All this "the next manager needs to be experienced" & "none of this foreign rubbish"
#1
Some very quick analysis suggests experience and know-how in the dugout at this level may be a little overrated.... 

This season:
Farke - never played in England, 2 seasons in the Champ, 2 titles.... no experience in his first season
Xisco - never played in England, and only experience previous was managing in Georgia 

Of the 4 managers currently competing in the playoffs, Woodgate is the only one who's managed in the Championship previously... Cooper, Ismael and Farke are all in their first jobs at this level and again, neither of them played in the Champ during their careers...

Of last year's promotion winners only Bielsa had managed in the Championship previously, having been at Leeds for 12 months prior... and I'm pretty sure neither Slav nor Parker played in the Champ unless Parker did for Charlton early in his career... 

And the year before that of Farke, Smith and Wilder only Wilder had managed in the Champ prior to that season... 

You actually have to go back to the previous season for an "experienced head" when Warnock took Cardiff up and Jokanovic took Fulham up having won promotion with Watford previously... At the same time Nuno won the title in his season in English football.

Ultimately it's all about the best fit for the club and having the right resources available. Looking over those names, I'm not always sure it's the best coach who ends up winning promotion...
Reply
#2
I don't disagree although I haven't heard anyone say "none of this foreign rubbish".

The problem is beyond next season. It's all fine and dandy choosing a manager to get us promotion, although that in itself isn't an easy task, but then having them keep us in the Prem is a completely different beast. Farke went up, straight back down, no Prem experience. Parker went up, straight back down, no Prem experience (beyond a couple of months). Wilder went up, two seasons later, down, no Prem experience, Wagner the same, the list goes on.

Unless we can find a Bielsa (who could never ever be described as inexperienced) or spend 300 million like Dean Smith then it's always going to be very difficult.

It baffles me to think that anyone reckons Michael Appleton, for example, would have given it a better go of keeping us up this season than the Bilic/Allardyce combination.
Reply
#3
Very good post
Reply
#4
>>Farke - never played in England, 2 seasons in the Champ, 2 titles.... no experience in his first season

Incorrect - he had a poor first season when Norwich decided to stick with him despite fans being unhappy.
Reply
#5
Not seen many “no foreigners” posts myself. If we went for someone from abroad I wouldn’t be against it.

To be honest I can’t say I’m actually that fussed who we bring in.
Reply
#6
(05-21-2021, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Some very quick analysis suggests experience and know-how in the dugout at this level may be a little overrated.... 

This season:
Farke - never played in England, 2 seasons in the Champ, 2 titles.... no experience in his first season
Xisco - never played in England, and only experience previous was managing in Georgia 

Of the 4 managers currently competing in the playoffs, Woodgate is the only one who's managed in the Championship previously... Cooper, Ismael and Farke are all in their first jobs at this level and again, neither of them played in the Champ during their careers...

Of last year's promotion winners only Bielsa had managed in the Championship previously, having been at Leeds for 12 months prior... and I'm pretty sure neither Slav nor Parker played in the Champ unless Parker did for Charlton early in his career... 

And the year before that of Farke, Smith and Wilder only Wilder had managed in the Champ prior to that season... 

You actually have to go back to the previous season for an "experienced head" when Warnock took Cardiff up and Jokanovic took Fulham up having won promotion with Watford previously... At the same time Nuno won the title in his season in English football.

Ultimately it's all about the best fit for the club and having the right resources available. Looking over those names, I'm not always sure it's the best coach who ends up winning promotion...

I think some are missing the point, you are right it’s about the best fit for the club but that hasn’t changed since Allardyce declined taking on the job. We still have an owner who wants to sell the club, we still have two seasons tops to compete with those clubs with owners who want to invest or have parachute payments. The onus is still on an immediate return and then staying up so Lai has a better chance of selling. If those are the parameters the club are going to try and manage / limit the rsk and reward more so than say a Bristol City or another mid table club who haven’t in reality got that much to lose.
Reply
#7
(05-21-2021, 11:39 AM)clem4england Wrote: >>Farke - never played in England, 2 seasons in the Champ, 2 titles.... no experience in his first season

Incorrect - he had a poor first season when Norwich decided to stick with him despite fans being unhappy.

You're completely right Clem... I didn't realise Farke had been there for 2 seasons when they got their first promotion!

(05-21-2021, 11:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: I don't disagree although I haven't heard anyone say "none of this foreign rubbish".

The problem is beyond next season. It's all fine and dandy choosing a manager to get us promotion, although that in itself isn't an easy task, but then having them keep us in the Prem is a completely different beast. Farke went up, straight back down, no Prem experience. Parker went up, straight back down, no Prem experience (beyond a couple of months). Wilder went up, two seasons later, down, no Prem experience, Wagner the same, the list goes on.

Unless we can find a Bielsa (who could never ever be described as inexperienced) or spend 300 million like Dean Smith then it's always going to be very difficult.

It baffles me to think that anyone reckons Michael Appleton, for example, would have given it a better go of keeping us up this season than the Bilic/Allardyce combination.

It doesn't necessarily have to be the same manager for both. 

Getting to the PL is likely to require a different set of skills to staying there... Whilst we'd have received a fair bit of scorn if we'd sacked Slav the minute we got promoted and replaced him with Sam, we'd have probably survived. 

First and foremost we need to get out of this division.... let's worry about finding someone to keep us in the next one when we're there.

Managers are big boys and are paid incredibly well, and compensated at a level the rest of us can only dream of when they're sacked... and players, whilst they may whinge and moan, don't really care who is in charge as long as they get paid!
Reply
#8
(05-21-2021, 02:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2021, 11:39 AM)clem4england Wrote: >>Farke - never played in England, 2 seasons in the Champ, 2 titles.... no experience in his first season

Incorrect - he had a poor first season when Norwich decided to stick with him despite fans being unhappy.

You're completely right Clem... I didn't realise Farke had been there for 2 seasons when they got their first promotion!

(05-21-2021, 11:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: I don't disagree although I haven't heard anyone say "none of this foreign rubbish".

The problem is beyond next season. It's all fine and dandy choosing a manager to get us promotion, although that in itself isn't an easy task, but then having them keep us in the Prem is a completely different beast. Farke went up, straight back down, no Prem experience. Parker went up, straight back down, no Prem experience (beyond a couple of months). Wilder went up, two seasons later, down, no Prem experience, Wagner the same, the list goes on.

Unless we can find a Bielsa (who could never ever be described as inexperienced) or spend 300 million like Dean Smith then it's always going to be very difficult.

It baffles me to think that anyone reckons Michael Appleton, for example, would have given it a better go of keeping us up this season than the Bilic/Allardyce combination.

It doesn't necessarily have to be the same manager for both. 

Getting to the PL is likely to require a different set of skills to staying there... Whilst we'd have received a fair bit of scorn if we'd sacked Slav the minute we got promoted and replaced him with Sam, we'd have probably survived. 

First and foremost we need to get out of this division.... let's worry about finding someone to keep us in the next one when we're there.

Managers are big boys and are paid incredibly well, and compensated at a level the rest of us can only dream of when they're sacked... and players, whilst they may whinge and moan, don't really care who is in charge as long as they get paid!

A bit! There would have been howling outrage from the media and fans, some of whom still don't think we should have sacked Bilic. 

I do agree with your priorities though. Get out of the Championship first. Then worry about the rest. Particularly because if our manager does such a good job, they're liable to be poached anyway.
Reply
#9
(05-21-2021, 02:22 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-21-2021, 02:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2021, 11:39 AM)clem4england Wrote: >>Farke - never played in England, 2 seasons in the Champ, 2 titles.... no experience in his first season

Incorrect - he had a poor first season when Norwich decided to stick with him despite fans being unhappy.

You're completely right Clem... I didn't realise Farke had been there for 2 seasons when they got their first promotion!

(05-21-2021, 11:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: I don't disagree although I haven't heard anyone say "none of this foreign rubbish".

The problem is beyond next season. It's all fine and dandy choosing a manager to get us promotion, although that in itself isn't an easy task, but then having them keep us in the Prem is a completely different beast. Farke went up, straight back down, no Prem experience. Parker went up, straight back down, no Prem experience (beyond a couple of months). Wilder went up, two seasons later, down, no Prem experience, Wagner the same, the list goes on.

Unless we can find a Bielsa (who could never ever be described as inexperienced) or spend 300 million like Dean Smith then it's always going to be very difficult.

It baffles me to think that anyone reckons Michael Appleton, for example, would have given it a better go of keeping us up this season than the Bilic/Allardyce combination.

It doesn't necessarily have to be the same manager for both. 

Getting to the PL is likely to require a different set of skills to staying there... Whilst we'd have received a fair bit of scorn if we'd sacked Slav the minute we got promoted and replaced him with Sam, we'd have probably survived. 

First and foremost we need to get out of this division.... let's worry about finding someone to keep us in the next one when we're there.

Managers are big boys and are paid incredibly well, and compensated at a level the rest of us can only dream of when they're sacked... and players, whilst they may whinge and moan, don't really care who is in charge as long as they get paid!

A bit! There would have been howling outrage from the media and fans, some of whom still don't think we should have sacked Bilic. 

I do agree with your priorities though. Get out of the Championship first. Then worry about the rest. Particularly because if our manager does such a good job, they're liable to be poached anyway.

Over the last 4 seasons 7 out of 12 promoted clubs have survived, and all 7 of those have kept the same manager for their promotion season / survival season which shocks me!!!

There is however, one common denominator... they've spent a LOT of money!!!

Leeds -> Bielsa is an anomaly and spent £100m+
Villa -> Spent £170m
Wolves -> Spent £100m
Brighton -> Spent £60m... they then continued to splash similar sums!
Newcastle -> Spent £50m but got promoted with a massive wage bill and a lot of very good players

The other 2 Huddersfield and Sheff United both spent very little comparatively, but both had a very similar surprise promotion and momentum that no doubt counted for a lot...
Reply
#10
(05-21-2021, 02:48 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2021, 02:22 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-21-2021, 02:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2021, 11:39 AM)clem4england Wrote: >>Farke - never played in England, 2 seasons in the Champ, 2 titles.... no experience in his first season

Incorrect - he had a poor first season when Norwich decided to stick with him despite fans being unhappy.

You're completely right Clem... I didn't realise Farke had been there for 2 seasons when they got their first promotion!

(05-21-2021, 11:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: I don't disagree although I haven't heard anyone say "none of this foreign rubbish".

The problem is beyond next season. It's all fine and dandy choosing a manager to get us promotion, although that in itself isn't an easy task, but then having them keep us in the Prem is a completely different beast. Farke went up, straight back down, no Prem experience. Parker went up, straight back down, no Prem experience (beyond a couple of months). Wilder went up, two seasons later, down, no Prem experience, Wagner the same, the list goes on.

Unless we can find a Bielsa (who could never ever be described as inexperienced) or spend 300 million like Dean Smith then it's always going to be very difficult.

It baffles me to think that anyone reckons Michael Appleton, for example, would have given it a better go of keeping us up this season than the Bilic/Allardyce combination.

It doesn't necessarily have to be the same manager for both. 

Getting to the PL is likely to require a different set of skills to staying there... Whilst we'd have received a fair bit of scorn if we'd sacked Slav the minute we got promoted and replaced him with Sam, we'd have probably survived. 

First and foremost we need to get out of this division.... let's worry about finding someone to keep us in the next one when we're there.

Managers are big boys and are paid incredibly well, and compensated at a level the rest of us can only dream of when they're sacked... and players, whilst they may whinge and moan, don't really care who is in charge as long as they get paid!

A bit! There would have been howling outrage from the media and fans, some of whom still don't think we should have sacked Bilic. 

I do agree with your priorities though. Get out of the Championship first. Then worry about the rest. Particularly because if our manager does such a good job, they're liable to be poached anyway.

Over the last 4 seasons 7 out of 12 promoted clubs have survived, and all 7 of those have kept the same manager for their promotion season / survival season which shocks me!!!

There is however, one common denominator... they've spent a LOT of money!!!

Leeds -> Bielsa is an anomaly and spent £100m+
Villa -> Spent £170m
Wolves -> Spent £100m
Brighton -> Spent £60m... they then continued to splash similar sums!
Newcastle -> Spent £50m but got promoted with a massive wage bill and a lot of very good players

The other 2 Huddersfield and Sheff United both spent very little comparatively, but both had a very similar surprise promotion and momentum that no doubt counted for a lot...

Those stats are worthy of a thread in themselves. Considering we possibly could have stayed up without having such a stupid summer, we are possibly over-achieving on our current budget and modus operandi.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: