The manager situation - a summary
#1
What a mess we find ourselves in. Some self inflicted, some inflicted on us, some simply caused by where we find ourselves as a club. How did we get to this position and what's the route out for us?

You can draw a line back 2 years ago. This was the 1st time we approached Wilder,  before we appointed Bilic. Seemed very unlikely at the time on paper but the cracks in the Wilder/Sheff Utd relationship were starting to grow then due his friend and ally, Kevin McCabe, losing his power struggle with the Saudi's. Despite a great season in 19/20, the writing was on the wall.

We had contact with Wilder again around his departure from SU. There was a mutual understanding that he and us would be a good fit if we went down. At that stage, that's all it was. We could do no more until the R was against our name. At this stage however, Allardyce then started to improve us, even giving us an outside chance of staying up. His stock rose and by April, the club were happy for Sam to stay even if we were relegated.

Sam then dillied and dallied, and the time, that could have been spent putting things into operation if he'd made a decision sooner, was lost. 

Then the process started. With restrictions around compensation in place, as illogical and inflexible as it is. We were looking for a manager not in work, willing to manage in the Championship. That's a pretty small lake to fish from, with a lot of sprats swimming around.

Wilder was and still is the no.1 choice of Dowling. Wilder was and still is desperate to join us. The failure to get this over the line is not about wages or desire from Wilder. It was all but done when Lai pulled the plug in bizarre circumstances. It seems the Saudi's, who have investment in China, have a big say in our selection process and the rift between them and Wilder continues.

That block a week or so ago threw things into turmoil and back to square one. This is where it gets very difficult, not helped by our crazy no compensation rule.  The merry go round of managers in the prem was reducing our lake further. Both Howe and Lampard have said they want a prem gig. Roy, has said he's taking time away to decide what he wants to do. Look around, there's little that fit the bill. This is when Wagner entered the equation and we all know that particular fish was lost out the keep net.

So this is where we are now. We either continue to look at out of work managers who tick enough boxes or we relax the no compensation rule which does at least allow us to fish in a bigger lake, albeit still not a great lake.

Hopefully the club will see sense and be more flexible. It is absolutely ridiculous to restrict yourself so much. We could get this sorted pretty quickly if we apply logic. If we don't,  we are left with a lot of very unpalatable choices.
Reply
#2
The "no compensation" ruling is baffling as you say Rich. When you consider the managers we would be looking at with that criteria probably wouldn't cost that much in the grand scheme of things.
Reply
#3
Pretty much cock on that Rich. Being Albion you know we will always make a difficult job of almost everything we do ,its the Albion way unfortunately and my big fear is this will drag on and on until we make a last min choice out of desperation and go into the new season totally unprepared and having to play catch up as we go, which if goes badly will lead to a very toxic atmosphere on match days quite quickly i fear.
Reply
#4
Great OP, although it certainly does not bring any good news.
Reply
#5
Like I said on another thread the club don't think anything when wasting multiple millions on players yet they won't speculate for a manager.

Very strange.....
Reply
#6
Gareth Southgate will be available after Croatia stuff us tomorrow
Reply
#7
(06-12-2021, 08:01 AM)tiptontown Wrote: The "no compensation" ruling is baffling as you say Rich. When you consider the managers we would be looking at with that criteria probably wouldn't cost that much in the grand scheme of things.

It seems particularly perverse that we'll pay compensation to rid ourselves of managers we've decided to move out, but won't stump up to secure those we're hoping to attract.
Reply
#8
On a general, not Albion point, I wonder if clubs are reluctant to take managers currently employed by other clubs because it can lead to, too much bad feelings between the clubs. Perhaps a polite enquiry ascertained very quickly whether things will get messy, and if they will, the club needing a manager leaves well alone.

There seems to be a lot of managerial positions open  how many are being filled by managers currently employed by other clubs.

Perhaps compensation is not the issue.
Reply
#9
(06-12-2021, 08:19 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: On a general, not Albion point, I wonder if clubs are reluctant to take managers currently employed by other clubs because it can lead to, too much bad feelings between the clubs. Perhaps a polite enquiry ascertained very quickly whether things will get messy, and if they will, the club needing a manager leaves well alone.

There seems to be a lot of managerial positions open  how many are being filled by managers currently employed by other clubs.

Perhaps compensation is not the issue.

There was a Prem agreement not to poach managers some years ago. Dunno if it still applies and it certainly doesn't in the FL.
Reply
#10
(06-12-2021, 07:53 AM)richbaggie Wrote: What a mess we find ourselves in. Some self inflicted, some inflicted on us, some simply caused by where we find ourselves as a club. How did we get to this position and what's the route out for us?

You can draw a line back 2 years ago. This was the 1st time we approached Wilder,  before we appointed Bilic. Seemed very unlikely at the time on paper but the cracks in the Wilder/Sheff Utd relationship were starting to grow then due his friend and ally, Kevin McCabe, losing his power struggle with the Saudi's. Despite a great season in 19/20, the writing was on the wall.

We had contact with Wilder again around his departure from SU. There was a mutual understanding that he and us would be a good fit if we went down. At that stage, that's all it was. We could do no more until the R was against our name. At this stage however, Allardyce then started to improve us, even giving us an outside chance of staying up. His stock rose and by April, the club were happy for Sam to stay even if we were relegated.

Sam then dillied and dallied, and the time, that could have been spent putting things into operation if he'd made a decision sooner, was lost. 

Then the process started. With restrictions around compensation in place, as illogical and inflexible as it is. We were looking for a manager not in work, willing to manage in the Championship. That's a pretty small lake to fish from, with a lot of sprats swimming around.

Wilder was and still is the no.1 choice of Dowling. Wilder was and still is desperate to join us. The failure to get this over the line is not about wages or desire from Wilder. It was all but done when Lai pulled the plug in bizarre circumstances. It seems the Saudi's, who have investment in China, have a big say in our selection process and the rift between them and Wilder continues.

That block a week or so ago threw things into turmoil and back to square one. This is where it gets very difficult, not helped by our crazy no compensation rule.  The merry go round of managers in the prem was reducing our lake further. Both Howe and Lampard have said they want a prem gig. Roy, has said he's taking time away to decide what he wants to do. Look around, there's little that fit the bill. This is when Wagner entered the equation and we all know that particular fish was lost out the keep net.

So this is where we are now. We either continue to look at out of work managers who tick enough boxes or we relax the no compensation rule which does at least allow us to fish in a bigger lake, albeit still not a great lake.

Hopefully the club will see sense and be more flexible. It is absolutely ridiculous to restrict yourself so much. We could get this sorted pretty quickly if we apply logic. If we don't,  we are left with a lot of very unpalatable choices.

You ruined someone's hattrick yesterday.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: