Photo ID to be needed to vote in future
#41
But the only way they will know without impunity that someone isn't going to vote is if they're not registered to vote, and you can't fraudulently vote in someone's name if they're not on the register. If they turn up to vote you're fucked.

And they tell you to take it up with the Council because the Council are in charge of the ballots, so that they can trace the fraudulent ballot using the traceable ballot number and remove it.
Reply
#42
(05-11-2021, 09:49 AM)Ossian Wrote: Slight change of tack, but last week our usual polling station had been substituted with one allowing separate entrance and exit; the replacement was about a further quarter mile walk and I'm ashamed to say that was almost sufficient to put me off bothering. I voted in the end, but never before with so little enthusiasm.

I didn't vote thinking that the Tory candidate would walk our ward so didn't bother and having met the tit he wouldn't have got my vote anyway. So happens the Lib Dem candidate beat him by a very slim margin (the local busy-bodies/resident's association were aghast at this) in which case I did feel some guilt as in something so close the odd vote could have made a difference.
Reply
#43
It still won't stop them trying, FFS.

As for your 2nd point, yeah, because a fraudster is going to report a person they are personating for validly casting their ballot before the fraudster managed to try it on, aren't they? In that case NOTHING will happen, a fraudster finds the person they are trying to personate has voted before them, that is the end of the matter. They have nothing to lose by trying it on.

Of course a person who has BEEN personated may well report it. But there are no cameras in polling stations by law so who the hell is going to know who it was that cast the fraudulent ballot?
Reply
#44
If they try then they are dumb and, with near statistical certainty due to compounding probabilities and the amount of evidence available, they will be caught.

And if a fraudster tries to vote in the name of someone who has voted before then that is due reason to refuse to issue a ballot as per the EC's rejected ballot guidance.
Reply
#45
(05-11-2021, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You couldn't know whether I'd turn up, and if you're paying me why not just pay me the tenner to have you as my proxy or give you a postal ballot to get around needing ID?

Well there you have it then. It's perfectly possible to organise electoral fraud on an industrial scale as Labour did in Birmingham not so long ago on several levels.

Nothing wrong with free issued voter ID at all. Nothing wrong with far more checks on postal voting.

Your objection to voter ID is groundless.
Reply
#46
(05-11-2021, 10:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: If they try then they are dumb and, with near statistical certainty due to compounding probabilities and the amount of evidence available, they will be caught.

And if a fraudster tries to vote in the name of someone who has voted before then that is due reason to refuse to issue a ballot as per the EC's rejected ballot guidance.

It isn't a statistical certainty if the fraudster knows the person is unlikely to vote, knows the person being personated has voted before so are on the register, knows their name and nows their address.

And if it was tried-on and the valid voter has already voted, explain how the fraudster would be caught and it would be proven as to who it was who tried to cast the fraudulent ballot.

I think even you know hat you have extended your argument to ridiculous lengths here and are flogging a dead horse. Just say, "Yeah, you've got a point there." It would have saved us all so much time.
Reply
#47
(05-11-2021, 10:35 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 10:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: If they try then they are dumb and, with near statistical certainty due to compounding probabilities and the amount of evidence available, they will be caught.

And if a fraudster tries to vote in the name of someone who has voted before then that is due reason to refuse to issue a ballot as per the EC's rejected ballot guidance.

It isn't a statistical certainty if the fraudster knows the person is unlikely to vote, knows the person being personated has voted before so are on the register, knows their name and nows their address.

And if it was tried-on and the valid voter has already voted, explain how the fraudster would be caught and it would be proven as to who it was who tried to cast the fraudulent ballot.

I think even you know hat you have extended your argument to ridiculous lengths here and are flogging a dead horse. Just say, "Yeah, you've got a point there." It would have saved us all so much time.

Lets be honest Borin Baggie, when I've run the board for the Tories it's exceptionally easy to identify who's unlikely to vote. The Labour Party has their own canvassing data too. In areas where turnout is low it would be incredibly easy to impersonate enough voters one way or another to swing a local election or to ensure victory.
Reply
#48
(05-11-2021, 10:32 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You couldn't know whether I'd turn up, and if you're paying me why not just pay me the tenner to have you as my proxy or give you a postal ballot to get around needing ID?

Well there you have it then. It's perfectly possible to organise electoral fraud on an industrial scale as Labour did in Birmingham not so long ago on several levels.

Nothing wrong with free issued voter ID at all. Nothing wrong with far more checks on postal voting.

Your objection to voter ID is groundless.

My objection to voter ID is based on statistical probabilities and the fact it's not been a noted solution after around 150 years of elections in Great Britain.

The fact of the matter is, if you want to organise voter fraud akin to the manner that you're proposing then it won't in any way stop what you're arguing it will stop as there's no assurance in me just going to vote then reporting you and still pocketing the money or organising fraud with voter IDs by organising Proxy votes or just bribing someone to vote as you want them to.

It's pointless, it doesn't solve any problems and it just disenfranchises those without ID. Not to mention the issue with the trials where to get the "free voter ID" you need a passport which defeats the whole purpose as those without a ID won't be eligible and those with a passport already had ID.

I find it utterly laughable that you describe yourself as a self professed liberal and then support mandatory ID and big state interference coupled with the pointless administration costs.

(05-11-2021, 10:38 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 10:35 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 10:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: If they try then they are dumb and, with near statistical certainty due to compounding probabilities and the amount of evidence available, they will be caught.

And if a fraudster tries to vote in the name of someone who has voted before then that is due reason to refuse to issue a ballot as per the EC's rejected ballot guidance.

It isn't a statistical certainty if the fraudster knows the person is unlikely to vote, knows the person being personated has voted before so are on the register, knows their name and nows their address.

And if it was tried-on and the valid voter has already voted, explain how the fraudster would be caught and it would be proven as to who it was who tried to cast the fraudulent ballot.

I think even you know hat you have extended your argument to ridiculous lengths here and are flogging a dead horse. Just say, "Yeah, you've got a point there." It would have saved us all so much time.

Lets be honest Borin Baggie, when I've run the board for the Tories it's exceptionally easy to identify who's unlikely to vote. The Labour Party has their own canvassing data too. In areas where turnout is low it would be incredibly easy to impersonate enough voters one way or another to swing a local election or to ensure victory.

With respect Proth, when I've worked with canvassers in the Liberal Democrats on local elections within Warwickshire and Birmingham and where to target campaigning, the likelihood to vote is based on probabilities and not certainty. Therefore, if you wish to apply that to this situation you need to go with it on the basis of statistical probability making it functionally impossible and a zero chance of certainty that someone won't vote.

You're not the only former party activist on here.
Reply
#49
I don't agree that it is illiberal to take any step to minimise potential electoral fraud, particularly as photo-ID is needed to do pretty much anything these days from picking up a parcel (illiberal?) to opening a bank account (illiberal?) to instructing a solicitor (illiberal?).

I also disagree with you about the 'certainty' of someone not voting. I could take you to hundreds of addresses in Sandwell and other historically low turnout areas where you could impersonate whole streets, secure in the knowledge that you'd never be found out.
Reply
#50
Picking up a parcel, opening a bank account and instructing a solicitor aren't democratic rights, do not involve the interference of the state and do not cost the taxpayer money.

You could never be secure in the knowledge, the only way to be secure that you won't get caught is if they aren't registered to vote and if they aren't registered to vote you literally can't impersonate them to vote as they aren't registered to vote. The compounding of the probability of the variables makes it a basically nil chance of it working and there's basically no evidence of in person voter fraud ever being an issue despite 150 years of the system we have being deployed.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)