Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
My Dad spent a bit of time in Calcutta (Kolkata) back in the 50s. My Mum was out there with him for a few weeks when she was expecting me. They got hold of a Bengali cook book (by Savitri Chowdary I think) and fed us curries in the Bengali style every week until my younger brother decided he didn't like it (he was about 15 at the time).
When me and Mrs Chesh were first a thing we watched Madhur Jaffrey's first series (1982?) and bought the book to widen my repertoire of turmeric/chilli/garam masala based delights. Nearly 40 years later, with many other Indian cookbooks on the shelf (plus the magic of the internet), we still regularly do dishes from both of the old books.
I've been mocked by colleagues for cooking Indian from first principles ("why don't you just get a takeaway like everyone else"), but I've rarely had a restaurant meal in the UK which matched what we do at home or gave us a new idea to try out. When I've been in India, I've enjoyed the lunches laid on at work - I remember the bitter disappointment on the day they sent out for Subway to give us a change. (Similar thing happened in Kuwait as it happens - some numpty decided we wanted KFC instead of those savoury pastries and pickled chillis. FFS!)
Posts: 3,775
Threads: 73
Joined: May 2020
(03-16-2021, 06:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My Dad spent a bit of time in Calcutta (Kolkata) back in the 50s. My Mum was out there with him for a few weeks when she was expecting me. They got hold of a Bengali cook book (by Savitri Chowdary I think) and fed us curries in the Bengali style every week until my younger brother decided he didn't like it (he was about 15 at the time).
When me and Mrs Chesh were first a thing we watched Madhur Jaffrey's first series (1982?) and bought the book to widen my repertoire of turmeric/chilli/garam masala based delights. Nearly 40 years later, with many other Indian cookbooks on the shelf (plus the magic of the internet), we still regularly do dishes from both of the old books.
I've been mocked by colleagues for cooking Indian from first principles ("why don't you just get a takeaway like everyone else"), but I've rarely had a restaurant meal in the UK which matched what we do at home or gave us a new idea to try out. When I've been in India, I've enjoyed the lunches laid on at work - I remember the bitter disappointment on the day they sent out for Subway to give us a change. (Similar thing happened in Kuwait as it happens - some numpty decided we wanted KFC instead of those savoury pastries and pickled chillis. FFS!)
Madhur Jeffrey is brilliant for authentic stuff.
Never quite got her opinion on using parsley as a substitute for coriander though... Yes she's said that!
Anyhow, anyone wanting a decent curry which sort of brings together BIR and authentic curry then Madhur's 'Chicken in a fried onion sauce' is a really good recipe.
Good recipe
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(03-16-2021, 09:53 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-16-2021, 06:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My Dad spent a bit of time in Calcutta (Kolkata) back in the 50s. My Mum was out there with him for a few weeks when she was expecting me. They got hold of a Bengali cook book (by Savitri Chowdary I think) and fed us curries in the Bengali style every week until my younger brother decided he didn't like it (he was about 15 at the time).
When me and Mrs Chesh were first a thing we watched Madhur Jaffrey's first series (1982?) and bought the book to widen my repertoire of turmeric/chilli/garam masala based delights. Nearly 40 years later, with many other Indian cookbooks on the shelf (plus the magic of the internet), we still regularly do dishes from both of the old books.
I've been mocked by colleagues for cooking Indian from first principles ("why don't you just get a takeaway like everyone else"), but I've rarely had a restaurant meal in the UK which matched what we do at home or gave us a new idea to try out. When I've been in India, I've enjoyed the lunches laid on at work - I remember the bitter disappointment on the day they sent out for Subway to give us a change. (Similar thing happened in Kuwait as it happens - some numpty decided we wanted KFC instead of those savoury pastries and pickled chillis. FFS!)
Madhur Jeffrey is brilliant for authentic stuff.
Never quite got her opinion on using parsley as a substitute for coriander though... Yes she's said that!
Anyhow, anyone wanting a decent curry which sort of brings together BIR and authentic curry then Madhur's 'Chicken in a fried onion sauce' is a really good recipe.
Good recipe
No whole spices. Sounds a bit naff to me tbh.
Posts: 3,775
Threads: 73
Joined: May 2020
(03-16-2021, 10:09 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-16-2021, 09:53 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-16-2021, 06:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My Dad spent a bit of time in Calcutta (Kolkata) back in the 50s. My Mum was out there with him for a few weeks when she was expecting me. They got hold of a Bengali cook book (by Savitri Chowdary I think) and fed us curries in the Bengali style every week until my younger brother decided he didn't like it (he was about 15 at the time).
When me and Mrs Chesh were first a thing we watched Madhur Jaffrey's first series (1982?) and bought the book to widen my repertoire of turmeric/chilli/garam masala based delights. Nearly 40 years later, with many other Indian cookbooks on the shelf (plus the magic of the internet), we still regularly do dishes from both of the old books.
I've been mocked by colleagues for cooking Indian from first principles ("why don't you just get a takeaway like everyone else"), but I've rarely had a restaurant meal in the UK which matched what we do at home or gave us a new idea to try out. When I've been in India, I've enjoyed the lunches laid on at work - I remember the bitter disappointment on the day they sent out for Subway to give us a change. (Similar thing happened in Kuwait as it happens - some numpty decided we wanted KFC instead of those savoury pastries and pickled chillis. FFS!)
Madhur Jeffrey is brilliant for authentic stuff.
Never quite got her opinion on using parsley as a substitute for coriander though... Yes she's said that!
Anyhow, anyone wanting a decent curry which sort of brings together BIR and authentic curry then Madhur's 'Chicken in a fried onion sauce' is a really good recipe.
Good recipe
No whole spices. Sounds a bit naff to me tbh.
Try it.
It's not about the spices and whether they're Whole or not. It's about, like many cuisines, about how you cook it. A really good mix powder fried in oil or 'roasted' will make a huge difference.
Any powder needs to be fried other than garam masala which is an aromatic and largely added in at the end.
Don't get hung up on whole spices.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
03-17-2021, 06:45 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-17-2021, 07:06 AM by Fulham Fallout.)
(03-16-2021, 10:15 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-16-2021, 10:09 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-16-2021, 09:53 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-16-2021, 06:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My Dad spent a bit of time in Calcutta (Kolkata) back in the 50s. My Mum was out there with him for a few weeks when she was expecting me. They got hold of a Bengali cook book (by Savitri Chowdary I think) and fed us curries in the Bengali style every week until my younger brother decided he didn't like it (he was about 15 at the time).
When me and Mrs Chesh were first a thing we watched Madhur Jaffrey's first series (1982?) and bought the book to widen my repertoire of turmeric/chilli/garam masala based delights. Nearly 40 years later, with many other Indian cookbooks on the shelf (plus the magic of the internet), we still regularly do dishes from both of the old books.
I've been mocked by colleagues for cooking Indian from first principles ("why don't you just get a takeaway like everyone else"), but I've rarely had a restaurant meal in the UK which matched what we do at home or gave us a new idea to try out. When I've been in India, I've enjoyed the lunches laid on at work - I remember the bitter disappointment on the day they sent out for Subway to give us a change. (Similar thing happened in Kuwait as it happens - some numpty decided we wanted KFC instead of those savoury pastries and pickled chillis. FFS!)
Madhur Jeffrey is brilliant for authentic stuff.
Never quite got her opinion on using parsley as a substitute for coriander though... Yes she's said that!
Anyhow, anyone wanting a decent curry which sort of brings together BIR and authentic curry then Madhur's 'Chicken in a fried onion sauce' is a really good recipe.
Good recipe
No whole spices. Sounds a bit naff to me tbh.
Try it.
It's not about the spices and whether they're Whole or not. It's about, like many cuisines, about how you cook it. A really good mix powder fried in oil or 'roasted' will make a huge difference.
Any powder needs to be fried other than garam masala which is an aromatic and largely added in at the end.
Don't get hung up on whole spices.
Cooking with whole spices means the taste varies from each mouthful depending on the mix of spices in each mouthful. Only using powders means each mouthful tastes exactly the same which is why Asians prefer home cooked food over restaurant food that use pastes and gravy. The Indian supermarkets aren’t full of whole spices for nothing!!!
That recipe is like a curry recipe for beginners and may as well have just stated “add curry powder”
Joking aside, when her books came out, the majority of non Asians were beginners at cooking Asian food. She took vesta curries to a new level
Posts: 3,775
Threads: 73
Joined: May 2020
(03-16-2021, 10:09 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-16-2021, 09:53 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-16-2021, 06:21 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My Dad spent a bit of time in Calcutta (Kolkata) back in the 50s. My Mum was out there with him for a few weeks when she was expecting me. They got hold of a Bengali cook book (by Savitri Chowdary I think) and fed us curries in the Bengali style every week until my younger brother decided he didn't like it (he was about 15 at the time).
When me and Mrs Chesh were first a thing we watched Madhur Jaffrey's first series (1982?) and bought the book to widen my repertoire of turmeric/chilli/garam masala based delights. Nearly 40 years later, with many other Indian cookbooks on the shelf (plus the magic of the internet), we still regularly do dishes from both of the old books.
I've been mocked by colleagues for cooking Indian from first principles ("why don't you just get a takeaway like everyone else"), but I've rarely had a restaurant meal in the UK which matched what we do at home or gave us a new idea to try out. When I've been in India, I've enjoyed the lunches laid on at work - I remember the bitter disappointment on the day they sent out for Subway to give us a change. (Similar thing happened in Kuwait as it happens - some numpty decided we wanted KFC instead of those savoury pastries and pickled chillis. FFS!)
Madhur Jeffrey is brilliant for authentic stuff.
Never quite got her opinion on using parsley as a substitute for coriander though... Yes she's said that!
Anyhow, anyone wanting a decent curry which sort of brings together BIR and authentic curry then Madhur's 'Chicken in a fried onion sauce' is a really good recipe.
Good recipe
No whole spices. Sounds a bit naff to me tbh.
Masalas or curry powders all begin life as 'whole spices'. You do know that don't you?
There's nothing wrong with making your own curry powders or masalas and using them in recipes. That's what your Balti house does. The mix of spice and how you cook them is the art.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
03-17-2021, 12:37 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-17-2021, 01:00 PM by Fulham Fallout.)
I’m struggling to see what you aren’t grasping that whole spices in a curry (along with ground spices) makes the world of difference.
If you have a fennel seed, cumin seed, clove, cardamom pod / seed etc in your mouth is totally different to having all the spices ground as you don’t get the same variations in taste. A curry made with pastes or just ground spices are flat in regards the taste. No variations in taste.
This is why Asians prefer home cooked food due to the whole spices in there also.
Cooking with ground spices alone is like an artist mixing all his coloured paints together into one and painting with the resultant colour.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(03-15-2021, 02:44 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Will look it up. I need more cookbooks, I find them better than random recipes you find online and I'm tired of browsing BBC Good Food for inspiration! The Hummingbird Bakery book is the best baking book I've found, the carrot cake is out of this world.
Having said that, I can highly recommend this website: https://pompomcooks.com/ by a British/Indian lady who lives out here in Chamonix. The Kerala Beef is one of the best curries I've ever made. She does popups out of her kitchen window sometimes which are always very well attended.
Ottolenghi, Cham?
Gennaro?
Posts: 3,775
Threads: 73
Joined: May 2020
(03-17-2021, 12:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m struggling to see what you aren’t grasping that whole spices in a curry (along with ground spices) makes the world of difference.
If you have a fennel seed, cumin seed, clove, cardamom pod / seed etc in your mouth is totally different to having all the spices ground as you don’t get the same variations in taste. A curry made with pastes or just ground spices are flat in regards the taste. No variations in taste.
This is why Asians prefer home cooked food due to the whole spices in there also.
That's bullshit.
And Asians like good tasting food like the rest of us regardless of ingredients or state of ingredients.
Adding the spices and pastes, regardless of whole or not, gives it layers of flavour. Eg adding garlic paste to the fry at the start and garlic at the end. Lime or lemon juice. A lot of restaurants use Worcestershire sauce because it adds depth. Authentic? No. Tasty? Yes.
A quick curry with a home made paste can be delicious.
Stick to your barbeque paella!
You were quite condescending to a recipe that uses just 'powders' whilst in the past you have processed your love of Balti and BIR food which 99% of uses powders. As I said, the skill is in the cooking as raw spice, powdered or whole, is not pleasant.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(03-17-2021, 01:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 12:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m struggling to see what you aren’t grasping that whole spices in a curry (along with ground spices) makes the world of difference.
If you have a fennel seed, cumin seed, clove, cardamom pod / seed etc in your mouth is totally different to having all the spices ground as you don’t get the same variations in taste. A curry made with pastes or just ground spices are flat in regards the taste. No variations in taste.
This is why Asians prefer home cooked food due to the whole spices in there also.
That's bullshit.
And Asians like good tasting food like the rest of us regardless of ingredients or state of ingredients.
Adding the spices and pastes, regardless of whole or not, gives it layers of flavour. Eg adding garlic paste to the fry at the start and garlic at the end. Lime or lemon juice. A lot of restaurants use Worcestershire sauce because it adds depth. Authentic? No. Tasty? Yes.
A quick curry with a home made paste can be delicious.
Stick to your barbeque paella! 
You were quite condescending to a recipe that uses just 'powders' whilst in the past you have processed your love of Balti and BIR food which 99% of uses powders. As I said, the skill is in the cooking as raw spice, powdered or whole, is not pleasant.
Ask Asians why they prefer home cooked food to restaurant food. I think you need to start using whole spices Nick and discover how wonderful Asian food can be.
|