The Covid Arms in Dudley Port
#31
(02-17-2021, 04:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-17-2021, 04:02 PM)Baggy Bruin Wrote:
(02-17-2021, 10:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-16-2021, 05:28 PM)Baggy Bruin Wrote: We've had no lockdown in Sweden TBF. No compulsory masks, no shops shut etc..

And we've done no worse than Blighty and even - in some respects - better.

(Not trying to justify people being selfish. Just saying that breaking some laws may not really be quite as bad as people seem to think....).

Different rules for different situations, the UK is far more densely populated and transmission is much easier resulting in more cases resulting in more transmission resulting in ... ad infinitum.

60M v 10M with Sweden being twice the size makes the decisions easier for govt to avoid lockdown. The 3 biggest cities total 2.5M people and that includes Malmo with 320k (The same size as Dudley MB).

Sounds a great place to live BB.

People say that but the population density is the same in many parts of Sweden as it is in many parts of France.  Because most of Sweden is empty.

But France (with its lockdowns and so on) has had shed-loads of cases.

So I think there must be more to it than that.

The denser populated areas of Sweden are much fewer than in France. France has 118 people per km whereas Sweden has 23. There are 3 areas that make up for a quarter of the population, transmission will be relatively limited to those areas and less likely to move from area to area. In comparison, if someone gets it in Dudley, without restrictions it will soon get to Wolverhampton and Sandwell and then their surrounding boroughs because there is no break in the urban areas. Gothenburg to Stockholm is about 300 miles.

And Sweden has had more cases and deaths per 100k than France, so it appears the approach isn't as effective even in a less densely populated country, imagine the damage in a more densely populated countries. It's probably better to compare Sweden will similar countries such as Estonia, Finland or Latvia who whilst Sweden has had 118 deaths per 100k, they've had 35, 12 and 70.

(02-17-2021, 04:28 PM)woodman Wrote:
(02-17-2021, 04:17 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-17-2021, 03:03 PM)woodman Wrote:
(02-17-2021, 10:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Different rules for different situations, the UK is far more densely populated and transmission is much easier resulting in more cases resulting in more transmission resulting in ... ad infinitum.

60M v 10M with Sweden being twice the size makes the decisions easier for govt to avoid lockdown. The 3 biggest cities total 2.5M people and that includes Malmo with 320k (The same size as Dudley MB).

Sounds a great place to live BB.

For those interested there is no correlation between population density, lockdown intervention severity/type and deaths per million.

So you think that the further people are apart doesn't impact on how a virus is transmitted? Interesting theory. How do you consider it transmits?

You've immediately conflated another thing with what I've stated. My statement is true and your statement (people in close proximity are more likely to contract illnesses from other people - although very much depends on environment, season and many other factors) shall we say is true. But one doesn't make another. It's called opinion bias.

"There is no correlation between population density..... and deaths per million" 

No conflation at all there, you're either bad at putting a sentence together or don't understand what you have said.

I really think you should read what I said more closely. You wouldn't get a job as a scientist.

In my short time here I'm not sure who made you forum covid spokesperson obviously it's a role you think you should play. I see it as a policeman role, yet you've said on a single other thread I've had the temerity to join that you're an open minded chap. Not stopping you believing anything that's your right but policing what other's say is quite frankly the position society has now found itself in due to a complete loss of faculty and perspective and some recently inherited god given right to tell others what they should say think or do.
Reply
#32
Stockholm has a density of 4,500 people per km2.

Yet it has dealt with the virus without lockdown, without compulsory masks etc..

People can dispute that until the cows come home, but the fact is - according to the science of lockdown - Stockholm should have been virtually wiped out. It hasnt been.
Reply
#33
(02-17-2021, 06:47 PM)Baggy Bruin Wrote: Stockholm has a density of 4,500 people per km2.

Yet it has dealt with the virus without lockdown, without compulsory masks etc..

People can dispute that until the cows come home, but the fact is - according to the science of lockdown - Stockholm should have been virtually wiped out.  It hasnt been.

Sweden has a worse infection rate per million than the UK and is 23rd in the number of deaths per 1million and is about to close gyms,  restaurants and hair salons so it's far rom being dealt with.

John Hopkins report found that while infection and death rates were not specifically affected by a single population density they were affected in large metropolitan areas with a high number of counties linked together through economic, commuting and social interaction, the absolute epitome of the UK where 1 conurbation buts up to another unlike Sweden

A report in India found that density did affect infection and mortality rates 

Pick your scientists
Reply
#34
(02-17-2021, 06:32 PM)woodman Wrote: I really think you should read what I said more closely. You wouldn't get a job as a scientist.

In my short time here I'm not sure who made you forum covid spokesperson obviously it's a role you think you should play. I see it as a policeman role, yet you've said on a single other thread I've had the temerity to join that you're an open minded chap. Not stopping you believing anything that's your right but policing what other's say is quite frankly the position society has now found itself in due to a complete loss of faculty and perspective and some recently inherited god given right to tell others what they should say think or do.

And still no solution to it all.

This is a message board, when you post something anyone can respond. I think that your apparent distance from the UK means that you seem to have lost touch with the reality of the situation over here. We went from 500 in hospital at the start of September to 34,000 in less than 4 months, and that was with restrictions in place, we both agree that if allowed to transmit freely then it would infect more people, therefore causing more hospitalisations, therefore causing more deaths.

You talk of seasonality of the virus when so far we've had it in Spring, Autumn and Winter, I suppose you can describe it as seasonal as long as you mean most of them.

I'm not fussed on what you think but will point out when it makes no sense, you could say the moon is made of cheese but don't get shirty when someone points out it's not.

It's simple, we've had over 100,000 more deaths than normal in less than a year and that is with restrictions in place. Are you trying to say it would have been no worse if we'd let it run without those restrictions? It's a simple question, let's see if you ca answer it.

(02-17-2021, 06:47 PM)Baggy Bruin Wrote: Stockholm has a density of 4,500 people per km2.

Yet it has dealt with the virus without lockdown, without compulsory masks etc..

People can dispute that until the cows come home, but the fact is - according to the science of lockdown - Stockholm should have been virtually wiped out.  It hasnt been.

And that is laudable and goes very much towards the attitude of the Swedes and their ability to self monitor the situation. Unfortunately as has been shown that doesn't work in the UK and we have had a terrible death toll even with restrictions in place, that would have been worse if we hadn't have had the limited restriction that has been in place since September.

Do you feel that the Swedish model would have worked in the UK and the figures would have been better / worse/ the same? A lot of things to consider in that which you will probably have an insight into the relative average age, health etc. Is Sweden healthier than the UK?

And a point to raise your awareness, Covid will only cause death in a % of the population, more the older it gets. It's not the black death, it won't virtually wipe out a whole cities population. You don't need to be worried that it will kill everyone.
Reply
#35
It's clearly a seasonal virus baggy1. They should have dropped all restrictions in summer as I've said a day or 2 ago to build a normal immunity but they didn't and shovelled that lack of immunity into the worst time - winter. There are great papers done on the circulation of respiratory viruses - when the world wasn't such a global place - and remote islands with no contact have outbreaks of viruses that reach them regardless of contact points. Similarly plenty of papers pre-covid showing evidence for lockdowns will only work if ALL contact is removed, complete and total isolation - I think there were some actual research studies done. Hence the advice by all bodies and govts before Covid that lockdown measures should not be used. You just can't do ALL contact removal in this world/time and the virus won't respect a policy of SOME or even ALL removal. It somehow got put in the bin alongside much common sense.

As for the question: "Are you trying to say it would have been no worse if we'd let it run without those restrictions?" We are in Bertrand Russell chocolate teapot/God territory. You ask me if it would have been worse/better and I can ask you the same question but reversed.

But in my mind lockdowns clearly don't work, they've killed an excess of 100K people "with" Covid - i wish we'd report things properly - 40-50 odd thousand of them in the home which I think looks a bit weird and they will continue to kill and disadvantage many others for a decade or more. The total death toll will be significantly higher and total QALYs will be huge. The average age of a Covid "with" death is over 80. The actual QALYs impact will be so much higher in years to come. I was in favour of the Spring lockdown to give us time to work out what it actually was. Was it a really lethal killer or not? It's not. It has a lethality that is greater than many influenza's and some other coronaviruses but let's put it in perspective. That's why the Swede's model worked in the sense of managing a terrible set of short term deaths against the balance of long term consequences. And I simply don't buy the behavioural analysis - blame the people for not doing what they're told - the vast majority have done exactly that.

We have had the worst of both worlds and it's a travesty. A terrible covid death toll and to follow a society, economy, education and people's future health (outside covid) extremely severely impacted by the measures taken the affects of which will be placed on a part of society that will be least able to shoulder the burden: the young, the poor and the vulnerable.

We should not be asking ourselves the question about whether lockdowns work when we consider an approach to a future similar pandemic. That is a question that is simply irrelevant. I don't get the total obsession with it and the labels used lockdown fanatics/deniers/sceptics. It's completely facile. It's the wrong question.

Clearly they don't work because if they did you would use it as a repeatable method for the future. But there is no way you would or could do this again in 5yrs etc.

What we should be asking is why our society in the UK is so fragile that it can't cope with a sharp shock like this. The health of our society, the distribution of wealth, the dependence on the state, the lack of personal responsibility, a lack of sensible govt policy, the conflict of interests of those politicians and scientists in power, a health service that clearly you can't keep shovelling money into, a lack of a balanced economy to generate wealth across sectors, an ageing population, significant population growth, the changing climate (impact on viruses), the affect of social media and other media outlets on our ability to respond sensibly. I'm sure there are plenty more.

There are so many more important questions than asking whether lockdowns work or focussing on a very simple and non-transparent death number. We should be asking these questions now - we should have started asking them in the summer. The trouble is sensible debate has disappeared. Labelling, tagging and slagging, abusing, shutting down, closing free speech. That's what Covid has given us as a byproduct and in many ways that's as troublesome hence my irritated reply to you at the end of my last message. I apologise for that because I fell into the trap too but working with people across the world brings a wider perspective and for those I work with they are horrified at the UK and what's happened and can't understand why we've taken the measures we have.
Reply
#36
Clearly living in the USofA has clouded your memory, lockdown was lifted in June and we had shops open and eat out to help out after that. It clearly didn't help build immunity. And I know it's an inconvenient truth but lockdowns do work as shown in Australia and New Zealand.

And what do you mean "our society in the UK" - I thought you were in the US.
Reply
#37
(02-18-2021, 04:19 PM)woodman Wrote: It's clearly a seasonal virus baggy1. - We've had it in Spring, Autumn and Winter now, are you saying we'll only be without in Summer?

They should have dropped all restrictions in summer as I've said a day or 2 ago to build a normal immunity but they didn't - Erm, They did and shovelled that lack of immunity into the worst time - winter.

There are great papers done on the circulation of respiratory viruses - when the world wasn't such a global place - and remote islands with no contact have outbreaks of viruses that reach them regardless of contact points. Similarly plenty of papers pre-covid showing evidence for lockdowns will only work if ALL contact is removed, complete and total isolation - I think there were some actual research studies done. Hence the advice by all bodies and govts before Covid that lockdown measures should not be used. You just can't do ALL contact removal in this world/time and the virus won't respect a policy of SOME or even ALL removal. It somehow got put in the bin alongside much common sense. - Are you saying it just floats around in the air until it lands on someone?

As for the question: "Are you trying to say it would have been no worse if we'd let it run without those restrictions?"  We are in Bertrand Russell chocolate teapot/God territory. You ask me if it would have been worse/better and I can ask you the same question but reversed. - It would have been worse clearly, we've locked down and cases, hospitalisations and excess deaths are dropping.

But in my mind lockdowns clearly don't work, they've killed an excess of 100K people "with" Covid - i wish we'd report things properly - 40-50 odd thousand of them in the home which I think looks a bit weird and they will continue to kill and disadvantage many others for a decade or more. The total death toll will be significantly higher and total QALYs will be huge. The average age of a Covid "with" death is over 80. The actual QALYs impact will be so much higher in years to come. I was in favour of the Spring lockdown to give us time to work out what it actually was. Was it a really lethal killer or not? It's not. - !!!! Really? !!!!

It has a lethality that is greater than many influenza's and some other coronaviruses but let's put it in perspective. That's why the Swede's model worked in the sense of managing a terrible set of short term deaths against the balance of long term consequences. - Sweden has admitted it failed and compared with other Nordic countries it's a basket case

And I simply don't buy the behavioural analysis - blame the people for not doing what they're told - the vast majority have done exactly that.

We have had the worst of both worlds and it's a travesty. A terrible covid death toll and to follow a society, economy, education and people's future health (outside covid) extremely severely impacted by the measures taken the affects of which will be placed on a part of society that will be least able to shoulder the burden: the young, the poor and the vulnerable.

We should not be asking ourselves the question about whether lockdowns work when we consider an approach to a future similar pandemic. That is a question that is simply irrelevant. I don't get the total obsession with it and the labels used lockdown fanatics/deniers/sceptics. It's completely facile. It's the wrong question.

Clearly they don't work because if they did you would use it as a repeatable method for the future. But there is no way you would or could do this again in 5yrs etc.

What we should be asking is why our society in the UK is so fragile that it can't cope with a sharp shock like this. The health of our society, the distribution of wealth, the dependence on the state, the lack of personal responsibility, a lack of sensible govt policy, the conflict of interests of those politicians and scientists in power, a health service that clearly you can't keep shovelling money into, a lack of a balanced economy to generate wealth across sectors, an ageing population, significant population growth, the changing climate (impact on viruses), the affect of social media and other media outlets on our ability to respond sensibly. I'm sure there are plenty more.

There are so many more important questions than asking whether lockdowns work or focussing on a very simple and non-transparent death number. We should be asking these questions now - we should have started asking them in the summer. The trouble is sensible debate has disappeared. Labelling, tagging and slagging, abusing, shutting down, closing free speech. That's what Covid has given us as a byproduct and in many ways that's as troublesome hence my irritated reply to you at the end of my last message. I apologise for that because I fell into the trap too but working with people across the world brings a wider perspective and for those I work with they are horrified at the UK and what's happened and can't understand why we've taken the measures we have.

You keep talking about 'with' and non-transparent death number. Are you saying there is something else that has caused over 100k more deaths than average in less than 12 months?

You're basically saying 'lockdowns don't work' but not listening to anyone that says lockdowns don't work on their own. We're just buying time until the vaccine adds to the armoury. Of course it isn't repeatable but it's something that is keeping the death toll down until we have more options.

You actually have shown again that you basically haven't a clue what's going on, you have no answers to anything, you just don't like this. It's simple, we open up, cases, hospitalisations and deaths go up; we lockdown, they stop increasing and then go down. It aint rocket science, you seem to want to question covid deaths and use the usual 'with' line, even down to the 'why are they all dying at home - that's strange' line. 

The points you raise around why it's hit us so hard are valid but down to long term structural issues from underfunding and years of widening the gap between rich and poor, but your views on covid is just lunacy mate. 

Your rhetoric casts doubt amongst the more gullible which leads to them not taking vaccines or not taking covid seriously enough. That in itself leads to more deaths. You can't even get basic facts straight - How the fuck is something we've had in Spring, Autumn and Winter now seen as seasonal? It's not a lethal killer when we have increased our deaths in E&W by 20% in less than one year. Sweden is a car crash compared to it's neighbours, even they've admitted it. Compare Stockholm with Copenhagen (a more densely populated city).
Reply
#38
I think you need to go and have a lie down. You do know saying the same things over and over again doesn't make them right don't you. You sound like a petulant school.kid.

You've not engaged with anything I've written. The last para says it all where you accuse me have not having a clue and yet go and show how biased your own opinion is. Like I said before I suggest you get off your soap box and the little pedestal you seem to have got yourself on in this small corner of the world and open your eyes.

By the way I almost stopped reading when you drew a causal line between lockdowns and cases.

I won't be engaging with you anymore my short time here has shown me what a little angry man you are with your insults and berating. Tells me a lot about your life and most of all your perspective and ability to debate with critical thinking.
Reply
#39
Thank fuck for that
Reply
#40
(02-22-2021, 07:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Thank fuck for that

+1 to Woodman’s views.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)