Big Sam (Match on Match)
#21
Madness, you obviously took some time and thought compiling your opening post, not that there was anything earth-shattering or unique within it, but perhaps you would lay down for us, your plans, as to who you would advocate as Sam's successor, how you would obtain proposed person's services, and the stategy, you would expect/or wish him to employ to regain our place back in the Prem, bearing in mind the Players who may be jumping ship in a few weeks time.
Reply
#22
I'm not a fan of Sam Allardyce the person. I wasn't a fan of SGM as a person either. Doesn't matter.

Since the transfer window, and having decent time on the training ground, there is no doubt Allardyce has changed us from a team that looked pathetic and clueless into a team that if the season started 3mths ago we would finish 14th/15th comfortably.

He has improved Bartley, Furlong, O'Shea and Townsend as defenders, who now play as a unit rather than individuals. He identified weaknesses and signed players to correct them. We LOOK like a football team.

I still have doubts. I still think he has a default setting of 'not lose' rather than 'win', i'm worried about his relationship with Diangana and Robinson and i worry that at his age he wont be able to do this much longer.

But right now i think he's the best we can get, knows the squad, knows what it takes to get out of the Championship and stay in the PL, has a good relationship with Dowling, has a good eye for a player and extensive knowledge on them.

So for now -  if he stays, i'll hold my nose, cover my ears, wait another transfer window and just look at our results.
Reply
#23
(05-05-2021, 12:09 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: Don't think there is really need for blame?  Club with limited budget gets relegated!! is no headline.

I agree you have to take our budget into account and it's extremely unlikely we'd be in anything other than a relegation fight. 

I do think we could have realistically done things better in the Summer even given our budget by attempting to address our glaring weaknesses. If we'd bought in a holding midfielder and a forward (of the likes of Diagne who is far more suited to the way we were going to play than Grant) and these didn't turn out to be good enough then I'd have more sympathy as at least we'd have tried to give ourselves a chance.
Reply
#24
I have not said that Slav would have kept us up. We will always likely to go down but we sacked and replaced him with someone who is "Experienced" in getting teams up the table and out of the relegation fight. Big Sam has failed. It doesn't matter if things were better under him in the last 10 games, We hardly won a 6 pointer when needed losing to Sheff United & Crystal Palace & drawing with Fulham and Newcastle. The Players failed, The Management failed.

I know i dont have a popular viewpoint on this (Some of you are so Bigsamasexuals its laughable)
Reply
#25
(05-05-2021, 10:27 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(05-05-2021, 08:12 AM)Madness Wrote: Since his reign & the myth that we are suddenly a decent side and its all Slav's fault


Aston Villa (L 0-3)- Poor performance and was a massive let down after the draw at Man City
Liverpool (D 1-1)- A good performance against a side who declined after this, well worked point
Leeds (L 0-5)- Absolutely shambolic, worst performance in the PL. But Big Sam escapes criticism from many
Arsenal (L 0-4)- Dreadful, Arsenal played well but alarm bells are ringing 
Wolves (W 3-2)- Wolves were their for the taking and we put in a fantastic performance. 2nd best of the season
West Ham (L 1-2)- Looked better and you can argue we could have come away with a draw
Man City (L 0-5)- Man City were too good, We deserve to lose by this much....moving on 
Fulham (D 2-2)- 2 points dropped, Hangover from Man City but 2nd half we were the better side and should have won 
Sheff United (L 1-2)- Deserved to lose, New Players begin to come in but its too late the rot set in with 4 weeks of madness from Big Sam
Tottenham (L 0-2)- 2 offside goals. But Spurs dominated and this was a match we could have targeted
Man United (D 1-1)- Played really well, Again 2 points dropped
Burnley (D 0-0)- We was very good even with 10 men, Again 2 points dropped
Brighton (W 1-0)- On balance we didn't deserve to win, but the last few performances perhaps told us we deserved a win from somewhere
Everton (L 1-0)- VAR stopped us from getting a draw, which i didn't think we deserved 
Newcastle (D 0-0)- Defensive tactics against an awful side, clearly 2 points dropped
Crystal Palace (L 0-1)- Awful simply Awful. No Desire and poor tactics
Chelsea (W 5-2)- Simply awesome performance, But it took Ivanovic to get injured before Big Sam realised that Robinson could do some damage
Southampton (W 3-0)- Southampton didn't turn up and we were very good, finished well- superb
Leicester (L 0-3)- Leicester for 20 mins were excellent and it was enough. But it was an alarming performance
Aston Villa (D 2-2)- We played ok, But Villa deserved something out the game i felt 
Wolves (D 1-1)- Wolves had key players out but we didn't capitalise on this 



Conclusion- We have improved since signing the loanees but we have dropped points against Burnley, Man United, Fulham and Newcastle & Didn't turn up against Crystal Palace 

This is a weak Premier League (Bottom 8 certainly) and we have missed the opportunity to close the gap even with our signings, Damage was done in the first few weeks. Big Sam has ultimately failed as manager and while he will be staying we have rewarded failure while some of you were delighted at Slav was sacked for achieving promotion 1 year ahead of the plan. 

We will learn as fans

What is quite clear is that before you composed your message you had already convinced yourself that it would one to demonise Sam with and mitigate the damage done by Bilic over the last 12 months of his managership. So with that mindset you have found reasons to fit your agenda.

Weak PL and the experienced manager failed to keep us up. Thats the facts mate. It doesnt matter about agenda

(05-05-2021, 11:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I have only liked two managers and they were GM and Hodgson not that it should matter whether you like a manager or not. It’s about who is the best fit for the circumstances and at the moment Allardyce is the best fit.

You are whiteknighting him in every post, Come off it lad
Reply
#26
Madness, you need to be a bit more clear. Are you saying that any manager who replaced Bilic with the brief of avoiding the drop would inevitably have to be sacked if he failed? Or are you saying that the nature of Allardyce's failure is in some way especially heinous, so he has to go?

You referred to Allardyce's "four weeks of madness". That's extremely harsh. We went out against Villa with some optimism (the players put an extra effort in for the departing Bilic against Man City -  which begs the question why couldn't they do it more often), but Livermore's sending off was pivotal. His reaction angered me, petulant but not unduly distressed. A steady performance against Liverpool gave us hope. Sawyers' own goal against Leeds was the most ridiculous thing I've seen on a football pitch. Against Arsenal, Furlong was ripped to shreds very early for the first goal, Ivanovic showed exactly what he was good for (absolutely nothing) and O'Shea was playing at left back because biscuit legs Gibbs couldn't quite get fit.

More recently, Ajayi's naive sending off probably cost us a win as well. I put it to you that Sam Allardyce or any other manager taking over could not have imagined that his players would be so poor, so flaky, so lacking in discipline as they turned out to be. Were they struggling to adapt to Sam's plan due to lack of training time? Were they completely lacking in confidence to the point where they played like 9 year olds? Did the departure of Bilic and the consequent end of the holiday atmosphere cause a negative reaction?

Almost all of the players mentioned above have now improved massively, for whatever reason. But some of their performances during Sam's "four weeks of madness" were completely and unacceptably unprofessional. He's made some odd decisions over the weeks but he can't carry the can for the carnage of those early matches.
Reply
#27
Madness- no one minds the cut and thrust of banter here, but where are the BigSamaSexuals(like the name)? Name names- I genuinely think most admit he's turned us around, but too late but without their tongues hanging out for a wave from Dudley's ugliest pensioner.

One point not taken into account is probably the window may have fell later in games played this year giving less time for new signings? I may be wrong, but the whole thing leads to the simple undeniable fact at the minute is he turned what was a shambles of a side representing us into something pretty decent now.

Based on that, his impressive record in his career also, many will be happy for him to stay.
Reply
#28
Chesh.

Excellent points about the discipline of the squad Sam inherited. It was pathetic, coupled with being woefully unfit just compounds my dislike for Bilic more and more.

I'm not a big fan of Sam, but logically he is the best bet if he wants it right now.
Reply
#29
One thing to bear in mind is that Bilic had a preseason to work with these players they were unfit and had a chronic lack of belief and focus . When Big Sam came in we were playing twice a week so he would barely have had time to work with the players due to recovery periods and work load .
Reply
#30
(05-05-2021, 05:45 PM)Faggits Wrote: One thing to bear in mind is that Bilic had a preseason to work with these players they were unfit and had a chronic lack of belief and focus . When Big Sam came in we were playing twice a week so he would barely have had time to work with the players due to recovery periods and work load .

He didn't have a proper, no match prep session fir a couple of weeks, even then they were sporadic.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: