Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-08-2021, 08:36 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (03-07-2021, 06:10 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He almost blew that crucial promotion despite having what was normally an unassailable lead, should have been dismissed for that to be honest. Can't say I enjoyed the football he served up much in 2020, a few halves of games here and there, but I preferred some Pulis games to it, because at least he got wins!
We weren't improving, fitness levels were getting worse, Gallagher, a player known for his stamina and fitness was starting to look as lethargic as the rest of them. I'm not going to deny that we almost blew promotion. I lived through it!
And the fitness levels criticism seems to have some truth in it, though, like all hindsight judgements, it's exaggerated on here. The championship is a tough league etc. And we did get out of it.
You can't seriously claim that Bilic should have been sacked at the end of a promotion season?!
And you're clearly remembering a different Pulis from me... I'm still scarred from watching that anti football.
I would have kept Bilic, for many good reasons above. But especially the long term thinking. Which we've not done since St Dan left.
I'd keep BFS...IF he really wants it. Which I doubt.
Pulis' only crime was not being offered a parting of ways the summer 18 months before we had to sack him. He did a great job and laid the foundations for what should have been our chance to push on.
Bilic, aside from the first four months and a week in February was atroicious. Not one player improved under him, none of the deficiencies that were there when he took over, had been solved by the time he was sacked and the majority of his transfer targets were shockers. We would have had every right to sack him after that Huddersfield game, we had 52 points at Christmas and only just scraped over the line.
Posts: 1,365
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
Yep I think we have improved. In fact I'd go as far as to say this current side, with Allardyce in charge, from the start of the season - would likely stop up. I know the players we brought in in Jan probably weren't available in the close season anyway but our summer transfer business was truly atrocious. Ivanovic for Hegazi, Krov brought in for what seemed like sentimental reasons and money squandered on Karlan Grant and, to a lesser degree, Robinson. We then played the first half of the first half of the season with the most ineffective central midfield pairing in our post 2002 top flight history - Livermore & Sawyers.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
03-08-2021, 09:09 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-08-2021, 09:14 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(03-08-2021, 08:52 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Yep I think we have improved. In fact I'd go as far as to say this current side, with Allardyce in charge, from the start of the season - would likely stop up. I know the players we brought in in Jan probably weren't available in the close season anyway but our summer transfer business was truly atrocious. Ivanovic for Hegazi, Krov brought in for what seemed like sentimental reasons and money squandered on Karlan Grant and, to a lesser degree, Robinson. We then played the first half of the first half of the season with the most ineffective central midfield pairing in our post 2002 top flight history - Livermore & Sawyers.
Hegazi was sold under Slav's nose, Robinson was a freebie as nobody was going to give us money for Burke. The real errors were in thinking Grant could play as a lone frontman, despite all the confirmation to the contrary by HT fans, and thinking that a midfield combination of JL, RS, Krov and Gallagher could be effective in the PL. We all knew it, even if we were hoping for some sort of footballing miracle to come to fruition where we found Sawyers and Krov were more suited to this level. It seemed fanciful at the time bit ludicrous now. The kind of poor judgement that does, and has, cost managers their job.
Purely by addressing this BS HAS improved us and hopefully provided a recruitment template for future attempts at PL survival under this owner. We at least look like a PL team now.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(03-08-2021, 09:09 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (03-08-2021, 08:52 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Yep I think we have improved. In fact I'd go as far as to say this current side, with Allardyce in charge, from the start of the season - would likely stop up. I know the players we brought in in Jan probably weren't available in the close season anyway but our summer transfer business was truly atrocious. Ivanovic for Hegazi, Krov brought in for what seemed like sentimental reasons and money squandered on Karlan Grant and, to a lesser degree, Robinson. We then played the first half of the first half of the season with the most ineffective central midfield pairing in our post 2002 top flight history - Livermore & Sawyers.
Hegazi was sold under Slav's nose, Robinson was a freebie as nobody was going to give us money for Burke. The real errors were in thinking Grant could play as a lone frontman, despite all the confirmation to the contrary by HT fans, and thinking that a midfield combination of JL, RS, Krov and Gallagher could be effective in the PL. We all knew it, even if we were hoping for some sort of footballing miracle to come to fruition where we found Sawyers and Krov were more suited to this level. It seemed fanciful at the time bit ludicrous now. The kind of poor judgement that does, and has, cost managers their job.
Purely by addressing this BS HAS improved us and hopefully provided a recruitment template for future attempts at PL survival under this owner. We at least look like a PL team now.
It's been said on here many times by reasonably ITK sorts, that Slav was happy for either Hegazi or Bartley to be sold to raise funds. For him to do the dying swan act and claim it was some great betrayal is entirely self-serving.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
Krovinovic was our "top target". I remember saying at the time that as much as I liked him, he was a bit part player in the Championship. Anyone trying to absolve Slav of blame for the summer transfer window is clutching at non-existent straws
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(03-08-2021, 09:09 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (03-08-2021, 08:52 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Yep I think we have improved. In fact I'd go as far as to say this current side, with Allardyce in charge, from the start of the season - would likely stop up. I know the players we brought in in Jan probably weren't available in the close season anyway but our summer transfer business was truly atrocious. Ivanovic for Hegazi, Krov brought in for what seemed like sentimental reasons and money squandered on Karlan Grant and, to a lesser degree, Robinson. We then played the first half of the first half of the season with the most ineffective central midfield pairing in our post 2002 top flight history - Livermore & Sawyers.
Hegazi was sold under Slav's nose, Robinson was a freebie as nobody was going to give us money for Burke. The real errors were in thinking Grant could play as a lone frontman, despite all the confirmation to the contrary by HT fans, and thinking that a midfield combination of JL, RS, Krov and Gallagher could be effective in the PL. We all knew it, even if we were hoping for some sort of footballing miracle to come to fruition where we found Sawyers and Krov were more suited to this level. It seemed fanciful at the time bit ludicrous now. The kind of poor judgement that does, and has, cost managers their job.
Purely by addressing this BS HAS improved us and hopefully provided a recruitment template for future attempts at PL survival under this owner. We at least look like a PL team now.
I conversed with a Toon-supporting pal yesterday about the game and he said if you'd just turned this and watched for 90 mins you'd have put money on it being a Championship game, not PL. Found it hard to disagree.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-08-2021, 10:32 AM)Fido Wrote: (03-08-2021, 09:09 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (03-08-2021, 08:52 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Yep I think we have improved. In fact I'd go as far as to say this current side, with Allardyce in charge, from the start of the season - would likely stop up. I know the players we brought in in Jan probably weren't available in the close season anyway but our summer transfer business was truly atrocious. Ivanovic for Hegazi, Krov brought in for what seemed like sentimental reasons and money squandered on Karlan Grant and, to a lesser degree, Robinson. We then played the first half of the first half of the season with the most ineffective central midfield pairing in our post 2002 top flight history - Livermore & Sawyers.
Hegazi was sold under Slav's nose, Robinson was a freebie as nobody was going to give us money for Burke. The real errors were in thinking Grant could play as a lone frontman, despite all the confirmation to the contrary by HT fans, and thinking that a midfield combination of JL, RS, Krov and Gallagher could be effective in the PL. We all knew it, even if we were hoping for some sort of footballing miracle to come to fruition where we found Sawyers and Krov were more suited to this level. It seemed fanciful at the time bit ludicrous now. The kind of poor judgement that does, and has, cost managers their job.
Purely by addressing this BS HAS improved us and hopefully provided a recruitment template for future attempts at PL survival under this owner. We at least look like a PL team now.
I conversed with a Toon-supporting pal yesterday about the game and he said if you'd just turned this and watched for 90 mins you'd have put money on it being a Championship game, not PL. Found it hard to disagree.
...and if you put either Newcastle or ourselves with our current squads in the Championship we would be the promotion places. That's the gap between the two divisions now and we simply failed to bridge it. I don't particularly blame Bilic, Dowling, or the owner I blame the obscene economics of the Premier League distorting the competition.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
I watched Brentford v Norwich the other day. Arguably the two best teams in the league and it was clear they both would get spanked in the Prem
Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(03-08-2021, 10:32 AM)Fido Wrote: (03-08-2021, 09:09 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (03-08-2021, 08:52 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Yep I think we have improved. In fact I'd go as far as to say this current side, with Allardyce in charge, from the start of the season - would likely stop up. I know the players we brought in in Jan probably weren't available in the close season anyway but our summer transfer business was truly atrocious. Ivanovic for Hegazi, Krov brought in for what seemed like sentimental reasons and money squandered on Karlan Grant and, to a lesser degree, Robinson. We then played the first half of the first half of the season with the most ineffective central midfield pairing in our post 2002 top flight history - Livermore & Sawyers.
Hegazi was sold under Slav's nose, Robinson was a freebie as nobody was going to give us money for Burke. The real errors were in thinking Grant could play as a lone frontman, despite all the confirmation to the contrary by HT fans, and thinking that a midfield combination of JL, RS, Krov and Gallagher could be effective in the PL. We all knew it, even if we were hoping for some sort of footballing miracle to come to fruition where we found Sawyers and Krov were more suited to this level. It seemed fanciful at the time bit ludicrous now. The kind of poor judgement that does, and has, cost managers their job.
Purely by addressing this BS HAS improved us and hopefully provided a recruitment template for future attempts at PL survival under this owner. We at least look like a PL team now.
I conversed with a Toon-supporting pal yesterday about the game and he said if you'd just turned this and watched for 90 mins you'd have put money on it being a Championship game, not PL. Found it hard to disagree.
You could say that about a load of Prem games, Fiders.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
03-08-2021, 11:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-08-2021, 11:45 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(03-08-2021, 10:32 AM)Fido Wrote: (03-08-2021, 09:09 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (03-08-2021, 08:52 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Yep I think we have improved. In fact I'd go as far as to say this current side, with Allardyce in charge, from the start of the season - would likely stop up. I know the players we brought in in Jan probably weren't available in the close season anyway but our summer transfer business was truly atrocious. Ivanovic for Hegazi, Krov brought in for what seemed like sentimental reasons and money squandered on Karlan Grant and, to a lesser degree, Robinson. We then played the first half of the first half of the season with the most ineffective central midfield pairing in our post 2002 top flight history - Livermore & Sawyers.
Hegazi was sold under Slav's nose, Robinson was a freebie as nobody was going to give us money for Burke. The real errors were in thinking Grant could play as a lone frontman, despite all the confirmation to the contrary by HT fans, and thinking that a midfield combination of JL, RS, Krov and Gallagher could be effective in the PL. We all knew it, even if we were hoping for some sort of footballing miracle to come to fruition where we found Sawyers and Krov were more suited to this level. It seemed fanciful at the time bit ludicrous now. The kind of poor judgement that does, and has, cost managers their job.
Purely by addressing this BS HAS improved us and hopefully provided a recruitment template for future attempts at PL survival under this owner. We at least look like a PL team now.
I conversed with a Toon-supporting pal yesterday about the game and he said if you'd just turned this and watched for 90 mins you'd have put money on it being a Championship game, not PL. Found it hard to disagree.
We look like a PL team in that the opposition aren't just steamrollering us, we are physically competitive and technically proficient enough to be in the game for the full 90. Just been missing that bit of quality to take points.
In my experience there is a lot of football played in this division that does not reflect what the likes of Man City and good Liverpool might produce. A lot of average games are settled by a few moments of that quality.
And yep, no doubt in my mind that this squad would be top two in the Champ. A player like OK would dominate midfield and allow more attacking options. Shame he won't be here next season.
|