Hartlepool
(05-12-2021, 07:52 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 07:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 07:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 06:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The question is flawed

The concept of supply and demand is not flawed. So neither is the question.

I'm not setting a trap for you, I'm simply explaining that the increasing incidence in the use of foodbanks in the UK and every other developed nation is not merely a product of "demand".

The demand is created by need not want.

I think we're agreed that there is a demand for free food Dekka.

What we're not agreed on is that the grinding poverty and mass unemployment of the late 70s and early 80s did not magically result in food banks springing up everywhere, yet the relative decadence of the Blair years and onwards did. Like I say, it's a sign of a civilised society that foodbanks are established - usage is as much a product of supply as it is of previously unmet demand.

Dekka raises a good point - what is the benefit to supply here? There's clearly a demand (shown by the usage) and you have a point in that if you offer free food people will take it, however supply and demand is an economic theory where the supplier benefits as does the demander (sp?) and there is no economic benefit to supply here, so why supply?
Reply
(05-12-2021, 08:16 AM)baggy1 Wrote: so why supply?

Altruism. It's one of the many things that makes Britain so great.
Reply
(05-12-2021, 09:21 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 08:16 AM)baggy1 Wrote: so why supply?

Altruism. It's one of the many things that makes Britain so great.

Unfortunately in that situation the burden for supporting the poor falls upon the few and we end up with a society that relies on them. A functioning society should support each other, not rely on the few as they are the last resort, not the solution. And altruism is something that makes the human race great, it can be found in all regions of the world including the UK. 

Scraps from the table politics is something to be ashamed of not revelled in. It highlights the failure of trickle down economics and a functioning taxation system.
Reply
As part of a functioning society altruism has co-existed with and often led the state sector for a couple of centuries or more in the UK. Rather than being a last resort altruism has been demonstrably necessary for social progress from sanitation to decent housing to education. The dead hand of the state is very often unable to offer services with the same compassion, to the same quality, with the same velocity and as cost-effectively as the third sector is - that's why, for instance, I'm eternally grateful that both my parents passed peacefully in a Marie Curie hospice rather than an NHS ward.
Reply
(05-12-2021, 09:48 AM)Protheroe Wrote: As part of a functioning society altruism has co-existed with and often led the state sector for a couple of centuries or more in the UK. Rather than being a last resort altruism has been demonstrably necessary for social progress from sanitation to decent housing to education. The dead hand of the state is very often unable to offer services with the same compassion, to the same quality, with the same velocity and as cost-effectively as the third sector is - that's why, for instance,  I'm eternally grateful that both my parents passed peacefully in a Marie Curie hospice rather than an NHS ward.

Agree entirely with that Proth, but we are not talking about the wealthy benefactors who are providing housing and jobs alongside a social structure and support mechanism to employees, we are talking about unemployed / retired individuals putting their time into supporting the most vulnerable. And when you add into that vulnerable group people who do have a wage, and some in what we would describe as good jobs in the health sector, then alarm bells should be ringing.

This model is unsustainable long term as it really has no plan to build, which is where altruism has sat in previous decades / centuries, is is just about that last resort that it provides. There is no alternative or plan to improve - there is the problem.

And a third of the Marie Curie funds is from the NHS and as blessed as you have been to be in that situation (and I'm glad that you did have that comfort) 7 out of 10 cancer patients don't have that option, and with only 9 Marie Curie Hospices in the UK it has a limited reach.
Reply
(05-12-2021, 07:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No one would open a food bank if there wasn’t the need, there is little personal benefit to those that do. People who have to use food banks don’t do it because they just like free stuff. Proth’s yes or no answer is deliberate obtuse nonsense.
I think Proth is suggesting (and trying to get you to accept) is that  there are some who do / would. I would hope he  accepts that not all those that use food banks are such types.

(05-11-2021, 06:34 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: 1) Clearly unacceptable- Obviously tweeting while pissed
2) "Not all Brexit voters are racist but there is an element of racism in the Brexit project and the rhetoric of those like Farage" - This doesn't seem enormously controversial to me but we may disagree
3) Some bloke was moaning about a local Polish family and calling them spongers while knowing nothing about them. Can't castigate her too much for calling a spade a spade.
4 & 5) Again, a very poor choice of words.
5) "Anti-immigrant voters in Hartlepool voted for the Tories and we (Labour) need to deal with that" - I don't see much wrong with this? She's saying that people who are anti-immigration lean more towards the Tories and Labour has to deal with that if they want to win their votes. She's right? Also the only source for this quote is the editor of HuffPost UK. Do we know what she actually said? I can't imagine the Express did much fact-checking.
I get what JOK is saying but I don't really agree that 2 notable incidents (imo) in 5 years is quite the 'gotcha' that Borto thinks it is.
As I said earlier, I do agree that the left-wing Twitterati hurling abuse is unhelpful if they want to turn people away from the Tories, but I don't think the blame for this can be laid at the door of the Labour Party. Let's be honest though there's as much abuse online thrown out about "woke, snowflakes" as there is about "thick, racists".
FWIW by the way, I don't 'wonder' why the electorate have turned away from Labour, I know exactly why. Nor am I on here trying to get anyone to vote Labour. Most on this bored are reasonably politically engaged and picked their side a long time ago. I come on here mostly to expose myself to different viewpoints and - occasionally - for a bit of catharsis!


As a total aside - There are 9 food banks in operation in Hartlepool whereas 10 years ago there were none. Most people link this to the changes in Universal Credit brought in over recent years.

I did point out that was just five minutes of searching. I’m sure with more intensive trawling more examples could be found. I would also suggest that if you ally yourself with such people you will cop for some of their fallout. (might also apply to the actions {alleged} of the previous incumbent in Hartlepool) Strange though, as Mike Hill was one of only 19 Labour MPs who voted in favour of the second reading of the 2019 withdrawal agreement.


The Huff post is mostly seen to have a liberal possibly slightly left of centre, and the editor considers it to be neutral in terms of reporting news, so I don’t think the editor would have leanings against Labour.

Re. Food banks; this  trend is not just a U.K. situation.
“this is not a trend specific to the UK: the number of food banks across Europe continues to increase and shows no sign of stopping.”  “The 2008 financial crash saw a surge in food bank use and demand across Europe, “
“In the UK, the top three reasons  for referral to a Trussell Trust food bank between 2017-18 were cited as income not covering essential costs, benefit delays and benefit changes. As the new Universal Credit system was rolled out in 2017, Trussell reported that demand for food parcels where it had come into place increased by an average of 30% (28% according to the LSE) from April to November, compared with 12% in areas still using the old system.”
So, two points there; The article suggests a 30% increase due to U.C. not 100% as is being inferred from the Hartlepool stat and clearly ‘demand’ was increasing rapidly pre 1917. So I don’t believe “most people” attribute this to U.C. So, I would suggest it would be as fair to say Austerity is as much if not more to blame. And austerity was Europe wide, thanks mainly to the commission and its rules.
 
europeandme.eu/hungry-europe-are-food-banks-becoming-the-new-supermarkets/

Cham, coming on here is surely more like self-flagellation than a cathartic experience. Blush  What on earth do you need to purge yourself of? You don’t sometimes have improper thoughts, do you?               Such as feeling drawn to the Vile!
Reply
(05-12-2021, 10:13 AM)JOK Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 07:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No one would open a food bank if there wasn’t the need, there is little personal benefit to those that do. People who have to use food banks don’t do it because they just like free stuff. Proth’s yes or no answer is deliberate obtuse nonsense.

I think Proth is suggesting (and trying to get you to accept) is that  there are some who do / would. I would hope he  accepts that not all those that use food banks are such types.

And I think Dekka's point that the question is flawed is correct - Proth is using an economic theory of supply and demand whereby the supplier would economically benefit, in this case there is a no benefit to the supplier. Proth says Altruism as being the benefit when that is a state of being not a benefit to the supplier.

To your point I don't think anyone could argue that there won't be people that would take free stuff because it is available, however that becomes the argument for the reason for food banks increasing in those people eyes rather than the real reason of need. It masks the problem and takes away the need to provide a solution when clearly one is needed.

Bottom line - food banks increasing is an indicator that we are heading in the wrong direction, if we don't heed those indicators we will fail as a society and find ourselves further down the road where it will become harder to return from.
Reply
(05-12-2021, 10:06 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:48 AM)Protheroe Wrote: As part of a functioning society altruism has co-existed with and often led the state sector for a couple of centuries or more in the UK. Rather than being a last resort altruism has been demonstrably necessary for social progress from sanitation to decent housing to education. The dead hand of the state is very often unable to offer services with the same compassion, to the same quality, with the same velocity and as cost-effectively as the third sector is - that's why, for instance,  I'm eternally grateful that both my parents passed peacefully in a Marie Curie hospice rather than an NHS ward.

Agree entirely with that Proth, but we are not talking about the wealthy benefactors who are providing housing and jobs alongside a social structure and support mechanism to employees, we are talking about unemployed / retired individuals putting their time into supporting the most vulnerable. And when you add into that vulnerable group people who do have a wage, and some in what we would describe as good jobs in the health sector, then alarm bells should be ringing.

This model is unsustainable long term as it really has no plan to build, which is where altruism has sat in previous decades / centuries, is is just about that last resort that it provides. There is no alternative or plan to improve - there is the problem.

And a third of the Marie Curie funds is from the NHS and as blessed as you have been to be in that situation (and I'm glad that you did have that comfort) 7 out of 10 cancer patients don't have that option, and with only 9 Marie Curie Hospices in the UK it has a limited reach.

I'm glad we've found some common ground. I think you underplay the very broad role of the public in providing to food banks amongst many other acts of financial generosity and altruism. My kids' primary school in Worcestershire has regular collections for food banks in Dudley, one of the social organisations I'm involved with collects permanently for a foodbank in North Solihull. A mate of mine who's the FD of a large law firm spends Christmas Day & Boxing Day every year cooking in a Crisis kitchen. Another mate heads a group who take inner city kids fishing.

These are all "good things" and in my view the state does not / cannot replicate the development and maintenance of social cohesion from such acts entered into willingly and voluntarily by providing inferior services via general taxation. As an example look at the shitty holiday food parcels handed out to the "Rashford kids" under outsourced state procurement - far better to have handed that full responsibility (and funding) to the third sector.
Reply
I’m sure I read a few years ago that the UK was the second most generous nation per head in terms of charitable contributions (Ireland was top, IIRC correctly). When the Olympic Games came to Athens they could hardly scrape enough people together to show people how to get from Alpha to Beta; in London they were beating volunteers away with a shitty stick. Altruism is alive and well in this country and something g to be very proud of.
Reply
Not saying it isn’t Fido, my concern is the reliance placed on it. We shouldn’t be in a position in one of the most developed economies in the world, and also one of the wealthiest, where we rely on donations and volunteers to feed the poorest and most vulnerable.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: