctly. 
But other people's sensibilities are fair game?

Threats of violence against this teacher are wrong and unacceptable and I would be amazed if the labour party disagreed with this.

What a stupidly desperate comparison, as desperate as some blaming Brexit because they can't find flat leaf parsley. I am quite happy for my kids to watch or look at non pornographic cartoons, i think this falls into the same category.
If the teacher had shown a picture of Mohammed with his cock out then you may have had a point. 
If we tip toe around every sensibility where do we stop? 
The threats of violence have come about because we have emboldened the religious fanatics by constantly bowing to the mantra of "don't offend at any cost".
Reply
#18
(07-01-2021, 05:07 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I would ask you this, do you think it is appropriate for a teacher to use blasphemous material in a classroom, even if it is done with the best of intentions.


The fella and his family are in hiding. He's had very little support from his union nor the Labour movement precisely because they risk offending the client vote (which they've managed to anyway).

It is entirely appropriate for a teacher to introduce the concepts of free speech and to challenge religious hegemony - particularly in communities where this will never be challenged in the home. This is a free and liberal society FFS (I hope), and it's entirely appropriate to question everything, particularly the medieval ramblings in various holy books. After all, the same medieval ramblings are often used to justify the most heinous acts in this country, but far more frequently in the Islamic world.

We don't have blasphemy laws in the UK. I don't give a damn if a believer in any denomination is offended, it's more a reflection of the fragility of their own faith than anything else.

(07-01-2021, 07:07 PM)Fido Wrote: Anything that mentions the prophet in a non-positive light is seen as blasphemous by his followers. It’s lunacy, it’s dangerous and we shouldn’t be cow-towing to such ideas in a 21st century quasi-secular state.

Ay it.
Reply
#19
Sorry Proth but you are wrong on this issue.

I am not religious, so I don't understand some of the beliefs that underpin them. I couldn't explain why Islam bans the use of images of the prophet, I can't understand why Hindus believe cows are sacred, I don't understand why some Christian sects disavow the use of modern machinery, but they do.

This teacher is a RE teacher he should know that images of the prophet are prohibited and yet he decided to use them in a class where some of the pupils were Muslim. In my opinion that was the wrong choice and displayed a lack of empathy for his pupils.

None of what I say excuses some of the responses to this.
I don't think demos outside school gates are right and intimidation is both wrong and a criminal offence.
It is intolerable that he has not been able to return to work or his home.
Reply
#20
So in the end it's more "nothing to see here" than "end of the Keir show". Typical bye-election with loads of candidates bringing national issues and different agendas to distort the statistics.

I'm not expecting Starmer to be leader by the next election. He's an important transitional figure to put some distance between Labour and the disastrous Corbyn era. The fact that so many Labour movers and shakers still can't acknowledge how badly Labour have performed for over 10 years is a millstone for the party and for Britain. This decade of "one party state" hasn't been brilliant.

There are potential candidates for the leadership, especially those with the credibility of doing big jobs as mayors. Rayner's biggest problem is that she talks like a 15 year old high school dropout from Stockport. It might impress the "mates in minimum wage jobs" she's always talking about, but it won't win a General Election. No-one minds an accent, but it's necessary to speak English properly.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)