I will personally drive Bartley to Leeds
#51
The truth is back four players and goalkeepers are always going to be the people most singled out for mistakes that cost goals simply by dint of their position. While posters occasionally point out mistakes made by midfielders missing tackles, giving the ball away, etc., that lead to goals, such errors are more often than not followed by a passage of play that removes the culprit from direct blame.

I was never that much of a fan of Bartley but in many games he's been tremendous this season. Ajayi are O'Shea are still relatively young for centre backs and still learning the game in a position where many of the best are often at their peak in their thirties - as past luminaries at our club such as Kaye, Talbut, Wile, Robertson, Olsson, McAuley, Evans proved.

For most of the season our back four has had fuck-all protection in front of them and the goals conceded were horrific. Since the midfield has been replaced the goals conceded has dropped off the scale. Yesterday was annoying and yes of course our defenders have made mistakes but in the wider context of the season they're not the reason we're in the shit.
Reply
#52
(04-26-2021, 08:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: The truth is back four players and goalkeepers are always going to be the people most singled out for mistakes that cost goals simply by dint of their position.  While posters occasionally point out mistakes made by midfielders missing tackles, giving the ball away, etc., that lead to goals, such errors are more often than not followed by a passage of play that removes the culprit from direct blame. 

I was never that much of a fan of Bartley but in many games he's been tremendous this season.  Ajayi are O'Shea are still relatively young for centre backs and still learning the game in a position where many of the best are often at their peak in their thirties - as past luminaries at our club such as Kaye, Talbut, Wile, Robertson, Olsson, McAuley, Evans proved.

For most of the season our back four has had fuck-all protection in front of them and the goals conceded were horrific.  Since the midfield has been replaced the goals conceded has dropped off the scale.  Yesterday was annoying and yes of course our defenders have made mistakes but in the wider context of the season they're not the reason we're in the shit.

Great post. Absolutely
Reply
#53
Ajayi lacks concentration and far too error prone for the top level where mistakes get punished. He's also 28 this year and I can't see him improving much now.

O'Shea has potential and I think is someone that could improve a lot.
Reply
#54
(04-26-2021, 08:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: The truth is back four players and goalkeepers are always going to be the people most singled out for mistakes that cost goals simply by dint of their position.  While posters occasionally point out mistakes made by midfielders missing tackles, giving the ball away, etc., that lead to goals, such errors are more often than not followed by a passage of play that removes the culprit from direct blame. 

I was never that much of a fan of Bartley but in many games he's been tremendous this season.  Ajayi are O'Shea are still relatively young for centre backs and still learning the game in a position where many of the best are often at their peak in their thirties - as past luminaries at our club such as Kaye, Talbut, Wile, Robertson, Olsson, McAuley, Evans proved.

For most of the season our back four has had fuck-all protection in front of them and the goals conceded were horrific.  Since the midfield has been replaced the goals conceded has dropped off the scale.  Yesterday was annoying and yes of course our defenders have made mistakes but in the wider context of the season they're not the reason we're in the shit.

I wouldnt consider 27 young, he should be in his prime. If Sam stays I can see him being moved on whilst we can still command a transfer fee and give him the opportunity to bring in his own defenders
Reply
#55
(04-26-2021, 09:22 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Ajayi lacks concentration and far too error prone for the top level where mistakes get punished. He's also 28 this year and I can't see him improving much now.

O'Shea has potential and I think is someone that could improve a lot.

O'Shea is really and truly one to watch. He could go a long, long way. There's a lot I'd criticise Bilic for, but fair play for spotting him and getting him signed up.
Reply
#56
I didnt actually think Bartley was to blame, ball to the chest with no real pace on it. Very difficult to deal with even for a pro. Maybe Johnstone should have caught it as ball came in?
Reply
#57
(04-26-2021, 05:39 PM)coxy134 Wrote: I didnt actually think Bartley was to blame, ball to the chest with no real pace on it. Very difficult to deal with even for a pro. Maybe Johnstone should have caught it as ball came in?

I don’t think either party covered themselves in glory to be honest.
Reply
#58
(04-26-2021, 06:16 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-25-2021, 11:47 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-25-2021, 11:23 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(04-25-2021, 11:19 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(04-25-2021, 10:19 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: Hope your post provided some obviously much needed catharsis Hoppy, but I doubt it did.

It took me two years to get over Foster's fuck up at Villa, so I can understand the knee jerk emotion you are feeling, even if, on reflection, you may not really stand by your sentiments.

No to your first question. 

Secondly, no, not knee jerk at all, I analyse situations quickly unlike Ajayi and Bartley who were totally unprofessional at key moments tonight and that may have cost us our Prem status - do people realise what that potentially means?   Probably the loss of more than half our starting line-up tonight and I bet my bottom dollar that had/if we survive,  the first thing Sam would do is sign two centre halves! 

Whilst they have both occasionally had a decent game,  they are both absolute liabilities like Livermore and Sawyers.

You think the draw tonight cost us our status in this league?

Come on now.

Honestly now, Dumbo, read what I said...did I say that?  

Those two points lost tonight (and the belief they would engender going into the last 5 games) are probably going to count towards costing us survival,  as so many others we've thrown away over the season, but we're now at the point where cutting out unnecessary mistakes is crucial.  The reaction of the players when their equalizer went in was palpable.  

Bartley and Ajayi cost us two points tonight.  Fact. 

Bartley and O'Shea cost us against Leicester.  

I could mention Spurs (Bartley arguably cost us twice),  Fulham, Newcastle and so many more....

I think you’ve invested a lot of energy in hoping we survive judging by your posts. It’s been bold of you to take the gambit or playing devils advocate some may say a tad delusional?
Perhaps your anger and justification for lambasting Bartley is a realisation that the fairy story won’t happen. 
Welcome back to our world Hopalong.

My comments were out of order and I've apologised,  they're both genuine blokes and human beings, I and we know that. 

Too many beers,  contempt for the seals (90 seconds from victory ffs!) and probably the final nail in the coffin lit the blue touch paper. 

Yes, I know I've probably been overly optimistic - you say some may say a tad delusional.   And yes as things stand we're 10 points from safety but just look at the stupid points we've either thrown away since Allardyce took over or in certain games failed to turn up - like Leicester last Thursday.  We should be a lot closer to making a final fist of it over these last 5 games but sadly barring a miracle now,  we'll be playing Blose and Cov next season...but you never know....wouldn't surprise me if Brighton or saints lose every game  Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: