First Euro game I have seen in years
#11
Football’s appeal is continued action, spontaneity and speed. VAR is damaging those fundamental elements of the game and adding to the opportunity for corruption due to added layer of officials.

It’s role should only be to determine whether the ball crossed the line and nothing more. There will always be controversial mistakes but arguably they have increased rather than decreased since the introduction of VAR.

It won’t happen as it’s all part of the TV / media circus that surrounds the game
Reply
#12
(04-07-2021, 07:58 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 07:42 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 09:06 PM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote: If England can find a couple of CB's we will have a really exciting side.

Yep. I've said it for years BLV. If you have Pickford, Stones and Maguire in your starting line up you ain't winning a tournament. Ever. Never mind how many great players you have in front of them. They just make too many mistakes and over play unnecessarily. I've never seen the fascination in Pickford. His self confidence far far out ways his ability imo.

We are crying out for a couple of no nonsense centre half's.

Pickford is from the Joe Hart school of using bravado to mask lack of technical ability.

Said dozens of times on here that defending isn’t our strength and we shouldn’t be looking to play that way. Our strength is in our attacking options and we need a formation that allows us to get the best out then, for me that isn’t three centre halves, two holding midfielders and wing backs.
Correct. Good management is in finding a system to get the best out of the available players - not sticking to a system and trying to fit the players around it. Whatever setup we use, we'll have to leave out attacking players that would walk into most international teams. Southgate's job is to include as many of those players as possible without leaving us too open, but I fear he'll stick to his two holding midfielders, etc., regardless of the opposition.

As for Pickford, surely Gareth will see what virtually everyone else can see and leave him out in favour of Pope.
Reply
#13
(04-07-2021, 09:09 AM)74bus Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 07:58 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 07:42 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 09:06 PM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote: If England can find a couple of CB's we will have a really exciting side.

Yep. I've said it for years BLV. If you have Pickford, Stones and Maguire in your starting line up you ain't winning a tournament. Ever. Never mind how many great players you have in front of them. They just make too many mistakes and over play unnecessarily. I've never seen the fascination in Pickford. His self confidence far far out ways his ability imo.

We are crying out for a couple of no nonsense centre half's.

Pickford is from the Joe Hart school of using bravado to mask lack of technical ability.

Said dozens of times on here that defending isn’t our strength and we shouldn’t be looking to play that way. Our strength is in our attacking options and we need a formation that allows us to get the best out then, for me that isn’t three centre halves, two holding midfielders and wing backs.
Correct. Good management is in finding a system to get the best out of the available players - not sticking to a system and trying to fit the players around it. Whatever setup we use, we'll have to leave out attacking players that would walk into most international teams. Southgate's job is to include as many of those players as possible without leaving us too open, but I fear he'll stick to his two holding midfielders, etc., regardless of the opposition.

As for Pickford, surely Gareth will see what virtually everyone else can see and leave him out in favour of Pope.

Agree 100%

Seeing Pope in those recent England games and watching him for Burnley he reminds me of a young Hoult. He doesn't do anything flash or showy but he just does everything really well with a limited amount of fuss. 

The "experts" say he's not great with the ball at his feet but I couldn't really give a shit about that. In fact that's one thing that drives me nuts about modern football. This fucking passing out from the back nonsense. All I want from my keeper is to make saves, command his area and kick it straight when asked to.
Reply
#14
(04-07-2021, 08:44 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Surely they could have checked it on the basis that Ederson denied a clear and obvious goalscoring opportunity?

Interesting point. Still couldn't give the goal but if Bellingham had gone down is likely they would give a red card and free-kick via VAR.

Also worth noting Romania don't use VAR so the referee is used to refereeing 'as normal' domestically. Very different to how refs/linos are expected to let the phase of play complete with VAR.
Reply
#15
(04-07-2021, 08:21 AM)BaggieTom89 Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 10:39 PM)hudds Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 09:20 PM)BaggieTom89 Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 07:44 PM)hudds Wrote: tonight and what a bloody shambles in terms of reffing/VARshite.

Disregarding the previous nonsense, Bellingham obviously to any fule gets the ball cleanly from a pitiful attempt at a clearance by the City keeper and scores.  But no - the ref blows for a non-existent foul and books bellingham and VAR doesn't sniff it.

What an absolute pile of shite.

VAR couldn’t intervene as the ref blew his whistle (wrongly) before Bellingham put it in. I’m no fan of VAR but the issue tonight was a dreadful Ref not VAR.

Fine. Keep shit reffing throughout.  We always lived with that.  Keep reviews to goals crossing line or not.  What we have instead is something not fit for purpose and effefively totally arbitrary.

Last of these circus games I will bother watching.

I would scrap VAR too but I think when criticising it’s important to criticise what is a problem caused by it. Without VAR yesterday the ridiculous penalty by Can on Rodri would be given too so Man City would have gone 2-0 up when right decisions would be 1-1. VAR isn’t the answer but the standard of refereeing being so poor doesn’t help either.
It comes back to decisions being imperfect but that is the same with incidents  looked at a dozen times from loads of angles with VAR and the outcomes are inexplicable or inconsistent.  The match could be "reffed" entirely by VAR and there would still be what look to be clearly wrong calls.
Reply
#16
(04-07-2021, 12:04 PM)hudds Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 08:21 AM)BaggieTom89 Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 10:39 PM)hudds Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 09:20 PM)BaggieTom89 Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 07:44 PM)hudds Wrote: tonight and what a bloody shambles in terms of reffing/VARshite.

Disregarding the previous nonsense, Bellingham obviously to any fule gets the ball cleanly from a pitiful attempt at a clearance by the City keeper and scores.  But no - the ref blows for a non-existent foul and books bellingham and VAR doesn't sniff it.

What an absolute pile of shite.

VAR couldn’t intervene as the ref blew his whistle (wrongly) before Bellingham put it in. I’m no fan of VAR but the issue tonight was a dreadful Ref not VAR.

Fine. Keep shit reffing throughout.  We always lived with that.  Keep reviews to goals crossing line or not.  What we have instead is something not fit for purpose and effefively totally arbitrary.

Last of these circus games I will bother watching.

I would scrap VAR too but I think when criticising it’s important to criticise what is a problem caused by it. Without VAR yesterday the ridiculous penalty by Can on Rodri would be given too so Man City would have gone 2-0 up when right decisions would be 1-1. VAR isn’t the answer but the standard of refereeing being so poor doesn’t help either.
It comes back to decisions being imperfect but that is the same with incidents  looked at a dozen times from loads of angles with VAR and the outcomes are inexplicable or inconsistent.  The match could be "reffed" entirely by VAR and there would still be what look to be clearly wrong calls.

Agree. It was sold as addressing clear errors. Goal line technology, clear offsides (when the guy a yard or 2 off to naked eye) and diving for pens is all it should look at. if its not obvious straight away on field decision stands. You can't ref football in that granular detail and decisions such as penalties will always be subjective.

Human decision is easier to take than overanalysing and still having such huge inconsistencies.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: