ID Cards
#1
This isn't particularly topical just out of interest.

I'm at dinner with some Swiss mates who can't believe we don't have ID cards and were incredulous when I said there was a strong negative movement towards them in the UK. "what if you don't want to carry your passport around with your". "what if you haven't passed your driving test" etc etc

I don't see a particular issue with them and don't see what data the govt would be harvesting they don't already have.

Does anyone have a strong opinion?
Reply
#2
Who gets access to the information held on ID? The last proposal indicated that the government was going to share access to tens of thousands of companies without prior consent.

What about ID theft? Due to having multiple avenues for ID with no requirement of consistency, identity theft is difficult. Having an ID card unifies that system and makes it so much easier.

How do we ensure that the domain for ID cards remain as they are? Feature creep is a serious issue and there's already been talk of tracking online identities by the UK government, how can we ensure that isn't allowed if all that needs to happen is a simple ammendment?

How do we ensure the right to privacy for an individual by forcing them to have something they don't want nor need?

How will the police use access to ID? There have been serious police discrimination issues in France and Germany with respect to ethnic minorities and there is a serious level of mistrust among ethnic minorities with the government, see the Covid vaccination issues currently ongoing in the UK for proof to its relevance.

How much would it cost? Will it be paid by the state? Will there be a fee if there is an address change? Will biometrics be tied in? How often will the biometrics need to be identified? Are gypsies/travellers or the homeless accounted for with no fixed address or a constantly changing address?

Finally, why do we need it? We already have access to ID, it's consensual and it works fine in practice. And we already trialled a national ID up until 1951 where it was abused by the authorities and nobody liked it, hence we got rid of it.

It just seems to me to be a massive waste of time and money with no upsides over our current situations and so many potential issues.
Reply
#3
Too much Big Brother for my liking. I think Boring Baggie covered most issues but, put simply, what's the point? If people intend to commit crimes, having an ID card won't stop them. There is too much creeping control now. I understand if I travel abroad I take a passport, to drive I have a license, to draw money I have a card, none of this is a problem to me. I see absolutely no advantage to having an ID card, details of which may be shared without my knowledge. I still cling to the unlikely dream that it is possible to just walk off into the sunset and walk the Highlands for days on end without Amazon or Google being able to find me. Maybe naïve but I really think some are putting too much faith in the benevolence of government.
Reply
#4
I'd tend to agree really. We as a society have never had them and therefore don't see a use for them. I'm not opposed to them ideologically as I don't see what info would be stored that isn't already but I just think the rollout would be a waste of time and money.

I was just taken aback by how fervently my Swiss mates were in favour of them and were genuinely amazed we didn't have them. I think travelling around mainland Europe/Schengen is the biggest single advantage of them though which obviously hasn't ever applied for us.
Reply
#5
Something free that could replace the need to carry a paper passport when travelling would be good. It's a pain in the arse having about five types of ID when travelling. No idea how you would get around driving licenses, different coloured ID cards for those who can and can't drive. We have so many forms of ID and yet some people are unable to access/afford any of them.
Reply
#6
(04-30-2021, 08:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We have so many forms of ID and yet some people are unable to access/afford any of them.

Absolute bollocks. It's impossible to even exist on benefits without proving who you are.
Reply
#7
(04-30-2021, 11:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2021, 08:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We have so many forms of ID and yet some people are unable to access/afford any of them.

Absolute bollocks. It's impossible to even exist on benefits without proving who you are.

It's got nothing to do with benefits. I'd bet there's a decent number of the UK population who either, don't have a passport or driving licence and a slightly smaller proportion who have no photo ID. I'm not against ID cards but if it were to be brought it, it would have to be given to people free of charge.
Reply
#8
(04-30-2021, 01:20 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-30-2021, 11:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2021, 08:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We have so many forms of ID and yet some people are unable to access/afford any of them.

Absolute bollocks. It's impossible to even exist on benefits without proving who you are.

It's got nothing to do with benefits. I'd bet there's a decent number of the UK population who either, don't have a passport or driving licence and a slightly smaller proportion who have no photo ID. I'm not against ID cards but if it were to be brought it, it would have to be given to people free of charge.

That's exactly the plan with voter ID.
Reply
#9
(04-30-2021, 02:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2021, 01:20 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-30-2021, 11:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2021, 08:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We have so many forms of ID and yet some people are unable to access/afford any of them.

Absolute bollocks. It's impossible to even exist on benefits without proving who you are.

It's got nothing to do with benefits. I'd bet there's a decent number of the UK population who either, don't have a passport or driving licence and a slightly smaller proportion who have no photo ID. I'm not against ID cards but if it were to be brought it, it would have to be given to people free of charge.

That's exactly the plan with voter ID.

Ah voter ID, the perfect example of the use of ID for a frivolous reason that solves no problems. ID for ID sakes.
Reply
#10
(04-30-2021, 06:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Ah voter ID, the perfect example of the use of ID for a frivolous reason that solves no problems. ID for ID sakes.

I'd sooner ban postal voting myself BB. I'm old enough to remember the likes of the Lib Dem's Mohammed Khan farming postal votes and beating up journalists in Birmingham. Postal voting is the biggest scandal in local politics.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: