Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
The Labour Party is a broad church left of centre party and, as we have an undemocratic voting system, they need to appeal to a large subsection of the population that don't like socialism or socialists.
There's a reason why Labour have only ever been at their most effective adopting liberal policies, whether that be from Snowden as chancellor, to Attlee establishing the post-war consensus and adopting the Beveridge Report, to Blair pursuing social democracy with a strong private sector.
And, speaking as a former Lib Dem member who is going to vote Lib Dem across the board tomorrow, you can put all the effort into making brilliant, popular policies and fully costing them but if people don't like the person delivering the message (Clegg in 2015, Swinson) they won't vote for them. The public don't like socialism and putting a self declared Marxist at the helm isn't going to help.
Posts: 613
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
2
(05-05-2021, 08:05 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: I'm sorry mate but you're still doing the same thing. You're accusing people of being 'communists' and "throwing the communist manifesto across the dispatch box" while at the same time saying that you agree with a lot of what was in their actual manifesto. Do you see how that's contradictory? On what basis are you labelling (and who is it you're labelling communists by the way?) people 'communists' when you also say you agree with the policies they are putting forward??
of the 6 policies you've put forward there, 3 are right-wing policies that I wouldn't like to see the Labour party adopt. The Labour party is*supposed* to be socialist and it was co-opted by the Thatcherite Blair, not the other way around.
I would argue that none of them are right wing policies. They are policies that are proven to win. You win first and then change society and move it more towards a socialist democracy. Blair understood that and it was popular and we won.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(05-05-2021, 08:01 PM)Logic1 Wrote: (05-05-2021, 07:44 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: You haven't really answered Shabby's question there Logic. What are the 'hard left' policies that you disagree with? You're perfectly within your rights to like New Labour if you want but you can't complain about the 'hard left' if you're not able to define what it is. I personally feel that terms like 'hard left' are used pretty frivolously these days. The policies in the 2019 Labour manifesto were pretty reasonable centre-left IMO.
I watched both candidates on BBC WM earlier, they both came across reasonably well though I think Byrne had the better arguments.
There was quite a lot of stuff in the Labour manifesto that was good. The problem was the communists delivering the message. People who throw the communist manifesto across the dispatch box should be vanquished and sent to the socialist workers party. Once that happens we will again have a chance of winning:
Education, Eduaction, Education
Tough on Crime, tough on the causes of crime
Real terms per capita growth in health care spending
Low and equitable taxes
Public Investment in infrastructure
Pro Trident, effective military spending
Those 6 things will make Labour win again but it only happens when the commies are eliminated.
I take it from that list that you'll be voting Tory today then?
Posts: 613
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
2
05-06-2021, 08:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-06-2021, 08:36 AM by Logic1.)
No, because out of all of those 6 things, the Tories only do number 6 and I’m not a big fan of number 6 anyway but you have to do it to get elected.
Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
05-06-2021, 08:42 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-06-2021, 08:43 AM by ChamonixBaggie.)
(05-06-2021, 08:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-05-2021, 08:01 PM)Logic1 Wrote: (05-05-2021, 07:44 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: You haven't really answered Shabby's question there Logic. What are the 'hard left' policies that you disagree with? You're perfectly within your rights to like New Labour if you want but you can't complain about the 'hard left' if you're not able to define what it is. I personally feel that terms like 'hard left' are used pretty frivolously these days. The policies in the 2019 Labour manifesto were pretty reasonable centre-left IMO.
I watched both candidates on BBC WM earlier, they both came across reasonably well though I think Byrne had the better arguments.
There was quite a lot of stuff in the Labour manifesto that was good. The problem was the communists delivering the message. People who throw the communist manifesto across the dispatch box should be vanquished and sent to the socialist workers party. Once that happens we will again have a chance of winning:
Education, Eduaction, Education
Tough on Crime, tough on the causes of crime
Real terms per capita growth in health care spending
Low and equitable taxes
Public Investment in infrastructure
Pro Trident, effective military spending
Those 6 things will make Labour win again but it only happens when the commies are eliminated.
I take it from that list that you'll be voting Tory today then?
Ayit? He's a weird dude
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-05-2021, 08:20 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The Labour Party is a broad church left of centre party and, as we have an undemocratic voting system, they need to appeal to a large subsection of the population that don't like socialism or socialists.
There's a reason why Labour have only ever been at their most effective adopting liberal policies, whether that be from Snowden as chancellor, to Attlee establishing the post-war consensus and adopting the Beveridge Report, to Blair pursuing social democracy with a strong private sector.
And, speaking as a former Lib Dem member who is going to vote Lib Dem across the board tomorrow, you can put all the effort into making brilliant, popular policies and fully costing them but if people don't like the person delivering the message (Clegg in 2015, Swinson) they won't vote for them. The public don't like socialism and putting a self declared Marxist at the helm isn't going to help.
This phrase always gets used but surely the Conservative party is as broad a church if not more-so, just right of centre?
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-05-2021, 08:20 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The Labour Party is a broad church left of centre party and, as we have an undemocratic voting system, they need to appeal to a large subsection of the population that don't like socialism or socialists.
There's a reason why Labour have only ever been at their most effective adopting liberal policies, whether that be from Snowden as chancellor, to Attlee establishing the post-war consensus and adopting the Beveridge Report, to Blair pursuing social democracy with a strong private sector.
And, speaking as a former Lib Dem member who is going to vote Lib Dem across the board tomorrow, you can put all the effort into making brilliant, popular policies and fully costing them but if people don't like the person delivering the message (Clegg in 2015, Swinson) they won't vote for them. The public don't like socialism and putting a self declared Marxist at the helm isn't going to help.
This phrase always gets used but surely the Conservative party is as broad a church if not more-so, just right of centre?
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-06-2021, 09:21 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-05-2021, 08:20 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The Labour Party is a broad church left of centre party and, as we have an undemocratic voting system, they need to appeal to a large subsection of the population that don't like socialism or socialists.
There's a reason why Labour have only ever been at their most effective adopting liberal policies, whether that be from Snowden as chancellor, to Attlee establishing the post-war consensus and adopting the Beveridge Report, to Blair pursuing social democracy with a strong private sector.
And, speaking as a former Lib Dem member who is going to vote Lib Dem across the board tomorrow, you can put all the effort into making brilliant, popular policies and fully costing them but if people don't like the person delivering the message (Clegg in 2015, Swinson) they won't vote for them. The public don't like socialism and putting a self declared Marxist at the helm isn't going to help.
This phrase always gets used but surely the Conservative party is as broad a church if not more-so, just right of centre?
Yeah?
I only brought it up because of the reference to the Labour party being a socialist party, when that excludes the social democrats, social liberals and third way centrists that form and vote for Labour.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
In reply to BB.
I don't think you could argue that Atlees govt was liberal.
Yes Beveridge was a liberal, but the report that he wrote was in his capacity as a civil servant. It was undertaken to appease the labour members of the wartime cabinet who were insistent that some planning should be made for when the war was won.
Not only that, but as I understand there was an important difference in what Beveridge proposed and what Labour implemented.Bevan insisted that funding for the nhs and welfare system should come from a tax on earnings from work, I don't believe that was a part of Beveridges original plan..
Interestingly when the report was published 600 000 copies were purchased, inconceivable today to think that the public would be that interested.Legend has it that they found an annotated copy of it in Hitler's bunker with handwritten comments by Hitler.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
The foundation and legacy of Attlee's Government was the postwar consensus, the provision of services (eg the NHS) might have differed from the originally conceived idea by Beveridge in its implementation but the core of that Government was built upon the expansion of the liberal welfare state (first implemented by Churchill no less as a Liberal minister) into its modern counterpart using the blueprints of another liberal (Beveridge) who's policies were consensus within the war ministry (including the Tory and Liberal Ministers) and the economic foundation was built upon the ideas of Keynesian economics and the need to build a budget surplus to bring national debt under control.
I'm not arguing that Attlee and his government were liberals, I'm saying that his government adopted liberal ideals to win popular support, which they did. This is further evidenced by them losing the 1951 election after a lurch within the party leftwards.
|