The 4th Test
#41
Wonderful morning of test match cricket! Lovely to have it on normal telly.
Reply
#42
(03-05-2021, 08:58 AM)Fido Wrote:
(03-05-2021, 08:53 AM)lesley Wrote:
(03-05-2021, 08:45 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What's the cutoff between 'hitting' and 'umpire's call'? Cause on the ball tracking it seemed like the seam was going smack dab into the bail?

Ok, I need help here. Half watching the cricket and hubby has just tried to explain that decision to me ( very badly!) Why , if he was out on the review did the decision revert back to the original umpire’s decision which was wrong? Huh

Think it has to be over half a ball hitting otherwise umpire's call.

Thanks. Don’t watch cricket that often, but don’t understand why the upstairs decision didn’t stand, as it was the correct one. Seems silly to have the upstairs people if they can’t correct any incorrect umpire decisions. As for 50% of the ball, pure daftness. If it’s out, then surely it’s out never mind what percentage of the ball was going to hit or not!  
Sorry for the rant, I think I’m still fuming over VAR decisions in football and letting it carry over into other sports Smile
Reply
#43
(03-05-2021, 09:13 AM)lesley Wrote:
(03-05-2021, 08:58 AM)Fido Wrote:
(03-05-2021, 08:53 AM)lesley Wrote:
(03-05-2021, 08:45 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What's the cutoff between 'hitting' and 'umpire's call'? Cause on the ball tracking it seemed like the seam was going smack dab into the bail?

Ok, I need help here. Half watching the cricket and hubby has just tried to explain that decision to me ( very badly!) Why , if he was out on the review did the decision revert back to the original umpire’s decision which was wrong? Huh

Think it has to be over half a ball hitting otherwise umpire's call.

Thanks. Don’t watch cricket that often, but don’t understand why the upstairs decision didn’t stand, as it was the correct one. Seems silly to have the upstairs people if they can’t correct any incorrect umpire decisions. As for 50% of the ball, pure daftness. If it’s out, then surely it’s out never mind what percentage of the ball was going to hit or not!  
Sorry for the rant, I think I’m still fuming over VAR decisions in football and letting it carry over into other sports Smile

I think the 50% of the ball must be hitting thing is designed to offer some protection to Umpires and to ensure the game doesn't become something of a farce. If any of the ball going on to hit the stumps was out that would, in my view, mean Umpires would be giving LBWs which on review wouldn't be going on to hit at all, because they'd have to base their decision on a tiny proportion of the ball hitting the stumps. This would make them look incompetent on review and distort the Umpires interpretation of the width of the stumps, which would effectively become an entire two balls width wider. I'm not sure that would be good for the game to be honest.

That said I can't see how the Bess LBW isn't out to be honest! Even on review it looked like enough of the ball was hitting.
Reply
#44
Thats what I thought. If bell tracking shows the seam hitting then surely thats at least half the ball? Should've been out IMO
Reply
#45
(03-05-2021, 09:33 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Thats what I thought. If bell tracking shows the seam hitting then surely thats at least half the ball? Should've been out IMO

It seemed to look more out in real-time than with DRS, to be honest.
Reply
#46
Dom Bess bamboozling the Indians with his full tosses.

One of the first things you learn as a spinner is that to give the ball a chance to spin, it's got to fucking bounce.
Reply
#47
Bess has handed the initiative back to India on a plate here. He's bowled poorly.
Reply
#48
(03-05-2021, 10:06 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Bess has handed the initiative back to India on a plate here. He's bowled poorly.

Shouldn't really be throwing up full tosses as a finger spinner; a bit more acceptable with the wristies.
Reply
#49
(03-04-2021, 08:56 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(03-04-2021, 05:49 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(03-04-2021, 04:22 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(03-04-2021, 11:30 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(03-04-2021, 11:24 AM)Albionmad Wrote: Bess is sending down some rank deliveries in his first over. England's spinners bowl the occasional jaffer but interspersed with long hops and full tosses. There's no sustained pressure unlike when India were bowling.

India are the better team on these surfaces without a doubt. However next time India host a test series they'll do well to attract mainstream coverage. Who's going to pay for the TV rights for 5 day tests when the matches are over half way through?

In a population domestically of over a billion and massive worldwide interest don't underestimate the demand.

"Indian cricket has the most powerful voice and thickest wallets on the world scene"
I think that's what really irks many and it brings out this manic Trump like conspiracy excuses....pitches & umpires are just a ruse England have been woeful and India not much better to be honest!!!....
ECB AC & SCB have accepted that they cannot bully anymore they have had there perceived superiority shoved up there backsides by India being the only super power in the sport.
The only tour that makes real money for any national board is an Indian tour the only one to come close is an Ashes tour even that is diminishing as we are getting an Ashes test series almost every two years. 
ECB and Lords are praying for a draw at best or and Indian victory otherwise it will be you your dad and your dog watching the test final in June!!!...  Big Grin

Can anyone explain the empty stadium today?  I would say England's home games pretty much sell out regardless of the opposition.

The Ch4 coverage isn't because England are touring India, it's because England are touring.  2 day tests will hit the TV companies and will see a reduction in revenue if that continues, it's the Indian domestic game\IPL that is generating the demand and given the Indian Cricket Board the power as that's where the money is at present.  The influence they try to wield with this power is rightly questionable...

I would imagine other TV deals, generated via India's participation will also be hit if this continues.

I struggle to see the interest in the World Championship Trophy.

England’s support for test cricket is absolutely second to none

When we’ve been seriously shite...I’m thinking back to when Nasser first took the reigns and we lost to New Zealand....yes I was there, we would still generally sell out and the away support is too notch

I guessed the crowds in India in the last couple of test were down to COVID restrictions, surely?

Cuzer
As you must be aware the real money is not from the attendance its the TV rights...when India plays these by far eclipses all other countries put together.
Australia v India was pay to watch in UK!!!!!.... shows the pull.
Reply
#50
I've edited this, in fact it was on BT Sport 2, what the hell are you talking about?

Make no mistake I was cheering on India to beat those lot, especially the way Paine acted and to ram his words back down this throat was truly wonderful

It's just a shame the completely blinkered approach the likes of you have Pindgill to all things Indian Cricket really puts me off wanting them to do well, that and Kholi being a prize wanker perhaps!

I'd say the real support is getting off your arses and goign to watch your team play, no?

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)