End Of The Keir Show?
#1
If they lose Batley & Spen, Angela Rayner is rumoured to be mounting a leadership challenge. Owen Jones wants McDonnell to be leader.

So if Labour doesn't retain the seat - which it may well do so, despite gloom in Labour circles - is it over for Mr Forensic? "What the Prime Minister should have done is..."

As an aside, what a shameful campaign it's been in that constituency.
Reply
#2
I don't want Labour to lose Batley & Spen but if it puts the final nail in Starmer's coffin then I could live with it.
Reply
#3
If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.
Reply
#4
(07-01-2021, 10:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't want Labour to lose Batley & Spen but if it puts the final nail in Starmer's coffin then I could live with it.

And if McConnell becomes leader, we'll probably see the end of Labour as any kind of opposition at all. (Outside Islington and Maida Vale, anyway).
Reply
#5
(07-01-2021, 11:36 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 10:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't want Labour to lose Batley & Spen but if it puts the final nail in Starmer's coffin then I could live with it.

And if McConnell becomes leader, we'll probably see the end of Labour as any kind of opposition at all. (Outside Islington and Maida Vale, anyway).

Burnham. Said it before Starmer got the job and it seems even more relevant now.

Starmer is the most Islington and Maida Vale candidate Labour could have gone with.
Reply
#6
My political forecasting skills are not so great at the moment. But I don't think he will go if they lose this by election. Nor should he.

I don't think he is up to the job, but he hasn't had a fair crack of the whip, particularly with the pandemic disrupting the way politics is normally conducted.

And this by election would be a bad one to base a national decision on.

I don't vote labour, but if I could vote in this by election I would have no hesitation in voting for Kim Leadbitter. The invisible man and the toxic part in the hat, the other 2 main contenders just do not deserve to be elected.
Reply
#7
I think it should be remembered that Mr. Starmer was starting from a very low eb and the Labour party can’t be turned around in a few months. Surely to keep chopping and changing leaders every 12 months or so is no  help for stability. The biggest criticism I can give stammer is that he seems to be just a ‘gain say’ politician at present. 

I couldn’t really say what the Labour ideas are at present. It would be nice to have some idea rather than wait for an election manifesto which would give us just a month or so to digest.
Reply
#8
(07-01-2021, 02:28 PM)JOK Wrote: I think it should be remembered that Mr. Starmer was starting from a very low eb and the Labour party can’t be turned around in a few months. Surely to keep chopping and changing leaders every 12 months or so is no  help for stability. The biggest criticism I can give stammer is that he seems to be just a ‘gain say’ politician at present. 

I couldn’t really say what the Labour ideas are at present. It would be nice to have some idea rather than wait for an election manifesto which would give us just a month or so to digest.

It seems to be wait for the Tories to do something, criticize it & then use hindsight to make out you had a better all along but just forgot to mention it. 
I think Derek may have got a job advising them on strategy.
Reply
#9
(07-01-2021, 02:47 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(07-01-2021, 02:28 PM)JOK Wrote: I think it should be remembered that Mr. Starmer was starting from a very low eb and the Labour party can’t be turned around in a few months. Surely to keep chopping and changing leaders every 12 months or so is no  help for stability. The biggest criticism I can give stammer is that he seems to be just a ‘gain say’ politician at present. 

I couldn’t really say what the Labour ideas are at present. It would be nice to have some idea rather than wait for an election manifesto which would give us just a month or so to digest.

It seems to be wait for the Tories to do something, criticize it & then use hindsight to make out you had a better all along but just forgot to mention it. 
I think Derek may have got a job advising them on strategy.

Labour do need to be clearer on their policies but let’s not go down the hindsight route with excuses. We had Italy’s health system melting down for weeks whilst we dithered and did nothing to stop rates in Covid escalating. At the same time we had a arf leader bragging about shaking hands with Covid patients! We then had a second wave  after telling people to go to work and eat at their local restaurants, then yet another delay to close down travel to India. There have been others but it’s difficult to keep up with the poor decisions. Hindsight it wasn’t.

The idea that those who criticised did so in retrospect is nonsense from people who can’t help themselves defend this government. I like the fact you’ve mention me twice already directly and indirectly today. Thanks for the use of your head rent free Wink
Reply
#10
(07-01-2021, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If Yvette Cooper were to put up a leadership challenge if Labour do lose the seat for example I would say bring it on. The optics of Boris trying to bluster and shout down Cooper wouldn't be a good look, and I suspect she would be a lot more effective as a leader.

It would be the most hilarious of ironies if the deluded Left started a leadership challenge only to end up with Yvette Cooper. 

Cooper or not, the question remains, what does Labour stand for? On the evidence of the last couple of weeks in Batley it would appear they have no idea - as their beloved multiculturialism begins to eat itself, they've comprehensively failed to support that poor teacher and managed to offend both Muslims and Hindus. Beyond the vapid slogans that are often repeated on here there is nothing to suggest that Labour has a reason to exist.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: