SWE v UKR
#21
Was more like watching ten pin bowling than football... Felt like someone went over every time they went near the ball...

In theory England *should not* have too much trouble, but we all know how that usually goes.
Reply
#22
I agree with the no foul brigade, personally.

It does look bad but he kicks the ball in a natural way and it's the opponent trying to tackle him; not the other way round. Complete accident and not something that should be punished out of football.

Rondon kicked a player in the back of the shin and broke his leg. No one was calling for a red there. What's the difference?
Reply
#23
Accident but definitely a red , you cannot go in like that nowadays, didn’t mean to hurt the player but definitely reckless. Had to go. Hit the ball with his studs showing you cannot tackle like that, with the follow though I will say ending that mans tournament.
Reply
#24
(06-29-2021, 10:01 PM)wba13 Wrote: Accident but definitely a red , you cannot go in like that nowadays, didn’t mean to hurt the player but definitely reckless.  Had to go. Hit the ball with his studs showing you cannot tackle like that, with the follow though I will say ending that mans tournament.

Reckless is a yellow though?
Reply
#25
The red for me was a yellow if that, it was when it was slowed down and constantly repeated that it got worse and worse, at normal speed he got the ball, the other guy ran into his foot...

Slowed down and zoomed in it looked much much worse.
Reply
#26
(06-29-2021, 09:43 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-29-2021, 09:27 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(06-29-2021, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-29-2021, 09:12 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: I fail to understand how a complete accident can be a "stonewall red", so we'll have to leave it there.

Because accidents and intent to win the ball haven't been a factor in whether or not a player deserves a booking for well over 20 years. Any challenge that is dangerous, like that one, will be a red card offence by virtue of there being excessive force regardless of whether it's an accident.

Which part of "we'll have to leave it there" wasn't clear?  However;

By extension of your argument, if on the field of play, I'm on one knee tieing a shoelace, and you, chasing a long aerial ball and not looking at the ground, fail to see me, run in to me, fall over and break your arm, that's a stonewall red for me. Which is, of course total bollocks.

I maintain that the Ukrainian ran into the foot full pelt; you could even argue that it was he who was reckless and displaying excessive force.

Oh, and just for clarity, FIFA changed law 12 to "...tackles an opponent in a manner that is careless, reckless or using excessive force..." in 2009, so a bit less than "well over 20 years". 

I still therefore retain sympathy for Danielson.  Hope that's OK, all about opinions and all that.

You're arguing that something that is dangerous is not a red because it was accidental. That isn't a thing anymore, it hasn't been for bloody ages.

Danielson had his leg so high up in the air studs up that it made contact with a Ukrainian player's knee while he was in mid-air. That is the factor that was dangerous, that was the factor that is covered by excessive force. My point cannot be twisted into the other player running into him as the other player wasn't goose stepping. And unless you're tying your laces while on your back with your feet in the air then no it isn't the same either.

Don't get pissy with my for pointing out the rule to you, if you object to the issue of excessive force take it up with IFAB. That is a red card every day of the week with the rules written as they are, no referee is ever not going to send off a player for that no matter how harsh you feel it is. It's absolutely, 100% a stonewall red card.

I'll get as pissy as I want with whoever I want, cocknose.
Reply
#27
Felt like Sweden were the architects of their own downfall tonight. They have one way of playing with a view to disrupting their way through tournaments by stifling better sides. It works pretty well in group stages, and the smattering of ability they have with Isak and Fosberg usually is enough to grab wins, but against an agricultural and motivated Ukraine they just didn’t show anywhere near enough intent.

We have nothing to fear from a very, very average Ukraine who in a normal tournament wouldn’t have made it out the group.
Reply
#28
(06-29-2021, 10:04 PM)HLS Wrote:
(06-29-2021, 10:01 PM)wba13 Wrote: Accident but definitely a red , you cannot go in like that nowadays, didn’t mean to hurt the player but definitely reckless.  Had to go. Hit the ball with his studs showing you cannot tackle like that, with the follow though I will say ending that mans tournament.

Reckless is a yellow though?

Sorry cannot agree definitely red to much force with studs leading the way.  But it’s good we can’t all agree we will all see it differently.
Reply
#29
That was never a red card, he played the ball and the player ran into his foot, at normal speed the other guy was not near the ball when he kicked it. The problem was it looked worse at super slow motion and in isolation. An unfortunate accident, but nothing deliberate, if those are red card offences they may as well ban tackling.
Reply
#30
Never mind the red card, what of Ukraine? I thought they were rubbish. So long as Southgate gets the heads right they have nothing to trouble us. However, England have previous so the mentality must be spot on.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: