Posts: 1,960
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
The views on Wilder sum up the modern football supporter. Less than a year ago, he was being touted as manager of the year for the season Sheff Utd had. They completely over achieved. When you add in where he took them from on taking over, it had been a heck of a job he'd done. You can go back further and see further evidence of him being a good manager with promotions at Northampton and Oxford. So 12 years of mainly success and good reputation.
This year has seen the wheels come off and they are having the season most expected last season given the average nature of their squad.
1 bad season in 12 and he's now seen as a failure and many are saying shouldn't be anywhere near our job.
There seems to be little balance in views these days. You are either brilliant or shit depending on most recent events. Moyes is a great example of this. Wasn't long ago Albion fans were against links with us.
Players are the same. In form, they are superb, out of form the same player is called shit.
Has this always been the way or is it a modern phenomena caused by social media?
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(03-13-2021, 08:37 PM)richbaggie Wrote: The views on Wilder sum up the modern football supporter. Less than a year ago, he was being touted as manager of the year for the season Sheff Utd had. They completely over achieved. When you add in where he took them from on taking over, it had been a heck of a job he'd done. You can go back further and see further evidence of him being a good manager with promotions at Northampton and Oxford. So 12 years of mainly success and good reputation.
This year has seen the wheels come off and they are having the season most expected last season given the average nature of their squad.
1 bad season in 12 and he's now seen as a failure and many are saying shouldn't be anywhere near our job.
There seems to be little balance in views these days. You are either brilliant or shit depending on most recent events. Moyes is a great example of this. Wasn't long ago Albion fans were against links with us.
Players are the same. In form, they are superb, out of form the same player is called shit.
Has this always been the way or is it a modern phenomena caused by social media?
It's always been there but social media has magnified it.
If it is Wilder, I'd be very happy, as I would with Appleton. They are my 2 choices.
Posts: 1,139
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(03-13-2021, 08:37 PM)richbaggie Wrote: The views on Wilder sum up the modern football supporter. Less than a year ago, he was being touted as manager of the year for the season Sheff Utd had. They completely over achieved. When you add in where he took them from on taking over, it had been a heck of a job he'd done. You can go back further and see further evidence of him being a good manager with promotions at Northampton and Oxford. So 12 years of mainly success and good reputation.
This year has seen the wheels come off and they are having the season most expected last season given the average nature of their squad.
1 bad season in 12 and he's now seen as a failure and many are saying shouldn't be anywhere near our job.
There seems to be little balance in views these days. You are either brilliant or shit depending on most recent events. Moyes is a great example of this. Wasn't long ago Albion fans were against links with us.
Players are the same. In form, they are superb, out of form the same player is called shit.
Has this always been the way or is it a modern phenomena caused by social media? Absolutely spot on. I have a Sheff U mate and he was desperate for him to stay.
FWIW I’d be very happy with Wilder but equally so with BFS or Appy. The midfield and front line needs a massive overhaul and this is the key to next season.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(03-13-2021, 08:37 PM)richbaggie Wrote: The views on Wilder sum up the modern football supporter. Less than a year ago, he was being touted as manager of the year for the season Sheff Utd had. They completely over achieved. When you add in where he took them from on taking over, it had been a heck of a job he'd done. You can go back further and see further evidence of him being a good manager with promotions at Northampton and Oxford. So 12 years of mainly success and good reputation.
This year has seen the wheels come off and they are having the season most expected last season given the average nature of their squad.
1 bad season in 12 and he's now seen as a failure and many are saying shouldn't be anywhere near our job.
There seems to be little balance in views these days. You are either brilliant or shit depending on most recent events. Moyes is a great example of this. Wasn't long ago Albion fans were against links with us.
Players are the same. In form, they are superb, out of form the same player is called shit.
Has this always been the way or is it a modern phenomena caused by social media?
It's ridiculous, but this is all true.
I also think it's worth pointing out that this season is truly unique due to the lack of fans. Some teams and managers have adapted while others clearly haven't. I genuinely think with fans in the ground the table at the bottom would be much tighter.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(03-13-2021, 09:14 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-13-2021, 08:37 PM)richbaggie Wrote: The views on Wilder sum up the modern football supporter. Less than a year ago, he was being touted as manager of the year for the season Sheff Utd had. They completely over achieved. When you add in where he took them from on taking over, it had been a heck of a job he'd done. You can go back further and see further evidence of him being a good manager with promotions at Northampton and Oxford. So 12 years of mainly success and good reputation.
This year has seen the wheels come off and they are having the season most expected last season given the average nature of their squad.
1 bad season in 12 and he's now seen as a failure and many are saying shouldn't be anywhere near our job.
There seems to be little balance in views these days. You are either brilliant or shit depending on most recent events. Moyes is a great example of this. Wasn't long ago Albion fans were against links with us.
Players are the same. In form, they are superb, out of form the same player is called shit.
Has this always been the way or is it a modern phenomena caused by social media?
It's ridiculous, but this is all true.
I also think it's worth pointing out that this season is truly unique due to the lack of fans. Some teams and managers have adapted while others clearly haven't. I genuinely think with fans in the ground the table at the bottom would be much tighter.
True. While there are other issues, we've not been the same team without fans.
Posts: 1,815
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(03-13-2021, 07:36 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (03-13-2021, 07:21 PM)Cuzer Wrote: 2 weeks ago people on here wanking themselves into a fury saying he's the man next season even if we go down, hang your fucking heads
Barely left the dugout today, for me he downed tools weeks ago, he's half hearted in what he does, the subs have been shambolic when we're in "must win" territory
He's had a go, maybe but it's failed miserably all eyes on next season and him nowhere near my club!
Cuzer
Correct, Sam only still here on the off chance Diagne hits a run of form and we pull off survival in spite of him and he gets his big fat bonus.
I expect Allardyce to go on a PR offensive in the coming weeks conveniently overlooking he’s as much responsible for our relegation as Slav.
12 points from 16 games and an exit to Blackpool in the cup is hardly any better than the shambles that was Bilic, and that’s with his own players now.
I didn’t want Sam and was willing to give him a chance.
The issue here is if Sam had had the budget Bilic had I’d bet we’d be in a far better position that we are in now.
Bilic did get us promoted for which financially we all agree was a godsend but he left us with an unbalanced squad.
Whilst the safe is now empty, our transfer business over the last few years has been in the main pretty woeful.
Whilst comparatively speaking we will be financially better off than most in the Championship next season our squad will revert to being small and unbalanced.
Whilst we may well need a new manager we may also need a magician. This really is shaping up to be 85/86 all over again. All we need to do now is sell Johnstone and Pereira to Wolves!
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
03-13-2021, 09:36 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-13-2021, 09:49 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
Modern football phenomenon? I’m really not knee jerk when it comes to football. Just because I don’t particularly want Wilder as manager doesn’t mean I think he’s a failure it’s simply a personal preference.
My reasoning is this... he’s had five years solid management at one club, he’s built the squad in his own image and had owners who have backed him financially this season far more so than ourselves. According to many media accounts he wasn’t happy, and wanted more money in Jan but it wasn’t forth coming. We don’t have the time to build anything at least in the Championship given the finite resources and the owners wish to sell the club. So I’m looking for an short term fix because the club has no long term plan. Does Wilder fit a short term fix of a couple of seasons and then a potential sale of the club? Not in my opinion it’s an awkward fit.
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(03-13-2021, 09:29 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (03-13-2021, 07:36 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (03-13-2021, 07:21 PM)Cuzer Wrote: 2 weeks ago people on here wanking themselves into a fury saying he's the man next season even if we go down, hang your fucking heads
Barely left the dugout today, for me he downed tools weeks ago, he's half hearted in what he does, the subs have been shambolic when we're in "must win" territory
He's had a go, maybe but it's failed miserably all eyes on next season and him nowhere near my club!
Cuzer
Correct, Sam only still here on the off chance Diagne hits a run of form and we pull off survival in spite of him and he gets his big fat bonus.
I expect Allardyce to go on a PR offensive in the coming weeks conveniently overlooking he’s as much responsible for our relegation as Slav.
12 points from 16 games and an exit to Blackpool in the cup is hardly any better than the shambles that was Bilic, and that’s with his own players now.
I didn’t want Sam and was willing to give him a chance.
The issue here is if Sam had had the budget Bilic had I’d bet we’d be in a far better position that we are in now.
Bilic did get us promoted for which financially we all agree was a godsend but he left us with an unbalanced squad.
Whilst the safe is now empty, our transfer business over the last few years has been in the main pretty woeful.
Whilst comparatively speaking we will be financially better off than most in the Championship next season our squad will revert to being small and unbalanced.
Whilst we may well need a new manager we may also need a magician. This really is shaping up to be 85/86 all over again. All we need to do now is sell Johnstone and Pereira to Wolves!
Absolutely no evidence to support this.
Sam was backed in January and has won one match since.
Posts: 1,960
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(03-13-2021, 09:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Modern football phenomenon? I’m really not knee jerk when it comes to football. Just because I don’t particularly want Wilder as manager doesn’t mean I think he’s a failure it’s simply a personal preference.
My reasoning is this... he’s had five years solid management at one club, he’s built the squad in his own image and had owners who have backed him financially this season far more so than ourselves. According to many media accounts he wasn’t happy, and wanted more money in Jan but it wasn’t forth coming. We don’t have the time to build anything at least in the Championship given the finite resources and the owners wish to sell the club. So I’m looking for an short term fix because the club has no long term plan. Does Wilder fit a short term fix of a couple of seasons and then a potential sale of the club? Not in my opinion it’s an awkward fit. Five years solid management? He took them from division one to challenging for Europe, I'd say that was rather more than solid. That's highly impressive.
There are question marks for me around his transfer dealings and I also wonder about his motivation after leaving the club he cherishes. However, I wouldn't be against it because he clearly knows how to get teams promoted without a great deal of money to spend.
You say you want a short term fix, but who would you suggest? And not Sam, I think even his backers today looked at him and realised his heart just isn't in it.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(03-13-2021, 08:37 PM)richbaggie Wrote: The views on Wilder sum up the modern football supporter. Less than a year ago, he was being touted as manager of the year for the season Sheff Utd had. They completely over achieved. When you add in where he took them from on taking over, it had been a heck of a job he'd done. You can go back further and see further evidence of him being a good manager with promotions at Northampton and Oxford. So 12 years of mainly success and good reputation.
This year has seen the wheels come off and they are having the season most expected last season given the average nature of their squad.
1 bad season in 12 and he's now seen as a failure and many are saying shouldn't be anywhere near our job.
There seems to be little balance in views these days. You are either brilliant or shit depending on most recent events. Moyes is a great example of this. Wasn't long ago Albion fans were against links with us.
Players are the same. In form, they are superb, out of form the same player is called shit.
Has this always been the way or is it a modern phenomena caused by social media? What an excellent post Rich. As ever you nail it.
|