Hartlepool
(05-11-2021, 06:34 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: In reply to JOK:

1) Clearly unacceptable- Obviously tweeting while pissed

2) "Not all Brexit voters are racist but there is an element of racism in the Brexit project and the rhetoric of those like Farage" - This doesn't seem enormously controversial to me but we may disagree

3) Some bloke was moaning about a local Polish family and calling them spongers while knowing nothing about them. Can't castigate her too much for calling a spade a spade.

4 & 5) Again, a very poor choice of words.

5) "Anti-immigrant voters in Hartlepool voted for the Tories and we (Labour) need to deal with that" - I don't see much wrong with this? She's saying that people who are anti-immigration lean more towards the Tories and Labour has to deal with that if they want to win their votes. She's right? Also the only source for this quote is the editor of HuffPost UK. Do we know what she actually said? I can't imagine the Express did much fact-checking.

I get what JOK is saying but I don't really agree that 2 notable incidents (imo) in 5 years is quite the 'gotcha' that Borto thinks it is.

As I said earlier, I do agree that the left-wing Twitterati hurling abuse is unhelpful if they want to turn people away from the Tories, but I don't think the blame for this can be laid at the door of the Labour Party. Let's be honest though there's as much abuse online thrown out about "woke, snowflakes" as there is about "thick, racists".

FWIW by the way, I don't 'wonder' why the electorate have turned away from Labour, I know exactly why. Nor am I on here trying to get anyone to vote Labour. Most on this bored are reasonably politically engaged and picked their side a long time ago. I come on here mostly to expose myself to different viewpoints and - occasionally - for a bit of catharsis!

PS. I don't know why anyone calls the politics bored an echo chamber. It's a bloody warzone Big Grin !


As a total aside - There are 9 food banks in operation in Hartlepool whereas 10 years ago there were none. Most people link this to the changes in Universal Credit brought in over recent years.

I completely agree that it is up to Labour to recognise the priorities and aspirations of the electorate - and then meet them - but you must admit it's a hard job when the electorate don't give a fig about lies, corruption or the destitution of their own people! It's not unreasonable to think people might give a shit about the fact they can't put food on the table anymore. Bloody hell.

Great post Cham, there have to be limits to where you will go as an opposition or it’s a race to the bottom. Currently the government are promising a lot, confirming beliefs rather than facts and generally telling many what they want to hear. Let’s see if they deliver, they’ve already had 11yrs and counting to put problems right that they had a huge part in creating  

As for the echo-chamber comments, it’s nonsense but a handy insult for some to throw about.
Reply
This is not 'whataboutery'. Remember that Labour refused to allow job centres to make referrals to foodbanks because it woiuld make them look bad. So there will be a mushrooming of referrals, need and use from that alone.

The 5 week wait for UC needs to be stopped, though. What the hell are people supposed to do during that time?
Reply
Just for bit of context BB, when did Labour refuse to allow the referrals?
Reply
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-12023054 December 2008.
Reply
Have you checked what Harold Wilson has to say on the matter?
Reply
You asked for evidence, you got it, so you resort to sarcasm.

Fantastic. What a guy.
Reply
Nothing of the sort - you seem to be using a reference to a 13 year old policy from a completely different Labour cabinet / membership / party, I was just highlighting how you are using any stick to beat the Labour party with. I was offering help in pointing you in the direction of previous Labour governments who will probably have made mistakes that you can reference that are equally relevant. You could even start the point by saying ' this isn't whataboutery'.
Reply
(05-11-2021, 10:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nothing of the sort - you seem to be using a reference to a 13 year old policy from a completely different Labour cabinet / membership / party, I was just highlighting how you are using any stick to beat the Labour party with. I was offering help in pointing you in the direction of previous Labour governments who will probably have made mistakes that you can reference that are equally relevant. You could even start the point by saying ' this isn't whataboutery'.

Erm, Labour hasn't been in government since 2010 so how else could he answer your question?
Reply
(05-11-2021, 10:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Nothing of the sort - you seem to be using a reference to a 13 year old policy from a completely different Labour cabinet / membership / party, I was just highlighting how you are using any stick to beat the Labour party with. I was offering help in pointing you in the direction of previous Labour governments who will probably have made mistakes that you can reference that are equally relevant. You could even start the point by saying ' this isn't whataboutery'.

It's very simple.

1. I said Labour prevented referrals to foodbanks which could account for some of the foodbank proliferation since 2010

2. You asked for evidence of when that was. Yes, it was in the past. But I am discussing the past, yes?

3. I provided evidence of when that was

4. You resort to sarcasm and your attempted ex post facto attempt at justification embarasses you even further

As being as Labour left office in 2010, when did you think it was going to be when Labour banned referrals? I can't change history, Old Son.

My point at number 1 remains, but there was always likely to be one of those with less acuity who says a valid point is whataboutery, as they often do. Except this time they went for sarcasm that has merely embarrassed them with their pettiness, attempted explanation and how facile a retort it was to attack historical evidence being provided to prove a historical point.
Reply
Foodbanks are also the sign of the generosity of a civilised society. They're in every major developed economy in growing numbers. I sense that won't be a popular opinion on here, but there you go.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)