VAR again...
#21
To be fair, one of ours would have been sent off for what McTominay did.
Reply
#22
I watched it, and it is without question one of the strangest decisions of VAR involvement. Son didn't help by pretending he'd been shot in the face by a Magnum. Therefore for all intended purposes they disallowed a goal because Son accidentally got slapped in the face during the build up to the goal, and whether he was crying on the floor or not the goal probably would have been scored and counted. Utterly ridiculous tbh.
Reply
#23
FWIW worth I didn’t think it was accidental.
Reply
#24
(04-12-2021, 05:21 AM)Fido Wrote: FWIW worth I didn’t think it was accidental.

Apparently VAR thought it was accidental, hence no straight red or second yellow.
Reply
#25
Takes me back to the game against them at OT. Connor Gallagher was fouled before their "Penalty" which won them the game and VAR didn't even look at it such was the fervour over the ridiculous Furlong handball. As blatant a foul as you will ever see.

Now they have this goal ruled out for the most ridiculous thing I have ever seen.

Oh the irony........
Reply
#26
(04-12-2021, 07:18 AM)Peachy Wrote: Takes me back to the game against them at OT. Connor Gallagher was fouled before their "Penalty"  which won them the game and VAR didn't even look at it such was the fervour over the ridiculous Furlong handball. As blatant a foul as you will ever see.

Now they have this goal ruled out for the most ridiculous thing I have ever seen.

Oh the irony........
Which goes to show that the old adage these things even themselves out over the season still apply with var.
Although you could argue, yesterday's  mistake didn't cost Man U, whilst it did cost us.
Reply
#27
(04-12-2021, 08:00 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-12-2021, 07:18 AM)Peachy Wrote: Takes me back to the game against them at OT. Connor Gallagher was fouled before their "Penalty"  which won them the game and VAR didn't even look at it such was the fervour over the ridiculous Furlong handball. As blatant a foul as you will ever see.

Now they have this goal ruled out for the most ridiculous thing I have ever seen.

Oh the irony........
Which goes to show that the old adage these things even themselves out over the season still apply with var.
Although you could argue, yesterday's  mistake didn't cost Man U, whilst it did cost us.

It's impossible that this is true though when 1 point can be the difference between getting into Europe or not or staying up and going down.....as Villa found out last season the flukey fuggers
Reply
#28
(04-12-2021, 05:21 AM)Fido Wrote: FWIW worth I didn’t think it was accidental.

Just seen it.  Seemed  a deliberate flick out to me.  Wasn't "natural".  FWIW Onions etc.
Reply
#29
(04-10-2021, 04:57 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Was surprised in first half that var didn't  intervene to give city a penalty, when Stones was having his shirt clearly pulled. Have we given up on this offence again.

Var is such a mess, I feel on field refs are avoiding making decisions because they expect var to help them out and the var officials are struggling to decide what are clear and obvious errors and what are not.

Scrap offside and you don't need VAR.   

If the ref doesn't see something he doesn't see it.  Averages out.  

Handball should be handball - hand to ball.  Simples.
Reply
#30
So many bad decisions in a weekend that I don't think we've even mentioned the Newcastle one on this thread. Such a blatant penalty, he almost had his head taken off
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: