Do you still care about Brexit?
#51
(05-06-2021, 06:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 04:52 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 04:32 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 03:42 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: To compare the EEC the UK voted to stay in, in 1975, to the EU we voted to leave in 2016 is daft.

Why?

Let me reiterate , the point I was making was that although I voted remain, I wouldn't approve of a campaign to re join the EU, because we have already changed our mind on this subject once, even if there was a future consensus to rejoin, why would we or the EU have any confidence that we wouldn't  change our mind again.

We are out, and in my opinion we will not be rejoining.

Because the EU is way bigger with way more competencies than the EEC in 1975 had. The EEC was mainly the Rome Treaty.

Since then there's been the Single European Act, Masstricht, Amsterdam, Nice, Lisbon and the Charter of Fundamental Rights.

The EEC was significantly more comprehensive than just the Treaty of Rome in 1975, the basis of the four freedoms had already been established by the time we joined it and the customs union was as comprehensive then as it is now, the European Communities portion of the EU was the direct competencies as established by the EEC and the only real development in that regard from 2009 onwards has been the formal amalgamation of the EC into the EU. The only real purposes that were added post 93 that are fundamentally different to how things operated in 73 are the other two pillars, which relate to security (things like the EAW) and the common foreign and social policy as established by the Council. Therefore, the unless you're really concerned by those two pillars, the only real contention that was fundamentally different has been Eastern expansion which was only made possible due to the end of the Cold War.

I did say 'mainly' the Rome Treaty. That was the centrepiece.

You can't really deny that the EU in 2016 was not way more expansive than the EEC and the EC as a result of the Treaties I mentioned.  It's not even arguable that it wasn't. Clearly, Maastricht was the most important but Amsterdam, Nice and Lisbon expanded competencies to varing degrees. You mention thed old pillar structure and the pillars added by Maastricht as if they are barely significant.

That's before we get onto every new piece of secondary legislation since 1975.

The fact is that the people in 1975 voted to remain in a common market of, what, 9 members? The people in 2016 voted to leave a nascent state with 28.

Very different.
Reply
#52
Any political decision campaigned for / supported by / governed by Johnson, Gove, Patel, Hoey, Farage, Hard Man Steve Baker, Murdoch, Francois, the Daily Mail, Express, Widdecombe, Ian Duncan Smith, Tim Martin, Redwood, Fox, Mogg, Cummings, Lawrence (the bloke from Lewis), Jim Davidson, Arron Banks, Katie Hopkins, Tommy Robinson etc etc I can never simply shrug and ‘get over it’. I’m happy to have ‘lost’ if this is the calibre of people I would have to support, admire, trust, or simply turn a blind eye to, to ‘believe’ in Brexit.
Reply
#53
(05-06-2021, 07:57 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 06:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 04:52 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 04:32 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 03:42 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: To compare the EEC the UK voted to stay in, in 1975, to the EU we voted to leave in 2016 is daft.

Why?

Let me reiterate , the point I was making was that although I voted remain, I wouldn't approve of a campaign to re join the EU, because we have already changed our mind on this subject once, even if there was a future consensus to rejoin, why would we or the EU have any confidence that we wouldn't  change our mind again.

We are out, and in my opinion we will not be rejoining.

Because the EU is way bigger with way more competencies than the EEC in 1975 had. The EEC was mainly the Rome Treaty.

Since then there's been the Single European Act, Masstricht, Amsterdam, Nice, Lisbon and the Charter of Fundamental Rights.

The EEC was significantly more comprehensive than just the Treaty of Rome in 1975, the basis of the four freedoms had already been established by the time we joined it and the customs union was as comprehensive then as it is now, the European Communities portion of the EU was the direct competencies as established by the EEC and the only real development in that regard from 2009 onwards has been the formal amalgamation of the EC into the EU. The only real purposes that were added post 93 that are fundamentally different to how things operated in 73 are the other two pillars, which relate to security (things like the EAW) and the common foreign and social policy as established by the Council. Therefore, the unless you're really concerned by those two pillars, the only real contention that was fundamentally different has been Eastern expansion which was only made possible due to the end of the Cold War.

I did say 'mainly' the Rome Treaty. That was the centrepiece.

You can't really deny that the EU in 2016 was not way more expansive than the EEC and the EC as a result of the Treaties I mentioned.  It's not even arguable that it wasn't. Clearly, Maastricht was the most important but Amsterdam, Nice and Lisbon expanded competencies to varing degrees. You mention thed old pillar structure and the pillars added by Maastricht as if they are barely significant.

That's before we get onto every new piece of secondary legislation since 1975.

The fact is that the people in 1975 voted to remain in a common market of, what, 9 members? The people in 2016 voted to leave a nascent state with 28.

Very different.

The three pillars added by Maastricht were the European Communities which was literally just the EEC, the joint foreign policy powers for the Council which was just there to allow the EU to have a foreign policy position and in no way inhibited that if independent nations and the joint security pillar which allowed for cross border policing. The functions of the EU, especially those that people take exception to, were already there within the European Communities pillar. What in the latter two pillars do you honestly take exception to? Every argument I've heard about the EU including my own gripes with the Commission pertain to the functionaries that have been there since the EEC.

The only functional changes to the Communities (until the pillars were amalgamated) added by Amsterdam and Nice were the operational functions to empower the Parliament. They didn't functionally grant powers to the Commission and they didn't impact sovereignty either pooled or that of the individual member states.
Reply
#54
(05-06-2021, 08:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 07:57 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 06:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 04:52 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 04:32 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Why?

Let me reiterate , the point I was making was that although I voted remain, I wouldn't approve of a campaign to re join the EU, because we have already changed our mind on this subject once, even if there was a future consensus to rejoin, why would we or the EU have any confidence that we wouldn't  change our mind again.

We are out, and in my opinion we will not be rejoining.

Because the EU is way bigger with way more competencies than the EEC in 1975 had. The EEC was mainly the Rome Treaty.

Since then there's been the Single European Act, Masstricht, Amsterdam, Nice, Lisbon and the Charter of Fundamental Rights.

The EEC was significantly more comprehensive than just the Treaty of Rome in 1975, the basis of the four freedoms had already been established by the time we joined it and the customs union was as comprehensive then as it is now, the European Communities portion of the EU was the direct competencies as established by the EEC and the only real development in that regard from 2009 onwards has been the formal amalgamation of the EC into the EU. The only real purposes that were added post 93 that are fundamentally different to how things operated in 73 are the other two pillars, which relate to security (things like the EAW) and the common foreign and social policy as established by the Council. Therefore, the unless you're really concerned by those two pillars, the only real contention that was fundamentally different has been Eastern expansion which was only made possible due to the end of the Cold War.

I did say 'mainly' the Rome Treaty. That was the centrepiece.

You can't really deny that the EU in 2016 was not way more expansive than the EEC and the EC as a result of the Treaties I mentioned.  It's not even arguable that it wasn't. Clearly, Maastricht was the most important but Amsterdam, Nice and Lisbon expanded competencies to varing degrees. You mention thed old pillar structure and the pillars added by Maastricht as if they are barely significant.

That's before we get onto every new piece of secondary legislation since 1975.

The fact is that the people in 1975 voted to remain in a common market of, what, 9 members? The people in 2016 voted to leave a nascent state with 28.

Very different.

The three pillars added by Maastricht were the European Communities which was literally just the EEC, the joint foreign policy powers for the Council which was just there to allow the EU to have a foreign policy position and in no way inhibited that if independent nations and the joint security pillar which allowed for cross border policing. The functions of the EU, especially those that people take exception to, were already there within the European Communities pillar. What in the latter two pillars do you honestly take exception to? Every argument I've heard about the EU including my own gripes with the Commission pertain to the functionaries that have been there since the EEC.

The only functional changes to the Communities (until the pillars were amalgamated) added by Amsterdam and Nice were the operational functions to empower the Parliament. They didn't functionally grant powers to the Commission and they didn't impact sovereignty either pooled or that of the individual member states.

And they were hardly inconsequential. You haven't addressed the other Treaties I mention at all, let alone the impact of ever piece of secondary legislation since 1975.

To try to argue that the 1975 and 2016 entities are similar in scope and jurisdiction is, I am afraid, ridiculous.

Pooled sovereignty is yet another remain lie, I am afraid. The phrase doesn't appear in ECJ (I still call it the old name) jurisprudence at all.

The ECJ has been clear since 1962 that membership means a diminution in sovereignty. See Van Gend for the first enunciation of that idea, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/...1962CJ0026, expanded-upon in 1964 in Costa https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/...1964CJ0006. That principle was also reiterated as recently as 2018 in Wightman, the Art 50 case: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/...2018CJ0621.

Our own highest domestic court has accepted this since 1990, in Factortame (No.2): http://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/1990/7.html

If the ECJ says membership means sovereignty is limited, it's limited.


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
               
Reply
#55
Single European Act - Irrelevant as all it did was plan out Maastricht.

Lisbon - Irrelevant as it's main purpose relates to empowering the Parliament and amalgamating the three pillars into a single entity, not the scope or jurisdiction.

CFR - Irrelevant as the UK (and Poland) had an opt-out. Also, not sure how human rights has anything to do with the discussion.

That is why I didn't address them.

Secondary legislation is, also, wholly irrelevant to the discussion as this doesn't pertain to the domain of scope or jurisdiction. Why would I mention it?

Pooled sovereignty does not need to be mentioned by any EU treaty as it applies regardless due to the existence of the EU. To deny that EU member states pool sovereignty through the EU is to genuinely deny reality as it ignores member states appointed commissioners and the existence of the Council and Parliament, I am not interesting in discussing this further and you can read the Oxford Reference on the concept of pooled sovereignty. The UN and NATO are two other examples of pooled sovereignty, as is the Anglo-Irish Council.

The functionaries and the domain of the EEC are identical in purpose and provisions to what it is today, those domains became the European Communities after Maastricht which were then amalgamated into the modern EU post-2009. The Council, the Parliament, the Commission, the Customs Union, the four freedoms, the ECJ, CAP, CFP, etc and all their domains were identical in 1975 as they were in 2016 and are in 2021.
Reply
#56
(05-07-2021, 10:17 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Single European Act - Irrelevant as all it did was plan out Maastricht.

Lisbon - Irrelevant as it's main purpose relates to empowering the Parliament and amalgamating the three pillars into a single entity, not the scope or jurisdiction.

CFR - Irrelevant as the UK (and Poland) had an opt-out. Also, not sure how human rights has anything to do with the discussion.

That is why I didn't address them.

Secondary legislation is, also, wholly irrelevant to the discussion as this doesn't pertain to the domain of scope or jurisdiction. Why would I mention it?

Pooled sovereignty does not need to be mentioned by any EU treaty as it applies regardless due to the existence of the EU. To deny that EU member states pool sovereignty through the EU is to genuinely deny reality as it ignores member states appointed commissioners and the existence of the Council and Parliament, I am not interesting in discussing this further and you can read the Oxford Reference on the concept of pooled sovereignty. The UN and NATO are two other examples of pooled sovereignty, as is the Anglo-Irish Council.

The functionaries and the domain of the EEC are identical in purpose and provisions to what it is today, those domains became the European Communities after Maastricht which were then amalgamated into the modern EU post-2009. The Council, the Parliament, the Commission, the Customs Union, the four freedoms, the ECJ, CAP, CFP, etc and all their domains were identical in 1975 as they were in 2016 and are in 2021.

The Single European Act set the groundwork towards the Single Market, mate, with measures working towards that aim and refiom of the legsilative processes. If you think that is irrelevant, that says it all for your knowledge base here. Sorry.

If you think all those Treaties and secodary legislation are irrelevant when it comes to the expansion of the EU compared to the EEC, there is little point continuing this discussion so this will be my last post on this matter. It is literally a waste of my time.

To say that secondary legislation has no effect on the scope of the EU's powers also says it all. It's as simple as this: as being as EU law is supreme, any EU legislation in any area displaces any contrary national legislation in member states and prevents those member states legislating against any EU legislation. So, secondary legislation expands the power of the EU at the expense of member states and increases the powers assumed by the EU overall.

I should have been more clear: pooled sovereignty *as an explanation of the powers held by the EU* is a remain lie. I don't deny that the concept doesn't exist at all.

My argument was also not that pooled sovereignty is not mentioned in any Treaty. You are not discussing this further because you know you are wrong.

I said that the phrase doesn't appear in ECJ jurisprudence because the ECJ, along with our own top judges, are clear that membership means a diminution in sovereignty. To say that the EU is an entity with pooled sovereignty is simply false. Who do you think you are, that you think you know better than the legal minds in the apex court of the ECJ regarding the effects of membership?! That you know better than our own best legal minds?! I also think those judgments I cite have a hell of a lot more weight than an unsubstantiated assertion from an online reference source.

You need to read the links I used and the screenshots. What the ECJ says EU law is and isn't, that is final. That is unchanged by that woefully inadequate reference source.

I also note that you provide no evidence for your assertion that the EU is pooled sovereignty, apart from that reference source. The fact that other organisations are pooled sovereignty is irrelevant as to whether the EU is. I'll also just point out that:

i) the UK is dualist. Other Treaties don't take effect within UK territory, they only bind on the international plain. The EU treaties had effect within the UK and were justiciable by UK courts.

ii) Legislation made under those treaties didn't take effect within the UK. Therefore those treaties did not confer jurisdiction *within* the UK. EU Regulations (and unimplemented Directives deemed to have Direct Effect) took effect *within* the UK, conferring intra-territorial jurisdiction upon the EU and diminishing national sovereignty as a result

The fact you say (inter alia) the ECJ's domain was the same in 2016 as it was in 1975 merely demonstrates you don't know what you are on about. The ECJ's power a was expanded via jurisdiction over the new Treaties alone, for starters.

You also demonstrate an ignorance of the shift in power between the legislative institutions, such as the co-operation procedure of the Single European Act and the co-decision procedure of Maastricht.

Professor Craig is the World-leading academic authority on EU law. He says there has been an expansion of EU power, with Treaty revisions and legislation as 2 of the key factors in this phenomenon. https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php...INDEX=TRUE

It is true to say that expansion in EU competence was agreed to by the member states (though you could argue that the ECJ effectively legislating interstitially, where it said there were gaps in the Treaties was not agreed to by member states). But to deny that there has been any exapnsion, as you do, is nothing but risible.

I think I'll leave things there and won't be revisting this thread.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)