Last Night
#1
Great win for us last night against a full strength Saints that have beaten us so many times over the last few seasons (going back to 2015).  Got to give SA credit for the improved form (we were outstanding the first 30 mins) and now results – just as he deserved criticism for the dire performances and results in that first few week. Marks

SJ 8  Excellent stop to what was not a bad penalty and some decent saves.  Was also alert in coming for loose balls when Saints pressed before and after HT

Furlong 8 thought he showed great pace and recovery a number of times.  Really should of taken one of 2 decent chances

Townsend - 7.5 a revelation at this level and much improved going forward.  Had chances too.  Needless pen – given cover was on.

Bartley -  8.5  unrecognisable from the ponderous error strewn CH of 2 years ago.  Good in the air and nullified an excellent striker. Was immediately missed when he went off

OShea – 8 probably his best performance at home.  Real bonus this season.  Numerous interceptions and covering

Okay – 7.5  outstanding since signing, felt he was slightly below his usual high standards – especially in the middle part of the game when he was careless with the ball and couldn’t get a foot in

AMN – 8.5  comfortably his best game for us.  Energy, pressing and loads of well-timed forward runs.  Great pass inside for the penalty.
 
Robinson – 8 lively, a good outlet and plenty of end product with the penalty and a confident finish.  Was actually going to be subbed just before he scored.  Really should have had much more game time than he has.

Phillips – 8  easily worth a place now he has recovered his fitness.  Slightly more defensive/disciplined than the player from 4 seasons ago – he got in a few times.  Excellent back post run and finish.

Perreira – 7.5  great pen after the delay and such a good player – even without the ball. Given the reliance on him, needed him to keep and use it better in that 25 mins after the 2nd half.

Diagne – 8 incredibly unlucky with the latest VAR nonsense and a great assist for the 2nd.  Very decent link man (a hybrid of MAF/ Rondon IMO) – he just needs to take more chances (had to score in the first half).

Gallagher – 6.5  Plenty of effort but he weakened us slightly.  Not quite the player he was pre-Christmas

Semi – 6 - got all the tools but does makes a lot of mistakes that undermine the whole defensive unit.  Lost the Saints CH way too easily for the free header at the end. 

HAL – 6 – put himself about and looked to keep the ball in the late stages.
Reply
#2
Pretty spot on there mate.

Think I’d bump Periera up half a mark though and think you’re being slightly harsh on Gallagher but bang on for the rest.
Reply
#3
Not a lot to disagree with there Manc. Phillips was excellent both offensively and defensively last night. I had to leave to go and play football so missed injury time and the Townsend challenge but I thought the two full backs were exceptional all night and the defensive unit looks seriously good now. This looks like a side that would get between 40 - 50 points in a fantasy Prem season starting now.
Reply
#4
Can't disagree with any of that. Good marks.

Back-to-back wins now; what was even more positive is that it wasn't a weak side we faced either (nor one reduced down to 10 as per the previous week). Stopped them scoring and for the vast majority of the game we bossed it.

As said on another thread nearby, just disappointing this couldn't be the case earlier on in the season. No point debating all of this all over again though!
Reply
#5
Bang on the money there Manc.
Reply
#6
Would give Conor 6.5 because when it was 0-0 he lost their player completely  who decided to shoot from a narrow angle instead of setting up one of his better placed teammates. Then there was the pen.
He seemed a bit hyped up early on but regained his poise for most of the game.
Reply
#7
Decent summary Manc. Close call between Furlong and AMN as MOTM for me.
Reply
#8
Bang on with those marks, MancB. Agree, Bartley was missed as soon as he went off.
Reply
#9
It was quite a relief when AMN got up after chinnin the floor.

Many solid individual performances but more importantly we're playing like a team.

The marks are in line with my thinking.
Reply
#10
Philips has been very good for a while,seems to be enjoying himself too.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: