From an ITK source
Again I don’t think the comparison is like-for-like, Mick.

I think Allardyce proved a failure given the scale of the task-at-hand. He also failed to hit the deck running. Had it been earlier, or more pertinently had the squad been better, he may have stood more of a chance. But had that squad been better then perhaps Bilic wouldn’t have required replacing.

But he wasn’t going to be tied in, and because of the timing of it all - just like Pardew - he couldn’t lose anyway. If he kept us up he’d worked a miracle. If he failed, meh - still got paid handsomely for it and could easily shrug-off the blame elsewhere.

I don’t really see how that compares with now; a fresh season and a rebuild job he can fully be a part of, rather than a compromised transfer window spent mainly chasing loans on a limited budget.

Plenty of boyhood club appointments go wrong. I wouldn’t let that count against him forever.
Reply
Anyone who thinks that last season is remotely representative of Chris Wilder's managerial career is not very bright.

Check your facts, KWs.
Reply
Wilder far and away the best candidate for the job.The one’s that don’t want him don’t seem to come up with a credible name to compete with the cv of Wilder.Maybe Lampard could attract players but is more of a gamble and Appleton I like but after that a lot of the candidates are just laughable or a huge gamble.Wilder gets the best out of what he’s got and isn’t set on one formation that’s been hugely exaggerated because of his time at Sheffield.We would be getting a manager who players like and respect but at the same time the players wouldn’t get away with anything.Heard a good podcast with Wilder and he came over very well.
Reply
(06-01-2021, 09:00 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Wilder far and away the best candidate for the job.The one’s that don’t want him don’t seem to come up with a credible name to compete with the cv of Wilder.Maybe Lampard could attract players but is more of a gamble and Appleton I like but after that a lot of the candidates are just laughable or a huge gamble.Wilder gets the best out of what he’s got and isn’t set on one formation that’s been hugely exaggerated because of his time at Sheffield.We would be getting a manager who players like and respect but at the same time the players wouldn’t get away with anything.Heard a good podcast with Wilder and he came over very well.
Well said. A year ago Wilder would have been out of our league as he was when Bilic joined. Hopefully it will turn out to be an inspired appointment for both parties like Roy’s.
Reply
(06-01-2021, 08:21 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Anyone who thinks that last season is remotely representative of Chris Wilder's managerial career is not very bright.

Check your facts, KWs.

Every manager gets it wrong and gets the sack, even Ranieri was sacked a few months after winning the title with lesta.

If we don’t want a manager that has failed in the Prem, our only other choice is a manager who hasn’t managed at that level.
Reply
(06-01-2021, 04:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Has anyone used the word ‘underwhelmed’ yet?

I wish him well but that is how I feel, ‘underwhelmed’

I hope he proves me wrong.......
Reply
Not a glamour name, but really the only glamour names are ones that have been big as a player and carried on that success. An unknown player always seems to be treated differently as a manager. A few years ago we'd have said: "Chris who?,' but yet Wayne Rooney looks like being a disaster as a manager, but he's got a name, as has Lampard, who probably got the Chelsea job too early.

As I've said before, I've seldom got it right with managers- I was only pleased with Bilic and Hodgson. I was also pleased with Brian Little! I wasn't with Megson.
Reply
(06-01-2021, 09:21 PM)sickParrot Wrote:
(06-01-2021, 08:21 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Anyone who thinks that last season is remotely representative of Chris Wilder's managerial career is not very bright.

Check your facts, KWs.

Every manager gets it wrong and gets the sack, even Ranieri was sacked a few months after winning the title with lesta.

If we don’t want a manager that has failed in the Prem, our only other choice is a manager who hasn’t managed at that level.

Hodgson = Iceland
Reply
baggiebloke Wrote:
sickParrot Wrote:
baggiebloke Wrote:Anyone who thinks that last season is remotely representative of Chris Wilder's managerial career is not very bright.

Check your facts, KWs.

Every manager gets it wrong and gets the sack, even Ranieri was sacked a few months after winning the title with lesta.

If we don’t want a manager that has failed in the Prem, our only other choice is a manager who hasn’t managed at that level.

Hodgson = Iceland

Wasn't Hodgson sacked after failing at Blackburn as well? Well, failure relatively speaking.

And surely everybody knows that Pulis replaced Pardew and not the other way round. Right?
Reply
(06-01-2021, 09:45 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Not a glamour name, but really the only glamour names are ones that have been big as a player and carried on that success. An unknown player always seems to be treated differently as a manager. A few years ago we'd have said: "Chris who?,' but yet Wayne Rooney looks like being a disaster as a manager, but he's got a name, as has Lampard, who probably got the Chelsea job too early.

As I've said before, I've seldom got it right with managers- I was only pleased with Bilic and Hodgson. I was also pleased with Brian Little! I wasn't with Megson.

Believe it or not, I was underwhelmed with Slav, but he proved me wrong. Back in the dark days there was less information around, so I don't recall having much of a feeling either way over SGM or Little. I know I was excited when BFR came back, then equally or more so peed off when he fecked off...

The irony is that about 8 years ago I'd have loved Allardyce. Right now I'd love Uncle Roy, but am unsure he'd be up to the long job, so maybe more if he was mentoring someone else. As for Wilder, he has a good cv, barring last year, and seems to be the sensible choice based on that. Doesn't fill me with excitement, but I won't be against him from the start.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)