Retained List
#21
Super_Slav Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:No shocks on that list for me, including the youngsters.

I presume Peltier, having been released, will be signed up again in August as has become tradition.  Dodgy

Harmon at left back was decent Ray?

Also NCP as an attacking midfielder?

I like Harmon's attitude. For example, he was the only player trying to keep everybody's heads up when Chelsea were spanking us 7-0 in the youth cup a few years ago. However, he lacks any sort of pace and doesn't make up for that with any special footballing ability.

Clayton-Phillips looked tremendous in a pre-season friendly for the reserves at Kidderminster (I think it was) a couple of years ago but has been exceptionally poor in every game I've seen him play in since. 

I really don't think either will go on to have any sort of meaningful football career.
Reply
#22
(05-27-2021, 06:13 PM)Fido Wrote:
(05-27-2021, 06:03 PM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(05-27-2021, 05:56 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: No shocks on that list for me, including the youngsters.

I presume Peltier, having been released, will be signed up again in August as has become tradition.  Dodgy

Harmon at left back was decent Ray?

Also NCP as an attacking midfielder?

NCP would be someone I’d keep for when you needed to park the bus.

Shame we decided not to pay, and display his talents out on loan
Reply
#23
(05-27-2021, 06:25 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
Super_Slav Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:No shocks on that list for me, including the youngsters.

I presume Peltier, having been released, will be signed up again in August as has become tradition.  Dodgy

Harmon at left back was decent Ray?

Also NCP as an attacking midfielder?

I like Harmon's attitude. For example, he was the only player trying to keep everybody's heads up when Chelsea were spanking us 7-0 in the youth cup a few years ago. However, he lacks any sort of pace and doesn't make up for that with any special footballing ability.

Clayton-Phillips looked tremendous in a pre-season friendly for the reserves at Kidderminster (I think it was) a couple of years ago but has been exceptionally poor in every game I've seen him play in since. 

I really don't think either will go on to have any sort of meaningful football career.

Thanks for engaging Ray
Reply
#24
Super_Slav Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:
Super_Slav Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:No shocks on that list for me, including the youngsters.

I presume Peltier, having been released, will be signed up again in August as has become tradition.  Dodgy

Harmon at left back was decent Ray?

Also NCP as an attacking midfielder?

I like Harmon's attitude. For example, he was the only player trying to keep everybody's heads up when Chelsea were spanking us 7-0 in the youth cup a few years ago. However, he lacks any sort of pace and doesn't make up for that with any special footballing ability.

Clayton-Phillips looked tremendous in a pre-season friendly for the reserves at Kidderminster (I think it was) a couple of years ago but has been exceptionally poor in every game I've seen him play in since. 

I really don't think either will go on to have any sort of meaningful football career.

Thanks for engaging Ray

That's what this board is for mate. That and piss taking.  Big Grin
Reply
#25
(05-27-2021, 06:19 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-27-2021, 06:06 PM)Cuzer Wrote: That’s a proper cull from the 23’s, can only imagine the plan is to throw the U18’s in at that level to see if they can handle the step up

Some names on the 23’s list which has surprised me

Edwards I would have liked to see stay, nice grounded lad from an Albion family and has the potential to play at a high level IMO, sure he’ll be picked up by a Championship rival

The rebuilding job certainly got a touch bigger…..


Cuzer

Edwards is a funny one, however think the club have a lot of faith in Tulloch and would rather he was developed rather than try to develop Edwards.

That's how I see it too Birdy. Tulloch will fill Edwards spot and is a cracking prospect. I really like Edwards and will watch is career closely. He could well come back to bite us but good luck to him.

Im on record as being a big fan of Clayton-Phillips but he hasn't kicked on so again I'll be interested to see where he ends up and see if he can make it. 

Shame to see two big Albion fans leave (3 if you include Field) but we move on. 

Clean sweep etc
Reply
#26
(05-27-2021, 06:40 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
Super_Slav Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:
Super_Slav Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:No shocks on that list for me, including the youngsters.

I presume Peltier, having been released, will be signed up again in August as has become tradition.  Dodgy

Harmon at left back was decent Ray?

Also NCP as an attacking midfielder?

I like Harmon's attitude. For example, he was the only player trying to keep everybody's heads up when Chelsea were spanking us 7-0 in the youth cup a few years ago. However, he lacks any sort of pace and doesn't make up for that with any special footballing ability.

Clayton-Phillips looked tremendous in a pre-season friendly for the reserves at Kidderminster (I think it was) a couple of years ago but has been exceptionally poor in every game I've seen him play in since. 

I really don't think either will go on to have any sort of meaningful football career.

Thanks for engaging Ray

That's what this board is for mate. That and piss taking.  Big Grin

I agree but many on here want to do the latter and not the former. So thanks.
Reply
#27
Shame about Edwards, decent lad, hope he goes on to do well.
Reply
#28
Mutterings on twitter that Edwards had a Christmas party and caught covid, which may possibly explain a lot.
Reply
#29
Kyle Edwards is 23 and has been badly managed and badly advised over the last few seasons...

He needed to go out in our promotion season, and should have done as soon as Grosicki was signed, but the Luton move fell through, and he certainly should have been loaned out to a Champ side last season...

He’s been offered deals, but he wanted more than we were willing to offer... I doubt wherever he ends up now he’ll get a contact at the level we offered.

He’s a nice lad by all accounts, and a Baggies fan, but we are well stocked in his position.
Reply
#30
We're looking a little thin up top!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)