Line Of Duty ***Spoiler Alert***
#31
(05-03-2021, 12:08 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:
(05-03-2021, 11:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-03-2021, 09:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: To be any good as a drama IMO it has to be recognisably a fantasy or recognisably factual. This whole series and indeed anything written by Mercurio was a fantasy portraying itself as fact and was complete and utter shite from the start.
The sad thing is people read deep sociological meaning and statement into this shit.
As I have said on here before Mercurio is an appalling writer who writes himself into sensational cul-de-sac and cannot get himself out of them.
Not at all surprised that most are very disappointed in the ending.

There are sociological points made and they aren't hidden they are written large in neon letters each episode. 

Drama's are designed to be first and foremost entertaining, most films are a mix of fact and fantasy. Which films are factual? For that matter which documentaries tell the truth and nothing but the truth?  I doubt many people think LoD is factual they recognise it for what it is a police drama that uses the backdrop of current policing methods, vernacular to tell an entertaining story. Some of it's contemporaries when it started were Lewis, Vera and Midsummer Murders! It's worth remembering that this wasn't a hyped up drama from the outset, it was on BBC2 and had loyal but not huge audience that grew. There hasn't been a drama that started so modestly and grew to where it is now for many years. I think dismissing it as 'utter shite' is as ott as some of the scenes in the show itself.

Spot on. The depiction of young Ryan as a vicious child thug manipulated by hardcore criminals in series 1 caused a massive stir at the time, and reflected brilliantly the emerging county lines drugs running problem in real life. The show had a gritty take that fed its reputation. Series 2 and 3 included scenes that became iconic, especially the brilliant interview scenes with Lindsay Denton, but were at their very best when tackling head on the accusations of institutionalised abuse and its cover-up. Nothing else on tv came close to this mixing of drama and real events, and it's been a standard that has proven hard for LoD itself to emulate. The show was in its pomp, groundbreaking and making headlines, however from series 5 the media circus seemed to engulf it and give it Prem-style over-hyping, so that everywhere is now awash with 'fans' predicting nothing more than 'who is H'? It was a series too long IMO, but the Denton / Waldron / Fairbanks era was brilliant viewing.

I used the words 'recognisably' in front of Factual and Fantasy as no-one can expect every matter to be portrayed accurately or that it would be entertaining.
In something over 40 years of 'adult' contact/employment with the Police I have never, under any conditions seen interview situations remotely like the ones portrayed on screen. I have never seen enquiries undertaken in such haphazard and farcical manner and I have never witnessed such twaddle that allows a charging thresholds to be attained.

Never in the field of TV drama has so much communication taken place, evidence gained and knowing glances exchanged over so many balconies, stairways or windows overlooking Police car parks or Police reception areas. FFS - surely he hasn't exhausted his imagination so much that he can't come up with other credible ways of evidence gathering?

Another example - an officer simultaneously engaged in Investigation/Interrogation work, who is also an active surveillance operative, who is also an authorised firearms officer is complete and utter fantasy. The crossover of such skills and disciplines for more reasons, practical and procedural, than I have the time to list, have not been allowed to overlap for over 30 years.
However the fact that there are some who remotely believe that the premise of this series in some small way reflects how corruption within the Police manifests itself shows exactly the reason why I feel about it as I do.
It is not even 10% accurate hence my 'utter shite' opinion.
Some may find it entertaining, but something so far removed from the real world, yet portrays itself as cutting edge and 'as close to accurate as possible', as Mercurio deludedly does, makes it far from that for me.
Reply
#32
I loved it. We know it’s not factual but it made good viewing as 10 mill as shown . Well Swag for someone who didn’t like it you did what the writer and the BBC wanted and watched it.
Reply
#33
I'd take Shetland over LOD any day of the week, and not just because the scenery is better.

But, different strokes and all that...
Reply
#34
(05-03-2021, 01:29 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Pilkington attended, and is involved with, the drama studio at Chawn Hill Church in Stourbridge.

Which is very close indeed to where I'm typing these words!
Are ypou buried there?
Reply
#35
(05-03-2021, 09:26 AM)wba13 Wrote: I don’t think that that was the end,  Buckles is covering for someone higher up the ladder.

Osborne.

We saw he was dodgy from the first series when he tried to cover up that bloke being shot when they went into the wrong flat. There's lots of other little things pointing towards him throughout the different series as well. 

I definitely think they'll be back for a 7th, I hope so anyway as I thought the ending was very rushed and disappointing.
Reply
#36
(05-03-2021, 03:06 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(05-03-2021, 12:08 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:
(05-03-2021, 11:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-03-2021, 09:52 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: To be any good as a drama IMO it has to be recognisably a fantasy or recognisably factual. This whole series and indeed anything written by Mercurio was a fantasy portraying itself as fact and was complete and utter shite from the start.
The sad thing is people read deep sociological meaning and statement into this shit.
As I have said on here before Mercurio is an appalling writer who writes himself into sensational cul-de-sac and cannot get himself out of them.
Not at all surprised that most are very disappointed in the ending.

There are sociological points made and they aren't hidden they are written large in neon letters each episode. 

Drama's are designed to be first and foremost entertaining, most films are a mix of fact and fantasy. Which films are factual? For that matter which documentaries tell the truth and nothing but the truth?  I doubt many people think LoD is factual they recognise it for what it is a police drama that uses the backdrop of current policing methods, vernacular to tell an entertaining story. Some of it's contemporaries when it started were Lewis, Vera and Midsummer Murders! It's worth remembering that this wasn't a hyped up drama from the outset, it was on BBC2 and had loyal but not huge audience that grew. There hasn't been a drama that started so modestly and grew to where it is now for many years. I think dismissing it as 'utter shite' is as ott as some of the scenes in the show itself.

Spot on. The depiction of young Ryan as a vicious child thug manipulated by hardcore criminals in series 1 caused a massive stir at the time, and reflected brilliantly the emerging county lines drugs running problem in real life. The show had a gritty take that fed its reputation. Series 2 and 3 included scenes that became iconic, especially the brilliant interview scenes with Lindsay Denton, but were at their very best when tackling head on the accusations of institutionalised abuse and its cover-up. Nothing else on tv came close to this mixing of drama and real events, and it's been a standard that has proven hard for LoD itself to emulate. The show was in its pomp, groundbreaking and making headlines, however from series 5 the media circus seemed to engulf it and give it Prem-style over-hyping, so that everywhere is now awash with 'fans' predicting nothing more than 'who is H'? It was a series too long IMO, but the Denton / Waldron / Fairbanks era was brilliant viewing.

I used the words 'recognisably' in front of Factual and Fantasy as no-one can expect every matter to be portrayed accurately or that it would be entertaining.
In something over 40 years of 'adult' contact/employment with the Police I have never, under any conditions seen interview situations remotely like the ones portrayed on screen. I have never seen enquiries undertaken in such haphazard and farcical manner and I have never witnessed such twaddle that allows a charging thresholds to be attained.

Never in the field of TV drama has so much communication taken place, evidence gained and knowing glances exchanged over so many balconies, stairways or windows overlooking Police car parks or Police reception areas. FFS - surely he hasn't exhausted his imagination so much that he can't come up with other credible ways of evidence gathering?

Another example - an officer simultaneously engaged in Investigation/Interrogation work, who is also an active surveillance operative, who is also an authorised firearms officer is complete and utter fantasy. The crossover of such skills and disciplines for more reasons, practical and procedural, than I have the time to list, have not been allowed to overlap for over 30 years.
However the fact that there are some who remotely believe that the premise of this series in some small way reflects how corruption within the Police manifests itself shows exactly the reason why I feel about it as I do.
It is not even 10% accurate hence my 'utter shite' opinion.
Some may find it entertaining, but something so far removed from the real world, yet portrays itself as cutting edge and 'as close to accurate as possible', as Mercurio deludedly does, makes it far from that for me.

As a former teacher I found Waterloo Road a totally ridiculous depiction of school life. But I took it with a pinch of salt and enjoyed the show. I also don't underestimate viewers' ability to distinguish between fact and fiction. On which point where have you taken your 'as close to accurate as possible' quote come from?
Reply
#37
(05-03-2021, 03:54 PM)Ossian Wrote: I'd take Shetland over LOD any day of the week, and not just because the scenery is better.

But, different strokes and all that...

Different Strokes was shit
Reply
#38
(05-03-2021, 04:18 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: As a former teacher I found Waterloo Road a totally ridiculous depiction of school life. But I took it with a pinch of salt and enjoyed the show. I also don't underestimate viewers' ability to distinguish between fact and fiction. On which point where have you taken your 'as close to accurate as possible' quote come from?

I can't find the I/V that states the 'as close to accurate as possible' as the internet is full of the debate on last night (and our match is about to K.O.)  but this is the type of thing. 
Mercurio said, “I think it’s important to be as close to the right procedures as possible. The starting point is with our advisers and I always get excited if we can use something I haven’t seen in any other series.”
As I said on a previous thread the 'advisors' must be either pissed, enjoying their moment of fame a little too much. or being completely ignored

Reply
#39
(05-03-2021, 04:58 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(05-03-2021, 04:18 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: As a former teacher I found Waterloo Road a totally ridiculous depiction of school life. But I took it with a pinch of salt and enjoyed the show. I also don't underestimate viewers' ability to distinguish between fact and fiction. On which point where have you taken your 'as close to accurate as possible' quote come from?

I can't find the I/V that states the 'as close to accurate as possible' as the internet is full of the debate on last night (and our match is about to K.O.)  but this is the type of thing. 
Mercurio said, “I think it’s important to be as close to the right procedures as possible. The starting point is with our advisers and I always get excited if we can use something I haven’t seen in any other series.”
As I said on a previous thread the 'advisors' must be either pissed, enjoying their moment of fame a little too much. or being completely ignored


Arf, that's worthy of Buckells at his best!  Wink
Reply
#40
(05-03-2021, 04:47 PM)Cornflake Wrote:
(05-03-2021, 03:54 PM)Ossian Wrote: I'd take Shetland over LOD any day of the week, and not just because the scenery is better.

But, different strokes and all that...

Different Strokes was shit
What you talking about Willis?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)