From an ITK source
(06-02-2021, 07:00 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
baggiebloke Wrote:
sickParrot Wrote:
baggiebloke Wrote:Anyone who thinks that last season is remotely representative of Chris Wilder's managerial career is not very bright.

Check your facts, KWs.

Every manager gets it wrong and gets the sack, even Ranieri was sacked a few months after winning the title with lesta.

If we don’t want a manager that has failed in the Prem, our only other choice is a manager who hasn’t managed at that level.

Hodgson = Iceland

Wasn't Hodgson sacked after failing at Blackburn as well? Well, failure relatively speaking.

And surely everybody knows that Pulis replaced Pardew and not the other way round. Right?

I had a meeting in Cannock with someone who turned out to be a Blackburn fan.

He really disliked Hodgson, called him all sorts of nasty things.

It felt a bit OTT.
Reply
Was his name MACCAD?
Reply
There’s definitely a malaise around Wilder, but when you look at it entirely objectively, he has the best CV for the role.

My biggest concern is that throughout his career he’s only had one season where there’s been any expectation. In fairness to him, he won the league with over 100 points that season so it seems he can deliver when the pressure is on, but the bulk of his achievements seem to have come when they’ve been plucky underdogs and next season we will be anything but.

That being said, very few - if any - managers have a record that can compare with his...he’s won promotion from every division in the UK and crucially he’s won one with every club he’s managed. I think only Colin has more promotions than him.

I think other than last season and him keeping Northampton up, he’s finished in the top half of a division in every season he’s managed... combine that record with a club that’s never finished outside the top 6 in the Champinship in over 20 years... what can go wrong!!
Reply
(06-02-2021, 08:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: There’s definitely a malaise around Wilder, but when you look at it entirely objectively, he has the best CV for the role.

My biggest concern is that throughout his career he’s only had one season where there’s been any expectation. In fairness to him, he won the league with over 100 points that season so it seems he can deliver when the pressure is on, but the bulk of his achievements seem to have come when they’ve been plucky underdogs and next season we will be anything but.

That being said, very few - if any - managers have a record that can compare with his...he’s won promotion from every division in the UK and crucially he’s won one with every club he’s managed. I think only Colin has more promotions than him.

I think other than last season and him keeping Northampton up, he’s finished in the top half of a division in every season he’s managed... combine that record with a club that’s never finished outside the top 6 in the Champinship in over 20 years... what can go wrong!!

Everything.


This move worries me so deeply. I worry with Wilder at the helm
Reply
Well on the grounds your football knowledge and preductions are about as good as those of a brain damaged ant after a lobotomy, there is no better recommendation.
Reply
(06-02-2021, 08:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think other than last season and him keeping Northampton up, he’s finished in the top half of a division in every season he’s managed... combine that record with a club that’s never finished outside the top 6 in the Champinship in over 20 years... what can go wrong!!

Well thats fucked it then!  Big Grin
Reply
(06-02-2021, 08:52 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(06-02-2021, 08:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: There’s definitely a malaise around Wilder, but when you look at it entirely objectively, he has the best CV for the role.

My biggest concern is that throughout his career he’s only had one season where there’s been any expectation. In fairness to him, he won the league with over 100 points that season so it seems he can deliver when the pressure is on, but the bulk of his achievements seem to have come when they’ve been plucky underdogs and next season we will be anything but.

That being said, very few - if any - managers have a record that can compare with his...he’s won promotion from every division in the UK and crucially he’s won one with every club he’s managed. I think only Colin has more promotions than him.

I think other than last season and him keeping Northampton up, he’s finished in the top half of a division in every season he’s managed... combine that record with a club that’s never finished outside the top 6 in the Champinship in over 20 years... what can go wrong!!

Everything.


This move worries me so deeply. I worry with Wilder at the helm

Given your preference was Lampard because “he might get some good loan players in” - which, unless they’re Mason Mount he won’t have a clue what to do with... and even then will fail to win promotion- I’m happy to discredit your concern Ziz.

(06-02-2021, 09:18 AM)sickParrot Wrote:
(06-02-2021, 08:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think other than last season and him keeping Northampton up, he’s finished in the top half of a division in every season he’s managed... combine that record with a club that’s never finished outside the top 6 in the Champinship in over 20 years... what can go wrong!!

Well thats fucked it then!  Big Grin

I’m not CIM Big Grin
Reply
(06-02-2021, 08:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Well on the grounds your football knowledge and preductions are about as good as those of a brain damaged ant after a lobotomy, there is no better recommendation.

I'm a bit 'meh' about the whole thing and the candidates. However I have no issue with Wilder and his CV. So he's had one poor season. He's the best that is available. Only concern is his motivation. Is he still up for it having lived his dream of taking his boyhood club to the PL? However on paper we have a team that is better than 21 other teams in the Champ. With a few additions he is no doubt confident he can get us up.
Reply
As said, I'm surprisingly meh about it even though he 2as my first choice.

Can't explain why, but logically he's the best choice.
Reply
I think the "meh" feeling, which I also have, comes from the fact that after that season in the Prem it's hard to see how even Alex Ferguson would ever be able to get us back up and competitive in the Prem with our budget.... sort of seems like a bit of pointless folly now that our expectations are much higher than in the early 2000's..
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)