Photo ID to be needed to vote in future
#61
I'll try again.

A person knows another's details. He knows where they vote. He knows they are on the Roll. He knows the person has said that they won't vote and they don't, accordingly. Therefore a criminal attempts personation.

1. What measures at the polling station end prevent successful personation?
2. If it occurs in the circumstances I hypothesise, what will allow it to be detected?
3. If detected how will the person responsible be traced?

That is NOT 'functionally impossible'. The 'barriers' you believe make it so are really quite low.

It really isn't hard to find out where someone you know votes by asking them. It isn't hard to find out if they do not intend to vote. The fact that a person in this situation MIGHT actually vote doesn't make personation a functional impossibiity. You know this which is why you won't respond to this situation I hypothesise and make your own.

As for being recognised at the polling station, they see thousands of people in general elections. So we are going on the basis of human facial recognition in these circumstances when it is not a very accurate capacity to begin with, let alone where hundreds, thousands of people are involved? In any case, the person being personated may use a different polling station to the fraudster's so where's your 'The tellers will recognise double voters' idea, there?

Your attempted bank robbery analogy fails for the following reason: I am talking about what polling stations do to prevent personation. Banks take various measures to minimise the risk of robbery.

You mention that someone might use a fake a driving licence. Maybe. But do you agree that giving a few details verbally - the current minimum requirement - is a bit easier and so fraud is more likely than if ID had to be produced?

Cue 'functional impossibility' because of barriers that aren't really barriers at all.
Reply
#62
1. Name, Address, knowledge as to whether they've already voted, knowledge as to whether they're going to vote, traceable ballot number.

2. The register, the people at the polling station, the person you're attempting to defraud, the ballot number.

3. Irrelevant. The issue is about ballots, which are traceable as they're numbered and assigned on the register. How the person will be traced applies the same way to all criminal offences.

I have answered all of that multiple times.

The guy who Loanee referenced in the European Elections was caught because he was recognised voting in someone else's name, there's literally more evidence for that being likelier than defrauding someone at a polling centre. It's another variable that can be compounded. There's loads of other things I haven't brought up, as happens when you've had centuries to work out a process.

It's functionally impossible as the variables compound. They don't apply in isolation. Passing one check? Likely. Passing all, functionally impossible. That's how probabilities work. Flip a coin, easy to get 1 heads but how easy is it to get 10 heads in a row? This isn't hard, I'm really confused as to why you're ignoring it.

I agree it's easier to use a name and address than faking ID, but we're not looking at things in isolation.

My robbing a bank analogy applies perfectly fine if you use it in the correct context. It's about risk. The measures that banks use are designed to compound the variables that add risk to reduce the probability of success for the robbers.
Reply
#63
There is another aspect at play here as well, if there is someone that hasn't voted regularly and turns up then that will raise a flag, where that happens a few times in a constituency then it will be looked at by the authorities Internal Audit / Fraud team, where there is a material amount of 'new' voters then that will also involve the Police.

The idea that it would be unnoticed if carried out on a material level is naive, i can guarantee there is a whole level of review control in place for these potential frauds.
Reply
#64
You still haven't responded to the situation I hypothesised. Try it like this. Whether or not it is functionally impossible, in the SITUATION I HYPOTHESISE, what will stop successful personation? What will lead to it being detected and the criminal traced?

Following on from that, do explain how it is functionally impossible to know or find out someone's details, that they are on the Roll, where they vote and that they are not going to vote.

If you think that is functionally impossible I hope you don't earn your crust in any industry where risk management is a facet.

EDIT - your bank robbery analogy doesn't apply for the reason I stated. WE are talking about security and identification. A better analogy would be, "What stops someone pretending to be me and drawing all my savings out?" That would be the need for ID.
Reply
#65
I have answered that, you've just chosen to ignore it repeatedly.

Those variables compounded will block it, the issue that needs to be addressed is the ballot which can be done through the traceable ballot. What you're talking about is irrelevant, it goes through the same process as any other crime. Having photo ID doesn't affect that as it doesn't make it easier to catch individuals and it doesn't change the criminal charges and police investigation processes.

Risk management is based on fucking statistics and probabilities, the things I'm fucking on about. Don't patronise me, especially when my point has significantly more relevance to risk management than yours as it's actually grounded in the mathematical reality of probabilities.

And the bank analogy works perfectly, what stops people robbing a bank is multiple security features which lower the risk as they compound. You're just misapplying the context. Stop looking at things in isolation as that isn't how this works.
Reply
#66
Then I must have missed it, could you do me a favour and answer it again?

The variables compunded are really not that much of a barrier where the person being personated is known to the person committing the crime, the personator knows where the victim votes and the victim has said that they won't vote and don't do so. They really are not much of a barrier. Keep uttering functional impossibility doesn't change that and make it one.

You said that the detection of the crime acts as a further disincentive but can't suggest how personation is detected when the victim doesn't attempt to vote, let alone how anyone doing it will be apprehended if there is detection.

You can swear all you want, mate. It doesn't change the fact that the probabilities are not anywhere near as low as you think and your beliefe is therefore not grounded in the mathematical reality of probabilities.

The bank analogy you now attempt to draw isn't the original one and the revised version works against you, I feel. You seemed to say that there was nothing theoretically stopping someone successfully personating but that there is also nothing theoretically stopping someone robbing a bank. You now say that there are multiple security features which lower the risk of bank robbery. What security features are there at the polling station that lower the risk of successful personation?

I'll tell you.

None.

I will leave this there, I need to go out.
Reply
#67
(05-11-2021, 03:03 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Then I must have missed it, could you do me a favour and answer it again?

The variables compunded are really not that much of a barrier where the person being personated is known to the person committing the crime, the personator knows where the victim votes and the victim has said that they won't vote and don't do so. They really are not much of a barrier. Keep uttering functional impossibility doesn't change that and make it one.

You said that the detection of the crime acts as a further disincentive but can't suggest how personation is detected when the victim doesn't attempt to vote, let alone how anyone doing it will be apprehended if there is detection.

You can swear all you want, mate. It doesn't change the fact that the probabilities are not anywhere near as low as you think and your beliefe is therefore not grounded in the mathematical reality of probabilities.

The bank analogy you now attempt to draw isn't the original one and the revised version works against you, I feel. You seemed to say that there was nothing theoretically stopping someone successfully personating but that there is also nothing theoretically stopping someone robbing a bank. You now say that there are multiple security features which lower the risk of bank robbery. What security features are there at the polling station that lower the risk of successful personation?

I'll tell you.

None.

I will leave this there, I need to go out.

You see there's the problem - by having me on ignore he's missed the one nugget of expertise I can apply to this discussion. The data will be reviewed and in the situation where material numbers of voter fraud is identified then there will be an investigation.
Reply
#68
Jesus fucking Christ. Are you genuinely taking the piss?

I've repeated myself enough, you're choosing to ignore it. Not my problem.

The variables being compounded are a factor as that is how probabilities work. This is basic maths. The compounded probability is the relevant thing, you have zero evidence for your position so you're applying a hypothetical and I'm pointing out that the due to the compounded mitigation procedures the probability is basically nil, therefore it's functionally impossible and that's why you have no evidence and are applying a hypothetical situation.

You patronise me and then get huffy about the word fucking? Give over. Compounding probabilities for product development is how establishing risk works, that's how statistics is applied and it's why your hypothetical situation is hypothetical and not evidence backed, even by an outlier, and it's not as though there's a small sample size either.

And my bank analogy is the exact same. In the first comment I brought it up I explicitly stated risk and talked about compounding probabilities, that hasn't changed. You misapplying the context doesn't change that.
Reply
#69
I wouldn't be bothered to even try to explain to him BB - he's one of the knucklehead brothers that used to troll this place and got banned on a regular basis if I've got that right.
Reply
#70
(05-11-2021, 03:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Jesus fucking Christ. Are you genuinely taking the piss?

Interestingly, I've been looking at the posts from many other activists I've known over the years too - particularly with respect to abuse of the marked register.

They don't agree with you either.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)