Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-13-2021, 03:06 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Pretty spot on there mate.
Think I’d bump Periera up half a mark though and think you’re being slightly harsh on Gallagher but bang on for the rest.
Agree with this.
Think Gallagher was maybe overrated by us given how much of an upgrade he was on Sawyers and Jake. Now we have two very good PL midfielders his lack of quality is showing. He’ll have a career in the PL, but not sure he’ll make it to Chelsea’s level.
Decent write up Manc.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
04-13-2021, 08:22 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-13-2021, 08:23 PM by Fulham Fallout.)
(04-13-2021, 03:03 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015). Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks
SJ 8 Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves. Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT
Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times. Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances
Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward. Had chances too. Needless pen – given cover was on.
Bartley - 8.5 unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago. Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off
OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home. Real bonus this season. Numerous interceptions and covering
Okay – 7.5 outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in
AMN – 8.5 comfortably his best game for us. Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs. Great pass inside for the penalty.
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish. Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored. Really should have had much more game time than he has.
Phillips – 8 easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness. Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times. Excellent back post run and finish.
Perreira – 7.5 great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.
Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd. Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).
Gallagher – 6.5 Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly. Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas
Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit. Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end.
HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Thank fuck for that.
Someone else who can see that;
He doesn’t tackle like Okay
He doesn’t have the passing through balls like Pereira
He doesn’t skin people like Diangana or Pereira can with their trickery
He doesn’t have the long accurate passing forward balls like Sawyers
But he can run like a Duracell bunny and force a team into mistakes. Other than that, I honestly don’t see what he offers and we are far better with Robinson in the team in his place.
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(04-13-2021, 08:22 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 03:03 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015). Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks
SJ 8 Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves. Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT
Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times. Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances
Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward. Had chances too. Needless pen – given cover was on.
Bartley - 8.5 unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago. Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off
OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home. Real bonus this season. Numerous interceptions and covering
Okay – 7.5 outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in
AMN – 8.5 comfortably his best game for us. Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs. Great pass inside for the penalty.
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish. Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored. Really should have had much more game time than he has.
Phillips – 8 easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness. Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times. Excellent back post run and finish.
Perreira – 7.5 great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.
Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd. Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).
Gallagher – 6.5 Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly. Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas
Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit. Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end.
HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Thank fuck for that.
Someone else who can see that;
He doesn’t tackle like Okay
He doesn’t have the passing through balls like Pereira
He doesn’t skin people like Diangana or Pereira can with their trickery
He doesn’t have the long accurate passing forward balls like Sawyers
But he can run like a Duracell bunny and force a team into mistakes. Other than that, I honestly don’t see what he offers and we are far better with Robinson in the team in his place.
You said that we’d be lucky to get our £8mill back on Periera.
If you think Sawyers offers more on the pitch than Gallagher, you’re clearly addicted to spice.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
04-13-2021, 09:10 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-13-2021, 09:21 PM by Fulham Fallout.)
(04-13-2021, 08:56 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-13-2021, 08:22 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 03:03 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015). Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks
SJ 8 Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves. Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT
Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times. Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances
Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward. Had chances too. Needless pen – given cover was on.
Bartley - 8.5 unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago. Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off
OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home. Real bonus this season. Numerous interceptions and covering
Okay – 7.5 outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in
AMN – 8.5 comfortably his best game for us. Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs. Great pass inside for the penalty.
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish. Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored. Really should have had much more game time than he has.
Phillips – 8 easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness. Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times. Excellent back post run and finish.
Perreira – 7.5 great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.
Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd. Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).
Gallagher – 6.5 Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly. Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas
Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit. Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end.
HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Thank fuck for that.
Someone else who can see that;
He doesn’t tackle like Okay
He doesn’t have the passing through balls like Pereira
He doesn’t skin people like Diangana or Pereira can with their trickery
He doesn’t have the long accurate passing forward balls like Sawyers
But he can run like a Duracell bunny and force a team into mistakes. Other than that, I honestly don’t see what he offers and we are far better with Robinson in the team in his place.
You said that we’d be lucky to get our £8mill back on Periera.
If you think Sawyers offers more on the pitch than Gallagher, you’re clearly addicted to spice.
Re Pereira’s price. We had this discussion a couple of days ago. Go back and re-read what I wrote.
So rather than attacking my posts (yet again, yawn), tell me what Gallagher brings to the team? Cos it sure ain’t though passes, dribbling, long passes nor tackling, nor free kicks , nor corners, nor headers.
So what is it he brings? All I have read is “can’t you see?”. No, I can’t, hence why I’m asking, yet again, what others “see” that I can’t.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
Good review Manc. I like the description of Diagne as a mix of MAF/Rondon - he's more of a goalscorer than MAF and has been unfortunate not to have about 4 or 5 goals to his name yet although he's missed a few he should have done better with. Wonder if there's any chance of us keeping him in the Chump, probably not I suspect.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(04-13-2021, 08:22 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 03:03 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015). Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks
SJ 8 Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves. Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT
Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times. Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances
Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward. Had chances too. Needless pen – given cover was on.
Bartley - 8.5 unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago. Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off
OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home. Real bonus this season. Numerous interceptions and covering
Okay – 7.5 outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in
AMN – 8.5 comfortably his best game for us. Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs. Great pass inside for the penalty.
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish. Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored. Really should have had much more game time than he has.
Phillips – 8 easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness. Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times. Excellent back post run and finish.
Perreira – 7.5 great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.
Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd. Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).
Gallagher – 6.5 Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly. Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas
Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit. Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end.
HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Thank fuck for that.
Someone else who can see that;
He doesn’t tackle like Okay
He doesn’t have the passing through balls like Pereira
He doesn’t skin people like Diangana or Pereira can with their trickery
He doesn’t have the long accurate passing forward balls like Sawyers
But he can run like a Duracell bunny and force a team into mistakes. Other than that, I honestly don’t see what he offers and we are far better with Robinson in the team in his place.
This gets boring FF! You're entitled to your view of Gallagher. You're going way over the top IMO with this "what does he bring?" nonsense. Spacegoating for the sake of it. But this thread is about how well the boys done, not how right you think you are about one of them. Have you spent lockdown having arguments in empty rooms?
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
04-13-2021, 09:30 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-13-2021, 09:31 PM by Dumbo.)
(04-13-2021, 09:10 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 08:56 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-13-2021, 08:22 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 03:03 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015). Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks
SJ 8 Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves. Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT
Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times. Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances
Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward. Had chances too. Needless pen – given cover was on.
Bartley - 8.5 unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago. Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off
OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home. Real bonus this season. Numerous interceptions and covering
Okay – 7.5 outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in
AMN – 8.5 comfortably his best game for us. Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs. Great pass inside for the penalty.
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish. Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored. Really should have had much more game time than he has.
Phillips – 8 easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness. Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times. Excellent back post run and finish.
Perreira – 7.5 great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.
Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd. Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).
Gallagher – 6.5 Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly. Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas
Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit. Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end.
HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Thank fuck for that.
Someone else who can see that;
He doesn’t tackle like Okay
He doesn’t have the passing through balls like Pereira
He doesn’t skin people like Diangana or Pereira can with their trickery
He doesn’t have the long accurate passing forward balls like Sawyers
But he can run like a Duracell bunny and force a team into mistakes. Other than that, I honestly don’t see what he offers and we are far better with Robinson in the team in his place.
You said that we’d be lucky to get our £8mill back on Periera.
If you think Sawyers offers more on the pitch than Gallagher, you’re clearly addicted to spice.
Re Pereira’s price. We had this discussion a couple of days ago. Go back and re-read what I wrote.
So rather than attacking my posts (yet again, yawn), tell me what Gallagher brings to the team? Cos it sure ain’t though passes, dribbling, long passes nor tackling, nor free kicks , nor corners, nor headers.
So what is it he brings? All I have read is “can’t you see?”. No, I can’t, hence why I’m asking, yet again, what others “see” that I can’t.
I told you yesterday what I think his qualities are...
Energy, bite, he can tackle, keep play ticking over, can pick a pass, has an engine on him, not afraid to have a shot....I could go on.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(04-13-2021, 09:30 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-13-2021, 09:10 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 08:56 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-13-2021, 08:22 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 03:03 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015). Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks
SJ 8 Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves. Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT
Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times. Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances
Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward. Had chances too. Needless pen – given cover was on.
Bartley - 8.5 unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago. Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off
OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home. Real bonus this season. Numerous interceptions and covering
Okay – 7.5 outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in
AMN – 8.5 comfortably his best game for us. Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs. Great pass inside for the penalty.
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish. Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored. Really should have had much more game time than he has.
Phillips – 8 easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness. Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times. Excellent back post run and finish.
Perreira – 7.5 great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.
Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd. Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).
Gallagher – 6.5 Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly. Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas
Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit. Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end.
HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Thank fuck for that.
Someone else who can see that;
He doesn’t tackle like Okay
He doesn’t have the passing through balls like Pereira
He doesn’t skin people like Diangana or Pereira can with their trickery
He doesn’t have the long accurate passing forward balls like Sawyers
But he can run like a Duracell bunny and force a team into mistakes. Other than that, I honestly don’t see what he offers and we are far better with Robinson in the team in his place.
You said that we’d be lucky to get our £8mill back on Periera.
If you think Sawyers offers more on the pitch than Gallagher, you’re clearly addicted to spice.
Re Pereira’s price. We had this discussion a couple of days ago. Go back and re-read what I wrote.
So rather than attacking my posts (yet again, yawn), tell me what Gallagher brings to the team? Cos it sure ain’t though passes, dribbling, long passes nor tackling, nor free kicks , nor corners, nor headers.
So what is it he brings? All I have read is “can’t you see?”. No, I can’t, hence why I’m asking, yet again, what others “see” that I can’t.
I told you yesterday what I think his qualities are...
Energy, bite, he can tackle, keep play ticking over, can pick a pass, has an engine on him, not afraid to have a shot....I could go on.
Energy and bite, yes. Tackle, nah. pass? Up to 10 yards, (engine is the same as energy, duplicated so struck off), a shot? How many on target, how many goals? .
Please, do go on, as I just don’t see it myself.
Posts: 1,372
Threads: 13
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(04-13-2021, 08:22 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 03:03 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015). Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks
SJ 8 Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves. Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT
Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times. Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances
Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward. Had chances too. Needless pen – given cover was on.
Bartley - 8.5 unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago. Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off
OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home. Real bonus this season. Numerous interceptions and covering
Okay – 7.5 outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in
AMN – 8.5 comfortably his best game for us. Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs. Great pass inside for the penalty.
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish. Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored. Really should have had much more game time than he has.
Phillips – 8 easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness. Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times. Excellent back post run and finish.
Perreira – 7.5 great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.
Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd. Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).
Gallagher – 6.5 Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly. Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas
Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit. Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end.
HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Thank fuck for that.
Someone else who can see that;
He doesn’t tackle like Okay
He doesn’t have the passing through balls like Pereira
He doesn’t skin people like Diangana or Pereira can with their trickery
He doesn’t have the long accurate passing forward balls like Sawyers
But he can run like a Duracell bunny and force a team into mistakes. Other than that, I honestly don’t see what he offers and we are far better with Robinson in the team in his place.
Strange that you keep comparing him to players in a completely different position. Why can’t Gallagher and Robinson both play in the same side? He’s certainly not the complete player yet but he has huge potential and I’m certain he will be a more than capable PL player
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(04-13-2021, 10:37 PM)wbamitch Wrote: (04-13-2021, 08:22 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (04-13-2021, 03:03 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015). Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks
SJ 8 Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves. Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT
Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times. Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances
Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward. Had chances too. Needless pen – given cover was on.
Bartley - 8.5 unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago. Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off
OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home. Real bonus this season. Numerous interceptions and covering
Okay – 7.5 outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in
AMN – 8.5 comfortably his best game for us. Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs. Great pass inside for the penalty.
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish. Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored. Really should have had much more game time than he has.
Phillips – 8 easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness. Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times. Excellent back post run and finish.
Perreira – 7.5 great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.
Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd. Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).
Gallagher – 6.5 Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly. Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas
Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit. Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end.
HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Thank fuck for that.
Someone else who can see that;
He doesn’t tackle like Okay
He doesn’t have the passing through balls like Pereira
He doesn’t skin people like Diangana or Pereira can with their trickery
He doesn’t have the long accurate passing forward balls like Sawyers
But he can run like a Duracell bunny and force a team into mistakes. Other than that, I honestly don’t see what he offers and we are far better with Robinson in the team in his place.
Strange that you keep comparing him to players in a completely different position. Why can’t Gallagher and Robinson both play in the same side? He’s certainly not the complete player yet but he has huge potential and I’m certain he will be a more than capable PL player
I have compared Gallagher with some of our other players to highlight what attributes he lacks.
We all see things differently, which is the beauty of the game.
If / when relegation is confirmed I hope we see less of the loan players and more playing time given to our players that will be here next season.
|