Posts: 1,324
Threads: 117
Joined: Dec 2020
06-21-2021, 12:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-21-2021, 12:59 PM by DJPunkRoc.)
(06-21-2021, 12:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:50 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:39 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:02 AM)Fido Wrote: (06-21-2021, 10:23 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Why on Earth excluding people born as men from womens' competitive sport is remotely controversial is beyond me.
This is a hill worth dying on tbh, as it's the thin end of the wedge in rendering all advances in womens' equality and safety redundant to appease a tiny minority of men (or X Men).
Is it? Seems a touch hyperbolic. Not quite up there with fighting Nazis...
How did daddy die mommy? He died fighting the evil transgenders winning a gold medal in the Olympics.
But why mommy? Because he said it was the thin edge of the wedge.
But what does that mean mommy? Fuck knows, he never said...he mumbled something about women's rights and competitive weightlifting...
...and they say the millennials over-react!
Perhaps I should refrain from using metaphors in future if they're beyond your comprehension. As the father of two daughters heavily into competitive sport I'd be leading the vanguard to boycott whichever organisation saw fit to allow a male to compete against them. It goes completely against the spirit of competitive sport.
The trans debate is led by some pretty poisonous people, and at its heart there is simple truth - mysoginistic "ex-men" wishing to impose their will and their 'rights' on women and girls. That's your wedge, ignore it at your peril if you value any of the advances made by women in the last 100 years.
"Any of the advances" - glad you're got off the hyperbole express, lad.
It's a muscular woman beating another woman in a race or a lifting things contest, not suffrage.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
06-21-2021, 12:57 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-21-2021, 01:27 PM by fuzzbox.)
(06-21-2021, 12:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:50 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:39 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:02 AM)Fido Wrote: (06-21-2021, 10:23 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Why on Earth excluding people born as men from womens' competitive sport is remotely controversial is beyond me.
This is a hill worth dying on tbh, as it's the thin end of the wedge in rendering all advances in womens' equality and safety redundant to appease a tiny minority of men (or X Men).
Is it? Seems a touch hyperbolic. Not quite up there with fighting Nazis...
How did daddy die mommy? He died fighting the evil transgenders winning a gold medal in the Olympics.
But why mommy? Because he said it was the thin edge of the wedge.
But what does that mean mommy? Fuck knows, he never said...he mumbled something about women's rights and competitive weightlifting...
...and they say the millennials over-react!
Perhaps I should refrain from using metaphors in future if they're beyond your comprehension. As the father of two daughters heavily into competitive sport I'd be leading the vanguard to boycott whichever organisation saw fit to allow a male to compete against them. It goes completely against the spirit of competitive sport.
The trans debate is led by some pretty poisonous people, and at its heart there is simple truth - mysoginistic "ex-men" wishing to impose their will and their 'rights' on women and girls. That's your wedge, ignore it at your peril if you value any of the advances made by women in the last 100 years.
I'm sure everyone understood the metaphor - it's a tired old trope we've all heard thousands of times before. I just don't agree with it used in this context.
I also understand the rhetorical tactic of attaching your point of view to an established truth or 'noble crusade' to help it get the credibility it doesn't deserve.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(06-21-2021, 12:08 PM)Squid Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:50 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:39 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:02 AM)Fido Wrote: (06-21-2021, 10:23 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Why on Earth excluding people born as men from womens' competitive sport is remotely controversial is beyond me.
This is a hill worth dying on tbh, as it's the thin end of the wedge in rendering all advances in womens' equality and safety redundant to appease a tiny minority of men (or X Men).
Is it? Seems a touch hyperbolic. Not quite up there with fighting Nazis...
How did daddy die mommy? He died fighting the evil transgenders winning a gold medal in the Olympics.
But why mommy? Because he said it was the thin edge of the wedge.
But what does that mean mommy? Fuck knows, he never said...he mumbled something about women's rights and competitive weightlifting...
...and they say the millennials over-react!
It's not just about the Olympics.
It's about women's sports becoming a sham from school age, as has happened in Conneticut where two formerly average male athletes are now taking titles and scholarships from female athletes.
It's about women being raped in prison, because they are being housed with male sex offenders.
It's about women not having any women only refuges anymore.
It's about women's health not communicating important information clearly because they have to address their messages to "people with a cervix" when most of the population doesn't know what a cervix is.
It's about women who speak out about this receiving death threats and the sack.
It's about meetings where women to talk about these matters having to be held IN SECRET because otherwise protestors will turn up to intimidate the women (and men) who wish to attend.
And that's not even getting into the current horrorshow happening to young people, which the Keira Bell case and multiple Tavistock whistle-blowers have unearthed. The BBC journalists who covered this, also received death threats, btw.
Do you still think being concerned about this is a "bit snowflakey"?
Absolutely fantastic post
Posts: 1,324
Threads: 117
Joined: Dec 2020
(06-21-2021, 12:58 PM)Sliced Wrote: (06-21-2021, 12:08 PM)Squid Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:50 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Is it? Seems a touch hyperbolic. Not quite up there with fighting Nazis...
How did daddy die mommy? He died fighting the evil transgenders winning a gold medal in the Olympics.
But why mommy? Because he said it was the thin edge of the wedge.
But what does that mean mommy? Fuck knows, he never said...he mumbled something about women's rights and competitive weightlifting...
...and they say the millennials over-react!
It's not just about the Olympics.
It's about women's sports becoming a sham from school age, as has happened in Conneticut where two formerly average male athletes are now taking titles and scholarships from female athletes.
It's about women being raped in prison, because they are being housed with male sex offenders.
It's about women not having any women only refuges anymore.
It's about women's health not communicating important information clearly because they have to address their messages to "people with a cervix" when most of the population doesn't know what a cervix is.
It's about women who speak out about this receiving death threats and the sack.
It's about meetings where women to talk about these matters having to be held IN SECRET because otherwise protestors will turn up to intimidate the women (and men) who wish to attend.
And that's not even getting into the current horrorshow happening to young people, which the Keira Bell case and multiple Tavistock whistle-blowers have unearthed. The BBC journalists who covered this, also received death threats, btw.
Do you still think being concerned about this is a "bit snowflakey"?
Absolutely fantastic post
Except the subject is about sport, not about prison rape.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
DJPunkRoc Wrote:Protheroe Wrote:fuzzbox Wrote:Is it? Seems a touch hyperbolic. Not quite up there with fighting Nazis...
How did daddy die mommy? He died fighting the evil transgenders winning a gold medal in the Olympics.
But why mommy? Because he said it was the thin edge of the wedge.
But what does that mean mommy? Fuck knows, he never said...he mumbled something about women's rights and competitive weightlifting...
...and they say the millennials over-react!
Perhaps I should refrain from using metaphors in future if they're beyond your comprehension. As the father of two daughters heavily into competitive sport I'd be leading the vanguard to boycott whichever organisation saw fit to allow a male to compete against them. It goes completely against the spirit of competitive sport.
The trans debate is led by some pretty poisonous people, and at its heart there is simple truth - mysoginistic "ex-men" wishing to impose their will and their 'rights' on women and girls. That's your wedge, ignore it at your peril if you value any of the advances made by women in the last 100 years.
"Any of the values" - glad you're got off the hyperbole express, lad.
It's a muscular woman beating another woman in a race or a lifting things contest, not suffrage. it's not, entirely, though. As explained back upthread, there are a lot of other issues around this one. Be free to identify as whatever you please but there are certain aspects of life you shouldn't be allowed to partake of, this is the price of freedom. Women's sports, prisons, refuges should all be out of bounds to all but women. Is that so unreasonable?
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
06-21-2021, 01:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-21-2021, 01:28 PM by fuzzbox.)
Am I missing something or is it the Olympic committee that decides this?
It's got nothing to do with laws in our country. So nothing to do with prison rapes or women only refuges.
Trying to conflate the two is bizarre.
What happened to the chemical analysis for Olympic athletes? Weren't some 'natural' women prevented from competing because of that? Does that mean they were excluded from women-only refuges or sent to be raped in men-only prisons? Of course not...
I don't personally agree with the Olympic committee decision, but the hyperbole is odd.
I'm waiting for the time there will only be universal competition - no women-only or men-only events. That should be fun....at least we won't have to worry about mediocre ex-male athletes or debates why the 700th best player who happens to be the first woman in the ranking should get paid the same as 'top' athletes....
Posts: 129
Threads: 6
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(06-21-2021, 12:41 PM)DJPunkRoc Wrote: (06-21-2021, 12:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-21-2021, 11:50 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Is it? Seems a touch hyperbolic. Not quite up there with fighting Nazis...
How did daddy die mommy? He died fighting the evil transgenders winning a gold medal in the Olympics.
But why mommy? Because he said it was the thin edge of the wedge.
But what does that mean mommy? Fuck knows, he never said...he mumbled something about women's rights and competitive weightlifting...
...and they say the millennials over-react!
Perhaps I should refrain from using metaphors in future if they're beyond your comprehension. As the father of two daughters heavily into competitive sport I'd be leading the vanguard to boycott whichever organisation saw fit to allow a male to compete against them. It goes completely against the spirit of competitive sport.
The trans debate is led by some pretty poisonous people, and at its heart there is simple truth - mysoginistic "ex-men" wishing to impose their will and their 'rights' on women and girls. That's your wedge, ignore it at your peril if you value any of the advances made by women in the last 100 years.
"Any of the advances" - glad you're got off the hyperbole express, lad.
It's a muscular woman beating another woman in a race or a lifting things contest, not suffrage.
The whole point of this being that it’s not a muscular woman though, is it? It’s a muscular Trans woman. Which is not the same thing at all
Posts: 1,972
Threads: 136
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(06-21-2021, 01:09 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Am I missing something or is it the Olympic committee that decides this?
It's got nothing to do with laws in our country. So nothing to do with prison rapes or women only refuges.
Trying to conflate the two is bizarre.
What happened to the chemical analysis for Olympic athletes? Weren't some 'natural' women prevented from competing because of that? Does that mean they were excluded from women-only refuges or sent to be raped in men-only prisons? Of course not...
I don't personally agree with the Olympic committee decision, but the hyperbole is odd.
I'm waiting for the time there will only be universal competition - no women-only or men-only events. That should be fun....at least we won't have to worry about mediocre ex-male athletes or debates why the 700th best player who happens to be the first woman in the ranking should get paid the same as 'top' athletes.... yes you're missing the point that whilst this particular case is related to the olympics, its posited on the notion that trans women are the same as biological women and there is a wider debate around that.
To suggest the IOC reached this decision in isolation with no reference to the wider on-going debate is bizarre.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(06-21-2021, 01:09 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Am I missing something or is it the Olympic committee that decides this?
It's got nothing to do with laws in our country. So nothing to do with prison rapes or women only refuges.
Trying to conflate the two is bizarre.
What happened to the chemical analysis for Olympic athletes? Weren't some 'natural' women prevented from competing because of that? Does that mean they were excluded from women-only refuges or sent to be raped in men-only prisons? Of course not...
I don't personally agree with the Olympic committee decision, but the hyperbole is odd.
I'm waiting for the time there will only be universal competition - no women-only or men-only events. That should be fun....at least we won't have to worry about mediocre ex-male athletes or debates why the 700th best player who happens to be the first woman in the ranking should get paid the same as 'top' athletes....
Actually it has.
The current law is that people can apply for a Gender Recognition Certificate. This means you can live as your chosen gender but there are exceptions under the Equality Act 2010.
But. In other countries there is a push for Self-ID. So that if someone says they are a women, they are, in all circumstances, with no exceptions whatsoever.
Self-ID is not the law in the UK, but under pressure from lobbying groups, some organisations have been acting as though it is. The UK Prison Service being one example and this is now undergoing judicial review.
Currently in Scotland they are looking to introduce Self-ID, hence the Women Won't Wheesht campaign against it. And Kier Starmer has just come out in support of Self-ID, as have several in the Labour Party, it was a Lib Dem policy at the last election (during which Jo Swinson couldn't explain what a woman was) and some Tories too.
So it does affect us in the UK and goes far beyond one Olympic competitor.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
06-21-2021, 04:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-21-2021, 04:14 PM by fuzzbox.)
My criticism was of the hperbole. It wasn't meant as a defence of the IOC. I already said I disagree with it.
Frankly, if I passionately disagreed with the IOC as some on here obviously do, rather than choosing this as a 'hill to die on' I would be hoping it goes ahead.
If the sport became ruined by people self-certifying 'post-men' women taking all the scholarships and winning all the events it would become fairly obvious, fairly quickly that it was the wrong decision.
It would also be comparatively easy to reverse, unlike in many other areas of life.
As regards the legislation, it's very, very easy to add exceptions. Simply add the words 'competitive sport' or 'women's refuge' to it. But again, in the sporting context, I'm ambivalent. It'll be very obvious, very quickly it was a crazy decision.
It's true the IOC didn't take this stance in isolation and there's an organised body that lobby for these decisions. However, I'm confident they will soon lose support when they are up against a much larger and more organised women's lobby once women start losing out. Then, when it goes 'tit's up' it will be much harder to push this agenda. (Now that's how you use a metaphor, Prothoroe !  )
So no, I don't agree with the decision but I absolutely don't think it's 'a hill worth dying on'.
|