Wilder REALLY
#11
Wilder got Sheff Utd from League One to top half Premier League. He gas got Oxford and Northampton promoted as well.
Can't believe the number of people backing Lumpard. Derby (with likes of Mason Mount) finished 6th under him. The position they had finished the year before.
Reply
#12
You could say managing a Championship side with one of the biggest budget and expectations to get promoted are quite different to any of those jobs.
Reply
#13
(05-20-2021, 07:34 AM)Artist Wrote: You could say managing a Championship side with one of the biggest budget and expectations to get promoted are quite different to any of those jobs.

It's Albion our budget is a pack of crisps and a dog eared copy of Razzle, are you new here?
Reply
#14
The main question is then, if not Wilder, who do people want?

I’m shocked that so many people idolise Sam despite his record of 0.8ppg, but are rejecting Wilder. His Sheff U were in pretty much every game this season under him, and their performances deserved a lot more, but decisions and the rub of the green went against them... pretty much all their defeats were by one goal.

Ultimately the fact it was a core side from L1 running on momentum that ran out was very difficult to turn round.
Reply
#15
(05-20-2021, 04:34 AM)Supamart Wrote: My biggest concern is that he brought Burke.

Name me a manager that hasn’t made a transfer mistake
Reply
#16
(05-20-2021, 07:29 AM)MassDebater Wrote: I wonder if we had never had anything to do with the Disaster Burke, whether our views on Wilder would be as clouded?

Yes, Blades had a terrible season, heck theirs makes ours look passable (OK now I'm stretching), but prior to that his record is better than most managers we have ever appointed. I like that he's a bit old school and has served his time in the lower echelons.

Negatives - Burke and this season. Pretty sure a lot of managers have bought duds (heck who was it that bought Burke here?)

Burke is one of the strangest players. Breaks through at Forest and plays a handful of games and looks quite explosive. Out of nowhere the money ball team at Leipzig think he'll be a good player and throw them £8m. Again doesn't do much out there and for some inexplicable reason we look at the fact that progressive Leipzig paid £8m so he must be good and we double their money to bring him back!

Turns out to be utterly useless. Wilder I assume was told he had to move players out and needed to be creative with his budget. Their scouting bods were probably tasked with finding a quick, direct striker and they've taken a punt that he might come good and blinded by how much people have paid for him in the past rather than if was actually any good.

Lots of managers back themselves to turn a player around.

I quite like Wilder and think he's a good fit personally. His record is very good up until this season where he will have learned a lot too. We could do a lot worse and I've yet to see anyone name a realistic name that excites me.
Reply
#17
(05-20-2021, 07:43 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The main question is then, if not Wilder, who do people want?

I’m shocked that so many people idolise Sam despite his record of 0.8ppg, but are rejecting Wilder. His Sheff U were in pretty much every game this season under him, and their performances deserved a lot more, but decisions and the rub of the green went against them... pretty much all their defeats were by one goal.

Ultimately the fact it was a core side from L1 running on momentum that ran out was very difficult to turn round.

Well said. I can’t believe the reaction to Wilder from some either. If he didn’t have that bad season last year we wouldn’t have a prayer of having him here. We’re dropping down a division, which ever manager we take is either going to be young/unproven or have failed somewhere down the line. I understood the reasons for wanting Sam, but Wilder was always the obvious choice imo.
Reply
#18
(05-20-2021, 06:26 AM)clem4england Wrote:
(05-19-2021, 11:33 PM)Lightnin Wrote: He’s being more than linked if the rumours are true and they’ve been running for weeks
That was all before the mini revival under BFS and him being offered the job. Unless that is just a story concocted and both parties always knew he wouldn’t stay?

My Toon mate reckons Wilder is favourite for their job if Bruce goes. There is the Palace rumour too. I don’t think he’ll be short of offers.

Absolutely, he'll have offers. I wouldn't doubt that at all.

We were seriously looking at him (I think before we appointed Bilic?) as he had a fall out with the Directors at Sheffield didn't he? Maybe over transfer budgets? There was no point looking at him when Bilic went for obvious reasons. Since he has been sacked by Sheffield, he has always been considered as the next choice if Sam wasn't to stay. I also remember it being mentioned on here by quite a good sauce (not Ziz) that the job was "as good as his" if he wanted it when it became available.

If a Prem job comes up and he's offered the position, he'll clearly go there. I can't see him going to Palace, I think that job is Lampards unless he rocks up and requests a £200m budget and I don't think Newcastle will sack Bruce. The rest of them seem safe apart from if Nuno goes somewhere but Wolves ain't going to go for Wilder, he's just not Portuguese enough. So, where does he go? We must be one of the more attractive Championship clubs to manage if he wants to get back in the game.

However, it only takes a good inerview from an outsider and our lot are easily swung! I find it all a bit "meh" at the moment, I think the Prem and a season of shite and VAR has knocked the footballing excitement out of me.
Reply
#19
Living up in Sheffield for the last 12 years I've got many Blades friends and colleagues who worshipped him (understandably so).

In reality though there are big concerns for me.

His recruitment record even through the divisions was poor. Aside from the big money flops last season they have no squad balance. They essentially don't have a single attacking winger or central attacking midfielder in their whole squad.

The above point then leads on to having no plan B. They adopted the 3-5-2, the overlapping centre-backs etc and it worked well. Took teams by surprise in their first season in the Prem and no question he/they over achieved with the squad at his disposal.

Sadly for him/them it got found out and he was too stubborn to try anything different. Injuries to key players this season didn't help but he refused to try anything different and generally shirked responsibility.

He also clearly jumped rather than being pushed from the sinking ship.

I really don't think he's the answer. The man swapped Robinson for Burke!
Reply
#20
(05-20-2021, 07:44 AM)Loanee Wrote:
(05-20-2021, 04:34 AM)Supamart Wrote: My biggest concern is that he brought Burke.

Name me a manager that hasn’t made a transfer mistake

I've had a look at SAF's transfer record.
Some dreadful wastes of money among the successes.
Bebe, Taibi, Veron etc etc.
You're right. Every punt risks failure.

As my mom used to say "if you don't make mistakes, you don't make anything"
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: