Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
BurleyBaggie Wrote:What’s the interpretation of the offside rule here? I know there was no such thing as interfering with play but hasn’t he just ran into his own deflection and not played the ball?
I wasn’t born for another 10 years so I’ve know idea how offside was interpreted in ‘71.
The offside rule was always the same. A player was in an offside position if they were ahead of the ball when it was played forward by a team mate and there were less than two opposition players between them and the opposition goal line.
In order to be given offside, though, the player had to be involved in the play in some way. If they were, for example, lying unconscious on the floor, they would not be given as offside and play would carry on.
Suggett was deemed as not interfering with play, i.e. he wasn't trying to gain an advantage or become involved in the play, so was not given as offside. Play carried on.
Although he did make an initial move to get involved when the ball broke, but managed to check himself, to the referee's satisfaction.
Posts: 2,843
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
I'm surprised how few amendments have been made to the offside rule considering how hotly it's been debated over the years.
Initially the rule was very similar to modern day Rugby with no forward passes allowed.
This was relaxed in 1866 when at least 3 opposition players had to be between the attacker and the goalline.
In 1925 this was changed to 2 players.
In 1990 a player was deemed onside if he was level with the 2nd closest player.
Some important points to note:
A player cannot be offside if he is in his own defensive half of the field. Bomber v Leeds was thus onside
Being offside is not, in itself, an offence. It only becomes one if the player attempts to touch the ball after it has been played forward by a team-mate.
The opposition’s goalkeeper counts as one of the players, but he doesn’t have to be one of their players.
So as Colin Suggett made no attempt to play the ball and it wasn't passed to him, he wasn't offside. The linesman flagged incorrectly, Tinkler rightly overruled him and Astle being behind Bomber when the pass was made was onside & scored.
Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
Astle is definitely offside when Bomber squares the ball for him, irrespective of Suggett.
Posts: 2,843
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
04-17-2021, 08:44 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-17-2021, 09:00 PM by Albionmad.)
(04-17-2021, 08:27 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Astle is definitely offside when Bomber squares the ball for him, irrespective of Suggett.
Astle was behind Brown when the pass was made. Therefore onside
The two most blameworthy things of that day were:
1) Leeds didn't play to the referee's whistle
2) Barry Davis's commentary.
And Albion should've been 3 nil up before the "incident". That somehow escaped most people's attention on the day.
Posts: 455
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(04-17-2021, 02:49 PM)Bear Town Baggie Wrote: The pitch invasion was down to "Yorkshire spirit" WTF
The most disgraceful commentary you're ever likely to hear. Didn't understand the rules of the game and glorified the violence that followed. Should have been sacked on the spot. Unfortunately, we had to put up with his garbage for many years to come.
Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
(04-17-2021, 08:44 PM)Albionmad Wrote: (04-17-2021, 08:27 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Astle is definitely offside when Bomber squares the ball for him, irrespective of Suggett.
Astle was behind Brown when the pass was made. Therefore onside
The two most blameworthy things of that day were:
1) Leeds didn't play to the referee's whistle
2) Barry Davis's commentary.
And Albion should've been 3 nil up before the "incident". That somehow escaped most people's attention on the day.
The benchmark is wherher Astle was behind the ball when it was passed as opposed to behind Bomber/the team-mate makinhg the pass (though there isn't much difference in this instance).
I think Astle is at least level with the ball when the pass is made which puts him offside. Due to bad camera work we will never now for sure.
In any case the man to blame for the goal is Hunter and his 2 bad attempted passes.
Posts: 2,955
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
(04-17-2021, 09:42 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: (04-17-2021, 08:44 PM)Albionmad Wrote: (04-17-2021, 08:27 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Astle is definitely offside when Bomber squares the ball for him, irrespective of Suggett.
Astle was behind Brown when the pass was made. Therefore onside
The two most blameworthy things of that day were:
1) Leeds didn't play to the referee's whistle
2) Barry Davis's commentary.
And Albion should've been 3 nil up before the "incident". That somehow escaped most people's attention on the day.
The benchmark is wherher Astle was behind the ball when it was passed as opposed to behind Bomber/the team-mate makinhg the pass (though there isn't much difference in this instance).
I think Astle is at least level with the ball when the pass is made which puts him offside. Due to bad camera work we will never now for sure.
In any case the man to blame for the goal is Hunter and his 2 bad attempted passes. On another forum I've been quoted Astle's autobiography, where he says he was offside.
As I say, I was at the match, and obviously took a great interest in the replays.
Nowhere was it suggested that Jeff was offside. All debate was about the initial break by Tony B.
Watching this clip, it's impossible to tell. TBF that was all the camera work we ever got in those pre Sky days.
But Bomber apparently used to tell Jack Charlton that he should have played to the whistle!
Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
(04-17-2021, 09:49 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (04-17-2021, 09:42 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: (04-17-2021, 08:44 PM)Albionmad Wrote: (04-17-2021, 08:27 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Astle is definitely offside when Bomber squares the ball for him, irrespective of Suggett.
Astle was behind Brown when the pass was made. Therefore onside
The two most blameworthy things of that day were:
1) Leeds didn't play to the referee's whistle
2) Barry Davis's commentary.
And Albion should've been 3 nil up before the "incident". That somehow escaped most people's attention on the day.
The benchmark is wherher Astle was behind the ball when it was passed as opposed to behind Bomber/the team-mate makinhg the pass (though there isn't much difference in this instance).
I think Astle is at least level with the ball when the pass is made which puts him offside. Due to bad camera work we will never now for sure.
In any case the man to blame for the goal is Hunter and his 2 bad attempted passes. On another forum I've been quoted Astle's autobiography, where he says he was offside.
As I say, I was at the match, and obviously took a great interest in the replays.
Nowhere was it suggested that Jeff was offside. All debate was about the initial break by Tony B.
Watching this clip, it's impossible to tell. TBF that was all the camera work we ever got in those pre Sky days.
But Bomber apparently used to tell Jack Charlton that he should have played to the whistle!
Yeah, everyone was so concerned about Suggett they missed what followed!!
If you were at the match, how was it in Leeds? Be just about the time their hooliganism issue started, was there any segregation? I am guessing not.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-17-2021, 09:30 PM)74bus Wrote: (04-17-2021, 02:49 PM)Bear Town Baggie Wrote: The pitch invasion was down to "Yorkshire spirit" WTF
The most disgraceful commentary you're ever likely to hear. Didn't understand the rules of the game and glorified the violence that followed. Should have been sacked on the spot. Unfortunately, we had to put up with his garbage for many years to come.
There's elements of pulling down statues about your comments. It was what it was 50 years ago- things change. Relax and we won anyhow!
Posts: 1,904
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(04-17-2021, 08:22 PM)Albionmad Wrote: I'm surprised how few amendments have been made to the offside rule considering how hotly it's been debated over the years.
Initially the rule was very similar to modern day Rugby with no forward passes allowed.
This was relaxed in 1866 when at least 3 opposition players had to be between the attacker and the goalline.
In 1925 this was changed to 2 players.
In 1990 a player was deemed onside if he was level with the 2nd closest player.
Some important points to note:
A player cannot be offside if he is in his own defensive half of the field. Bomber v Leeds was thus onside
Being offside is not, in itself, an offence. It only becomes one if the player attempts to touch the ball after it has been played forward by a team-mate.
The opposition’s goalkeeper counts as one of the players, but he doesn’t have to be one of their players.
So as Colin Suggett made no attempt to play the ball and it wasn't passed to him, he wasn't offside. The linesman flagged incorrectly, Tinkler rightly overruled him and Astle being behind Bomber when the pass was made was onside & scored. Just for clarity: " Being in an offside position is not an offence in itself, but a player so positioned when the ball is played by a team-mate can be judged guilty of an offside offence if they become "involved in active play", "interfere with an opponent", or "gain an advantage" by being in that position."
|