Craig Dawson
#11
(03-09-2021, 07:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: When you think of what he cost us and what he delivered on the pitch, the fact anybody has a reason to moan at him is beyond me

Especially when "Our Tone"played him out of position at right back for the bulk of his time here

Top player who only want to play at the highest level he can after coming through the lower leagues, fair play to him

Cuzer

This.
Reply
#12
(03-09-2021, 07:54 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-09-2021, 07:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: When you think of what he cost us and what he delivered on the pitch, the fact anybody has a reason to moan at him is beyond me

Especially when "Our Tone"played him out of position at right back for the bulk of his time here

Top player who only want to play at the highest level he can after coming through the lower leagues, fair play to him

Cuzer

This.

I can't fault Dawson as a footballer, but the contrast between how he and J-Rod conducted themselves when we were relegated is very noticeable and people are right to comment about it.

Both players have popped up in recent articles on The Athletic and it's fair to say that both are very different characters.
Reply
#13
(03-09-2021, 07:13 PM)Duffers Wrote: What did we have in the Championship? Someone barely arsed a lot of the time.

He’s thriving now because he’s playing under a manager who plays to his strengths. He would thrive under Allardyce too. We saw under Moore and again at Watford what happens when he’s taken out of his comfort zone.

Good player who gave us 5 years of great value. Especially in a defensive team

The downside was the last 18 months. He was one of those who decided to down tools under Pulis and Pardew. He was then well below his usual standards in the Champo. Getting ripped a new one by Lawrence and Assombolonga had nothing to do with Jones telling him to pass the ball
Reply
#14
(03-09-2021, 08:39 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(03-09-2021, 07:13 PM)Duffers Wrote: What did we have in the Championship? Someone barely arsed a lot of the time.

He’s thriving now because he’s playing under a manager who plays to his strengths. He would thrive under Allardyce too. We saw under Moore and again at Watford what happens when he’s taken out of his comfort zone.

Good player who gave us 5 years of great value. Especially in a defensive team

The downside was the last 18 months. He was one of those who decided to down tools under Pulis and Pardew. He was then well below his usual standards in the Champo. Getting ripped a new one by Lawrence and Assombolonga had nothing to do with Jones telling him to pass the ball

Moore and Jones asked our central defence to play in a way that was clearly not suited to them. It was incredibly stupid and cost us points all season
Reply
#15
(03-09-2021, 08:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-09-2021, 08:39 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(03-09-2021, 07:13 PM)Duffers Wrote: What did we have in the Championship? Someone barely arsed a lot of the time.

He’s thriving now because he’s playing under a manager who plays to his strengths. He would thrive under Allardyce too. We saw under Moore and again at Watford what happens when he’s taken out of his comfort zone.

Good player who gave us 5 years of great value. Especially in a defensive team

The downside was the last 18 months. He was one of those who decided to down tools under Pulis and Pardew. He was then well below his usual standards in the Champo. Getting ripped a new one by Lawrence and Assombolonga had nothing to do with Jones telling him to pass the ball

Moore and Jones Laurel & Hardy asked our central defence to play in a way that was clearly not suited to them. It was incredibly stupid and cost us points all season
Reply
#16
(03-09-2021, 07:48 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Duffers Wrote:
Big Daddy Cool Wrote:Dawson was a great center half who was played out of position by Pulis and asked to play like a Man City defender under Moore/Jones.

I'll never forget his goal against Villa in the play offs.

Disagree, his best performances in an Albion shirt came at RB under Pulis.
I thought so too. Not a great centre half at all.

Yeah, he's rubbish at centre back, which is why West Ham have done so badly since he got into their side. Why do you people have so much difficulty separating personality and talent? Pulis missed a trick by not pairing him with Evans or Hegazi in the first half of our relegation season. He didn't want to play in the Championship. Current form maybe suggests that he doesn't need to play there at the moment. I'm disappointed that it didn't work out for us with him. He's a rare example of a player who moved on to better things. No point being churlish about it. I don't think he lacked effort or application during his last two seasons with us, at least no more so than anyone else. And his best performances for us were alongside Hegazi at the beginning and end of the relegation season. I'm tired of reading this "He's just a Pulis full back" shit.
Reply
#17
(03-09-2021, 10:31 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-09-2021, 07:48 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Duffers Wrote:
Big Daddy Cool Wrote:Dawson was a great center half who was played out of position by Pulis and asked to play like a Man City defender under Moore/Jones.

I'll never forget his goal against Villa in the play offs.

Disagree, his best performances in an Albion shirt came at RB under Pulis.
I thought so too. Not a great centre half at all.

Yeah, he's rubbish at centre back, which is why West Ham have done so badly since he got into their side. Why do you people have so much difficulty separating personality and talent? Pulis missed a trick by not pairing him with Evans or Hegazi in the first half of our relegation season. He didn't want to play in the Championship. Current form maybe suggests that he doesn't need to play there at the moment. I'm disappointed that it didn't work out for us with him. He's a rare example of a player who moved on to better things. No point being churlish about it. I don't think he lacked effort or application during his last two seasons with us, at least no more so than anyone else. And his best performances for us were alongside Hegazi at the beginning and end of the relegation season. I'm tired of reading this "He's just a Pulis full back" shit.

Your bizarre hard-on for him Chesh was an amusing facet of the Pulis years, regular claims that he should be playing for England...

Said it before and I’ll say it again, Dawson does well in pragmatic teams under pragmatic managers, where he has little to do other than tackle, head and clear. He did well under Pulis that way, and yes he always looked better at RB than CB. It shouldn’t be any surprise that he’s doing well again under a similarly pragmatic manager and system.

The problems came when he was asked to actually play football.

PS... in terms of “better things” he left us to join a Watford side who were subsequently relegated.
Reply
#18
Dawson is a good right back that's finally having a decent season at CB
Reply
#19
(03-09-2021, 10:31 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-09-2021, 07:48 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Duffers Wrote:
Big Daddy Cool Wrote:Dawson was a great center half who was played out of position by Pulis and asked to play like a Man City defender under Moore/Jones.

I'll never forget his goal against Villa in the play offs.

Disagree, his best performances in an Albion shirt came at RB under Pulis.
I thought so too. Not a great centre half at all.

Yeah, he's rubbish at centre back, which is why West Ham have done so badly since he got into their side. Why do you people have so much difficulty separating personality and talent? Pulis missed a trick by not pairing him with Evans or Hegazi in the first half of our relegation season. He didn't want to play in the Championship. Current form maybe suggests that he doesn't need to play there at the moment. I'm disappointed that it didn't work out for us with him. He's a rare example of a player who moved on to better things. No point being churlish about it. I don't think he lacked effort or application during his last two seasons with us, at least no more so than anyone else. And his best performances for us were alongside Hegazi at the beginning and end of the relegation season. I'm tired of reading this "He's just a Pulis full back" shit.

Not at all. He just isn't that good.
Reply
#20
As always in this the truth is somewhere in the middle. Just because he’s doing well for West Ham doesn’t mean his time with us needs to be reappraised. We didn’t let the second coming of Franco Baresi slip through our fingers. It’s possible to hold the view that he’s doing well for West Ham, did well for us for a while then went off the boil.

As plenty have said we got great value out of him consider what we paid. Ultimately he’s an average PL defender who’s having a good season. With us he was good up until the end of the Pulis era, then it went wrong afterwards. His time at Watford was a disaster too.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)