Is Robinson better than HRK?
#1
It made sense to be bringing him on v the other albion as the ball sticks to him and he knows the offside rule better than Diange.

But last night, I thought Robinson was a better option? 

Maybe Im missing something here, is having two conors and a callum too much for Sammy Lee? This would expalin why Kamil has been bombed out.  Big Grin
Reply
#2
HRK holds the ball up, which us what Sam wants from that forward role. Last night though I'd have thought Robinson personally, but don't think he's impressed Sam in the time he's been here.
Reply
#3
Robinson has been unfairly underused this past month. It’s my only criticism of Sam recently.

Robinson was brilliant in our win at Wolves and always creates a chance or two.

The worrying thing is Sam alienating these players (Grant, Grady, Robinson), that will probably be needed to be called upon for next season.
Reply
#4
(03-05-2021, 01:33 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Robinson has been unfairly underused this past month. It’s my only criticism of Sam recently.

Robinson was brilliant in our win at Wolves and always creates a chance or two.

The worrying thing is Sam alienating these players (Grant, Grady, Robinson), that will probably be needed to be called upon for next season.

Most definitely they will be used next season.

But if they're not good enough for this league this season then why play them?

I agree with you on Robinson. I think the lad's a decent player. The other two are nowhere near good enough.
Reply
#5
I thought Robinson on for Phillips should have been the switch at some point. We offered fugg all down the left in terms of attacking intent.
Reply
#6
(03-05-2021, 01:40 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(03-05-2021, 01:33 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Robinson has been unfairly underused this past month. It’s my only criticism of Sam recently.

Robinson was brilliant in our win at Wolves and always creates a chance or two.

The worrying thing is Sam alienating these players (Grant, Grady, Robinson), that will probably be needed to be called upon for next season.

Most definitely they will be used next season.

But if they're not good enough for this league this season then why play them?

I agree with you on Robinson. I think the lad's a decent player. The other two are nowhere near good enough.

I’m not saying they should be played. Although I do believe Robinson should be allowed more game time.  I’m saying it’s a fragile situation leaving them out when we will probably be forced to rely on them next season. Especially if Sam stays, what’s his relationship going to be like with them.
Reply
#7
For a while now I have advocated playing Robinson or Grant alongside Diagne. The big fella is fantastic at holidng the ball up, but he does need someone up front to play off him. And vice versa.

Even if - as some on here argue - we don't line up that way... we should at least switch to that approach when we need to score. As was the case last night once Everton took the lead.

We have to WIN games, Sam. Win. Drawing is no good to us now. We are better off losing thatn drawing! We have to go for the wins.
Reply
#8
When HRK was brought on I did pass comment that he's a "defensive attacker".

Robinson is undoubtedly more mobile and quicker but HRK has had impact as a sub on a number of occasions so it's a toss up between the two.
Reply
#9
I have no problem with bringing on HRK, but IMO if HRK is up top then Robinson should be on out wide so we have at least some attacking threat.

Snodgrass is a good player, but Robinson is more likely to actually score
Reply
#10
If you're looking to hold onto what you've already got, then I can understand why HRK would be brought on, but if you're chasing the game it's either Grant or Robinson Shirley?
HRK has been a decent servant but I'm hoping he's not here next season, even in the Championship.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)